10 Best Arrowverse Performances Of 2019

Emotional breakdowns, villainous delights and quiet powerhouses - the Arrowverse had it all.

Supergirl Season 5 Kara Danvers Melissa Benoist
The CW

The end of the year (and decade) is upon us, and that means we can look back on everything that film, TV and pop-culture had to offer us in 2019. And when it comes to the TV conversation, it's inevitable that the Arrowverse is going to come up.

In hindsight, it's been a rather big year for the Arrowverse, hasn't it? Not only has it welcomed a brand new show (the first in three years) into its midst in Batwoman, it's also begun laying the groundwork for two more. To top it all off, the shared universe of costumed heroes has also been building towards its biggest crossover yet - something that came to fruition in the first three parts of Crisis On Infinite Earths.

Naturally, a major year such as this wouldn't be complete without some awe-inspiring performances. Yes, being on The CW, the actors of the Arrowverse are often overlooked at awards ceremonies when, in all honesty, some of them are every bit as formidable (if not better) than those who aren't.

With that in mind, let's take a look back at the Arrowverse's 2019 and admire the very best that its actors had to offer.

10. Rachel Skarsten

Batwoman show
The CW

Show: Batwoman

Episode: 'Mine Is A Long And A Sad Tale'

If this writer is being honest, Rachel Skarsten's entry on this list could be based upon any of the episodes of Batwoman in which she has appeared so far. She's got this incredible ability to effortlessly shift between gleeful psychopath and heartbroken child in an instant, and that makes all of her performances that much more unpredictable.

However, it was the fifth episode of the season that delved into Alice's roots, and that allowed her to go that much further with it. Giving us an insight into why Batwoman's beloved sister had become such a depraved villain, Skarsten sold the heck out of Alice's emotional scars - giving life to every single word with eccentric mannerisms or emotive outbursts.

Batwoman still has a lot of work to do if it wants to catch up to its Arrowverse counterparts, but if it continues to rely on Skarsten's acting prowess, it could find its way there in 2020.


9. Candice Patton

The Flash The Void Iris
The CW

Show: The Flash

Episode: 'Into The Void'

Candice Patton has been at the forefront of The Flash quite often, but she hasn't always had material worthy of her (as Iris West once found herself shoehorned into the damsel-in-distress role). However, Seasons 5 and 6 have given the leading lady some really great storylines that emphasised her overall importance to the show. More than that, however, they emphasised her acting prowess.

A perfect example of this was her turn in the Season 6 premiere, as Iris struggled with grief over the fact that her daughter Nora West-Allen had been erased from existence. And this provided Patton with multiple opportunities to deliver a powerful, nuanced performance that encapsulated the range of emotions her character was feeling.

One of the most underappreciated performers in the Arrowverse, this was just one example of how amazing she truly is and it set the bar incredibly high when it came to premiere performances.


8. Stephen Amell

Arrow Oliver Queen Green Stephen Amell
The CW

Show: Supergirl

Episode: 'Crisis On Infinite Earths, Part 1'

Would you believe that the Green Arrow's best performance this year didn't actually come on his own show? Well, that's what you get when you pull the trigger on the biggest crossover of all time.

Crisis On Infinite Earths was expected to feature the death of Oliver Queen, but it wasn't supposed to happen in the very first episode. However, that's exactly what happened when the Emerald Archer took on a horde of Shadow Demons and fought to his very last breath in a bid to save Earth-38.

Stephen Amell produced a last stand for Oliver as triumphant and resilient as we've come to expect from him, but it was his emotional delivery of his character's death scene only seconds later that really threw viewers for a loop. And it was his unexpected emotional subtlety - as Oliver bid farewell to Barry, Sara and daughter Mia - that had us all crying our eyes out.

'You keep me in your heart, okay?' he told Mia. Oh Stephen, after that, you're never leaving our hearts. Ever.


7. Jon Cryer

Supergirl Lex Luthor
The CW

Show: Supergirl

Episode: 'O Brother, Where Art Thou?'

Jon Cryer was so positively delicious with villainy throughout his three-episode run on Supergirl during its fourth season that he left an unforgettable impression on the show - an impression that started with his debut appearance in 'O Brother, Where Art Thou'.

From his suave and smooth portrayal of the self-proclaimed 'Man of Tomorrow' to the occasionally unhinged crazy genius who roars things like 'Miss Teschmacher' with reckless abandon, Cryer brought so many elements of the comic book Lex Luthor to life without even trying.

If you want to see the personification of the perfect Lex Luthor, wathc the episode's closing moments as Cryer confidently summons the Luthor Mansion's laser beams as if he were conducting some kind of killer orchestra. That's Lex Luthor at his finest.


6. Brandon Routh

Crisis On Infinite Earths Kingdom Come Superman Brandon Routh
The CW

Show: Batwoman, The Flash

Episode: 'Crisis On Infinite Earths' Parts 2 and 3

Brandon Routh has been one of the Arrowverse's most consistent players over the past half-decade, making us all laugh and love him as the adorable Ray Palmer on DC's Legends of Tomorrow, but it was this year's crossover, Crisis On Infinite Earths, that finally allowed him to shine.

Reprising his Superman Returns role, Routh donned that iconic uniform one more time - except this time, it was the Kingdom Come version. And he delivered a performance that reminded us all why he deserved so much more credit for bringing the Man of Steel to life in the first place - because that's exactly what he did all over again.

'Even in the darkest of times, hope cuts through,' - this Superman's answer as to why he was so hopeful in spite of the loss he had suffered. And if that doesn't sum up Supes in a nutshell, nothing will. Routh is the Man of Steel personified.


5. Ben Lewis

Arrow Season 8 William
The CW

Show: Arrow

Episode: 'Present Tense'

Arrow's flash-forward narrative wasn't the show's most coherent, but it was elevated by strong performances from the likes of Ben Lewis and Katherine McNamara. The former, however, finally got his chance to shine when his character, William Clayton - the son of Oliver Queen and Samantha Clayton - was transported to the present.

The scene between him and Stephen Amell in which William came out to his father may just be the most quietly powerful moment in the history of the show. We already knew that William was gay, but the authentic way in which Lewis approached it made viewers feel like they were discovering it for the first time, and that made it all more emotional. The delivery was so genuine, and the heartfelt moment had us all wanting to smile like Oliver and give him a big hug.

Everything about his performance was real, and it resonated with so many people; moving would be an understatement.


4. Grant Gustin

The Flash Season 6 Barry Allen
The CW

Show: The Flash

Episode: 'The Last Temptation of Barry Allen, Pt 1'

Grant Gustin spent The Flash's first two seasons absolutely amazing fans with his outstanding offerings as the lovable Barry Allen, but as the show moved into more superheroic territory, it meant that we were treated to less of these simply because there were less character-driven offerings. That being said, it all turned around in Season 6's 'The Last Temptation of Barry Allen, Pt 1' and, as always, Gustin was nothing short of incredible.

As Barry found himself torn between life in a deadly world or death in a safe one, the young actor brought all of the Scarlet Speedster's fears to life so naturally. From his pained expressions to his erratic behaviour, he personified Barry's desperation to live with a single performance - one that will undoubtedly go down in history as one of the best of his entire career.

Powerhouse doesn't even begin to cover what he accomplished here.


3. Melissa Benoist

Supergirl Kara Danvers Melissa Benoist
The CW

Show: Supergirl

Episode: 'Event Horizon'

Melissa Benoist has given us no shortage of super moments throughout Supergirl's run but her finest might have been her turn in the Season 5 premiere, when the show finally pulled the trigger on a moment it had been building to for years.

As Kara revealed to Lena Luthor that she was Supergirl, Benoist attacked us with emotions in a way that had quite frankly never been seen before. Watching her quake with terror as tears rolled down her face, she effectively personified the fear that the beloved hero was feeling as she came clean about a secret she was harbouring for years.

What made this scene all the more impressive is that it all clearly took place in the one shot, showcasing her immense talent by presenting it like a theater-esque monologue - something the Broadway star is no stranger to. A world-class performance.


2. Chyler Leigh

Supergirl Alex Danvers Chyler Leigh
The CW

Show: Supergirl

Episode: 'Red Dawn'

Chyler Leigh has always been Supergirl's most reliable hidden gem, but there was nothing hidden about her emotional offering in the penultimate episode of Season 4 earlier this year. A scene that many of us had been waiting for, it was the culmination of the season-long mind-wipe storyline in which her character Alex Danvers remembered that her sister was Supergirl just as she was dying - but no amount of anticipation could have prepared us for Leigh's powerhouse performance.

The convincingly naive optimism in the darkest of times, the desperate pleas and those heart-wrenching voice cracks, she pulled out all the stops here and you'd be hard-pressed to find anyone who didn't bawl their eyes out watching her do it. This wasn't just one of the best Arrowverse performances of 2019, but one of the best across all of film and TV.

Stunning, beautiful and heartbreaking, Leigh is a class act.


1. Katie Cassidy

Arrow Season 8 Laurel Lance Black Canary
The CW

Show: Arrow

Episode: 'Welcome To Hong Kong'

Katie Cassidy was always going to be in the Top 5 of this list ever since she delivered that unexpectedly moving performance at the beginning of the year in 'Past Sins', but her offering in Season 8's 'Welcome To Hong Kong' stood out even more - and given the magnitude of the first, that's really saying something.

Laurel Lance (a.k.a. Black Canary) may have avoided death by anti-matter but she was left with a serious case of survivor's guilt as she mourned the destruction of her entire universe. The silver lining in that, however, is that it provided resident heavy-hitter (and leading lady) Cassidy to showcase why she's carried much of the show over the years.

There's no particular scene to highlight here, because she effectively channeled Laurel's feelings of grief, guilt, resentment and heartbreak every time she was on-screen, but if there's anything we can learn from this, it's that the Arrowverse's original leading lady has always been its most underappreciated performer. She was, quite simply, outstanding.

-

Which Arrowverse performer impressed you this year? Tell us in the comment section below.


The Flash Season 6 Quiz: How Well Do You Remember The First Half?

The Flash The Void
The CW

1. On Which Date Did The Flash Season 6 Premiere?

In this post: 
Arrowverse
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.