10 Best TV Shows That Were Never Made
From adaptations of great books and films to Anti-Semite: The Show, these were nixed by executives.
Pilot season must feel like Christmas to TV aficionados and executives, and with the changing landscape of the medium, radically different and more daring programming can find a home on streaming services, HBO, FX - anywhere that'll buy it. But every season, network executives inevitably come down with a serious case of buyer's remorse.
For whatever reason, be it the content too controversial or sub-standard, some shows never find an audience. There's no particular rhyme or reason why certain shows don't find an audience, but executives are numbers guys, and if Nielsen ratings don't spell success, the shows are quickly pulled from the primetime line-up.
Other shows come off as tone-deaf, not echoing the social and political morays of their time.
Even further down the rabbit hole, some of these pilots have crackerjack premises, but ultimately fail to sing when shown to the general public.
All these reasons, and more, amount to why the following shows lasted only a few episodes or broadcast none at all. Some never made it that far into production. But we certainly wish they did
Here's just a handful of shows that, for whatever reasons, just didn't work out.
10. L.A. Confidential Almost Happened...Twice
L.A. Confidential was successfully adapted into a feature film by Curtis Hanson and Brian Helgeland in 1997, excising or condensing the novel's epic scope and whittling it down to its core. Even author James Ellroy, who at that point had seen his work butchered on the big screen, praised the adaptation and shepherded the project in his own creepy, creepy way (he would call star Russell Crowe and leave unusual poems on his answering machine).
Six years after the film's success, a television pilot was ordered starring Kiefer Sutherland as Jack Vincennes, the role originated by Kevin Spacey. It was never picked up, but the episode is available on the two-disc DVD edition of the film. In fairness to networks who rejected it - the pilot doesn't quite gel, despite offering up more subplots from the novel to delve into.
Two years ago, it had another shot at television when CBS announced it was going to shoot a new pilot with Walton Goggins as Vincennes and character actor Shea Whigham as corrupt cop Dick Stensland.
Despite a promising cast, the network pulled the plug on it before it even began. But it definitely appeared to be moving in the grittier direction more in line with Ellroy's prose. Still, CBS is a bit of a warning sign - a network that exists primarily to continue to run shows only your parents watch.
It seems just as Hanson and Helgeland had condensed the novel's sprawling narrative, the networks had difficulty expanding upon it.
9. Beverly Hills Cop Has Been At Various Stages Of Development Over The Years
Eddie Murphy broke a comedic glass ceiling when he headlined Beverly Hills Cop. Though he had touched on the buddy cop picture in the past, Martin Brest's fish out of water comedy further highlighted the comic's talents and paired him with not one, but a whole city full, of straight men. Though two sequels followed (the second Murphy referred to as "atrocious"), the future of the franchise has been up in the air, bouncing between TV and film.
In 2013, CBS approached TV writer and showrunner Shawn Ryan to shoot a pilot featuring Brandon T. Jackson as Murphy's son. Ryan's aim was to infiltrate the landscape of network procedurals and stealthily inject some social commentary.
Ultimately, CBS passed on the pilot and the franchise's future has ranged from hopeful - with Murphy on board after years of hesitation - to hopeless - with noted hacks like Brett Ratner attached at one point.
8. Who's Your Daddy? Was The Reality Show That Would Have Usurped Maury Povich
Before reality TV took hold of our braindead couch zombie existence, we had Maury Povich, Jerry Springer and Sally Jesse Raphael to satiate our desire to view the worst of society like caged animals, the ringleaders of these white trash circuses providing a shameful finger-wagging at the end to remind us of our superiority.
Then came the dawn of Survivor, a reality game show. At least, at that point, the contestants resembled something average. It seemed as though audiences actually wanted to see exaggerated versions of themselves on TV. Alas, no, it turns out we still just want to watch the obscenely wealthy act like catty, immature hellspawn and throw drinks at one another. We've progressed; at the height of Spinger's popularity, it was chairs.
FOX clearly saw that Who's Your Daddy? was problematic, calling it a "special" rather than a series premiere when it aired so they could pull the plug without any questions asked. Pro-abortion groups were up in arms about a show that trivialized the process - using the reality show format to play Maury's old game and have the contestant guess who their birth parents are. But it seems to attempt to bridge that gap, and a culturally insensitive at the start of the reality craze is at least more honest than what the genre became.
The premise was simple: a foster child is tasked to identify their birth parents from a group of "impostors". It was a "special" disaster, prompting adoption rights groups to protest before airing.
Still, it's probably the first reality show that spoke to the blatant huckerism and dishonesty that embodies the "reality" of such shows. It was just too much too soon - we still had to give money to that jackass who won Survivor and pretend we were glad.
7. Heil Honey, I'm Home! Was The Hitler Sitcom Nobody Wanted, But Was Ahead Of Its Time
It was comedy legend Mel Brooks who said that laughing at people and groups that inspire hatred takes away their power, and if recent years have taught us anything, there are smart, funny, even tasteful ways to mock to leader of the Third Reich. Works like JoJo Rabbit, Brooks' The Producers and its musical as well as To Be or Not To Be serve as perfect examples of how to make Hitler the subject of ridicule.
In 1990, however, England's Heil Honey, I'm Home proved how not to do it. Most criticisms of the sitcom centered around its tasteless premise, which saw Adolf and Eva Braun living in Berlin in 1938 next to a Jewish couple, but few mention how shrill and irritating it is apart from the controversy. None of the jokes land successfully, and the show's main flaw is glaring: it doesn't centre around subtle criticism of the genocidal maniac, but instead mocks the standard set up of a 50s sitcom - using I Love Lucy as a template.
One episode aired, much to the disgust of the country. With some adjustments, however, it's not a premise without merit. Years earlier, National Lampoon Magazine did a photoshoot with Adolf on the beaches of South America - equally in bad taste, but much funnier. So a show about the leader of the third Reich wrestling with domestic hassles is not without comedic potential, Heil Honey just aimed at the wrong targets.
6. Utopia Was Pulled Because The BBC Was Afraid To Offend
Younger readers may not know the name Spike Milligan, but his influence on British Comedy through his radio troupe The Goon Show - particularly Monty Python - is fairly significant. Co-starring a young Peter Sellers, the absurdist, subversive comedy bled into other areas of Milligan's work, including poetry, theatre, novels and eventually television.
The Melting Pot was a step too far for the BBC. Starring Milligan as "Mr. Van Gogh" (in brownface), an illegal Pakistani immigrant who winds up in a boarding house with a diverse group of people in similar situations, it ran only one episode before the BBC pulled the plug, leaving the other seven filmed unaired. Milligan would reuse some of the situational comedy in his novel The Looney, but most people agree the show was too racially insensitive tor run.
Milligan's legacy, even if it's just a footnote in Peter Seller's ultimate biography, deserved better. He and the Goons were the enfant terribles of British radio - so perhaps sticking through some of the less than politically correct work to find at least something amusing.
5. Ford Nation Gave Toronto's Crack-Smoking Mayor A Platform
Those who know of Rob Ford's antics as the Mayor of Toronto either are Canadian or caught wind of the funniest, creepiest scandal in politics this side of Marion Barry from their favourite late-night talk show. Ford was caught on video smoking crack in a hotel room, using racial slurs and in general coming across as an obese pig. He also mocked a fellow politician in session for being caught driving under the influence by pantomiming drinking and driving from his seat.
That guy? He's dead and his brother is the Premier of Ontario now. His brother, for the record, is no better, bringing a terrifyingly conservative edge to Canadian politics that includes cutting funding for children with autism - you know, the real enemy of the people.
The struggling Canadian news network Sun News offered the brothers a Monday night talk show at the height of the crack scandal. Despite fantastic ratings from rubberneckers, Sun didn't want to be associated with such scandal and pulled the plug after one episode.
Apparently, though, we live in an era where society cannot differentiate TV personalities from politicians, and Doug Ford is the face of Canadian Conservatism. One would have preferred a crack-induced McLoughlin Group. At the very least, it would have kept the Ford family busy, sparing us the Trump-inspired new Canadian Right.
4. James Ellroy's American Tabloid Has Been Attempted Multiple Times
Author James Ellroy is best known for his L.A. Quartet, featuring four interconnected novels that play with the stories behind the real history of the city of angels from the 40s to the early 60s. Starting with The Black Dahlia and concluding with White Jazz, every novel in the series has, at one point, been at some stage in production.
As for his other masterworks, producers felt they were ripe for serialized television. His Underworld U.S.A. Trilogy opens with American Tabloid and concludes with Blood's A Rover - each novel covering the notable assassinations in the 1960s and the men who orchestrated them, either indirectly or intentionally.
In 2002, the property fell into the hands of Bruce Willis, who felt the first two novels (Blood's a Rover had yet to be written) would work well as a miniseries. But his option expired before he could get production running.
In 2008, Tom Hanks' production company Playtone was developing them as either a mini or ongoing series for HBO - the one place on television that would tolerate the racial slurs, violence and vicious takedowns of important historical figures.
Currently, none of Ellroy's work is optioned, with several projects falling through. He continues to write and be a particularly vulgar guest on Conan O'Brien.
3. Heat Vision And Jack Was One Of The Best Things That Just Didn't Happen
Though Hollywood and critics didn't catch on at the time, 1999 was a huge year for comedy, ringing in the new century with a new cast of rogues that had paid their dues in bit parts and small roles before getting discovered.
Ben Stiller was one of the first casualties of this gross miscalculation, and even though his sketch show took home an Emmy, it was canceled early. With misleading ratings and a lack of understanding 90s teens, Stiller's whole team had their careers briefly stymied. This included the heavy-drinking, Community creator Dan Harmon, Jack Black, and Rob Schrab.
With a cast comprised of Black, the voice of Owen Wilson as his talking motorcycle and the late Ron Silver as himself, Harmon and Schrab set out to create a send-up of those high-concept one-hour dramas of the 70s and 80s such as Knight Rider and Manimal.
Black is a former astronaut who, after an accident, gained the super abilities powered by the sun (Black: "I KNOW EVERYTHING!"), his best friend Wilson merged with his motorcycle. Together, they're on the run from NASA agent Ron Silver. You know, from Timecop.
FOX ordered a pilot but no follow up. Heat Vision has gained fans since its appearance online and Schrab alluded to a feature script in the works as late as 2007.
2. Lookwell Was The Next Police Squad!
Like Heat Vision, Lookwell gained a lot of traction after appearing online and in the "Brilliant but Cancelled" collection. Also like Heat Vision, it was birthed by two writers who clearly grew up on 70s Network Television - in this case writers Conan O'Brien and Robert Smigel.
Lookwell finds an aging Adam West - used before Family Guy ever got turned on to the idea of keeping him around for a laugh - as a former TV star who had a show decades ago in which he played hard-boiled L.A. cop, but now teaches an actor's workshop. His instincts from the show, however, kick back in gear and with the help of his students, he solves a ring of stolen luxury cars.
It was a favourite of NBC Network Chairman Brandon Tartikoff, but by the time it came to optioning the show, he was replaced by Warren Littlefield. Smigel chalks up the failure of the show to the change in leadership. He still runs live screenings of the episode at festivals and to the day he died, West said it was his favourite project that didn't work out.
1. Confederate, From The Writers Of Game Of Thrones, Will Never Be Made Thanks To Internet Outrage
It's somewhat surprising what America chooses to get angered about online, and Confederate, from Game of Thrones writers David Benioff and D.B. Weiss was the most recent casualty of such outrage. Set in an alternate history in which the Civil War ended in a stalemate, it's genuinely surprising this show didn't make it further in production. With the success of Amazon Prime's The Man in the High Castle and HBO's The Plot Against America, Confederate felt like a sure thing.
Alas, the internet threw a tantrum. April Reign, originator of the popular hashtag #oscarssowhite, led the rebellion with #noconfederate and alas it was never to be.