10 Actors Who Played MANY Roles In The Same Show

Good luck keeping track of Tatiana Maslany's clones on Orphan Black.

Orphan Black Tatiana Maslany
BBC America

Generally speaking, playing one character in a long-running hit TV show is plenty of work for an actor, but sometimes circumstances call for them to play more than one person in a series - perhaps several more, in fact.

For one of many reasons, an actor might be asked or required to play more than one character in a TV show, whether for heightened in-universe reasons or simply because the showrunners loved the actor enough and wanted to use them more.

And so, these 10 actors all ended up playing many characters - by our definition a minimum of three, but generally far more than that - throughout these beloved TV shows.

In some series the visual similarity between characters was absolutely acknowledged and totally part of the creative conceit - in the case of relatives, clones, and multiversal variants - while in others it amounted to little more than giving the actor more to do for the sheer fun of it.

Though this sort of tricky casting has massive potential to backfire or seem a little too cute for its own good, thankfully in these examples fans largely loved it...

10. Brent Spiner - Star Trek

Star Trek Brent Spiner
CBS

Brent Spiner is of course best remembered for his unforgettable portrayal of Data in Star Trek: The Next Generation, but that's far from the only character he's played across various Trek media.

Spiner also portrayed two other androids modelled after Data's creator Doctor Noonian Soong - Lore and B-4 (the latter appearing in the film Star Trek: Nemesis and making a cameo in disassembled form in Star Trek: Picard).

He's also been given the opportunity to play four separate members of the Soong family: elderly cyberneticist Noonian Soong himself on The Next Generation, his ancestor Arik Soong in Star Trek: Enterprise, and in Star Trek: Picard he portrayed both Noonian Soong's son Altan Inigo Soong and another of his ancestors, Adam Soong.

In The Next Generation's season four episode "Brothers," Spiner even played Data, Lore, and Noonian Soong at the same time in the very same scene, per some digital trickery of course. Incredible.

Spiner is set to reprise the role of Lore in Picard's upcoming third and final season, though it wouldn't surprise anyone if he also pops up as yet one more member of the Soong empire.


9. Meryl Streep - Angels In America

Angels In America Meryl Streep
HBO

In HBO's acclaimed 2003 miniseries Angels in America - adapted from Tony Kushner's Pulitzer Prize–winning 1991 play of the same name - Meryl Streep won an Emmy and a Golden Globe for her sublime performance which saw her play four separate characters.

First and foremost, Streep plays Hannah Pitt, the conservative Mormon mother of a gay Republican; as well as the ghost of Ethel Rosenberg, a woman executed by the U.S. government for spying for the Soviet Union; the Angel of Australia; and most unexpectedly, male Rabbi Isidor Chemelwitz.

For the latter part, Streep underwent a drastic physical transformation, disappearing underneath a metric ton of makeup to play an old Jewish man, and despite the potential for snickering, she absolutely knocked it out of the park.

As much as people love to say that Streep wins awards for reading the phone book, in this case she most certainly earned her plaudits with an impressive plate-spinning exercise across four totally singular characters.


8. Rowan Atkinson - Blackadder

Blackadder Rowan Atkinson
BBC

The brilliant central conceit of legendary Brit comedy series Blackadder is that Rowan Atkinson portrays a different member of the Blackadder dynasty in each series, no matter that the characters generally share a number of character traits both detestable and hilarious.

In the show's first series, he plays the dim-witted yet highly ranked Prince Edmund at the end of the British Middle Ages, while in Blackadder II he takes the role of Edmund's considerably smarter great-grandson Lord Blackadder during the reign of Queen Elizabeth I.

For Blackadder the Third, set during the Georgian Era, Atkinson portrays Mr. E. Blackadder, Esquire, a butler to the Prince Regent and by far the most cunning of all the Blackadder iterations - enough that he actually survives the events of the series and is implied to become King George IV.

For the fourth and final series, Blackadder Goes Forth, Atkinson then played the cynical, caustic British Army Captain Blackadder during World War I.

His tenure didn't quite end there, though: in 1988's Christmas special episode, Blackadder's Christmas Carol, he assumed the guise of Mr. Ebenezer Blackadder, the apparently nicest man in Victorian England, and in 1999's short film Blackadder: Back & Forth, he played a modern day Lord Blackadder who attempts to change history in his favour.

This is without even counting minor members of the Blackadder family who've been briefly featured, ensuring that Atkinson has played a bevy of separate-but-similar characters throughout the show's run.


7. Evan Peters - American Horror Story

American Horror Story Evan Peters
FX

American Horror Story has relished recasting actors in numerous roles across its many seasons, and no actor has typified that unhinged playfulness better than Evan Peters. Hold your breath, now, as we recount his major characters throughout each season.

During his tenure on the show, Peters has played psychiatric patient Tate Langdon, a man framed as a serial killer called Kit Walker, university student Kyle Spencer, deformed "Lobster Boy" Jimmy Darling, serial killer James March, actor Rory Monahan, alt-right cult leader Kai Anderson, gay hairstylist Mr. Gallant, and songwriter Austin Sommers.

This is not to forget that he also briefly played a number of cult leaders - Andy Warhol, Marshall Applewhite, David Koresh, Jim Jones, Jesus Christ and Charles Manson - in the show's seventh season.

Evans has close to 20 character to his name in American Horror Story alone, a part for which he should've received considerably greater awards attention, honestly.


6. Rachel Dratch - 30 Rock

30 Rock Rachel Dratch
NBC

Rachel Dratch was a recurring member of the ensemble cast on hit sitcom 30 Rock, appearing in 16 episodes across its seven seasons, and playing a different character almost every single time.

Dratch played almost a dozen separate bit-part characters throughout the series, as quickly became a running gag for fans to keep an eye out for.

These roles included cat wrangler Greta Johansen, Latina cleaning lady Maria, a doctor named Dr. Beauvoir, Russian hooker Vlem, an Eastern European woman called Jadwiga, and also real-life figures Barbara Walters and Elizabeth Taylor in hilarious caricature form, among others.

Legend dictates that this was something of a consolation prize for Dratch, who was originally cast in the role of Jenna Maroney in 30 Rock's pilot episode, but reportedly after test audiences responded negatively to her, the part was recast with Jane Krakowski.

While it's a shame that Dratch missed out on such a lucrative lead role, she did nevertheless prove to be an hilarious presence any time she showed up in day-player capacity.


5. Patton Oswalt - Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D.

Agents Of SHIELD Patton Oswalt
ABC

Patton Oswalt certainly gets around, and in the case of Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D., the showrunners ultimately decided one of him just wasn't enough.

Oswalt first appeared in two episodes of the show's first season as high-ranking S.H.I.E.L.D. operative and Nick Fury (Samuel L. Jackson) confidante Eric Koenig.

After he was killed by HYDRA agent Grant Ward (Brett Dalton), though, Oswalt re-appeared three episodes later as his twin brother Billy, and the next season a third twin was introduced, Sam.

Things calmed down for a while after this, until in season four Oswalt showed up as a fourth twin brother, Thurston, who was a slam poet and the only one of the four twins not to work as a S.H.I.E.L.D. agent.

And then in the seventh and final season Oswalt resurfaced once more as Ernest Koenig, the grandfather of all the other featured Koenigs, appearing in scenes set in the 1930s.

As much as we can't get enough of Patton, this was a lot.


4. Nina Dobrev - The Vampire Diaries

The Vampire Diaries Nina Dobrev
The CW

Nina Dobrev pulled quadruple duty throughout her tenure on The Vampire Diaries. First and foremost, she of course played protagonist Elena Gilbert, a young woman whose life becomes forever intertwined with the Salvatore family.

She soon enough also began playing Elena's doppelgänger and vampiric ancestor Katerina Petrova, better known as Katherine Pierce - a deeply devious foil for Elena and co. throughout the series, and yet an undeniable fan favourite.

Dobrev also took the role of Amara, the world's first immortal woman and originator of the Petrova doppelgängers, during the show's fifth season.

While Dobrev "only" played these three roles in The Vampire Diaries' initial run, she did also make a one-off appearance in the second season of spin-off show The Originals.

Dobrev portrayed Tatia, the first doppelgänger spawned from Amara back in the 10th century, whose blood was responsible for creating the world's first vampires.

Evidently the Vampire Diaries universe had a lot of fun with placing Dobrev in numerous roles, and why the hell not?


3. Tom Cavanagh - The Flash

The Flash Tom Cavanagh
The CW

Across his 145 episodes on The Flash to date, Tom Cavanagh has played a head-spinning number of characters, or rather, variations on the same character.

Cavanagh initially plays the role of Barry Allen's (Grant Gustin) mentor Harrison Wells, before it's revealed that he was actually the villainous Professor Eobard Thawne aka Reverse-Flash all along, who killed Harrison Wells and assumed his identity.

But throughout the show's subsequent seasons Cavanagh plays numerous versions of Wells from alternate realities, including the sarcastic Dr. Harry Wells from Earth-2, novelist H. R. Wells of Earth-19, detective Sherloque Wells of Earth-221, and adventurous explorer Nash Wells.

Cavanagh also briefly played a number of other versions of Wells as part of the Council of Wells and the Council of Harrisons.

Each iteration of Wells typically differed significantly in terms of their personality, and so Cavanagh was given a ripe opportunity to play a wealth of same-but-different characters throughout his time on the show - years before the MCU made variants the "in" thing.


2. Tatiana Maslany - Orphan Black

Orphan Black Tatiana Maslany
BBC America

Tatiana Maslany gave a phenomenal, Emmy-winning performance throughout Orphan Black's five seasons, where she played more than a dozen clone "sisters," all of whom have their own distinct accents, appearances, and personality quirks.

Maslany played five of the clones on a regular basis during the show: con artist protagonist Sarah Manning, American PhD student Cosima Niehaus, housewife Alison Hendrix, psychotic stalker Helena, and the manipulative Rachel Duncan.

But beyond this, Maslany also made regular appearances as a bevy of other clones, including perhaps most laudably a transgender male clone, Tony Sawicki.

Given that Maslany had to regularly portray numerous clones interacting with one another in the very same scene, it was an enormously demanding and multi-faceted part.

To portray so many characters and make them feel persuasively alive in their own right with no overlap at all is incredibly impressive.

And yet she absolutely nailed it, finally winning herself a well-earned Emmy in the process in 2016.


1. Garret Dillahunt - Deadwood

Deadwood Garrett Dillahunt
HBO

Garret Dillahunt is one of those great character actors who improves just about everything he appears in, apparently enough that the producers of HBO's Deadwood couldn't resist but cast him in three separate roles.

Dillahunt appeared in the Western series' first season as Jack McCall, the drunken degenerate who shoots and kills Wild Bill Hickock (Keith Carradine), and who is later caught and presumed to be executed.

Despite this, Dillahunt returned for a much larger role throughout season two as Francis Wolcott, a seemingly dapper geologist whose well-attired front conceals a penchant for sexual violence, resulting in him killing three prostitutes in Deadwood. Wolcott later hangs himself out of despair.

And though that was Dillahunt's lot in the show proper, he made one final appearance in 2019's Deadwood: The Movie, which effectively served as a belated series finale.

Almost 15 years after the last episode aired, Dillahunt returned for a brief cameo as a drunk man, credited as "Drunk Number Two," as if to make a little fun of anyone who complained about Dillahunt playing two totally separate characters without explanation in the main series.


In this post: 
orphan black
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.