10 Times Star Trek Went Woke
Star Trek was never WOKE in the past! Give me ONE example! OK, another ONE! OK, another...
What does it mean to go 'Woke'? How does Star Trek, a show from the 1960s, fall under that particular term if it is something that's only become widespread in recent years? On this topic, let's begin with the Merriam-Webster definition. To be Woke is to be:
aware of and actively attentive to important facts and issues (especially issues of racial and social justice)
The term 'Woke' traces its roots back to African American Vernacular English, and more specifically from figures like Marcus Garvey, the musician Lead Belly, and the 1962 Op-Ed 'If You're Woke, You Dig It' by William Melvin Kelley. Early modern examples began to appear in the public consciousness in 2008, with Erykah Badu's song Master Teacher. It gained widespread reach around 2014, when it became linked with the Black Lives Matter movement, particularly in the wake of the shooting of Michael Brown in Ferguson, Missouri.
The word has since been adopted, and coopted, to become a short-hand, dismissive descriptor for those who are more left-leaning. It is used as a catch-all term, with shows, individuals, and entire movements being described as 'Woke' - in an attempt to delegitimize them.
There is a long, sad history of culture theft, particularly from African American communities. While this article uses the word as a deliberate tool to highlight Star Trek's racial and social awareness through the years, TrekCulture is committed to amplifying the origins, and correct meaning of, Woke.
10. We Pledge Allegiance...
The Omega Glory is an ideal first entry on this list as it displays Star Trek trying to say something about racial prejudice, while also sliding right into the very stereotypes it aimed to highlight. It was also one of the initial story pitches that Gene Roddenberry submitted to the network in his attempt to have the show green-lit.
The 'Yangs' and the 'Cohms' are born from the Cold War context in which this episode was written. By its airdate (March 1st, 1968), America had been in a simmering stalemate with the USSR for over twenty years. Those intervening years had seen combat in North and South Korea, with the war in Vietnam now underway as well.
The question of violation of the Prime Directive is very much front and centre here, with the original script going further than the televised version. There, the people of Omega IV are assumed to have developed exactly like Earth, save for a disease that tore their society down. Spock suggests they may even be Human. This was ultimately scrapped.
The Omega Glory sets out to highlight the damage done when so-called 'developed' nations interfere with the progression of others. However, it ends up showing the 'Yangs' as the downtrodden, ultimately 'good' group, with the 'Cohms' - very much styled after Asian stereotypes - serving as the oppressors.
What could have existed in subtext rapidly becomes text when the American Flag, the Pledge of Allegiance, and the American Constitution are all shown to have variants on this world. The episode ends with a moment of Kirk silently admiring said Flag as well.
The Omega Glory, in its attempt to decry intervention, stereotype, and even Imperialism, falls flat on all fronts. It elevates them, thus making this one of the lower-rated episodes of Star Trek.
9. The Endless War
A Taste Of Armageddon was produced roughly mid-way through the Vietnam War. David Gerrold, writer of The Trouble With Tribbles stated that the tallies of the dead on Eminiarian computers were directly inspired by the tallies that began appearing on the nightly news reports by 1967.
The Vietnam War broke out in 1955, lasting through until 1975. By 1967, US forces had been engaged in the War for just over a year. The story for this episode depicts American interventionism ultimately helping the societies they interfere with, even if it's down to the common soldiers to set things right.
Ambassador Robert Fox orders the Enterprise, over Kirk's objections, to open diplomatic negotiations with Eminiar VII. This comes after a clear warning not to approach their planet. Fox then plunges the ship and its crew into a five-hundred-year-old conflict between Eminiar VII and the neighbouring Vendikar.
The episode depicts the rashness of the expansionist policies of the day. Fox orders forced contact. Kirk, and by extension Starfleet, has to clean up Fox's mess - while simultaneously ending a centuries-old War. Kirk disarms one side, calculating that the other side doesn't want a messy affair - a dangerous tactic that pays off. The Ambassador sees the error of his ways when presented with the truth.
There is jingoism here - Starfleet stands in the US Military, and it is a military captain - supported by his crew - who saves the day for everyone. What, then, is the message? Is Star Trek attempting to condemn US involvement in Vietnam? Was it celebrating the troops and their commitment to the fight?
Which, ultimately, is the 'right' view to take?
8. A Policy Of Non-Interference
A Private Little War is one of the most discussed episodes of Star Trek. Its parallels to the Vietnam War are unmissable, though, with this example, the show managed a far more subversive take than in A Taste Of Armageddon.
Kirk's decision to arm Tyree's people is met with shock and confusion from his crew, with Kirk in full possession of the knowledge he's prolonging a conflict. This echoes not only the Vietnam War but the Korean War before it. A Private Little War is the only episode of the show's second season not to feature an upbeat ending score cue.
The episode also introduces Joseph M'Benga, played by Booker Bradshaw, as being not only an expert in his field of medicine but having been personally recommended by Dr. McCoy for his position. Though Star Trek had, of course, introduced Uhura early on (naturally, more on this later), featuring a highly skilled specialist who was a person of colour was a clear statement in 1967.
A Private Little War is one of Star Trek's earliest and strongest attempts to depict not only the failings of the day but the attempt to rectify the wrongs of modern society as well.
7. Are You Blind?
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield is often the first example that comes to mind of Star Trek discussing racism. Bele and Lokai, deliberately designed to be almost identical, fester a hatred based on nothing other than perceived racial and biological inequalities.
This episode is an easy choice when one is asked - when did Star Trek go 'woke'? Though, as discussed in the introduction, the term originated with a far different meaning than when it is used in the pejorative, Battlefield is the quickest response. The final design of Bele and Lokai was an adaptation from the initial script, which had called for an Angelic and a Demonic pairing. This switches the comment to Racial, rather than Religious, strife.
Bele's indignant argument against Lokai's equality elicits confusion from Kirk and Spock, who stand in for the audience here. Armin Shimmerman would recall that this episode affected him enormously as a young man, though Harlan Ellison had harsher words regarding not just this episode but Gene Roddenberry himself.
In the February 1997 edition of Vibe magazine, he accused the plot of being too simplistic and heavy-handed, proceeding to direct some personal accusations towards Roddenberry in terms of the latter's liberalism. Battlefield certainly could be a stronger episode overall and suffered from the budgetary issues that plagued the show's third season.
It did take one of the most direct approaches toward commenting on the futility of racism and total war - another reference to the ongoing Vietnam War.
6. Sweet As A Kiss
Plato's Stepchildren is an infamous episode. It contains 'The Kiss' - a moniker that audiences will immediately associate with William Shatner and Nichelle Nichols embracing. Though theirs was not the first interracial kiss on television, nor even the first interracial kiss in Star Trek, it has become the legacy of the show.
However, a far superior moment of 'woke' storytelling, when one remembers that Kirk and Uhura are forced into this kiss, occurs in the discussions around Alexander. He is the lone Platonian without psychokinetic powers thanks to his genetic dwarfism, thus leaving him a servant to his peers.
The episode displays Kirk assuring Alexander that in Starfleet, no one is judged based on their size, shape, or colour. The episode depicts the Platonians' abilities stemming from ingesting a rare substance. This substance is processed by the pituitary hormones, while Alexander's hormones are unable to do the same.
Those Platonians who subjected Alexander to torment did nothing to earn their powers; they are no better than him. This is the crux of the story. Kirk and Spock both ingest the kironide and meet the Platonians on their playing field.
Alexander leaves with the Enterprise by the episode's end, presumably to live a long and productive life in the Federation. While there again remains elements of 'the grass is greener' when it comes to Starfleet, here Alexander's story is one of the more successful attempts to discuss 'there but for the grace of'.
5. Welcome Aboard, Mr. President
The Savage Curtain is a strange episode. For Uhura, it was an ending. This was Nichelle Nichols' final appearance in Star Trek until The Animated Series, though her scene with Lincoln forms the basis for this entry. When aboard the ship, Lincoln refers to her as a "Negress", for which he then apologizes. She assures him that in her time, people respect who they are and that she is not offended.
The context in which the scene is set - featuring Uhura and Abraham Lincoln - lacks any subtly, in true Trek fashion. It is one of the last episodes in the series' run while featuring one of the most explicit references to the Civil Rights Movement to that date. Here, Lincoln is treated as the 'president to end all presidents' - a true hero of a man that all others should aspire to be. Kirk's reaction - including the call for full dress uniforms - highlights this.
Uhura's assurance that people have learned not to be offended by words is at best naive and at worst sugarcoating the power of language. The episode aired barely a year after the assassination of Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., and three years after the assassination of Malcolm X. The United States Civil Rights Movement was facing opposition in almost all directions, so the inclusion of this scene feels like an attempt to say - things will get better, though thanks to the actions of this 'heroic' and stalwart Lincoln and men like him.
There is another message in the episode about the banality of violence on television, evidenced by the Excalbians en masse enjoying the death matches playing out on the planet's surface. This is lost amid the execution of the script.
The Savage Curtain is perhaps best viewed as an episode that set out to do too many things, with the end result failing to rise above the sum of its parts.
4. A Japanese Pilot With A Pan-Asian Name
Including the character who would become Sulu proved a challenge for Gene Roddenberry. He wanted the character to represent all of Asia, yet as George Takei would note, Asian surnames were nationally specific. Roddenberry was inspired by the Sulu Sea, which sat to the west of the Phillippines. He reasoned that an ocean touches all shores, thus his pilot was named.
Takei and Roddenberry both viewed Sulu as a character who would serve to reverse Asian stereotypes of the time. Takei himself had played these kinds of characters before - villains, untrustworthy, alien to a certain extent. Here was an Asian man who not only was the best helmsman in the fleet, and part of the starship's leadership team but also spoke with an American accent.
As Takei has detailed in the years that followed, anti-Asian sentiments were high in the post-WW2 and Vietnam years. Takei's graphic novel - They Called Us Enemy - describes his internment during the war, simply for being of Asian descent. The Asian American Movement gained traction in the 60s, itself supporting a Pan-Asian message, not unlike the name Sulu.
As Sulu was being created, various college campuses saw protests against Asian discrimination in the US. If we look at the word 'Woke' as its co-opted version - what could be more 'Woke' than including a character that directly legitimizes the hopes for these college-aged activists, particularly when those hopes are for a more racially inclusive future?
3. Russians Are Navigating In The Future
Pavel Chekov arrived on the bridge of the Starship Enterprise in the show's second season, sporting an awful wig and a hammy Russian accent. The character was created in response to a scathing editorial that had been run in the Communist Russian national newspaper Pravda. What was this, if not Gene Roddenberry rushing to include a hot-button topic - the Cold War?
However, the truth is far less clear than myth would lead us to believe. Did Roddenberry truly create Chekov in response to an article decrying the lack of Russian inclusion, particularly at a time when the Russians were heavily involved in the space race? Herb Solow and Bob Justman produced a letter, allegedly written by Gene to Pravda, from 1967, apologizing for the delay in including Chekov.
William Shatner, on the other hand, would claim the story was entirely created by the PR department in his book Star Trek Memories. Who then to believe? Perhaps then it's best to believe one's eyes - Chekov was clearly an attempt to latch on to the excitement of the Beatles, and what would become The Monkees craze. There may be nothing Woke about his inclusion, or it may have been another attempt to show a better future - one where a Russian man is welcomed on the bridge of the ship and is proud of his Russian heritage.
How many things, after all, were invented by little old Russian ladies?
2. Leave Your Bigotry In Your Quarters
Balance Of Terror introduces the Romulans, it is the final appearance of Janice Rand until The Motion Picture, and it is the episode in which Kirk utters the immortal line:
Leave any bigotry in your quarters. There's no room for it on the bridge.
While the episode is often considered for its Romulan legacy, it is the character of Stiles that is the true focus. Stiles, a Starfleet officer, is openly racist and hostile toward Spock, who as a Vulcan looks identical to the (contemporary) Romulans. This evolves as Stiles refuses Spock's help in the phaser room, only for an accident to almost claim his life and threaten the Enterprise. Spock intervenes, saving Stiles and the ship in the process.
Kirk's command to Stiles is clear, though it also highlights how even in the future, humans will judge on looks and prejudice alone. Balance Of Terror was born out of a particularly paranoid time. The HUAC hearings and McCarthy-inspired mistrust of one's neighbours, especially in Hollywood, feed into the depiction of Stiles. Kirk is unable to stop this mistrust in his officer and is only able to order him not to act on it.
This is perhaps one of the most prescient messages that Star Trek ever delivered, with the quote still finding supporters and detractors today.
1. Hailing Frequencies Open, Captain
Lt. Uhura answered the phone.
Does this do an incredible disservice to Nichelle Nichols' legacy? Or does it speak to the limitations, as Amy Foster puts it in her book Integrating Women into the Astronaut Corps: Politics and Logistics at NASA, placed on women's rights and positions in the 1960s?
Though The Cage didn't feature the character, Roddenberry was keen to create his future with as diverse a crew as possible. Where No Man Has Gone Before featured Lloyd Haynes as communications officer Alden, though he was keeping Uhura's seat warm for her when she arrived to serve in the position for the majority of the show's run.
As previously discussed in this article, the Civil Rights Movement was both gaining traction and facing major challenges in the mid-60s. Nichelle Nichols described a meeting with Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. wherein the latter convinced her to remain with the show beyond the first year, citing the importance of representation in media.
When viewed through a 21st-century lens, Uhura's inclusion seems obvious and less a statement than another role filled. In 1966, casting an African American actor in a main role, for a character with a Swahili name, visible in almost all episodes that featured the bridge - was nothing short of transgressive.
Can we say that Star Trek was 'Woke' in the 1960s? If to be 'Woke' one has to be aware of the struggles faced by the African American citizens of the US, then this writer would argue that yes, it was. If to be 'Woke' is to use the pejorative meaning of the word of recent years, then this writer would have to argue that yes, it was.
Star Trek, from its earliest days, has displayed both racial and social awareness. It is by no means perfect, stumbling almost as often as succeeding, yet in its contemporary setting, that too is almost as impressive. It fell, but it tried again.
Star Trek has been 'Woke' since its earliest days.