Newcastle 0-1 Sheffield Wednesday – Player Ratings & Analysis

Disgraceful.

"Oh for gods sake Florian" shouted Steve McClaren as Florian Thauvin misplaced his fourth pass in just 28 minutes at St James' Park where Newcastle United faced Championship side Sheffield Wednesday (who rested 10 first team players) in the Capital One Cup. The Magpies' boss then turned round in disgust and slumped back onto the bench shaking his head and muttering expletives to himself. It's an all to familiar scenario and I'm unsure as to what McClaren's thinking is behind it. Since the opening day of the season, the former Derby boss has flamboyantly swung his arms around the dugout and thrown a few f-bombs into the wind but rather than it demonstrate an intimate passion for the game it appears more like a non-football fan trying to fit in at the local boozer as his pals try to concentrate on what is actually happening. What is happening, is a man who was very lucky to get a job in the Premier League currently looks like a man who was very lucky to get a job in the Premier League. His Newcastle side appeared shapeless, naive and short on confidence against a Sheffield Wednesday reserve team and whether it's a dishevelled bark at Georginio Wijnaldum to inform him of his ball-collecting duties or a petulant notepad throw it further identifies how far McClaren is out of his depth at St James' Park. A Lewis McGugan strike (that Tim Krul should have saved) proved to be the difference - a player who struggled to break into Watford's team over the past two seasons. The supposed world class ability of Wijnaldum, Moussa Sissoko and Siem de Jong among others was simply non-existent and the Magpies now go into two league games against Chelsea and Manchester City without a cup run to even hang onto.

1. Tim Krul - 2

Should have saved the shot that gave Sheffield Wednesday the win. His leadership and kicking was below par.

2. Daryl Janmaat - 5 (Replaced At 45 By Kevin Mbabu)

Once more, the only player on the pitch who looks like he can doing anything going forward.

3. Jamaal Lascelles - 5

Possibly the only positive to come from tonight was Jamaal Lascelles performance. Looked decent in the air and was relatively composed throughout the game.

4. Mike Williamson - 3

Shouldn't be anywhere near the team regardless it's the League Cup or not. Another Steve McClaren blunder.

5. Chancel Mbemba - 4

Right well we've acknowledged that Mbemba can't play left-back...

6. Vurnon Anita - 3

As usual, a fairly decent performance positionally from Anita but his passing is woeful.

7. Georginio Wijnaldum - 3

I'm struggling to understand how a player of Wijnaldum's quality can't do anything against a Championship side's reserve team. Hopeless.

8. Moussa Sissoko - 2

Imagine claiming to be good enough for the Champions League and not being able to influence a game against Championship opposition. Sissoko's worst game of the season.

9. Florian Thauvin - 2 (Replaced by Ayoze Perez 45')

Thauvin doesn't show enough for the ball and when he does he looses it. Needs to improve quickly.

10. Gabriel Obertan - 2 (Replaced by Ivan Toney)

Hopeless. Doesn't do anything. Seriously he is one of the worst footballers I have ever seen.

11. Siem de Jong - 3

He should have scored and it's becoming a problem as the chances keep falling to him. Looks very short of confidence.

12. Steve McClaren - 3

He didn't put out a bad team but he still doesn't have a plan B and looks terrifyingly out of his depth.

Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-accredited football writer with an MA in Sports Journalism. What Culture football editor. Write for the official Newcastle United programme. Former video reporter at North News. Featured and published in the Sunderland Echo, Shields Gazette, Mail Online, The Mirror, The Sun and others.