10 Terrible Star Trek Episodes With Awesome Endings
Further proof that Star Trek knows how to stick the landing, even on shaky flights
We can all single out our favourite awesome ending to a Star Trek episode. There are certainly plenty to choose from. Some are grandiose and dramatic, and are often the midway of a two-parter. Others are more understated, but equally as effective — Kirk's "Let's get the hell out of here" and Barclay's "Computer. End program!" for example. Others still have capped off a chef-d'oeuvre with little more than a hearty belly laugh on the bridge.
An awesome ending typically also means an awesome rest of an episode has gone before it. That final payoff has to feel earnt, after all. Sometimes, however, a great ending must swing in to bolster a not so great episode. Thankfully, this list took some time to compile, for there are very few examples in Star Trek of the bad needing last minute rescue by the good where quality is concerned.
An awesome ending doesn't mean redemption for a terrible episode either. It simply means they stuck the landing. In some cases, however, a conclusion (even years later) has provided at least a fresh perspective on a previously maligned part of the franchise.
So, like Data with a punchline to a bad joke, let's have a look at those episodes that got there in the end.
10. Fair Haven
With our sincerest apologies to Seán Ferrick and this writer's paternal grandfather, we're about to take a trip to Tom Paris' interpretation of 19th century Ireland. Get ready for some dodgy accents, and even dodgier signage!
Beyond the stereotypes and lack of a competent dialect coach, what is no doubt least fair about Fair Haven is the episode's treatment of Captain Janeway's love life. After all those years guiding Voyager safely through the Delta Quadrant, sacrificing romance for responsibility, Janeway deserved better than a dalliance on the holodeck. No offense, Doc! Plus, if you can ask the computer to stop your partner snoring, don't ask too many questions!
Whilst Fair Haven struggled on many fronts, it was the head of a neutronic storm that saved it. When Voyager begins to lose the inverse warp field it was using as an anchor, the only solution is to use a deflector beam to cut their way through the rest. To get the power they need will mean saying farewell to most of Fair Haven and maybe a certain Michael Sullivan.
For a moment, thanks to some superb acting from Kate Mulgrew, you can see all of the consequences of the decision to re-route power from the holodeck in Janeway's regretful expression, but it's only a moment. "Do it!" she orders, never forgetting her duty. Seconds later, we are also treated to one of the most awesome lines ever uttered in Star Trek: "Scrape the residual ions off the sonic showers if you have to!"
Oh, and "Delete the wife!"
9. A Mathematically Perfect Redemption
"You know what? Peanut Hamper is a stupid name!" Things have got to be pretty bad to annoy D'Vana Tendi. That's exactly what this exocomp did, however, when she beamed herself off the Cerritos to avoid saving the day in No Small Parts.
It's no secret that the direct follow up to that episode didn't win many fans here at TrekCulture. In fact, I'm thoroughly surprised I haven't been ejected from Cargo Bay 101 for bringing it up! Sure, all that was wrong with A Mathematically Perfect Redemption was the detestable central character and their entire story arc, but that's literally Peanut's! You know what, I blame Data!
The clue, however, was very much in the name. If 'Peanut Hamper' was the "mathematically perfect," yet pointedly absurdist ("stupid"), choice, we probably shouldn't have expected anything less than ridiculous from the ending of the exocomp's noddingly titled second episode.
In A Mathematically Perfect Redemption, Peanut Hamper's supposed change of heart, then most definitely not as she betrays everyone at the end, doubly subverts our expectations. In Star Trek, we're used to things and people turning out just fine, so it's a bit of a shock when they don't. Looking back at the title of the episode, we then realise they'd been telling us that the ending, like the name, would be irredeemably "stupid" all along! And that is redeemably awesome!
Now, can we all just focus on trying to teach Tyrannikillicus how to be friendly? [evil laughter]
8. Hatchery
This late outing of Star Trek: Enterprise's third season is more of an oddity than it is out-and-out terrible. After they'd obtained the coordinates from Degra through… creative means, it took the crew of the NX-01 a while to get to the Xindi staging ground Azati Prime. It's the stretching-out of that journey that gave us Hatchery.
Spoiler alert: Captain Archer gets sprayed in the face by a dangling appendage in a room full of sacs — eggs aboard a crashed Xindi insectoid ship, to be more precise. Unbeknownst to even Doctor Phlox at first, the spray had caused Archer to "reverse imprint on the baby insectoids." He became obsessed, going to greater and greater lengths to protect the hatchlings, and in doing so endangered the mission. Eventually, his senior staff decided enough was enough.
Although not a unique idea for Star Trek, Hatchery is saved from the madness by the idea for a mutiny at its end. As the situation with Archer went from bad to worse, the members of Starfleet realised they had to intervene (before they ran out of antimatter, for a start) to relieve the Captain of his command. The same level-headed thinking couldn't be said of the MACOs, who, so obsessed with 'following the chain of command' above all else, would have probably gone skinny-dipping in the warp core if the Captain had ordered them to. The Starfleet crew were then forced to seize the bridge (and ship) from MACO control in dramatic fashion.
7. Encounter At Farpoint
If we're honest, Star Trek: The Next Generation had to work to achieve a greatness that was none too evident in its pilot episode. If you skip ahead about three and a half seasons, it's almost like you're watching a completely different show (for a multitude of behind the scenes reasons). Encounter At Farpoint is, in essence, two scripts forced together that don’t quite work: something about giant space jellyfish and an omnipotent letter of the alphabet that freezes people. "Captain. I'm sensing a powerful mind" in these knee-high boots.
Accounts are contradictory for the finer detail, but the general idea, as reported in the 2014 documentary Chaos on the Bridge, is that Encounter At… was originally a 90-minute script written by veteran Star Trek: The Original Series and Star Trek: The Animated Series writer/story editor D.C. Fontana. Fontana's draft focussed exclusively on the mystery of Farpoint Station and on assembling the new crew. Gene Roddenberry then took Fontana's script and added the Q character to bump it up to two hours as the network had wanted.
"To this day, I have no idea what that episode was about," former Paramount President John Pike said in Chaos on the Bridge. "It didn't really even have an ending," Pike (not that one!) later noted. That's not strictly true, however. Encounter At Farpoint's saving grace is its very last, now iconic, Picard line that was the shape of things to come: "Let's see what's out there. Engage!"
6. Spock's Brain
Yes, we know. You're probably thinking we've all lost our minds too. It's the episode that's regularly voted as one of the worst of all of Star Trek. Even its lacklustre title feels like they'd just given up as The Original Series entered its third season. Budget cuts were going on, and, unfortunately, they began most literally with Spock's Brain.
So terrible an episode is Spock's Brain that it has often been used as a marker by which other terrible episodes are judged. For example, the 2008 reference book Star Trek 101: A Practical Guide to Who, What, Where, and Why gave out the 'Spock's Brain Award' to the worst episode of each of the then series. Leonard Nimoy is also on record as having been "embarrassed" throughout the filming of the episode, as he described the process in his autobiography I Am Spock.
There is no way of getting around the simply bonkers concept of Spock's Brain, but then maybe we don't have to. We can just lie back and enjoy its equally crazy ending in which Doctor McCoy downloads into his brain all the advanced surgical knowledge he needs (from 'The Teacher') to reattach Spock's brain. Halfway through, McCoy starts to lose this knowledge and has to reconnect Spock's speech centre so that his own patient, Spock, can help him with the rest of the operation. It's silly, it's fun, it's Star Trek. That's awesome enough for us.
5. Star Trek: Nemesis
At the time of its release in 2002, Star Trek: Nemesis was panned by fans and critics alike. Without the box office receipts, it put paid to a follow-up movie for The Next Generation crew and taxed the rest of the franchise with 'fatigue,' hoisted by its own title! Nemesis isn't an episode of television (aside from the Voyager one), but by now it is, for all intents and purposes, a mini-series that you must watch before Star Trek: Picard, and really before Star Trek: Lower Decks and Star Trek: Prodigy too.
Looking back at the film in strict isolation, we can reproach Nemesis for its over-reliance on action sequences, some of which (and you know which) border on the absurd. The central premise of 'mistreated clone come to seek vengeance on the Federation via a magical new superweapon' was also arguably not strong enough to carry an entire movie. Then, of course, Nemesis tried to pull off a double allegory with Data and B-4/Picard and Shinzon, but p**sed everyone off instead with the most senseless death of a beloved character.
We've now got to spend a good deal more time with the Next Gen crew and, most notably here, we've had rebirth and resolution for Data, thanks to B-4. In that way, the ending to Nemesis is no longer a disappointing and dangling conclusion, but the awesome set-up for something much bigger (and better). It can't redeem the film as a whole, but it does place it within the properness of context that we'd begun to think it would never have.
4. The Disease
It's the one where Harry Kim gets a space STD, and not without irony, from a member of a supposedly xenophobic species, the Varro. We also learnt that if you want to have sex in Starfleet, you might need to ask the Captain first. I think the 'birds and the bees' might have flown out the airlock a while back. Harry was glowing, but sadly the episode wasn't, save for its final few scenes.
Although finely acted, the love affair between Harry and Derran Tal in The Disease never quite felt as overwhelmingly intense as it was meant to be. In fact, it is only towards the end of Act Four and into Act Five that the episode really reaches its stride. Janeway must reprimand Harry once more for his actions and dismisses him to sickbay. Instead, he follows the Captain from the conference room to the ready room, pleading his case in a pretty awesome tracking shot across the bridge.
There is also some excellent CGI work in those last scenes — particularly the shot of Voyager on its side as it decouples from the generational ship. Ultimately, however, it's the conversation between Janeway and Kim in sickbay that caps the episode. Janeway opens up to Kim in an honest exchange and shows her protective, caring side. The Varro generational ship has fragmented, but the crew of Voyager are more united than ever — not as Starfleet officers, but as a family.
3. Coming Home
If we're including the season four finale of Star Trek: Discovery on this list, then it's not because the episode was terrible per se, but that it came to conclude what was an imperfect season in general that often fell afoul of its overarching plot, stretched to its limit across 13 episodes.
No sooner was Discovery out of the gate in what was looking to be a bit of a brighter galaxy after the resolution to the Burn, than yet another doomsday event was set in motion with the Dark Matter Anomalies (DMAs). We weren't even given the first episode to catch our breath before disaster kicked in.
What the ending to the DMA crisis provided, however, was something distinctly spectacular. We might have been teased with all sorts of candidates for Species 10-C — from the Q to the Nacene to the Metrons to the Iconians — but the actual choice was innovative and truly in the spirit of Star Trek, aided by outstanding visual effects.
The 'coming home' to Earth, and of Earth to the Federation, at the very end of the episode also felt like a welcome return to basics for Discovery itself. With season five soon to air as the show's last, Coming Home, as an episode and a title, is ever more prescient. Discovery now has to finish what it started.
2. Anomaly
Sorry, Enterprise, it's another third season episode. We did actually enjoy that season as a whole. Promise! Only the second episode in, Anomaly has received some of the strongest criticism (and rightly so) for its depiction of torture as used by Captain Archer on an Osaarian prisoner. For a Starfleet officer, and an episode of Star Trek, this is 'terrible' in the sense of 'causing terror,' and 'awe-some' when that is mixed with fear.
As the episode reaches its climax, fear is the theme for everyone on board the NX-01. Using the information Archer has 'obtained,' the crew is engaged in a fight with an Osaarian ship in order to get hold of its Xindi database. Things are touch-and-go for a bit — the sparks fly, and Enterprise loses its hull plating before Hoshi completes (90% of) the download. All things considered, it's a rather decent space battle.
Whatever your thoughts on the episode, the fact also remains that it happened — it's there now for us all to watch as a part of canon. The same applies to Archer by the episode's end. He has done what he's done but will have to atone for it later. For now, he must get on with the mission. Played just on the edge between stoic and guilt-ridden by Scott Bakula, Archer walks into the command centre. Shrouded by the darkness that fills most of the room, he simply says, "Computer. Load the Xindi database."
1. Tuvix
Yep. You read that right. Hold on to your orchids because we're going there!
Normally in good fun, Tuvix never fails to divide fans down the middle more than the man himself. What began as a transporter accident, fairly commonplace for Star Trek, turned into something dreadfully, gloriously, more. We all know what happened at the end, but what's terrible about Tuvix is that we're still picking sides.
It's not unusual to read 'Janeway murdered Tuvix,' and then to scroll down to find 'Janeway was right [to sacrifice Tuvix].' The actors have also weighed in over the years. As Kate Mulgrew herself said on Twitter back in 2020,
Willing to hear the crew's thoughts, as always. However, shouldn't Tuvok and Neelix have the biggest say… oh, wait, they couldn't! I stand by my decision to restore them to their lives.
However, the episode already sets up the duality in its final act:
Tuvix: "Captain, what you're considering is an execution…"
Janeway: "Aren't you arguing for an execution too? Of Tuvok and Neelix?"
In all of this, we've been missing the point. It's not about which side you're on, or who is right or wrong, but the luxury of the debate. That is something we, the viewer, can afford, but that Janeway, as Captain, in the end could not. "There isn't an answer. […] It was an opportunity to show [Janeway] making the really tough decisions which captains are faced with," as Tuvix scriptwriter Kenneth Biller stated in Cinefantastique, Vol. 28, No. 4-5. Either way, the final decision is hers, and, here, inaction is a choice the same as action.
It is, then, not the choice Janeway makes, but the fact that she makes one which gives the ending of Tuvix its enduring power. Or, in other words, "Holy s**t. Janeway didn't mess around." After all, it's only because she made a decision that we can argue over it all these years later.