Newcastle Manager's First Interviews - Did They Deliver On Their Promises?
McClaren said all the right things, but how did his predecessors fair in their first interviews...

I moved into this area 15 years ago and became manager of Middlesbrough - and then I realised how big a club Newcastle was. I always wanted to have this job - always. Ive had two or three opportunities, as far back as 2004 when I was at Middlesbrough, meeting Freddy Shepherd. But everything is about timing in football and it wasnt the right time in 2004. Then I was at Twente, they got relegated, there was an interest, but unfortunately I was at FC Twente and Id only been there for a year. So again, timing, and loyalty to FC Twente to stay on. And then obviously the well-documented (offer) of January just gone, where again, the timing wasnt right. I had a job to do at Derby. We were on course doing that. Id only been there just over a year and I felt that the timing wasnt right: we were top of the league, going to achieve what we wanted to achieve getting into the Premier League and the job...I wanted to finish it. It wasnt a case of turning Newcastle down at all. It was a case of staying loyal to Derby and thats what I wanted to do. The objective is top eight, to win a trophy.It goes without saying that only time will tell if McClaren's comments are accurate ones. But if former United managers are to go by, then there is more than a slight chance that everything McClaren said yesterday was a pack of lies...
13. John Carver

"I have worked with, and learnt from, the best manager that this football club has had in Sir Bobby Robson. I know what this club means to this city and its people. "I believe in my players and the staff I have around me. I am confident that we can deliver exciting, successful football and look forward with relish to my role as head coach of this great football club."It only took a few weeks for these quotes to be blown well and truly out of the water. Yes, he may have been the luckiest fan in the world by landing the top job at the team he supports, but that clearly wasn't enough as The Magpies went into the final day of the season with the chance of relegation still looming over them. As for believing in the players and staff around him, hanging people like Mike Williamson out to dry after the defeat away to Leicester and seemingly having some sort of personal vendetta against Mehdi Abeid prove this to be a false claim. Carver clearly lost the dressing room long before the season's end and certainly wasn't helped by any of those around him, most notably Steve Stone, who was sacked alongside Carver earlier this week. JC couldn't have gone much further in the opposite direction when he claimed he would deliver "exciting, successful football". Boring, one paced, lethargic, low on quality, and ultimately losing football is what he gave us instead. Did He Deliver? NO!
12. Alan Pardew

"I understand what this club means to its supporters. Throughout the football world people recognise that this is a unique club in many ways, with supporters who are second to none in their loyalty, passion and devotion for the team. "I'm not a Geordie of course, but I'm a football person with a love of the game and I can assure you I bring great drive, desire and commitment to the job. "Chris Hughton did a great job last season, guiding the club back to the Premier League, and he continued that good work this season. It is my aim to build on that now and take this club forward. "I have always managed teams that have played attacking positive football, something I know the supporters here appreciate. "At the same time I intend to focus on developing exciting young players through the club's excellent Academy and development squad, and I know the board here at St James' Park are very committed to that too."To be fair to Pardew, much of what he said in his first interview came true. But there is one line in there that makes your cringe you recall the utter dross he put us through at times during his four years at the club. First of all, there was little doubting his commitment to the cause. He weathered a plethora of storms that would have had a lesser man (or one more in tune with what was really best of the club) tucking his tail between his legs and crying all the way home to his mummy. No one can blame Pards for eventually walking out on the club, it was a decision that was best for both parties. He also left the club in a slightly better position than when he arrived. Newcastle were 11th in the table when he arrived and despite coming close to relegation once, he had the club sitting 10th and with a European campaign under his belt. That positive, attacking football he spoke about only reared it's head for around half a season as the front three of Ba, Cisse and Ben Arfa dazzled United into a fifth place finish. For the rest of the time, the sight of Mike Williamson hoofing an aimless ball up the park had become so commonplace that you almost didn't realise that it was happening. And there's little doubting that the squad he (or Graham Carr) left behind at Newcastle has plenty of potential in it, meaning his final sentiment has some truth to it. However, it remains to be seen how much of that potential the players will be allowed to release before they're inevitably sold off. Did He Deliver? Sort Of!
11. Chris Hughton

10. Alan Shearer
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oiSsAOV6MvQ A very honest assessment from the club's record goal scorer Alan Shearer who didn't promise that he would save Newcastle United from relegation. In fact he said the very opposite and laid everything out on the table exactly how it was at the time. He set everything straight and put it in black and white. The players were low on confidence, there was a whole host of injuries in the squad, costly mistakes had been made throughout the 2008/09 season and he was as inexperienced as they come in managerial terms. In reality, he made things out to be as bleak as they would eventually turn out to be. Admirable. Did He Deliver? Al Made No Bones About How Tough It Was Going To Be, So In A Way, Yes!9. Joe Kinnear

"I've never run from a fight in football and this is just about getting the team through. I believe the club will be sold soon and at the moment (coach) Chris Hughton needs all the help he can get. I hope now that I can help to get a few results together. Those are the cards that I have and I'll do the best that I can. "The fans will be disappointed, I understand that, but I can't do anything about that. I will just be doing my very best because I am desperate to get back into the game. "I will be going up to Newcastle on Monday and will pick the team from then. I'll speak to Chris about it. "Newcastle United is a great club. When I was in charge of Wimbledon I always remember the passion of the fans up there and how great a stadium St James' Park is. "It is a big challenge but one I am really looking forward to. "The team are riddled with injuries with nine players out, which makes the job even harder, but myself and Chris will be working all hours to turn it around. "I am very excited by this challenge. I am aware that the new owners have Kevin Keegan and possibly Alan Shearer parked around the corner. "I understand investors are about to buy the club, (current owner) Mike Ashley told me openly. I will be here for six to eight games."There isn't much killer when it comes to this filler of an opening statement, but when it comes to the final two sentences one of two things has happened here. Either Joe was misinformed or he made these claims up out of thin air. Given his infamous appearance on talkSPORT just after being appointed the clubs director of football, we simply cannot rule out the possibility of the latter being true... The rest of the quotes don't really tell us anything. Kinnear clearly set the bar very, very low and somehow failed to achieve those goals as Newcastle would be relegated at the end of the season. At least he understood the fans would be disappointed by him being there though... Did He Deliver? No!
8. Kevin Keegan (2nd Coming)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jmq6iDvtK2k"Having met Mike Ashley I certainly know what his ambitions are, he certainly knows what mine is." "I know there's finance there if we need it." "Mike Ashley said 'I want to win something'."Hindsight is such a wonderful thing... It is painfully clear to see that Kevin Keegan was sold something completely different to what he was eventually given by Mike Ashley, which makes the former England manager's infamous ESPN interview where he said that Newcastle United wouldn't go anywhere under the current regime and that there is no trust between fans and bosses look very much spot on. Did He Deliver? How Could He? Keegan Was Blatantly Lied To throughout His Time At The Club.
7. Sam Allardyce

"I'm ambitious and I know this club is. It hasn't had the best success but I feel I can turn it round. "I've left a football club that is very, very healthy so when my time to leave Newcastle does come I hope I have done the same here. "I hope I can bring the success that the fans are so desperate for. "I'm not saying I can get it right at the flick of a switch. If there are some sticky times I hope we can get over them for the best of the supporters and me. "When I beat big clubs their manager used to have to come up with an excuse for us beating them and that was because we played long-ball football. "When they do it at Manchester United they call it a long pass. "There have been too many injuries. They seem to be forever talking about the everlasting injury list. One of the first things I will have to look at are why those injuries have happened. "Far too many players have had too many injuries too often."That ambition thing again. It seems that Sam Allardyce was sold the same pack of lies that Kevin Keegan was. Nevertheless, the fact that Big Sam was sacked after only 24 games says it all. Yes the club were 11th and arguably wouldn't have gone on to be relegated the following season if he was still in charge, but the football he played simply didn't fit the ethos of the club one bit. It was horrible to watch, not matter how much he felt the need to defend it, and meant that he was never going to deliver on his promise of bringing success back to St James' Park. Furthermore, his signings didn't exactly pay off either. The likes of David Rozehnal, Cacapa, Geremi and Alan Smith could all be considered as flops. The other main thing to take from his press conference is his promise to rectify the injury problems at the club. It's a disease that has blighted many manager and Big Sam's scientific approach to management didn't prevent it at the time and hasn't helped to rectify it since. Sam was one of, if not the biggest flop in United's modern history. Did He Deliver? NO!
6. Glenn Roeder

"I'm happy with a two-year deal because it keeps us all on our toes. "When I came up here as a player, I suppose that having an ambition of managing the team would not have been an option. "As I went on, and if you had asked me a couple of years down the line, I would have said I would like to be a manager here one day. "Now it has happened it shows that dreams do come true. "If you work hard and fight for the dream it proves that anything in life is possible - and when the opportunity comes along you have to be ready for it. "I am looking forward to the next few seasons now and I think it is going to be an exciting time for everyone connected with this football club."Roeder was spot on when he said that everyone was on their toes as he was out of a job before the 2006/07 season came to a close. Glenn really didn't say too much after being handed the reigns on a full time basis following an extraordinary second half to the 2005/06 campaign as caretaker. Although it was great to see how much it meant to him. Ultimately however, he will go down in the record books as the caretaker who stayed too long. As he proved at West Ham before, Glenn simply wasn't up to the standards that Premier League management requires. Saying that, no one was complaining with a European quarter-final appearance... Did He Deliver? He Kind Of Predicted He Wouldn't Be Around For Long, So Yes, In A Way.
5. Graeme Souness

"I think I'm ready for a big challenge, and they don't come much bigger than this. I don't need to be told by anyone that Newcastle are one of best supported clubs around. Everything is geared to be successful, and I hope I can bring success. I know what I have to do to be successful here. "This is arguably the best squad I have ever worked with but I know that I have to win something. The players know that and, although I'm coming in with my own ideas, there won't be any dramatic changes." "I'm so excited to be here I can't tell you - my vocabulary doesn't extend that far. I have played and worked at some big clubs before but this is up there with any of them. I can only relate to my own experience. (speaking about the alleged problems Sir Bobby Robson had with some of the squad) "When I was 22 I went to Liverpool thinking I knew all the answers. I learned far more from senior players about football and how to live my life away from it. "I was beaten up verbally by senior professionals at Liverpool. "You might have your players for two hours a day. The senior players have a big part to play in terms of educating the younger ones."Too much emphasis was put on the disciplinary procedures here after Sir Bobby was let go in the midst of talk about how certain players were taking advantage of his old age. Souness would have been better off in the army rather than at Newcastle as he proceeded to take the club back a long, long way in less than one season. After finishing fourth, third and fifth United were down in 14th by the end of the 2004/05 season. Arguably the worst (full time, don't worry John) manager in Newcastle's Premier League history. Did He Deliver? No!
4. Sir Bobby Robson

"I have got a massive job ahead of me. It's a great challenge and I am up for it. There is no need for panic here. "I thought Barcelona was a big club but I think this has just pipped that. "It's a lovely sunny day - a great day to be manager of Newcastle United."There's quite literally no need to analyse these. The great man's record speaks for itself. Did He Deliver? Hell Yeah!
3. Ruud Gullit

"Chelsea is out of my system now although I feel I'm a better manager for my experience. I prefer to play good football but I will have to see just how good the players I have inherited are. "But if I can bring entertainment into it as well I will be a happy, happy man. "I've always enjoyed going to clubs who haven't been successful for a while. I like to go somewhere and start again, although my philosophy is to work day-to-day rather than think months ahead. "I don't know whether this will be a big enough club to fulfil my ambitions but I certainly hope so. I believe that you have to build things step- by-step and that's what I will be doing here. I know I am the third manager to be at Newcastle in 20 months, but I know what it feels like to be on the way out also. "One of the most important things is that we enjoy it with the fans, and I hope I can have a good relationship with them."An FA Cup final simply wasn't good enough from Gullit who left United less than a month into the 1999/00 season with the club bottom of the Premier League. His brand of football at Chelsea got him the Newcastle job as Freddy Shepherd saw him as a Kevin Keegan mark 2, but as good as that was in the beginning he simply didn't win enough games to make it viable. To be fair to him however, he didn't promise to bring success, he guaranteed entertainment. And Magpies' fans certainly got that, even if they had no finger nails left by the end of it. Did He Deliver? Sort Of!
2. Kenny Dalglish
