Liverpool: 10 Reasons Why Rodgers Must Face The Axe

There's no way back for the Liverpool boss now.

Brendan Rodgers' tenure as manager of Liverpool has witnessed miraculous highs and punishing lows. But this season the Northern Irishman has come under mass scrutinisation following his side's gutless performances, epitomised by Sunday's 6-1 horror show at Stoke. "It was embarrassing and if the owners want me to go, I'll go," was Rodgers' rather defeatist response when asked about his future on Merseyside after the rout. And while Liverpool did not expect a title challenge following the damaging sale of Luis Suarez to Barcelona last summer, they were still expected to finish in the top four but emphatically missed out on a place in next season€™s Champions League. There is a feeling that Rodgers has not only missed his desired targets, but he has irritated owners FSG with some of his public statements, while senior figures at Anfield have complained about the 42-year-old€™s arrogance. A dead man walking, it seems. FSG are preparing to review Liverpool€™s season and Rodgers is set to meet with Mike Gordon, the president of the ownership group, where he intends to present a plan determining how he is to get the Reds back on track next season. But he is more likely to face probing and uncomfortable questions over exactly what went wrong in this disastrous campaign. Kenny Dalglish attended an end-of-season review in Boston in similar circumstances in 2012, only to be told that the Liverpool board had decided to change direction. An ominous indictment of Rodgers' fate, perhaps, and here are ten reasons why he simply has to face the chop this summer...

10. Inability To Fix A Leaky Defence

The prolificness of Suarez and Sturridge in the 2013/14 campaign masked Liverpool€™s utterly calamitous defensive unit, which conceded 50 goals that season, and 48 this.

With Johnson essentially resembling a lamp-post, Enrique being on a heavily-documented, never-ending holiday with his girlfriend, and young Jon Flanagan being the most beaten defender in the Premier League, it was clear improvements were needed.

Daniel Agger, arguably Liverpool€™s best defender, was flogged to Brondby and replaced in the squad by Croat blunderer Dejan Lovren, for a quite astronomical fee, having only impressed in one full season at Southampton. Lovren was brought in to fill the €˜leader€™ void which was vacated by Jamie Carragher, yet within five minutes of his debut, Lovren looked like a fish out of water - and he has been a disaster all season.

Moreno has produced a handful of good performances but has been susceptible to gallivanting out of position, leaving the defence mightily exposed. Fellow young Spaniard Javi Manquillo appears to have vanished off the face of the earth since November.

Another defensive revamp is needed, and Liverpool fans can hardly trust Rodgers to fix the issues when looking at his track record.


9. Tumbling Out Of Europe (Twice)

With the exception of Real Madrid, Liverpool really should have been relatively comfortable in advancing into the knock-out stages of the Champions League.

Rodgers€™ decision to start Fabio Borini in the Bernabau whilst dropping Champions League-ready Steven Gerrard says a lot about his management skills (or lack therefore of) - and his side managed only one win in the competition, with a lucky last minute winner against Bulgarian minnows, Ludogorets.

When the Europa League came around, there was an unexpected optimism once again - European nights at Anfield have been rare in recent years, after all - but, yet again, the optimism was dumfounded as Liverpool crashed out at the first hurdle, yet again.

After two below-par performances and a Dejan Lovren penalty which is still hurtling towards Jupiter, Liverpool€™s European campaign came to a devastating, embarrassing halt, with a penalty shoot out loss to an average Besiktas side.


8. Failure To Win Trophies

Three years, zero trophies. This simply is not good enough for a Liverpool side who want to be taken seriously. Put it this way - in Rodgers€™ time at the helm, Wigan Athletic have won more domestic cups than Liverpool. Yes, now-League One side, Wigan Athletic.

To think that an outlay of just over £215m has not brought in players with enough quality to win a singular trophy in three years of trying is hugely alarming, to say the least. Although the Northern Irishman praised his team's efforts in getting to two semi-finals, you need to actually lift the trophy to consider it a €œgood cup run€, surely.

Another trophy-less season should really put the final nail in the coffin for Rodgers, as even Kenny Dalglish, who won the Carling Cup and actually reached the final of the FA Cup during his final year at Liverpool, was sacked by FSG a matter of weeks later after a cripplingly poor Premier League campaign.

Sounds familiar.


7. Transfer Gaffes

As mentioned, Rodgers has spent the best part of a staggering £215m on 24 different players during his tenure as Liverpool boss.

Daniel Sturridge and Philippe Coutinho have proven to be spectacular purchases - but with these two success stories aside - it could be argued that not one of Rodgers' 22 other signings have actually established themselves successfully at the Merseyside club.

Buys such as Mario Balotelli, Dejan Lovren, Rickie Lambert, Victor Moses and Fabio Borini to name just a few, exemplify Rodgers' incompetence in bringing in the calibre of player which is required at Liverpool FC.

And with Danny Ings, James Milner and Christian Benteke being lined up as Liverpool's top summer transfer targets, the trend in sub-standard, underwhelming signings looks set to continue.

Either his say in transfers should be abolished entirely, or the Northern Irishman should face the sack - because Liverpool really are slowly morphing into mid-table fodder.


6. FA Cup Semi-Final

If squandering their top-four chances when bottling must-win games against West Brom and Hull didn€™t leave Liverpool fans infuriated enough, a horrific showing against Aston Villa in the FA Cup semi final left fans thoroughly perplexed.

Having taken the lead against a relegation-threatened Villa side, Liverpool were blown away by Tim Sherwood's outfit who were clearly more equipped to battle for the win on the day - raising questions about Rodgers€™ inspirational qualities and whether or not the players are actually in sync with the bosses ideas.

Jack Grealish dazzled on the Wembley turf, resembling a young Andres Iniesta, and Christian Benteke was made to look like Rivaldo-reborn, such was the lack of passion, drive and quality shown by a limp Liverpool side entirely bereft of ideas.

One of the most embarrassing days in Liverpool's recent history which means yet another season without silverware. This must be aggravating the decision-makers at the top of the club.


5. Struggle To Attract Big-Name Stars

How many times in recent transfer windows have Liverpool supposedly €˜monitored€™ or €˜agreed in principal€™ deals with big-name players who later decided to join a club with a better-recognised manager at the helm?

Alexis Sanchez ended up at Arsene Wenger€™s Arsenal after Liverpool bewilderingly failed to use Suarez as a makeweight for any potential deal for the Chilean.

Memphis Depay, who Rodgers is said to have kept in regular contact with for the past 18 months, moved to Manchester United at the first opportunity to play under Louis Van Gaal - another huge managerial name.

Willian chose Mourinho and Chelsea, Henrikh Mkhitryan opted for Klopp. You get the idea - it is a worrying trend which shows no signs of coming to a halt.

Liverpool haven€™t actually €˜won the race€™ for a real, top quality player's signature under Rodgers€™ management - and this is due to the better players being swayed to work under the supervision of a more prestigious, proven coach.

Jurgen Klopp and Carlo Ancelotti are available, right?


4. Outrageous Misuse Of Signings

For one reason or another, Rodgers has deployed his signings out of position on a regular basis since his 2012 appointment.

Nuri Sahin, who signed on loan for Liverpool after an epic tug of war with Arsenal, cut short his time at the club having been utterly misused and featured only 12 times.

Not since Xabi Alonso have Liverpool had a deep lying playmaker in the ranks with such class, yet Rodgers deployed the stylish Turk in an unfamiliar number ten position.

€œI spoke with him (Rodgers) and asked him why I was still playing there. It is not my real position. The boss could not answer me€still, I am not sorry about it. To play in the red jersey and be in Anfield is something marvellous.

€œMaybe if I had not gone there I would not have been able to return to Dortmund. For that I am happy. But I have left Brendan Rodgers, thanks be to God€.

Emre Can, once rendered 'The Next Schweinsteiger' due to his excellence in a central midfield role, has featured only sporadically in his favourite position, scoring against champions Chelsea in one of his rare outings in midfield.

And although the young German powerhouse seemed comfortable in a back three, Rodgers simply hung Can out to dry in the last few weeks of the season by playing the midfielder at right back - a position so emphatically unsuited to the 20-year old's skill-set.

If Rodgers persists with playing the talented midfielder out of position and abusing his 'versatility role', it won't be long until Can asks for a move back to his native Germany.


3. Gerrard Leaving

Surely more could have been done to persuade Liverpool's talismanic skipper and this season's top goal scorer to stay at the club?

The captain€™s farewell appearance ended in one of the clubs€™ most embarrassing defeats in recent memory. In reality though, this really shouldn€™t have been Gerrard€™s last appearance in a Liverpool jersey.

There is a sense that Liverpool and Rodgers could not come up with a deal to satisfy their captain despite his incredibly loyal service to the club.

Steve McManaman, an ex-team mate of Gerrards claimed: €œHe won€™t regret leaving and Liverpool will be fine without him. However, I think he should have stayed and retired at Liverpool.

€œThere€™s a player who would have signed if he had been offered a contract at the right time. €œI look at the midfielders there and I think €˜Are the other midfielders better than him?€™ and the answer€™s a resounding no.€

The former England captain deserved to see out his Liverpool career on his own terms but it feels like Gerrard has been ushered out of the Anfield exit door against his wishes.

Only when Rodgers replaces Liverpool's greatest ever player with James Milner come the start of the 2015/16 campaign will he realise that he probably should have done everything in his power to persuade his captain to stay.


2. Mid-Table Mentality

Apparently, a sixth place finish, two unsuccessful domestic cup campaigns and a truly embarrassing European run represents a "par" season for Liverpool Football Club. Does Rodgers still think he's the manager of Swansea? Or is he so utterly deluded at this moment in time that he genuinely believes Liverpool should be relatively content with what, in all honesty, was a complete and utter shambles of a season? The man is becoming a parody. Even by his own peculiar standards, branding a season when Liverpool failed in achieving any of their targets as "par" was lunacy. Plain and simple. How can Liverpool fans look forward to the future with a man in charge who spends money so wastefully, plays so many players out of position and is content with a sixth placed finish?

1. Stoke City 6-1 Liverpool

Surely this spells the end for the manager. There is no returning from this utter embarrassment. The players will point the finger at him for the defeat. And he will point the finger at them for it. How do you make that unhealthy situation healthy again? There€™s been a lot of talk this week about Liverpool€™s identity as a club as they continue to "move forward" under Rodgers' management. Well Liverpool€™s identity right now is a club that has finished sixth in the Premier League and lost by a record margin at Stoke City. A club that€™s lost home and away to Crystal Palace, was humiliated at Wembley by Aston Villa, couldn't figure out a way to beat Hull City and crashed out of Europe. Twice. The team trudged its way through the last two months of the campaign and three wins in 10 tells its own story. What came before was bad enough €” but the Stoke game was downright embarrassing. A new low. The worst for 52 years. The biggest Liverpool defeat in Steven Gerrard's career on the last day as a Liverpool player - a degrading epitaph to an Anfield CV that puts him among the greatest ever. Gerrard's face painted the picture - he looked apologetic. Sorry he couldn€™t sort it. Sorry that his manager had no idea how to sort it, either. Liverpool were bullied, battered and humiliated by the ninth best team in English football. It has to be the end for Rodgers.

Contributor

Journalism student at Northumbria University. Huge Liverpool supporter and Mamadou Sakho's biggest fan. That's about it, really.