Man Utd: 10 Reasons Louis Van Gaal Is Doomed To Fail

Clearly, it's a marriage that's going to end in tears.

It€™s been a tough old season for Manchester United fans to bear. I think a lot of fans appreciated that the transition from Sir Alex Ferguson to David Moyes would be a tough one, but the season went about as bad as it could have done. Therefore, Man Utd were really left with little option to make another change so soon after their last one. It€™s certainly been a real change from the stability that Ferguson has given the club for so many years. Louis Van Gaal was finally appointed this week after weeks of speculation, and the Red Devils will be hoping for a long and successful period under his leadership. However, it would be crazy to take for granted his success especially after this season. Many people will feel that employing the Dutchman is a sensible and sound move, but here at What Culture we explore why that may not prove to be the case. In summary, the purpose of this slideshow is to look at the reasons why fans should be cautious about this appointment, and why ultimately it will end in failure. So, with all that said let€™s get started€

10. He May Struggle To Get Back Into The Swing Of Club Football

There is no doubt that there is a world of difference between club and international management. The differences are obvious enough to point out such as less games and time with the players on the international side. It€™s also worth pointing out that certain parts of the normal job are not required such as being involved with player transfers. Van Gaal will have people around him at Old Trafford to take some of the pressure off, but it will still be an incredible culture shock for him €“ especially in the early stages of the season. It will also be interesting to see how he manages all the various things that he will need as a club manager again. It€™s worth noting that Van Gaal hasn€™t been involved in club management since 2011 and that€™s quite a long time out, so that represents a big challenge to him.

9. His Partnership With Ryan Giggs May Not Work

It€™s clear that there was a feeling at Old Trafford that Ryan Giggs must be involved in the new set-up; he has been installed as the Dutchman€™s assistant. However, it€™s always dangerous when two people are put together that may not have same ideas or their personalities may not be compatible. Therefore, although Giggs is seen as an important part of the Manchester United family, that doesn€™t mean to say that it will work. Managers take the credit and the flak on results, but the reality is it€™s always a team game. Van Gaal may be the main man, but his backroom team will be absolutely crucial if he is to be a success. This is nothing against Giggs€™ coaching ability, but more about if he and the Dutchman will make cohesive coaching team or not. I€™d have to say that at the moment, the jury is certainly still out.

8. Is Going Foreign Really The Right Move?

Of course, one thing that you can€™t get away from is that this is a foreign appointment. A situation that is foreign to Manchester United after their long succession of British managers. It€™s clearly a road that they wanted to continue to go down after the Moyes appointment. Like foreign players, you can never be quite sure how a foreign manager will work out. As mentioned, we already know that Ryan Giggs will be involved as well €“ but it may well be that other former British players will join him in the same capacity. That being said, it€™s also highly likely that Van Gaal will come with one or two Dutch friends.Therefore, how the British and Dutch blend together is another potential interesting aspect to this. Finally, it will interesting to see how strongly Man Utd onto their traditions. For instance, the club has a history of bringing through players from the youth system as well as keeping a strong nucleus of top British players. The Dutchman may feel that he doesn€™t need to do that, so as well as failing he may lead the club down a path that could lead to a loss of identity.

7. The Dutchman Doesn€™t Have Any Previous Premier League Experience

The big problem for David Moyes was he didn€™t have the experience of winning titles. This certainly isn€™t an issue here as the Dutchman has had plenty of success, but he doesn€™t have any direct experience of the Premier League. Experience of the league is important in terms of determining which sort of players should be signed and used as well as coming up with a suitable style of play for that country. Van Gaal is in for a steep learning experience, something which could well turn out to be a problem given that Man Utd really need to hit the ground running after their poor season under Moyes. There is an argument that he has taken charge of top clubs in other countries so will learn quickly, but it doesn€™t always like that especially since the Premier League is unique and unlike the other leagues that he has worked in.

6. Van Gaal€™s Judgement On Players Could Be Impaired By Dutch Involvement

Due to the manager€™s involvement with Holland at the 2014 World Cup, there is a chance that he may favour Dutch players to some extent €“ which may not be in the best interests of Manchester United. For instance, Robin van Persie€™s influence at the club is starting to dwindle after only scoring 12 league goals in an injury wrecked season for the player. Before Van Gaal€™s appointment, most people would say that the striker to put your faith in is Wayne Rooney. This could be in a variety of ways such as the captaincy of the team, and most people would think that van Persie€™s future lies elsewhere. The Dutch striker is now 30 years old and his best years are behind him. United€™s new manager would be best placed in invested in a new young forward, rather than simply relying on van Persie. The same argument applies for the acquisition of new players. For instance, reports have started to emerge that the current Dutch boss is interested in signing Norwich City midfielder Leroy Fer. Nothing against Fer as he is a decent player, but not one with the capabilities to rebuild the Man Utd midfield. With Norwich relegated to the Championship, it would also rather suggest picking up a cheap option rather than going out and getting top talent at the market rate.

5. Van Gaal Isn€™t As Invincible As Some People Make Out

It€™s easy to look at Louis Van Gaal€™s record and get a bit carried away. After all, the Dutchman has managed some of the biggest club€™s in world football, and to a large extend his win percentage success has been highly impressive. However, he isn€™t a manager that has never been sacked as you might expect from one of the game€™s so-called great managers. In fact, he was sacked while managing both Barcelona and Bayern Munich; these were arguably his two biggest club jobs. Yes, he has been successful in his home country against Ajax and has done well elsewhere as well, but success is not guaranteed. Many people still regard Manchester United as the biggest club in the world, and the pressure will certainly be on him to deliver results. Pressure and expectancy can do funny things to people. Also, remember that he hasn€™t been involved in club management for a while so we are yet to see how smooth of a return he will make.

4. This Is Not A Long-Term Appointment

Louis Van Gaal has signed a three-year contract and it remains to be seen if he will see that out or extent it beyond that time period. Football has clearly changed a lot in recent years, but I still like the fact that a manager can stay at one club for a long time. This is a big reason why the appointment of this manager is strange, I would have preferred to have seen a younger man brought in. Van Gaal is 62 now and probably won€™t be looking for a long stay in England. I earlier mentioned his two biggest jobs in charge of Barcelona and Bayern Munich it€™s worth mentioning that his spell at the German giants only lasted around two years while his second spell at Barcelona was less than a year. When it comes to staying in a job for a long time that has only really come in the jobs he has held in his own country. Therefore, a stay for even three years at Old Trafford has to be put in some doubt.

3. How Well Does He Know The Current Market?

This appointment may succeed or fail on the back of how well Van Gaal does in the transfer market. Many people are in agreement that a massive rebuilding job is required at Manchester United this summer. It remains to be seen if the Dutch coach is the right man to do that job. As ever, there are a few different sides to this because he certainly has the pull to attract some of the best players, and we are led to believe that there is a fair bit of money to spend. However, there is no Champions League football to attract players and Van Gaal may not be not familiar with the current transfer market due to his involvement in international football. As we know, the decisions he makes need to be the right ones. So, if he is to be successful then he is going to be somewhat reliant on other people around him. Man Utd want to rebuild, but they will find things difficult and many players may not fancy a spell at Old Trafford just now. If he can€™t add well to the squad €“ then he may suffer some of the same problems that David Moyes faced.

2. His High Opinion Of Himself May Not Come Across Well

One thing is for sure is that Louis Van Gaal won€™t suffer from a lack of self-confidence when he arrives at Old Trafford after the World Cup. He is certainly one that rates himself higher than anyone else ever will. Not that there is a massive problem with this, since plenty of successful people have a certain confidence about him. However, he needs to remember that this isn€™t an easy job to walk into. Moyes€™ spell serves as a reminder that it€™s not purely a case of picking a team that will beat anyone. In fact, if the team isn€™t set-up right then they can be beaten by nearly any team in the Premier League. This isn€™t about putting himself back in the limelight again, but getting a great club back to where they should be. It€™s going to be hard work, a lot of which will take place over a very important summer period that will be disrupted by the World Cup. The problem with arrogant people is they sometimes become complacent and that€™s one thing that Manchester United can€™t afford right now.

1. His Controlling Management Style Might Backfire

Here is another reason why Louis Van Gaal€™s appointment is risky. The Dutchman likes to control everything that he can. This includes knowing all he possibly can about his players including the names of their wives and what kind of things they get up to in their spare time. The approach is understandable to some extent, because we know that there is a lot of different things that impact the way a player plays on the pitch. To be honest, it could go either way because some players may trust his methods due to his reputation as a manager. However, it€™s inevitable that his methods won€™t please every player and there may well be conflicts. Surely something that United don€™t need as they look to rebuild and improve morale. Feel free to let us know what you think about this article, and if you would think this appointment will be a success of failure.

Contributor
Contributor

James Kent is a freelance writer published on Yahoo! Sports, Bleacher Report, FTBpro, Bloomberg Sports and many others. He has also been featured in the Daily Telegraph, Zoo Magazine, MSN Sport and the Manchester Evening News. His role on What Culture is currently to produce compelling football articles that nearly always use of combination of stats and strong opinion. Feel free to connect with James via Facebook, Twitter and Google Plus.