10 Actors Who Left Hit TV Shows And Then Came Back

They always come crawling back...

The X-Files Mulder Abduction
Fox

The dance between a successful television show and an even more successful actor is a tale as old as time. As the show grows more popular, it inevitably generates breakout stars. Those stars then begin to accept roles in other shows or films and begin to think that maybe they don't need the show after all, so they leave.

Then, either the show falls apart and begs the star to return, or the star's career turns out to not be so hot and they come slinking back for some extra cash. The recently confirmed news of Jon Bernthal returning to The Walking Dead for an episode is a clear case of the former. The news that Andrew Lincoln plans to depart soon? That could lead to a clear case of the latter.

So with that in mind, let's take a look at the most infamous cases of an actor leaving and subsequently returning to a series in television history. Because writing a character out of a narrative is easy, but writing someone back in to a narrative is a whole other story

10. Scott Weinger (Full House)

Full House
ABC

Oh, Steve, your hair was always so cool.

Scott Weinger first appeared as Steve, DJ's on-again-off-again love interest on Full House, in 1991. Though he was introduced late in the series (season five of an eight-season run), the character quickly became a fan favorite. He was goofy and lovable, in a way that idiotic sitcom characters of the nineties rarely were, all of which was solely because of Weinger's performance.

However, after two full seasons of dating, Steve and DJ broke up at the end of the seventh season. But despite his success and Aladdin-related fame, it wasn't money or a big ego that lead to Weinger's departure. It was because he was accepted into Harvard University.

Considering his studies lasted all the way up until 1998, even when he did return to Full House for the finale, it was for no more than a brief cameo. His proper return was saved for the Netflix revival, Fuller House. Weinger has appeared in nearly every episode thus far and shows no signs of stopping.


9. David Duchovny (X-Files)

X Files Mulder
Fox

After spending seven seasons playing special agent Fox Mulder on the hit sci-fi show, The X-Files, actor David Duchovny had had more than his fair share of time in the role. Which is why at the end of season seven, Mulder is bizarrely abducted by aliens (allegedly) and his character is all but written out of the show.

Sure, it left the door open for Duchovny's potential return, but this was a pretty big narrative twist to throw at audiences. It wasn't as if Mulder only went missing for a few episodes, his dissapearance was the driving narrative force behind the entire first half of the eighth season. Inevitably, Duchovny returned for the latter half of season eight when he was offered greater payment.

Then, after the finale of the eighth season, Duchovny announced he was leaving AGAIN.

This time it seemed to be for good, as his appearances in the ninth season were limited to archival footage and cameos. That is, until Duchovny found himself stepping back into the role for the series revival in 2016.


8. Chad Michael Murray (One Tree Hill)

One Tree Hill
The WB

For the first six seasons of One Tree Hill, Chad Michael Murray's Lucas Scott was the anchor of the ensemble. He got the most screen time, the most gratuitously extended close-ups of himself looking pensive, and even got to narrate regularly.

Murray had appeared in bit roles on television shows prior to One Tree Hill, such as Gilmore Girls and Dawson's Creek, but One Tree Hill was his first big break as a leading character. As his star took off on the show, he was offered greater movie roles as well. In the first three years alone that he was on One Tree Hill, and appeared in films such as Freaky Friday, A Cinderella Story, and House of Wax.

Ultimately, when his contract expired, Murray opted to leave the show rather than re-up, partly because he was more interested in exploring other opportunities. Murray and co-star Hilarie Burton were written out together, with the narrative being that their characters had a happily ever after and moved away from Tree Hill. The show would continue to air without its lead for two more years, before deciding their ninth season would act as an abridged finale.

Murray would return for one final appearance in the ninth season, that lasted all of about three minutes (if that) and featured him sporting some of the weirdest hair imaginable.


7. Nina Dobrev (Vampire Diaries)

Katherine Pierce The Vampire Diaries
The CW

In the heat of the sexy vampire craze of the late 2000's, The Vampire Diaries was launched to huge success. The crux of the show was essentially a love triangle between Nina Dobrev's Elena Gilbert and two feuding vampire brothers.

As the seasons dragged on, the narrative of the series grew increasingly ridiculous, giving Dobrev the chance to actually play multiple evil versions of herself as well. But alas, after six full seasons, Dobrev left the series as her character, Elena, essentially went into a magical coma. At the time she claimed it was simply because her contract was up, but has since been a bit more open, citing her desire to avoid typecasting and to seek out other roles.

The show carried on for two more seasons following her departure before calling it quits. The final episode saw Dobrev's character rising from her magical coma (it's much more complicated than that, but it's REALLY not worth diving into the details here) and getting to live out a happily ever after with one of her sexy vampires.

All's well that ends well.


6. Angus T. Jones (Two And A Half Men)

Two and a Half Men
CBS

Angus T. Jones spent his entire childhood working on a sitcom that just so happened to also star Charlie Sheen. That can't have been healthy for the poor boy.

Jones was less than ten years old when he first appeared as Jake on the show, the titular 'half' to Sheen and Cryer's 'men'. At first, his storylines mostly revolved around a goofy adolescence or making jokes at the expense of his father or uncle.

But as the show grew older, so too did Jones. The result was that by the time Sheen infamously left the show, Jones was a teenager and was having to take part in increasingly mature storylines, such as his character dating and having sex with an older woman. This did not sit well with Jones, who is a self-professed God-fearing man, and the actor made it clear.

In 2012, Jones openly chastised the show, calling it 'filth' and encouraging people to never watch it. This led to Jake being written out of the eleventh season with a Jake-goes-to-Japan storyline.

But even after all of this, Jones did return to the series for a brief appearance in the series finale the following season, which is more than can be said for Charlie Sheen.


5. Josh Charles (The Good Wife)

The Good Wife Josh Charles
CBS

Josh Charles's role as Will Gardner had been an integral part of The Good Wife from the very beginning.

One of Alicia's closest friends and a clear fan-favorite, Charles had even been nominated for an Emmy award multiple times for his work in the role. Which is exactly why it was so shocking when Will Gardner was violently killed off in the middle of season five.

Behind the scenes, Charles confirmed that the cast and crew had known about this twist for well over a year. His contract was up and he was looking to move on to other projects, and so he and the writers agreed to bid a definite farewell to his character while also opening up further stories for the show.

Despite his being violently murdered by not one but several gunshots, Charles did return for the final episode of the series as a ghost...? Which is perfectly normal for a grounded legal show.


4. Steve Carell (The Office)

The Office US
NBC

The cast of The Office was incredible from the get-go. But among the many scene-stealers, the most impressive was always Steve Carell's Michael Scott.

Acting as the Regional Manager of the Scranton branch of Dunder Mifflin Inc., Carell's zany yet heartfelt performance wormed its way into the hearts of both viewers and critics, earning him an Emmy nomination for Lead Actor.

But as the show wore on, Carell's star in Hollywood continued to rise. All throughout his six years on the show, Carell was balancing a growing film career alongside it. Finally in 2011, at the end of the seventh season, Carell bid a fond farewell to the show. Michael Scott was written out as having to leave the branch, leading to the majority of season eight being a fairly meta-take on trying to replace him.

The show would carry on for two more seasons before ending. During the finale, Carell would return one last time to utter one more "that's what she said" during Dwight's wedding.


3. Topher Grace/Ashton Kutcher (That 70's Show)

That 70s Show Kelso
Fox

After eight full seasons of keeping the gang together, That 70's Show began to fall apart.

The finale of season eight saw long-time lead character, Topher Grace's Eric Foreman, leave on a trip to Africa. In reality, Grace had recently met with director Sam Raimi and been offered the part of Eddie Brock in Spider-Man 3, and jumped at the chance.

Along with Grace, Ashton Kutcher more-or-less departed the show around the same time. His character of Kelso was written off as having a new job in Chicago, which would keep him apart from the rest of the gang. In truth, Kutcher was far-and-away the biggest name on the show at the time, having found success with several other projects and was looking to pursue other options.

The show spent the bulk of its ninth season attempting to replace the two, in vain. The ninth season wound up being the show's last. Both Grace and Kutcher returned for the final episode, ringing in the new decade with the original gang.


2. Brett Dier (Jane The Virgin)

Jane the Virgin
The CW

Oh, Jane the Virgin. Come season five, you got some major 'splainin' to do.

The main narrative of the early seasons of the show may have been about how a virgin was accidentally artificially inseminated, but the heart of the show was always the love triangle between Jane, her baby-daddy Raphael, and her long-time boyfriend Michael (Brett Dier). So when, at the end of season two, Jane and Michael finally got married, team Michael fans had a lot to celebrate, right?

Not exactly. Michael was shot in the final moments of the season, and though season three initially fooled viewers into thinking he was fine, he unceremoniously died of gunshot wound-related heart failure in the middle of the season.

This was a HUGE moment for the show, leading to a time-jump for the narrative of four years and completely flipping the script of the entire show.

So, it was more than a bit shocking to see a scruffy-looking Michael suddenly return in the final moments of season four.


1. Patrick Duffy (Dallas)

Dallas Bobby Ewing Shower
CBS

Never before or since has a television show so brazenly ridiculed its fans for paying attention.

Patrick Duffy spent several seasons leading the show as Bobby Ewing, Duffy was looking to pursue other opportunities. His decision to depart did not sit well with the writers of the show, leading to them opting to mercilessly kill his character. After breaking up his marriage to Pam, Katherine is distraught when she doesn't choose her over another woman, Jenna, and she viciously runs him over with her car.

But a year later, Duffy decided he wanted to return to the show. Faced with the issue of how to bring back their formerly-very-dead protagonist, the writers settled on one of the most infamous shortcuts in television history. After airing an entire season of the show, developing a story set in the aftermath of Bobby's death, the 1986 season began with a sequence in which Pam discovers Bobby in the shower and he tells her;

"It was all a dream."

Everything the show had been building to for the past year was suddenly chucked out the window, all in the name of Duffy's return.


In this post: 
The X-Files
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A film enthusiast and writer, who'll explain to you why Jingle All The Way is a classic any day of the week.