10 Best Doctor Who Episodes According To YOU
We’ve told you our favourites, but what about yours?
To celebrate Doctor Who's 60th anniversary year, WhoCulture has been recapping some of the greatest episodes of the show – but of course, these are just our opinions.
This time however, we’re doing something different – in this list, we’re going to count down the top ten greatest standalone NuWho episodes, as voted by the public on IMDb.
A few house rules before we begin: firstly, as stated, we’re only taking standalones into consideration for this one. No multi-parters! Often, the two halves of a story sit at very different places in the public ranking, and it wouldn't make sense to include one without the other. This means no gas mask children, no Mondasian Cybermen, and no River Song in the Library. Sorry Ellie.
Secondly, to make this list a little more exciting, we’re banning the two obvious frontrunners – Blink and Heaven Sent – which do indeed sit at number one and number two, respectively, in the public ranking.
All clear? Lovely. Let's get to it! There are quite a few surprising entrants here, so prepare to be surprised...
10. The Waters Of Mars
Rating: 8.8/10
We start off with an RTD classic.
The Waters of Mars takes Ten’s god complex, sets a fire under him, and watches him boil. Tennant gives one of his greatest performances in the role, jumping from his usual bouncy self to unhinged and desperate, to cold and downright unnerving.
All that angry staring aside, it's a top-tier episode elsewhere too. It gives us one of the best supporting casts ever in the doomed crew of Bowie Base One, and Lindsay Duncan couldn't have been a more suitable one-off companion for the story that was told. The Mars setting is beautifully realised, and a big up for "Gadget Gadget"!
The icing on the cake is an all-timer villain in the Flood, creatures that are absolutely bone-chilling both visually and conceptually. There are few episodes that sell a threat like this one does.
For such an important and memorable episode it's no surprise fans voted it near the top. In fact, the only surprise is that it isn't higher!
9. The Doctor’s Wife
Rating: 8.9/10
Remember when Neil Gaiman wrote for Doctor Who? Not that naff one with the Cybermen and the world’s most annoying children. This one.
It took until 2011 for Doctor Who to do something that, quite frankly, it was a little shocking it took 48 years to think of. It gave the TARDIS a body and a voice and let it run around with the Doctor, and oh boy was it fun.
With an incredible script that is funny, exciting, and emotional all at once, The Doctor's Wife hits the beats you’d want from a conversation between the Doctor and his loyal ship. Suranne Jones takes a role that could've easily slipped into cringe territory and toes the line perfectly, and an unrecognisable Michael Sheen is fantastic as the sadistic House.
That scene where Amy and Rory are tormented in the TARDIS corridors. Chef's kiss!
The Doctor's Wife narrowly missed out on our own top ten list so it's great to see it here. A worthy contender indeed, and it's about time Gaiman was given another bite at the apple.
8. Turn Left
Rating: 8.9/10
Turn Left also missed out on our own top ten but again, it came close!
This is an episode that could only work in the era of the show it was created for. RTD spent years building a connected universe of spinoffs, and the back half of Series 4 is where we really saw this pay off, with Turn Left bringing these Whoniverse characters together… and systematically killing off every single one of them.
It's a true powerhouse of a ‘what if’ story. How would various Earth-based adventures play out without the Doctor’s intervention? Catastrophically, is the answer. Seriously, Doctor Who has rarely, if ever, been so bleak.
This is without a doubt Catherine Tate’s best performance as Donna, showcasing a vulnerability we don’t see much outside this story, and we’d argue it’s also the strongest performance of the late Bernard Cribbins. If Wilf’s reaction to the government opening labour camps doesn’t get your lip quivering, you are a stone-cold robot.
7. The Angels Take Manhattan
Rating: 9/10
We arrive at what will likely be the first big surprise for many of you. The Angels Take Manhattan is good, but it's not widely considered superior to The Doctor's Wife, The Waters of Mars, and Turn Left!
Still, it's an episode with some dizzying highs. It gets full marks for style and setting, mixing New York detective noir with paranormal horror to great effect. The Weeping Angels slot into this setting immaculately, though the Angel of Liberty continues to be one of the most baffling creative decisions of the modern era.
But it’s the Ponds' final farewell that makes this one for the history books. Moffat pulls an End of Time on us, allowing us to hope for a moment that the inevitable goodbye has been averted, only to snatch Amy and Rory away at the last moment. It was brilliantly written, brilliantly acted... and Murray Gold, stop making us cry you monster!
The Ponds spent more time in the Doctor’s life than almost any other companion, and watching them get torn away from him was always going to be rough. It's been over a decade, and this doesn’t get easier to watch.
6. The Name Of The Doctor
Rating: 9/10
Thought The Angels Take Manhattan would be the most surprising entry on the list? Think again.
Serving as a direct lead-in to the 50th anniversary extravaganza, Series 7 finale The Name of the Doctor sits firmly in the shadow of its successor. It tends to be remembered for the shock reveal of John Hurt as the War Doctor, but upon closer inspection it's got a lot going for it that might explain its high ranking.
Love it or hate it, the episode provides an interesting explanation for the Impossible Girl mystery, and finally gives us a look at the Doctor’s grave on Trenzalore. There's a broader cast of companions, with the ever-lovable Paternoster Gang in tow, and River rather awkwardly watching her husband from beyond the grave.
Richard E. Grant is having the time of his life as The Great Intelligence too, though the less said about the wasted potential of the Whispermen, the better (Jenny dying mid-Zoom call is a great moment though).
For such a monumental moment in Doctor Who history it doesn't quite come together as well as you'd hope, though clearly the people of the internet disagree!
5. A Good Man Goes To War
Rating: 9/10
Now this is a banger.
If you’re looking for pure adrenaline, A Good Man Goes To War is a hype train that shoots out the station the moment Rory swaggers onto the bridge of a Cyberman ship (in full centurion garb) and blows up a fleet just to make a point. The fist-pumping energy of this episode doesn’t relent as it continues, giving us multiple moments of badassery throughout. The Doctor feels absolutely unstoppable here, and it's glorious.
And that’s why the moment he does fail hits like a truck. Well, there's the liquifying of a newborn baby too, which also helps sell the tragedy. It seems like all hope is lost until the last minute of the episode – and quite possibly the best twist in modern Who – with the reveal that Melody Pond is River Song! It was guessable pre-release, sure, but the moment itself was flawlessly executed.
It's the complete opposite of The Name of the Doctor in that it brings its subplots and series arcs together in an almost perfect manner while delivering a knockout standalone episode to boot.
It's rarely included in lists like these though, so we're glad it made the cut.
4. Midnight
Rating: 9/10
The Doctor has always had an innate ability to take control of a situation, and to convince others that they’re the smartest person in the room. It’s an element of the show we take for granted – after all, as the audience, we know the Doctor can be trusted – but characters in the show don’t have 60 years of context.
So what happens if you take the Doctor's authority and sprinkle in some intense paranoia? Midnight answers that question.
This fan-favourite bottle episode gives us one of the creepiest villains ever in the entirely unexplained ‘Midnight entity’, a creature of unknown power which can steal a victim's voice. We watch a group of mostly rational tourists descend into utter hysteria and succumb to pack tactics, as they turn against the one person who might be able to help.
It’s riveting psychological horror, with one of the greatest scripts ever written for the show and some knockout sound design and performances. It’s fairly common consensus that this is the best RTD-penned episode (to date!) so it's no surprise to see it so high up.
3. The Girl In The Fireplace
Rating: 9.2/10
The Girl in the Fireplace is a very interesting episode to look back on with the Moffat era under our belts. At the time, it was rather unique in its premise, and was incredibly well-received – so well-received in fact that Moffat would recycle the ideas in this plot throughout his reign as showrunner.
Little girl meets strange man who saves her from the monsters and grows up with him as an imaginary friend. He turns up again when she’s older and saves her once more, but this time she’s into him. He then accidentally abandons her a second time. Sound familiar?
There’s plenty to love elsewhere – the setting of pre-revolution France is beautifully realised, the clockwork droids make for striking villains, and David Tennant’s chemistry with Sophia Myles rather awkwardly blows what he has with Billie Piper out of the window.
It's an interesting microcosm of Moffat that tells you all you need to know about him as a writer in 45 minutes, despite predating Matt Smith by a whole four years. It's actually seventh on the full IMDb list – which is higher than you'd expect it to be – but there's no doubt it's a special episode.
2. The Day Of The Doctor
Rating: 9.3/10
Yeah, obviously.
Doctor Who’s 50th anniversary was a success in a way that few people anticipated, flinging the show back to the top of mainstream cultural relevance. With a fan-favourite Doctor returning and a brand-new secret incarnation played by acting royalty, the scale of this story was immense.
The decision to finally tackle the Time War head-on was well-earned, and it feels like the culmination of the seven series leading up to that point, flicking the switch on a status quo reset for Twelve and allowing the incoming Doctor to tread new ground in his character development.
It's an episode that has it all, sticking the landing on every emotional beat, every joke, every bit of bantering and every badass action sequence, and the ending, in which Gallifrey is saved, is pure euphoria. It's rare for fans to unanimously agree on something, but show us someone who doesn't like The Day of the Doctor and we'll show you a unicorn.
It was worthy of the occasion and then some, and look, no disrespect to the 60th anniversary specials, but this is how you celebrate a major milestone in Doctor Who history.
1. Vincent And The Doctor
Rating: 9.3/10
It's delightful to see Vincent and the Doctor so high up the ranking. Of all the celebrity historicals in the modern era, none hold a candle to the emotional power of this one.
Cutting right to the chase, the story is most fondly remembered for the scene in which Van Gogh, a man who died penniless with no respect or renown, sees the full extent of his legacy. It's an iconic Doctor Who moment, and a genuine tear-jerker.
The episode does a fantastic job of portraying Vincent’s depression and erratic nature, especially upon discovering that the Doctor and Amy plan to leave once the Krafayis is dealt with (the metaphor of the invisible monster that only Vincent can see is sublime). Likewise, the scene in which we see the world through Vincent’s eyes as the trio stares at a starry night is an absolute triumph.
Vincent and the Doctor shows the full extent of what Doctor Who is capable of. It has the power to change your view of the world. It educates, it entertains. It reminds you that there is always hope, even in dark times. It continues to leave a powerful impression on Doctor Who fans, and it's a thoroughly earned number one choice.