10 Arrowverse Villains Who Were Actually Heroes

These baddies were not as cruel and dangerous as they were initially presumed to be.

Arrow Slade Wilson Felicity Smoak
The CW

Common storytelling knowledge dictates that a good villain often believes themselves to be the hero of their story. Their motivations are relatable and the moments where they break bad are often tragic and, in a way, understandable.

This narrative trope extends to the Arrowverse, where for every moustache-twirling baddie running amok, there is a character who, for one reason or another, went down the path of villainy only to find redemption and commit to a life of good.

Sometimes, the heel-face turn is short-lived (or situational), and once the villain has achieved their objective they return to a life of crime. In other cases, the villain goes on to be a hero and accomplish, and even sacrifice, a lot for the greater good.

Such a shift in alignment can be a goldmine of narrative opportunities, as the creative team is able to explore the former villain's new dimensions and sensibilities, and provide an interesting contrast to their former life.

From former mercenaries and assassins, to thieves and tech geniuses, this list is filled with layered backstories and memorable redemption arcs that have defined the Arrowverse's story over the years.

10. Kuasa

Kuasa Legends of Tomorrow
CW

The older sister of Mari McCabe (the present day Vixen), Kuasa did not live as heroic life a her grandmother or sister. Due to her tragic and lonely background, the would-be protector of Zambezi forged alliances in the criminal underworld, and this left a young Kuasa slipping off the edge into full-on villainy.

She was motivated by a burning desire to retrieve her grandmother's Spirit Totem and get revenge for the tragedy her family and community suffered at the hands of the Zambezi ambassador, Benatu Eshu. This led her to crossing paths with Mari, who had already bonded with the Totem and gained its abilities.

After an intense fight, Kuasa was defeated and incapacitated after being poisoned by her sister. Later events saw her die at the hands of Eshu, be revived at the hands of the demonic Mallus, and clash with her time-displaced grandmother, Amaya Jiwe

Despite her antagonistic tendencies, Kuasa has on multiple occasions put aside her vengeful objectives and desire to possess the Spirit Totem and work with her family, often at great personal cost.

Fortunately, through the Legends' intervention, Kuasa never went through her childhood trauma and instead became a hero alongside her younger sister.


9. Pied Piper

The Flash Pied Piper
The CW

Hartley Rathaway was a former STAR Labs employee who was fired by Harrison Wells (Eobard Thawne in disguise) for attempting to stop the activation of the particle accelerator due to its risk of exploding.

This left Rathaway resentful of his former mentor, and, upon realizing that he obtained abilities from the explosion, he sought to get his vengeance on Wells and STAR Labs as a whole.

Naming himself the Pied Piper, the embittered prodigy attempted to drive apart Wells and Team Flash then take them down, only being foiled by the combined genius of the resident STAR Labs team and Wells/Thawne's deception. He was captured by the heroes and later escaped by taking advantage of Cisco's guilt over Ronnie Raymond's death.

Despite this, Rathaway helped the team on two separate occasions - during their time battling Zoom, and in the post-Crisis timeline battling Godspeed when Flash lost most of his speed, for which the help was in exchange for Team Flash helping Hartley restore his boyfriend's health.

These instances showed a kinder, more heroic and caring side to the character that was only hinted at in his early appearances.


8. Nyssa Al Ghul

arrow nyssa al ghul
The CW

The younger daughter of Ras al Ghul, Nyssa Raatko did not enjoy as normal childhood as most children; an expected outcome when your father is the head of the League of Assassins.

Nyssa was trained in the ways of the League and, after her older sister Talia left the group to create her own path, Nyssa was chosen as her father's next successor.

She later encountered a weakened Sara Lance and brought her to the League, where Sara trained as an assassin and later began a relationship with the younger al Ghul sister.

This relationship was short-lived due to Sara's abandonment of the League and return to Star City, and this led to Nyssa and Oliver Queen crossing paths and clashing - only abandoning the fight due to Sara's pleas.

Nyssa's time in the Arrowverse has been defined by her torn allegiances to her father and the League, as well as her desire to see justice prevail, which often put her on the same side with Oliver and Sara. She even teamed up with Team Arrow on several occasions and sought to undo the damage caused by her family and the League.


7. Bronze Tiger

Arrow Bronze Tiger Ben Turner
The CW

Ben Turner was one of Green Arrow's more physically intimidating villains early in Arrow's run, and with good reason. The mercenary was well versed in various martial arts disciplines, and was skilled enough to go toe-to-toe with Green Arrow and even overwhelm the Emerald Archer in some of their encounters.

These abilities made him a natural fit for the criminal underworld, and he allied himself with the likes of China White, Danny Brickwell and Amanda Waller under Task Force X (though the latter was forced). It was his time on the Suicide Squad that Turner's more noble qualities began to shine through to the surface, saving his teammate Lyla Michaels during a mission.

However, it was not until Oliver's stint in Slabside Prison where the full extent of Bronze Tiger's heroism was revealed. At first resuming his antagonistic stance against the embattled Queen, Turner later teamed up with the hero to save the prison guards from Ricardo Diaz's rampage - and upon his release, Turner helped Oliver battle his half-sister Emiko and her Ninth Circle terrorist organisation.


6. Heatwave

Crisis On Infinite Earths Legends of Tomorrow Mick Rory Heat Wave
The CW

One half of the elemental rogues, Mick Rory's journey from criminal to hero, bounty hunter and back to hero is as layered as it is filled with (sometimes) amusing hijinks.

Heatwave may appear to be gruff, intimidating and apathetic to everything around him, and while this is true, he has surprising depth, warmth and is even cultured to some degree.

The pyromaniac Legend developed his obsession with fire and criminal tendencies at an early age, and, as they grew in intensity, he teamed up with Leonard Snart/Captain Cold to conduct various heists - with one job going horribly wrong and leaving Rory badly burnt.

This series of heists led to Mick and Snart crossing paths with The Flash several times and later joining the Legends. Heatwave's brash, impulsive nature made him a liability to the Legends on many occasions, and it even led to his removal from the group.

Following a brief stint as the bounty hunter Chronos, Rory began his reformation process, and it was during this time that the newly minted hero's layers were revealed - making him a fan favourite in the Arrowverse and a mainstay of the Legends team.


5. Malcolm Merlyn

Arrow Malcolm Merlyn
The CW

The Dark Archer set the bar high for Arrowverse villainy, with his intimidating presence and John Barrowman's engaging presence placing the character as both a fantastic villain and a last-minute but well crafted hero.

Malcolm Merlyn's journey from grieving widower to vengeful villain - and later antagonistic supporting character - had its bumps along the way, but was wrapped in a fitting and somewhat tragic tale.

Born Arthur King, Malcolm's life before the events of Arrow was just as storied as his later years. From joining clandestine society the Hidden, to joining the League of Assassins after the death of his wife, Merlyn gained knowledge and skills that cemented him as a formidable foe and ally to Oliver Queen and his fellow heroes.

Merlyn's personal connection to Oliver gave their clashes and scattered alliances weight that most villain-hero team-ups lacked, especially as he was Thea Queen's father.

This softened Malcolm somewhat, as he tried to win over his daughter's affections. But this was no small feat, as Merlyn's more sinister side constantly pushed Thea away. However, the Dark Archer proved himself to be a caring (in his own way) father as he saved Thea from a landmine during Oliver's final stand against Adrian Chase.


4. Killer Frost

The Flash Killer Frost Season 3
The CW

Dr. Caitlin Snow is one of the more endearing characters on the Flash due to her compassionate and kind nature, and this has made her a favourite among fans of the show. However, she has a darker, colder edge to her persona that belies her warm, outward nature - and this manifests itself as Killer Frost (later renamed as simply Frost).

Caitlin's cryokinetic abilities are a result of her father's experimental tests to prevent her ALS marker from fully manifesting into the disease. Unfortunately, her abilities have affected her mental state to some degree, and her split personality was initially vindictive, angry and cruel, even towards her friends in Team Flash.

Snow's anger and fragile mental state have seen her ally herself with the likes of Savitar and Amunet Black and commit various atrocities during these alliances.

Thankfully, during her alliance with the Black, the conflicted scientist was able to reconcile her two personas into a singular entity.

Caitlin/Frost has since reconciled with her team and taken great steps to atone for her past actions.


3. Captain Cold

Captain Cold Wentworth Miller The Flash
The CW

One of the original Rogues and founding members of the Legends, the late Leonard Snart was initially a composed yet dangerous thief who committed a multitude of crimes before switching to the side of good during his time on the Legends.

He and fellow Rogue Mick Rory/Heatwave share a compelling dynamic that is embodied by their temperaments and their choice of weaponry.

Before joining the Legends, Snart used his skills as a master thief who operated with a precision and moral code rarely seen in Central City's criminal underworld. Despite this, he was ruthless and did not hesitate to put down anyone who dared cross his path - and this, of course, placed him in conflict with The Flash several times, to the point where Leonard even got to learn the Scarlet Speedster's secret identity.

However, the notoriously cold villain began to gradually warm up to the side of good when he joined the Legends.

Snart began to trust his new teammates and hold Rory accountable for his more reckless actions - an act that would not have happened pre-Legends and eventually the more heroic, selfless Leonard Snart sacrificed himself to save his team, and the timeline in the process.


2. Black Siren

Green Arrow and The Canaries Laurel Lance Black Canary
The CW

The Laurel Lance of Earth-2 was a far cry from her more heroic Earth-1 counterpart.

Earth-2 Laurel turned towards a life of villainy after acquiring her abilities, as well as due to the trauma caused by the deaths of her lover and father. Her arc from metahuman enforcer, to Star City criminal, to reformed hero and district attorney was compelling to watch, and she was a perfect foil to the Earth-1 Laurel Lance.

This Earth-2 Laurel was key in Hunter Zolomon's plans to take over Earth-1, as well as Adrian Chase's plans to destabilize Oliver Queen and Team Arrow by pretending to be her deceased counterpart. Her stints under Cayden James and Ricardo Diaz reinforced the idea that Laurel was susceptible to manipulation by authority figures due to a lack of parental guidance in her formative years.

Fortunately, Laurel became aware of this and sought to make amends with Team Arrow (though not without struggle) and even took on her doppelganger's role as district attorney. Her road to redemption was not easy, but was eventually impactful enough to earn the trust of the heroes.


1. Deathstroke

Arrow Deathstroke Season 2
The CW

Slade Wilson is one of the Arrowverse's most complex characters, and arguably its greatest villain. His fall from grace and eventual redemption arc is one of the franchise's best, as it has given audiences exhilarating action and compelling character work- and it helped no end that Manu Bennett's performance helped flesh out a possibly clichéd military-driven antagonist.

One of Oliver's first allies, Slade was trapped on Lian Yu after a mission to rescue Yao Fei went awry due to the machinations of mercenary Edward Fyers. He and Fei's daughter, Shado, trained Oliver in a number of martial arts disciplines and they later took down Fyers and his operation.

Unfortunately, Shado's death and Wilson's Mirakuru-induced rage led to Slade and Oliver becoming enemies - which is an event that would haunt the future Green Arrow for years to come.

Slade channelled his desire for vengeance and his bloodlust into a plan designed to take everything from Queen and destroy Star City.

Of course, that stunning second season of Arrow saw Oliver eventually stop Deathstroke, and Slade Wilson was imprisoned on Lian Yu where he eventually regained his sanity and aided Oliver on a number of occasions - somewhat atoning for his past actions and finding some measure of peace in his life.


Contributor

David Ng'ethe hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.