10 Awesome Doctor Who Ideas That Nearly Happened
Doctor Who's fifth series almost had a lot more Scottishness about it...
Over the years, we've seen many talented showrunners, producers, and writers all bring fresh ideas to spice up our beloved Doctor Who.
But for all of the things that have since become staples of the show, there are an equal amount of interesting concepts that sadly failed to materialise.
With every single series going through rigorous changes and edits in the hands of producers and directors alike, oftentimes the ideas that were initially included in the scripts and proposed as concepts end up getting dropped for a variety of reasons. This can include budget limitations, availability of actors, or simply just plans that were deemed too extreme or ridiculous for Doctor Who.
And yes, it is possible for something to be too ridiculous for this show.
Not every idea that gets floated around is solid gold, mind you. There was serious chatter about killing off Sarah Jane Smith at the end of her classic run, which, needless to say, would've been a horrific mistake.
But certain unused concepts actually do sound quite good (on paper, at least), and that includes these ones...
10. The Weeping Angel Fact Book
The Weeping Angels' first appearance after Blink revealed quite a bit more about the species than most fans expected, for better or worse.
However, one crucial element in The Time of Angels that went unexplained was the origin of the Weeping Angel book (described by River as "the definitive work on the Angels... written by a madman") that the Doctor flicks through.
Despite its importance, we never learn where this book came from, and that's because writer Steven Moffat removed an entire subplot about its origins.
He intended to reveal that the book had been written by one of Octavian's clerics. This cleric came on the mission we see in the episode, encountered an Angel, got zapped back in time, and then wrote the book, allowing the Doctor to access it in the future. However, this plot point was ultimately axed due to a lack of story space.
The Angels don't zap anyone back in time in this story, so it would've been cool to see a subplot revolving around that ability. And learning more about that book - one of the only known in-universe works about the Angels - would've been fascinating to boot.
9. Sibling Rivalry
Without a doubt, the Doctor's deadliest foe is the Master. First introduced in 1971's Terror of the Autons, he was originally portrayed by Roger Delgado, who revelled in being Jon Pertwee's most hated enemy.
The Doctor-Master rivalry was intended to come to a head in the serial The Final Game, which was also set to be Pertwee's regeneration story. It would also include the shock revelation that the Master was in fact the Doctor's brother, before the Master would be killed off for good.
However, this story was never made due to a truly tragic event: while filming the miniseries Bell of Tibet in Turkey in 1973, Delgado was killed in a car crash.
This event shook everyone involved with Doctor Who, and as a result, this epic final battle between the Third Doctor and the Master sadly never got made.
It's a shame, because the brother reveal would've added a very interesting layer to the Doctor/Master conflict, and getting one more story with Delgado in the role would've been a real treat too.
8. The Age Of The Toclafane
For Doctor Who's return in 2005, Russell T Davies commissioned writer Robert Shearman to create a story which would see the show's most iconic villains back on our screens. The eventual episode, Dalek, proved to be a huge hit, and is now regarded as a quintessential Doctor Who story.
One slight obstacle stood in RTD's way however, as the Daleks were the property of the Terry Nation estate, with the BBC needing their permission to bring the creatures back.
Just in case he wasn't granted permission, RTD prepared a backup idea which featured most of the same elements and plot points, except the Daleks were replaced with what we would later know as the Toclafane.
Thankfully, the Terry Nation estate and the BBC eventually reached an agreement, but the idea of the Toclafane potentially being this overarching villain of early NuWho (like the Daleks ended up being) is pretty darn intriguing, especially considering their link to humanity - a species we know the Doctor is rather fond of!
7. An Enterprising Crossover
Doctor Who and Star Trek have crossed paths in comic-book form, with the 2012 limited series Assimilation featuring the Eleventh Doctor and Jean-Luc Picard dealing with a Cybermen/Borg alliance.
And seven years previously, these two sci-fi juggernauts almost crossed paths on TV too.
In 2005 (the first year of the Doctor Who revival), serious consideration was given to the idea of the TARDIS vworp-vworping over to the Star Trek universe, and would presumably have seen either the Ninth or Tenth Doctor meet Captain Jonathan Archer - the lead of Star Trek: Enterprise, which was the Trek show on TV at that time. However, when Enterprise was cancelled after its fourth season, any potential crossover plans were nipped in the bud.
Though it probably wasn't the right timing for a dwindling Star Trek series and a fresh, full-of-potential Doctor Who series to combine forces, there's no doubt that this would've been a pop-culture event for the ages, and a real treat for fans of both properties.
Oh, and shoutout to the folks at TrekCulture. Lovely bunch.
6. Evil Doctor
Like the creation of any new show, the inception of Doctor Who in late 1963 was, to say the least, a difficult time, and there were many interesting ideas and concepts that were scrapped along the way.
One of these concepts was put forward by writer C. E. Webber in the original briefing describing the character of the Doctor. It posited that the Doctor was a sinister character who had an ulterior motive for his travels in time and space. This motive was that the Doctor was searching for a perfect society in the past, and would go so far as destroying the future in order to achieve his goals.
This idea (along with the idea of naming the companions "Biddy, Lola, and Cliff") was vetoed by Sydney Newman, who sought to make the Doctor more of a kind figure, rather than an evil genius.
A malicious Doctor is an intriguing concept, and is something we've seen flashes of over the years. It would've definitely been an intriguing way to kick-start the show.
5. The Raggedy Tenth Doctor
In 2008, Russell T Davies announced that he was leaving Doctor Who, and that he would be replaced by Steven Moffat, who had written some of the most iconic episodes of the show under Davies.
Fans were relieved at the announcement because they knew they were safe in Moffat's hands, but one unanswered question was the fate of David Tennant, with even Moffat wondering if he would stay on under a new showrunner.
This was not the case however, as Tennant announced his departure in October 2008 - but Moffat was not unprepared for the possibility that he would stay, and in fact, he had an alternative version of the Amy Pond storyline ready to go.
This storyline would see the Tenth Doctor appear to young Amelia Pond, like we saw in The Eleventh Hour with Matt Smith's Doctor. But in a typical Moff twist, it would later be revealed that the Tenth Doctor was at the end of his life here, and had arrived in Amy's garden, dying, after travelling with her older self for an entire series.
There's no doubt that a series of Doctor Who led by Moffat and Tennant would've been amazing, and though this would've robbed us of Matt Smith's wonderful incarnation, we wouldn't have known that at the time!
4. The Martha Jones Adventures
Martha Jones is one of the most underrated companions of the revival era, likely due to falling in the middle of much more popular supporting characters like Rose Tyler and Donna Noble.
However, Martha gets bonus points over those two companions because she's the only one who appeared in Torchwood, popping up in the second series for a handful of episodes. And at one point in time, there were even bigger plans for the character too, which would've almost transformed her into the Nick Fury of the Whoniverse (sans eyepatch).
After her stint in Series 2 of Torchwood, the plan was to bring Martha back for Series 3, and integrate her closer into that team. But unfortunately, Freema Agyeman's successful career outside Doctor Who prevented this from happening.
Furthermore, Martha was also slated to appear in the second series of The Sarah Jane Adventures, only for Agyeman's other commitments to again throw a wrench in the works. On the plus side, this did lead to Martha's role being filled by the marvellous Nicholas Courtney as Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart.
Giving Martha an even bigger role in the Whoniverse would've been fantastic, so it's a damn shame these plans fell through. Let's hope she returns for that rumoured UNIT spinoff, eh?
3. Tom Baker And The Talking Cabbage
Starting off in 1963 with Ian, Barbara, and Susan, the Doctor has always had a friendly and familiar face by their side.
Whether it's a human, an alien, a fellow Time Lord, or a creaky old robot (shoutout to Kamelion), the companion exists to represent us, the audience, and to ask the Doctor questions about the plot. The companions also introduce human emotion, in contrast to the Doctor's otherworldly madness.
After the departure of companion Leela however, Tom Baker had a slightly different idea for his next companion: a talking cabbage. He even pitched this idea to the producers - that this magical cabbage would sit on his shoulder and play the role of companion in the next season.
In a somewhat understandable decision, the BBC declined Tom's idea.
Now, would this have been a disaster? Quite possibly. But would we have given everything we own to see it? Hell yes. Look, Doctor Who thrives on silliness - sometimes, this doesn't work (the Abzorbaloff), but sometimes, it works brilliantly (sentient fat taking over London).
This damn cabbage could've been the next Doctor Who icon. If anyone could've made it work, it's Tom Baker.
2. The Day Of The Ninth Doctor
50th anniversary special The Day of the Doctor was a triumph, and celebrated everything that made the programme so wonderful and special.
One element that contributed to this was the much-anticipated return of David Tennant as the Tenth Doctor, alongside John Hurt as a totally new incarnation of the Doctor known as the War Doctor.
However, the special was originally going to be a very different episode, and would've seen all of the modern Doctors onscreen together.
When writing those early drafts of the story, Steven Moffat spoke to Christopher Eccleston about returning as the Ninth Doctor. Eccleston listened to what Moffat had to say, but upon reading the script, politely said that it wasn't right for him. As a result, Moffat created the War Doctor to fill the gap that was intended for Nine.
Eccleston has since admitted that he's not a fan of multi-Doctor stories in general, so that's probably another reason he was reluctant to join Smith and Tennant in the episode. But needless to say, it would've been amazing to see.
1. The Doctor's Temporary Recast
Modern Doctor Who peaked in popularity at the end of the 2000s, and the peak within that peak was arguably The Stolen Earth/Journey's End.
The end of that first episode - where the Doctor starts to regenerate - is one of the biggest cliffhangers in Doctor Who history, and there was genuine uncertainty among fans as to whether or not Tennant would turn into someone else. Bookies were even taking bets about which actor would replace him!
And while it did feel like a bit of a cop-out for the cliffhanger to be resolved so easily, there was a chance we could've had a vastly different (and totally brilliant) opening scene, as explained by showrunner Russell T Davies:
"If I had my time again… I'd have MILKED that. I'd have cast a whole new Doctor, a superstar for ONE scene. Ian McKellen! Judi Dench! Have them run around the TARDIS. Then discover the hand, and regenerate back. IMAGINE!!! Why didn’t I?"
As fate would have it, RTD is back at the helm once again, so don't be surprised to see David Tennant regenerate into a Hollywood A-lister for a scene or two.
Ooo, what if Neil Patrick Harris is actually the Doctor, and we're all being tricked!? Stranger things have happened in this show.
Watch Next
Doctor Who Quiz: How Well Do You Know Matt Smith's 11th Doctor?