10 Actors You Won't Believe Were Nearly Cast In Friends

Try imagining Friends with these actors in the main roles instead (all of whom were considered). Stop! It's making our brains hurt!

Most of us have probably spent so much time hanging out with the friends in Friends, that we kind of feel like they're our pals in real life (even though you've always been separated by a screen, you can't deny the love). Likelihood is, though, that you would know exactly what to say if you ever bumped into Rachel or Chandler or Phoebe or Joey in the real world, because you've sat staring at them for an uncountable amount of hours for the last 20 years (seriously, working out all the hours this generation has spent watching Friends would be embarrassing - and terrifying). So although we know that Courtney Cox plays Monica and David Schwimmer plays Ross, we also kind of don't know that at all, in the sense that these "characters" genuinely feel like real people to fans of the show. If Matt LeBlanc came up to you on the street, you'd probably call him "Joey." Now prepare to feel weird as you imagine that, once upon a time, these characters could have been played by... YES: DIFFERENT ACTORS ENTIRELY. Okay, take a deep breath for a second and relax. Remember - it didn't happen. That's the main thing to consider right now, all right? But it could have. Seriously. Because the actors who were eventually cast in these beloved roles didn't always have dibs on the parts. The producers considered other people. People you know from other shows and everything. People you like, even. People such as...

10. Jon Cryer - Chandler

It's not completely impossible to imagine that Jon Cryer might've made a good Chandler Bing had he landed the role, but nobody really wants to imagine that, given that we all love Matthew Perry, and nothin' or nobody is gonna tell us otherwise. Still, in the early '90s, Cryer - who you'll know mostly for his role as Alan in Two and a Half Men, of course - was given a script called "Six of One" (one of the terrible early names for the show) and was asked to come in for an audition. That's to say, the process didn't fare well. Not because Cryer was bad or anything, but because he was in London at the time performing in a play, and was unable to fly to L.A. to audition for the part. Still, they asked him to send an audition tape over, which he did - unfortunately for Cryer (and thankfully for Matthew Perry), the tape didn't make it to Los Angeles in time, and nobody got to see Cryer "doing Chandler." Still, it's interesting to ponder what was on that audition tape, and whether the performance would have been good enough to land him the part.

9. Tea Leoni - Rachel

Jennifer Aniston is perhaps the most universally famous of the Friends actors, and is the one who's probably had the most success outside of the show, what with all those successful Hollywood movies and that high profile relationship with that Brad Pitt guy. In a way, then, Aniston often feels like the most Friends-y of Friends characters (we won't tell anybody about that sentence if you won't) - the epitome of a Friends character, if you will, and the one who we presumably identify most with the show itself. But originally the producers of the show considered another actress entirely: Tea Leoni. Leoni, who decided that she wanted to star in The Naked Truth instead (cancelled on its third season), turned down the part. Aniston, who was then being groomed for a spot on Saturday Night Live (can you imagine) swept in to play Rachel, and the rest is history. Yes, she turned down a part on SNL to star in Friends, which - as you can imagine - was a huge risk. Had she had opted for a gig on SNL, the likelihood is we'd know her face now anyway... but not for Rachel.

8. Hank Azaria - Joey

Hank Azaria is best known for the voice work he does on The Simpsons, but he also auditioned for the part of Joey back when Friends was called "Friends Like Us" and the first script was being passed around. "I went and auditioned for Joey and got rejected," Azaria said on the matter. "But - and this was the first and only time I've done this - I asked to go back in. I said, 'I know you said 'no' to me once, but I just want to try it again, because I like that show that much.' And I went back in... And I got another very quick 'no.' As quick as the first time." It wasn't meant to be for Azaria, of course - and though there are rumours of other actors, like Vince Vaughn, auditioning for the role of Joey, it's assumed that the producers found Matt LeBlanc pretty early on in the process, and considered him the right man for the job. Azaria eventually did nab a re-occurring part on Friends, though, as Phoebe's geeky boyfriend David, who is forced to leave her for a job opportunity in Minsk. David is nebbish, timid and shy: everything Joey really isn't. Which kind of explains why Azaria didn't get that role.

7. Jon Faverau - Chandler

Can you really picture anybody else as Chandler Bing other than Matthew Perry? Could he BE any more perfect for the part? Fans of Friends will obviously say, "No, of course not," because that's how this stuff works, but isn't it odd to think that he was very nearly played by Jon Faverau, who you know as the director of Iron Man and the star of movies like Swingers? Faverau is a talented guy, of course, but imagining him reading Perry's lines - and hanging out with Matt LeBlanc - feels blasphemous and wrong. Luckily Faverau turned down the part to concentrate on his writing, but fans of the show will know that the actor later appeared in multiple episodes of the show as a completely different character - Monica's super rich boyfriend (and wannabe cage fighter) Pete. Faverau was great as Pete, and for a while audiences might've even been okay with Monica ending up with him forever. The writers eventually opted to reduce the character into something of a weirdo, however, though Faverau managed to make it both hilarious and pathetic in equal manner. Aw, Pete: you freak.

6. Janeane Garofalo - Monica

Although you could certainly argue that changing any members of the final cast would have given the show a completely different edge, here's the one that really, really would've changed proceedings - arguably for the worse. Yes, it was Courtney Cox who eventually found herself cast as the perky, clean-obsessed Monica Geller, but she wasn't originally what the creators were looking for. "When we originally wrote the role, we had Janeane Garofalo's voice in our head," said main man David Crane. "Darker and edgier and snarkier." So you can instantly picture the sort of character that Monica was supposed to be when you imagine Janeane Garofalo in the role, right? And having an edgier and snarkier Monica certainly would have brought an added dynamic to the table, as none of Friends really fit that description. Still, we can't help but feel as though having Garofalo in the mix would've meant the entire show could've found itself bogged down in a kind of mean-spiritedness. And we all love Friends 'cause it's warm and comforting, don't we? Yes, that's why we love it.

5. Craig Beirko - Chandler

You don't even know who this is, do you? You do? Oh, well congratulations. Believe it or not, then, Mr. Craig Beirko - who appeared alongside Russell Crowe in Cinderella Man - was originally offered the role of Chandler Bing. As in, they said: "Here, you can have this part. It's yours. Take it, Craig Beirko. Take this incredible opportunity. We're actually giving it to you." As you probably guessed from the overtly sarcastic and hyperbolic way in which that was written, Craig Beirko declined and shot a pilot for another show called "Best of Friends" instead. You'll agree that that move is probably one that he regrets. If you've seen the man acting, you can picture how he might've made Chandler work, though. Creators David Crane and Marta Kauffman noted that, had Beirko taken the role, the character would have been entirely different, somebody audiences would have "loved to hate" as opposed to just love, what was the case with Matthew Perry's less angry take on the character. Still, Craig's doing okay these days - don't feel too bad - and was last seen... playing Miss Trunchball in Matilda on Broadway? Oh, okay.

4. Eric McCormack - Ross

Many critics originally considered Ross to be the weakest character in the Friends line-up, and he was - for a time - perhaps the least popular character on the show. But then something happened: the writers found Ross' voice and realised how great David Schwimmer was at blending both physical and verbal comedy to hilarious results. It became clear that Ross made for awesome writing opportunities, primarily because he could be either be pegged as the bigger man or as the pettiest guy in the room, depending on the situation at hand. It probably helped that David Schwimmer is kind of funny to look at, too, in that goofy way. Nowadays, ask somebody who their favourite Friends character is and you're likely to get "Ross" as the answer - even those younger people who grew up watching Ross and not really getting him seem to have changed their minds about the character. That's to say, Schwimmer is a undeniably large part of the show's success, and it's weird to think Eric McCormack - yep, Will from Will and Grace - almost ended up as our favourite paleontologist after several successful auditions (he won an Emmy for his Will role, so don't feel too bad for the guy).

3. Leah Remini - Monica

The wonderful Leah Remini was presumably considered for the part of Monica back during the "she should be kind of like Janeane Garofalo" stages, because this actress is far more at home with snarky, sarcastically-minded characters, and doesn't really fit the description of the Monica that we all know and love now (obviously the part was remoulded around Courtney Cox's personality when they decided to cast her). You'll know Remini, of course, as Carrie from sitcom King of Queens, on which she starred - alongside Kevin James - for nine seasons. Imagining this actress in the Friends line-up is strange, though, given that there doesn't really seem to be another place for the sort of dry, quipping character that she presumably would have ended up playing, given that we've already got a Chandler, and too much sarcasm might've been something akin to overkill. Can you imagine those two as a couple? No thank you. Die hard fans of the show will recall that Remini does appear in a single episode of Friends, however: Joey helps her give birth to a baby in season one's "The One With The Birth." Hilarious!

2. Jane Krakowski - Phoebe

It's hard to picture anybody else other than Lisa Kudrow pulling off Phoebe's strange, spacey hippyness - she somehow managed to make a potentially irritating character into an undeniably loveable one, which was no mean feat. But, as with all of the actors on our list, Kudrow was never considered as the first choice for Phoebe - creators Marta Kauffman and David Crane originally envisioned Jane Krakowski for the role, who you'll know for her roles on Ally McBeal and 30 Rock (you can't forget 30 Rock - she became one of the show's best aspects). It seems odd to think of Krakowski amongst the cast of Friends (people didn't originally take well to her casting in 30 Rock, either, a role which she later nailed) - she has something inherently hardened about her demeanour, and Phoebe, of course, though occasionally frightening, is fairly mellow. We're not sure whether Krakowski ever got to audition for the role, however, but it's interesting to know that it was written with her in mind. Fun fact: before Kudrow was cast in Friends, she was cast as Roz on Fraiser... before being quickly fired and replaced.

1. Courtney Cox - Rachel

Say it ain't so, right? Unfortunately, we can't: before Friends was even a thing and words like "Jennifer Aniston" and "Rachel" went together like that was the most natural thing in the world, Courtney Cox was originally brought in to play Rachel. Despite the fact that one could have probably argued that Rachel was the more interesting character of the two (on paper, at least), Cox felt that she was wrong for it, and went about trying to convince the producers that she would make a better Monica. And she was right, of course (at least - we hope!). But picture an alternative world in which Courtney Cox was cast as Rachel, and your brain starts to hurt - especially if you imagine that, for some reason, Jennifer Aniston ended up as Monica. Is this the stuff that nightmares are made of? Would we have eventually had to have watched Jennifer Aniston and Matthew Perry making out with one another for the last five seasons? Or Jennifer Aniston and David Schwimmer pretending to be brother and sister instead of destined lovers? But they're Ross and Rachel! Don't you get it?! THEY'RE ROSS AND RACHEL! Hey, hey! Wake up! You were just having a bad dream, old pal. Now, go on: there's probably a Friends episode playing on at least one channel somewhere. Found it? There we go. That's better, isn't it? Aren't you glad the casting went the way it did in the end? Yeah, us too. Us too. Like this article? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Articles published under the WhatCulture name denote collective efforts of a number of our writers, both past and present.