10 Awesome TV Shows That Never Won A (Major) Emmy Award

The biggest snubs from the Academy of Television Arts & Sciences.

The Leftovers Water And Tears
HBO

Well, that was the Emmy Awards 2017. Stephen Colbert delivered a musical monologue that featured Chance the Rapper, Millie Bobby Brown, and the Demogorgon; Lena Waithe made history; Sterling K. Brown was unceremoniously played off; Veep, Big Little Lies, and The Handmaid's Tale all won big; Donald Glover rocked a purple tux (and won two awards); and Sean Spicer was somehow invited in on the joke.

For every big victory at the TV equivalent of the Oscars, though, there's a snub to go with it. The Handmaid's Tale deserved its win, for example, but it also means Better Call Saul is now 0-3 (and perhaps more egregiously, so too is its star, Bob Odenkirk).

This is nothing new for the Emmys, which has a habit of sticking to what it knows (especially looking at the Outstanding Comedy Series category), and given only a select number of shows can be handed the statues each year, it means that a lot of great TV series have had their best efforts go unrewarded. (Note: this is focused on the major directing, writing, acting, and overall series awards, rather than the technical or guest categories).


11. Honourable Mention. The Simpsons

The Simpsons Streetcar Named Desire
Fox

Yes, The Simpsons has won 32 Emmy Awards, including Outstanding Animated Program 10 times. And yet despite that, it has never received any love in the main awards categories.

Due to it being an animated series it wasn't initially eligible for these, but after a rule change in 1993 the show was submitted a few times for Outstanding Comedy Series. Despite the mid-90s representing the show's peak - and as such, the apex of TV comedy writing as a whole - it didn't even get a nomination, with voters clearly unable to look past the fact it was animated and recognise its true greatness.


10. Parks And Recreation

NBC

Greg Daniels and Mike Schur's political sitcom was frequently nominated by the Emmys, but never received any proper love during its seven-season run. The show was nominated for Outstanding Comedy Series twice - in 2011 and 2015 - with star Amy Poehler earning Oustanding Lead Actress nods on six occasions but never picking up the prize.

The reason for this comes down to two shows the Emmys adore: Modern Family and Veep. Parks & Rec emerged just when the former was hitting its stride as an awards giant, while most of Poehler's nominations coincided with Julia Louis-Dreyfus picking up the Actress award every year.

While both of those shows have deserved some of their dominance, it's hard to think that Parks & Rec, and certainly Poehler, didn't deserve at least one moment of recognition during that run (Poehler also lost out to Nurse Jackie's Edie Falco, and Mike and Molly's Melissa McCarthy). All that's not to mention the supporting performances and the sharp writing, none of which garnered nominations, much less an actual win.


9. Battlestar Galactica

Sci-Fi

Sci-fi doesn't get a lot of love at the Emmys - or any big awards shows across movies and TV, really, which is a whole other issue - and that's led to a few misses, but one of the biggest is Ronald D. Moore's reboot of Battlestar Galactica.

Airing from 2004-2009, the series used its space setting to deal with a number of deeply resonant and relevant themes, from religion to the war on terror, and featured excellent performances and writing.

The ATAS did recognise this to a degree, as it won awards for Sound Editing and VFX, but only nominations for writing and directing. Unfortunately, its run coincided with the rise of Lost, the end of The Sopranos, and the beginning of Mad Men, so it didn't get much of a look in, but losing writing and directing awards to House and especially latter-day E.R. feel like serious snubs for the show.


8. Star Trek

Star Trek The Original Series Where No Man Has Gone Before
NBC

Speaking of sci-fi TV shows, they don't come more iconic than Star Trek, and it's incredible now to think that one of the most influential series of all time didn't get any recognition at the Emmys.

The worst example is The Original Series, which was nominated twice for Outstanding Drama Series, and lost on both occasions to Mission: Impossible, with Leonard Nimoy's Spock also overlooked both of those years.

The Next Generation fared better, with a number of technical wins, but was only nominated once in the Outstanding Drama Series category, where it lost out to Picket Fences, and Patrick Stewart didn't get any recognition for his leading role.


7. Gilmore Girls

Gilmore Girls
The CW

The CW, formerly known as The WB, isn't a network that gets much recognition from Emmy voters, due to it being outside the 'Big 4' and typically skewed at a younger audience. That, though, means some great shows miss out (see also: Veronica Mars, Crazy Ex-Girlfriend).

Gilmore Girls definitely suffered from this, as well as being a dramedy, and thus slightly harder to put into either category (it entered both over the years). The series won just one Emmy over its original seven-year run, for Makeup, and that was also its only nomination.

It's easier to buy that if treating it as a Drama, because The West Wing and The Sopranos were dominating, but in the Comedy race it was certainly deserving. Its run saw awards go to the likes of Everybody Loves Raymond and Malcolm in the Middle, and the rapid dialogue, emotional beats, and whip-smart pop-culture references of Amy Sherman-Palladino's writing should've been recognised there, as should Lauren Graham's wonderful performance as Lorelai Gilmore.


6. Oz

Oz HBO
HBO

The Sopranos may have been the series that really turned HBO into a dramatic powerhouse, but Oz was the one that showed it was even possible. And while David Chase's epic took home 21 Emmys, including two wins for Outstanding Drama Series, Oz received just two nominations across its six-year run (for Guest Actor and Casting).

Prior to The West Wing and The Sopranos hitting big, Outstanding Drama Series was largely fought between shows like The Practice and NYPD: Blue. Oz, despite its stellar writing and cast, couldn't get a look in. It's a sign that the show was slightly ahead of its time, with its shocking, brutal nature garnering some controversy and critical backlash.


5. Community

Community Study Group
NBC

Another victim of Modern Family's dominance, it's a major shame that one of the smartest and funniest sitcoms of its generation consistently went unrewarded by the Emmys. The closest it came was in 2012, when it was nominated for Outstanding Writing, but lost out to Louie.

Even just the fact that was its first major nomination was bad enough, though. Seasons 2 and 3 especially saw the show operating on another level, which should've seen it earn at least one Oustanding Comedy Series award.

Advanced Dungeons and Dragons should've received some love for writing, and either Modern Warfare or A Fistful of Paintballs would've warranted an Outstanding Directing win, while all of the cast were pretty great throughout too (especially Donald Glover and Danny Pudi).


4. The Leftovers

The Leftovers Season 3
HBO

The most recent series on this list, with Damon Lindelof's series being completely overlooked during its three-season run (with the exception this year of Ann Dowd, who received a Guest Actress nod). And with the show coming to an end earlier in 2017, there's no longer any chance of putting it right.

The series had a difficult first season, but Seasons 2 and in particular 3 provided some of the most beautiful television of the decade so far. And while you can point to the victories of shows like Game of Thrones and Orphan Black over the past couple of years, there's not much of an excuse for it not sweeping the board this year.

The Leftovers Season 3 was the best drama on TV; Carrie Coon the best actress; and Mimi Leder's director was exceptional. That none were even nominated is something of a travesty.


3. Twin Peaks

Laura Palmer Twin Peaks Pilot
ABC

Twin Peaks: The Return could well sweep the Emmys next year, especially if it's in the Limited Series category, and that would at least go some way to correcting the wrongs of the early '90s, when David Lynch's mystery series was massively overlooked.

The show's incredible first season was nominated for a bunch of big categories, including Outstanding Drama, Directing, Writing, Lead Actor, and Lead Actress, and yet came away with just Costume Design and Editing wins.

The winners of those other categories? L.A. Law, Equal Justice, L.A. Law again, Peter Falk, and Patricia Wettig, and it's hard to argue for any of them over what Twin Peaks and its cast did.


2. Buffy The Vampire Slayer

Buffy The Vampire Slayer Season 1
Mutant Enemy Productions

From one groundbreaking series to another, Buffy the Vampire Slayer was a remarkable achievement, but one that garnered almost no recognition from the Academy of Television Arts & Sciences. The series won for Outstanding Makeup and Music Compilation back in 1998, and received a further 12 nominations, almost exclusively in technical categories - with a Writing nod for Joss Whedon the sole exception.

Like Oz, it should've been in with a shout for the top prize before The West Wing started dominating, but was likely a bit too weird (and, of course, on the wrong network) to really succeed. Going further into its run, when the dominance of other shows was clearer, there's still a strong case to be made for Writing and Directing wins: Hush was only nominated for the latter, and somehow The Body and Once More With Feeling - two very different, but equally brilliant episodes - didn't even receive that much.


1. The Wire

The Wire
HBO

This is the biggie, and the one it's impossible not to mention when discussing TV shows the Emmys didn't recognise. If any series gives evidence to the failings of awards shows like this, it's The Wire.

The magnum opus of David Simon (whose Treme and Show Me A Hero were largely ignored too), there's a very strong argument to be made that it is the greatest TV drama ever produced. Despite that, it received just two nominations over its five-season run - both for Outstanding Writing - and didn't win either.

Obviously there were some great shows of that time, such as the oft-mentioned Sopranos and West Wing, but for The Wire - which was operating on the same level as those, if not higher, in every category - to not win anything is absolutely shocking (especially when Lost and 24 took the top prize in 2005 and 2006 respectively).

What do you think were the biggest Emmys snubs? Share your thoughts down in the comments.


Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.