Ranking Every Liverpool Transfer Under Jürgen Klopp

Assembling the best team in club football.

Upon arriving at Liverpool, Jurgen Klopp dubbed himself "The Normal One". It should be clear by now he's anything but that. Many traits set the founder of "heavy metal football" apart from the lot of managers. His tactical brio is undisputable. His man-management is unmatched, as he always finds the key to unlock a player's hidden potential. His cool-dad attitude and subtle elegance bespeak that behind the great coach lies a great man.

Liverpool's transfer business under his tenure has been remarkable. The 2016 squad was very decent but still lacking, and almost every area of the pitch had its problem. The answer given by Klopp, Michael Edwards and the oft-neglected Ian Graham has almost always been the right one. They don't panic-buy, they don't binge-sign. Each season, a couple of players are brought in for specific reasons, and they (almost) all more than repay their price. Klopp always has long-term future in mind and to that regard, it's telling that out of the 15 players who joined the team in the four years he's been there, only two, Klavan and Solanke, have already left the club.

Let's take a look into how he built a team that can, since last Saturday, call itself the best in club football.

(PS: Loan signings aren't taken into account, so Steven Caulker doesn't feature)

16. Alex Manninger

We did say that only 15 players joined the team under Klopp, and while it's technically untrue, the thing is Manninger doesn't really count. That's not to say signing him in 2016 was a bad piece of business, not at all. It's just that it wasn't really transfer business. It was more like appointing a new staff member.

The Austrian veteran, who won a Premier League title with Arsenal back in 1998, returned to England on a free transfer. He's had an honourable career, mostly being a back-up goalie for sides all across Europe. During his one year at Liverpool, he spent more time at Melwood than Anfield, effectively serving as an unofficial goalkeeper coach. It's hard to judge whether he did well given the lack of information. Karius and Mignolet didn't significantly improved after he arrived, but expecting that would've been unrealistic. An article published on Liverpool's official website acknowledged Manninger as a "positive presence" who offered " unwavering support and advice". That's the best he could've done.


15. Dominic Solanke

Dom may be the only clear-cut flop of Liverpool's transfer business under Klopp. Viewers of the 2017 U-20 World Cup could see in Solanke a strong, elegant player, who often led the line as a target forward. The Benteke style, as experience proved, doesn't suit Liverpool though, and so it was crucial that Solanke also seemed able to play in behind the striker as a creative n°10, showcasing his abilities to dribble, turn himself on goal or link-up with his teammates. He brought home a winner's medal, the Player of the Tournament Award and a Liverpool deal.

He did look promising in his first couple of games. But come the end of the season, when the only positive thing you can say about a player who's received so much game time is that he has potential, it may be time to reconsider. Solanke had chance after chance to prove himself, but never delivered. By the end of the season, he registered one last-day goal and two assists. Nothing in comparison to his many failed chances (Burnley, Everton, Leicester in the EFL Cup).

Divock Origi just came out of a season where he had scored 11 and assisted three. Solanke had a better pre-season, but was it really worth taking a gamble on him, meanwhile sending Origi, a very decent back-up, who knew the team and the playing system, on loan at Wolfsburg, a move from which his confidence never recovered ? At the end of the day, the best thing Solanke brought to Liverpool is the £19M from his Bournemouth sell.


14. Marko Grujić

The trouble with gauging Grujić's transfer is that he spent most of his time away from Liverpool. If you judge him by his performances on loan, he's surely a good player. But if you ask what he's offered Liverpool in the last three years, the answer is nothing (or an assist in an EFL Cup match against Tottenham, which is pretty much the same).

His loan spells have been fantastic, and would've granted him a run in the first team at many other clubs. Both at Cardiff City and Hertha Berlin, he made his presence felt in midfield. Cardiff's boss was begging for the Serbian to return for another season. Hertha Berlin's manager was even more flattering, as he claimed the youngster, who registered five goals and an assist last season, was "Hertha Berlin's best midfielder in 20 years."

He will reportedly be sold this season, having only played 14 times for the club. Many would have hoped for Klopp's first ever Liverpool transfer not to end so bitterly. It's a shame that a team which had to settle for the likes of Jay Spearing and Alberto Aquilani a couple of years ago is now so midfield-packed that they must turn down Grujić. Right place, wrong time lad.


13. Loris Karius

loris karius
Sky Sports

The final verdict on Karius is straightforward: he's not good enough. He never really was.

Signed for only £6M, fresh off being named Bundesliga's second best goalkeeper of the season behind Manuel Neuer, he looked a wise acquisition. But, just as a backroom staff member from Mainz put it, Karius has been unrecognisable since joining Liverpool. He's had his moments some say. But did he? Karius can claim two decent spells, one in autumn 2016 and one in the first five months of 2018. The first one ended in disaster at Bournemouth, the second ended in Kiev's embarrassment.

It's not just his mistakes. These happen: Alisson nonsensically gave a goal away at Leicester four games into this season. But he, unlike Karius, gives an enduring sense of composure and security to the team. The German is currently playing in the Turkish Süper Lig, and that he doesn't fly high above the rest of keepers says it all. Put Alisson in that Besiktas team and they'd probably win the league, or at the very least they'd concede the fewest goals. Put Karius in this Liverpool team, and Tottenham surely would've scored one or two in the final.


12. Naby Keita

With Liverpool finally winning the cup with the big ears, many players have made the headlines. Van Dijk, Salah and Mané are strong candidates for the Ballon d'Or. Robertson and Alexander-Arnold are praised as arguably the best full-backs in the world. Alisson showed again why he is one of the world's finest. Origi further cemented his status of cult hero. Henderson's finally getting the acclaim he deserves. It's been a glorious season for the Reds, and one in which Naby Keita, truth be told, has been a complete afterthought.

It was hard not to get excited, as the highlight videos from his Leipzig performances were mouth-watering. This writer remembers comments on Liverpool forums predicting Keita would "take the Premier League by storm" and was "the missing piece to win the title". And just look at the title of this article. Reality hit hard.

Keita's technique is apparent from the minute he touches a ball, as is his desire to drive it forward and play good-looking football. But his decision-making is off. No one denies he's a good dribbler and a good passer: the problem is he dribbles when he shouldn't and doesn't pass when he should. His positioning and tactical awareness have been merely okay. Two goals and one assist are depressingly disappointing stats.

That being said, Keita is 24. If he manages to find his form next season and is lucky not to get injured, he can become an amazing player. That means there's a possibility that in one year's time, Klavan being ahead of him in this list could sound absolutely foolish. But as of now...


11. Ragnar Klavan

After being a sort of cult figure, "Lord" Klavan has been quickly forgotten. The emergence of Joe Gomez, the rebirth of Matip and the signing of Van Dijk meant he wasn't really missed. Yet, during his two year-spell, he has been a very dependable soldier in Klopp's army.

The record-tying six-time Estonian Footballer of the Year was bought for a fourth of Lovren's £20M fee and regularly looked as good if not better. His time at the club wasn't without blunders, but it's fair to say he did well overall. He was experienced, more comfortable on the ball than Lovren, and left-footed, which is always a good thing to have in a back four. Switching between 4th and 3rd choice, on his day he had some fans clamoring for a starting role. A man of the match performance at Goodison Park in 2016 and an unforgettable last-minute winning goal against Burnley are the highlights of his career in red.

He was sold to Cagliari for £2M in 2018, an acceptable offer for a 31 year old back-up. A reliable defender with a good price to performance ratio, Klavan was a sensible piece of business if not an eye-catching one.


10. Xherdan Shaqiri

Notwithstanding the now-legendary front three, Liverpool's attack going into last season looked slim. Sturridge and Origi were sub-par (even if it hurts to write this), Danny Ings was understandably allowed to leave, Rhian Brewster was still injured and Harry Wilson wasn't deemed ready. In this context, signing Shaqiri from Stoke City on a £12M fee was a masterstroke.

A versatile footballer, who can be casted as a wide forward or as an offensive midfielder, with a devilish left-foot renowned for its set-piece wonders and long-range stunners, Shaqiri is the prototype of a top-team squad player. He isn't quite there to be an undisputed starter amongst Europe's finest, but any team in the world would like to have him as a substitute. Six goals and five assists from 30 appearances (mostly as a sub) are satisfying stats.

The last six months of the season have been frustrating for Shaq, as he barely played. The general consensus as for why is that his lack of tactical discipline leaves the team too wide open. As Josh Williams suggested on the Liverpool Echo, he brings more chaos than control. This lack of game-time has led some to speculate that a move away was on the cards for this summer. Fortunately, fans can trust that Klopp knows better. Shaqiri is a sound attacking option, young enough to keep improving, and could still offer a lot to Liverpool. If Klopp's tactical requirements sink in, and he increases his defensive workrate, he could reach the next level.


9. Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain

It's impressive how quick it took Chamberlain to evolve into a completely different player under Klopp. At Arsenal, he was a bland winger, whose speed didn't make up for his lack of end-product and creativity. The kind of player that's only good on FIFA because of his acceleration stats. Thankfully, Klopp's reasoning delves a little deeper than that. He turned the England international into a tactically aware, ball-playing, proper offensive midfielder, with a rare mix of speed and strength. He went from Bellerinish to Seedorfesque. From gazelle to ox.

Last season Chamberlain assisted eight and scored five, including that stunner against Man City in the UCL. His goals against Man City (in the league) and assists against Newcastle and West Brom highlight what's maybe his biggest quality: he's able to run through the opposition's horizontal lines, to get past those midfield players with ease. He then has the shooting or passing skills to make the most out of his incursions. Straightforwardness, impact, industry: just what was ironically lacking when he was a Gunner.

The Ox could very well be Liverpool's secret weapon for next season. His comeback cameo against Watford reminded fans of how he could dynamise an already electric midfield. With such quality players around him and what must be a burning desire to return to his best, it's likely that Chamberlain's apex is yet to come.


8. Joel Matip

Burton Albion v Liverpool: EFL Cup Joel Matip
2016 Getty Images

It seemed like a huge step forward in solving Liverpool's defensive issues when Klopp signed Matip on a free transfer in January 2016. Composed, dominant in the air and positionally acute, on his day, Matip looks like Van Dijk's little brother, and while he can't match Virgil's leadership, long-range passing ability and overall defensive quality, his quick vertical ground passes and surprisingly flawless forward runs are something he brings to the team that the Dutch colossus doesn't. Had Matip played at his best during his three seasons in a Reds shirt, he'd crack the top 5 without a doubt.

Unfortunately, Matip only revealed himself as the player Liverpool fans hoped he was in spells. The rest of the time, he was either injured or going through a poor run of form. When he's been bad, he's been really bad, backheel-clearance-in-the-area bad. He was erratic, panicky, and running everywhere on the pitch except where he should.

Not many bet on him this season, but after Gomez' November injury, he once again stepped up, and thrived alongside Van Dijk, occasionally outshining him. Has he finally found his feet once and for all ? His recent performance in the Champions League final was magisterial, and he should be in the starting XI going into next season. If they want to claim his spot, Lovren and (more realistically) Gomez have no small hill to climb.


7. Fabinho

A seventh place may feel harsh for Fabinho, but it's only due to the quality of the players yet to come. Fans do owe him a big thanks for finally solving the defensive midfielder situation that had been going on since the departure of Javier Mascherano. The Argentinean moved to Barcelona in 2010, and in the eight years since, Liverpool's only decent defensive midfielder has been Lucas Leiva. Can, Lallana, Henderson, Wijnaldum or Milner, Shelvey or Charlie Adam, and most obviously Gerrard: every Liverpool midfielder in the last couple of years was better at attacking than defending.

News that the Reds had signed Fabinho on a long-term deal was met by fans with surprise and delight, but probably more of the later (even more so considering that there was strong speculation of a move to Manchester United). After undergoing Klopp's usual treatment of sitting out games until deemed trained enough, he went for that n°6 role and put it in his pocket, along with a whole bunch of Premier League forwards.

How pleasing must it be for Liverpool fans, and for Klopp, to finally have that player who can break up the opposition's play, intercept key passes, commit smart fouls and build counter-attacks from the back. Fab is now a guaranteed starter and at only 25, shows a very promising learning curve. The Premier League title is within Liverpool's reach, and he will be a central piece of that journey for the seasons to come.


6. Georginio Wijnaldum

A couple of months ago, I asked my 10 year old cousin if he knew who Paul Pogba was. Of course he told me, dabbing joyfully. Then I asked if he knew who Georgino Wijnaldum was. He had no idea.

If you were to name the most underrated midfielder in the Premier League, not just this season but in the last couple of seasons, Wijnaldum would be the most serious contender. He's intelligent, hard-working and versatile, he has a habit of scoring when it matters and, as he proved once more against Busquets and Arthur in the Champions League, his ball retention skills are second to none. As a midfielder, he's like Eminem. He rips it any style you want: assured in possession, dynamic in defense and dangerous going forward. Yet in discussions about PFA's Team of the Year, he wasn't even mentioned as a potential replacement for Pogba.

Even Liverpool supporters sometime seem to forget how much he contributed to this team's success. He was Liverpool's top playmaker in his first season with 11 assists. He scored massive goals against Man City, Chelsea, Middlesbrough, Roma, Cardiff and, obviously, Barcelona. And this year, he finally did away with his oft-criticized tendency to disappear away from home. No doubt when we'll look back years from now, we'll remember Wijnaldum as a standout of the Klopp era.


5. Alisson

"We simply identified another keeper, who is better, and signed him."

£66M is expensive. A Champions League and the 3rd best Premier League points tally of all time is priceless. Liverpool can now pride themselves on having a serious candidate for the title of best goalkeeper in the world, and when was the last time, if ever, that they could have said that? Alisson's career in red has been triumphant so far.

His Champions League MOTM display (Van Dijk & Matip could also claim that) was just the last in a season full of spellbinding performances. The excellence of his positioning makes most of his saves look easy, as is the case with every great keeper. But heart-stopping miracle saves have also defined his campaign, be it against Chelsea, Napoli, Everton, Watford or Cardiff. He's arguably more responsible for Liverpool's historical slaying of Barcelona than Origi or Wijnaldum. He's won the Premier League Golden Glove in his first season, and you'd be careless to bet on it being his last.

Improving a squad is simple. Identify another player, who is better, and sign him.


4. Andy Robertson

Both Alisson and Robbo have been stellar, but the reason we've given the edge to the Scotsman is simple: an £8M price tag. This isn't a bargain, this is robbery (robbory anyone ? No ? ...). He cost 15M less than Aurier, 22M less than Lindelöf, 42M less than Mendy, and you won't see them in the PFA Team of the Year anytime soon.

You could say Robertson has been the opposite of Keita: expectations were low for a recently relegated Hull City player, but he turned out to be, excuse the cliché, world class. He is the best left-footed crosser in the league, no less. His strong presence, sustained focus and apt decision-making are a breath of fresh air after years of Alberto Moreno. Unlike the Spaniard, he can actually track back, cover up space and tackle without being reckless. A Wolverine-like pain endurance allows him to run up and down his wing from the first minute to the last, always positioning himself where he's useful. Only Firmino possibly matches his workrate.

In many ways, Robertson's an old school left-back. He's not the type to take players on or leave his position like Marcelo. He's the type to make the right runs at the right time, and expertly cross the ball. You won't see him trying to do stepovers or elasticos next season, but you'll probably see him reach double figures for assists once more.


3. Sadio Mané

Easily the best dribbler in the Reds squad, and one of the best in the world, Mané has dropped players on their asses and fans' jaws on the floor for three years now. Add to that his borderline genius movement and his natural ability to make the goal-alert of the referee's watch go off, and no doubt could be left in your mind as to why he's amongst the best forwards on the planet.

Now many Liverpool fans will admit this, but when he was first signed in 2017, disappointment was the overwhelming feeling in the fanbase. We wanted Götze, Reus or Draxler. Not yet another player from Southampton. Three seasons of Mané later, and the question on every Liverpool fan's lip can only be: "What the hell's a Götze?"

After falling a bit under the radar last season, in the shadow of Salah and Firmino's earth-shaking seasons, Mané reclaimed his superstar status in 2018-2019, scoring 26 in all competitions (just one fewer than Salah), taking home the Premier League Golden Boot, and being in fact the only member of the front three to feature in UEFA's Champions League Squad of the Season as well as in the PFA's Player of the Year shortlist.

If he can light the CAN on fire (ideally win it) and produce a strong start to next season, Mané could do what Eto'o, Drogba and Touré couldn't, and get his hands on that shiny golden ball...


2. Mohamed Salah

The usual anti-conformist smartasses are already branding him overrated, but do we actually even realize how good Mo Salah is? Time will tell where his record-breaking ascension will take him, but as of now, he deserves all the praise that's been coming his way.

What do you point to? His individual achievements? PFA Player of the Year in his first season, fifth on the Ballon d'Or, Premier League Golden Boot twice in a row? His yet-to-stop goalscoring spree? He, not Agüero, not Henry, not Cristiano Ronaldo, is the all-time record scorer for a Premier League season. He, not Owen, not Suarez, not Torres, is the quickest Liverpool player to reach 50 goals.

It's not only the quantity, but the quality. His goals against Watford, Bournemouth, Everton, Southampton or AS Roma were the stuff Ballon d'Or winners are made off. His dazzling speed, top-notch linking up, superb cutting skills and extraordinary ability to conjure up goals out of nothing are the stuff that lives on in fans' memories for ages. It may seem far-fetched to suggest so now, but if Salah stays with Liverpool long enough, he may become the club's best striker ever.

Klopp reportedly told Coutinho that if he left, he'd be just another player, but if he stayed, he could end up having a statue to his name. That didn't happen. Let's hope Salah doesn't make the same mistake.


1. Virgil Van Dijk

When £75 million feels like an absolute bargain, you're in the presence of a special player. Virgil is something else. He makes the difference.

Ryan Babel bragged to have identified Van Dijk's weakness back in march. Understandably, it was met with universal laughter. Speed or strength, tackling or heading, playing the ball out from the back or passing it 40 yards, anticipation or aerial challenges, he's got it all. His nerves are made of steel, his natural authority make him the commander any back line needs, and it seems easier to uproot a sequoia bare-handed than dribble past him. He can even shoot. The data backs up what is clear for all to see on the pitch.

OptaJoe reported that in Van Dijk's last 64 apps, not a single player dribbled past him, Son being the last one to unsuccessfully attempt it in the UCL final. Since he arrived at Anfield, no player has recorded more clean sheets in the Premier League (30). This season he was first for most won challenges (77%) and aerial duels (76,2%).

If this Liverpool team keeps on achieving greatness, we quite possibly will have no one to thank more than Virgil. At 27, he has the potential to be the greatest defender of his generation. Don't believe it ? Wait and see.


Contributor

Reppin' the land of smurfs and chocolate. Interested in everything, and nothing else.