10 Biggest Plot Holes In Buffy The Vampire Slayer
We all love Buffy's adventures, but sometimes they don't make sense...
Buffy the Vampire Slayer looks like a disaster on paper. A story about a teenage girl battling the forces of evil in a town called Sunnydale is a bizarre premise that some struggle to take seriously.
But thanks to an exceptionally talented team of writers, this unique show was a huge success and remains popular today. Though some seasons are certainly better than others, there are only a handful of bad episodes. Most of the time, Buffy’s adventures are loaded with gripping storylines, satisfying character arcs, and fascinating villains.
Occasionally, however, the show is tarnished by a plot hole, and this is hardly surprising given there are almost 150 episodes. These plot holes often arise in the form of inconsistencies that Buffy fans are quick to notice. And there’s also a number of plot holes that are simply nonsensical. They leave us scratching our heads, unable to understand why something has or hasn’t happened.
When watching Buffy for the first time, these plot holes can tarnish the experience a little bit. But once you’ve become accustomed to them, they actually make the show more entertaining.
10. Buffy Has More Than One Birthday
In 1997, Buffy arrives at Sunnydale High as a sophomore student and turns sixteen by the end of the show’s first season – at least in theory.
In ‘I Robot…You Jane’, there’s a major blunder involving Buffy’s birthday. When a demon called Moloch starts investigating Buffy, he finds her school profile and her birthday: 24th October 1980. Seconds later, Fritz looks at the very same profile, and the date has changed to 6th May 1979. This is an obvious inconsistency, and the latter doesn’t even make sense – Buffy’s not meant to be seventeen until the next season.
To make matters worse, even the first date is wrong. Officially – and Joss Whedon has confirmed this – Buffy’s birthday is 19th January 1981, which aligns with the birthday episodes in the other six seasons.
But this still doesn’t explain what happened in the first season. Somehow, they managed to mess up Buffy’s birthday twice in the same episode.
9. The Praying Mantis Eggs
The fourth episode of the first season involves a giant praying mantis disguised as an attractive biology teacher. Xander develops a crush on her, and before long, he has to be rescued by Buffy and the gang.
It’s a pretty dumb storyline, all things considered, and in the final shot of the episode, the camera drops down to reveal a cluster of praying mantis eggs inside the biology classroom. You would assume, therefore, that there’s going to be some kind of follow-up episode.
But there isn't. The murderous offspring of a giant praying mantis are never addressed again. Did they fail to hatch? Did someone destroy the eggs? Are there more praying mantises roaming around somewhere?
Turns out we’ll never know. The cliffhanger at the end of the episode has no payoff whatsoever. Still, this is probably a good thing given the praying mantis is one of the worst villains in the show.
8. Vampire Breath
During the finale of Season 1, Buffy is bitten by the Master and collapses into a pool. When Angel and Xander find her body, they rush over to her. After claiming to have no breath, Angel has to watch as Xander tries to revive his friend.
The thing is, there’s plenty of evidence to contradict Angel’s claim. Throughout the show, vampires – including Angel – will pant during fights or chase sequences. And in ‘Becoming, Part 2’, Spike knocks out Drusilla by putting her in a chokehold. This should be impossible – if you can’t breathe, you can’t suffocate either.
Speaking of Spike, he smokes throughout the entire show, and you can't smoke unless you have breath!
Does it really matter in terms of the overall story? No, but it’s still odd that the writers chose to include this rule in the first place.
7. Vampire Reflections
Which brings us to yet another vampire-related issue: reflections.
Once again, it’s Angel who establishes this rule. Back in the penultimate episode of Season 1, he shows up in the library, and Giles is quick to notice something: ‘A vampire casts no reflection.’
The trouble is, anyone with a knack for observation will know that vampire reflections appear throughout the show’s run. If you keep an eye out, you can spot these reflections in mirrors, windows, and even pools of water. It’s hard to notice unless you’re looking for it, but it’s there nonetheless.
Just like the breath issue, it would have been easier to not include this rule in the first place. After all, the absence of a reflection never has any effect on the plot.
6. Buffy’s House Repairs Itself
The Summers’ household is one of the most iconic locations in the show. Most of the time, it’s a sanctuary for Buffy and the gang, a place where our heroes can relax and recuperate.
But Buffy’s home is far from fool proof. In every season, there’s at least one outbreak of violence within its walls. Vampires, robots, zombies, assassins, and a number of other demons all wreak havoc, and they rarely leave the house in a presentable state.
Whenever this happens, the damage they cause seems to evaporate overnight. In ‘Dead Man’s Party’, for example, Buffy’s welcome-home celebration is interrupted by an army of the undead. They smash windows, destroy doors, break ornaments, and upend the furniture. But in the next episode, everything’s fine – there’s no evidence that anything happened at all.
Whilst the show is often ambiguous about how much time has passed between episodes, it would have been more realistic if we saw some repair work going on at some point.
5. Vampires Entering Homes
The vampires of Sunnydale have no problem entering public buildings. The Bronze and Sunnydale High are often attacked, which usually ends in a violent tussle between the Slayer and her foes.
Houses, on the other hand, are more problematic. Supposedly, vampires can only enter someone’s home with their permission. Fully aware of this fact, the Scooby Gang use it to their advantage numerous times throughout the show.
But sometimes, this rule is completely abandoned. When Angel loses his soul in Season 2, he has no difficulty entering Enyos’s house and committing murder. And it’s the same in Season 4 when Spike enters Willow’s dormitory at UC Sunnydale – he just strolls in without a care in the world.
Given this rule is a fundamental plot point in several episodes, completely removing it wouldn’t have worked. But it would have been nice if the writers didn’t ignore their own rule from time to time.
4. The Power Of The Vengeance Demons
Season 3 has many outstanding moments. ‘Anne’, ‘The Zeppo’, ‘Doppelgangland’, and ‘Graduation Day’ are all classics. Yet the most interesting episode is definitely ‘The Wish’.
This story introduces us to Vengeance Demons for the first time. Anya grants Cordelia’s wish and turns the world into a dystopian nightmare where vampires rule Sunnydale. It’s a gripping adventure, full of intrigue, suspense, and sadism.
And this isn’t the last time we see a Vengeance Demon. Anya becomes a central character, and the history of her kind is explored in ‘Triangle’ and ‘Selfless’. Crucially, Vengeance Demons have the potential to manipulate the world with their abilities. Given such power, you’d have thought more people would try to exploit them for their own ends.
Only they don’t. Neither the Scooby Gang nor the vampires of Sunnydale seem to recognise the significance of the Vengeance Demons.
Of course, this is really just a plot convenience. If our heroes changed the past in order to thwart their enemies in the present, the show would cease to be interesting.
3. The Inconsistency Of The Ubervamps
The First Evil plays mind games with our favourite characters throughout the show’s final season, and this wicked entity is assisted by the ubervamps, a powerful horde of vampires with advanced speed and strength.
Buffy – a veteran Slayer with more than five years’ experience – gets beaten to a pulp by one of these beasts in ‘Bring on the Night’. And in the following episode, she just manages to take down her first ubervamp.
But if we jump to the final episode, the ubervamps are nowhere near as powerful. Though they’re still threatening, the younger Slayers have no trouble taking them down despite their lack of experience. And the writers make no attempt to explain this either – we’re just supposed to accept it.
To make matters worse, there’s an entire army of ubervamps beneath Sunnydale High, so even if they were weakened, our heroes should have been overwhelmed by these monsters – there are literally hundreds of them!
2. Everyone Forgets About Jesse
Of all the plot holes in Buffy the Vampire Slayer, this is probably the funniest.
In the very first episode of the show, we’re introduced to all the main characters. Jesse McNally, a close friend of Xander’s, also makes an appearance.
Unfortunately, he doesn’t last for very long. After getting captured by Darla, he’s transformed into a vampire soon after. Xander and Buffy are the first to discover this, but they’re not particularly upset about Jesse’s transformation – they just want to get out of the sewers as soon as possible.
Jesse turns up again when the vampires attack The Bronze, and Xander accidentally kills his friend with a stake to the heart. It’s a dumb end for one of the most bizarre characters in the show, and no one – not even Xander – seems to care about Jesse’s death. Our heroes walk off at the end of the episode, unconcerned about the demise of their classmate.
And they continue to act this way for the rest of the season as well. There’s no indication that Jesse even existed. It’s an amusing plot hole, but the writers clearly weren’t thinking straight when they created Jesse.
1. Nobody Ever Goes To The Library
Throughout the high school years, Buffy and the gang use the library as their central meeting place. They plan, research, argue, and train here for three solid years.
Though the library is open to all students and staff members at Sunnydale High, the Scooby Gang are rarely disturbed – their secret meetings are allowed to go ahead without any interruption.
In fairness, the writers do acknowledge this issue. At the start of ‘Passion’, Jonathan comes into the library and asks for some books on Stalin, the infamous dictator of the Soviet Union. The gang are shocked by this simple request, which is a clear nod to the fact the library is never visited by other students.
What's more, constant interruptions would have been an annoying inconvenience. And given the library is an iconic part of the show, changing the gang’s meeting place would have been a terrible idea.
Still, even Buffy fanatics can’t deny the absurdity of this plot hole.