10 Biggest TV Disappointments Of 2015

We aren't mad...we're just disappointed.

It seems like every year television gets better and better. The budgets get bigger, the casts more illustrious and the sheer amount of choice and content keeps on growing. In general, 2015 has been a great year for television. AMC's Mad Men, for example, was capped off with intelligence and dexterity, satisfying audiences around the world. The same can be said for Parks And Recreation, which gave us an emotional and satisfying conclusion to NBC's brilliant comedy. Not only that, but there were also shows that continued to build upon the previous promise of brilliance, like the second season of Adult Swim's Rick And Morty. For all that was great, though, there was also disappointment. Sure, there were many shows that were straight out terrible, but there were also shows that had promise; shows that should have been more yet simply weren't. In many ways these are the worst shows, shows that audiences anticipate but that ultimately let them down. These are undoubtedly the worst offenders of 2015.

10. True Detective Season 2

It seemed like the key piece of True Detective's formula was there: Nic Pizzolatto, the show's creator, was once again set to write every episode of the second season. The first season had such unbelievably strong writing that fans and critics were certain that Pizzolatto's follow up would at the very least be good. Nevertheless there were a few niggling worries. Unlike the first season (in which every episode was directed by Cary Joji Fukunaga, lending it an amazing aesthetic coherence) various directors were set to helm individual episodes, including Fast And Furious director Justin Lin. Not only that, but the plot was less Louisiana occult and more LA crime. And what on earth was Vince Vaughn doing on the cast list? When True Detective season two finally arrived, many fears were confirmed. The story was a mess. The dialogue was frequently laughable. And Vaughn wasn't the revelation we'd all hoped he was. Gone was the weighty, oppressive atmosphere, replaced by a bunch of depressed cops whose defining characteristics were that they drank a lot. Whether or not we get a third season remains to be seen, but perhaps it's best the show uses this failure to admit how much lightening it managed to bottle during season one.

9. House Of Cards Season 3

One of the joys of House Of Cards is watching the Underwoods crush those around them, stamping on anyone they have to in order to gain power. All of this is punctuated by a brooding Kevin Spacey, who remains a pleasure to watch regardless of what he's doing. Sprinkle a few plot twists into the mix and you've got a total winner. The problem with season three is that it's got none of those things €“ at least, it's got them in much lower doses. What starts out great (Frank pees on his father's grave, what's not to love?) soon becomes...well, a bit boring. So much time is spent on Doug Stamper, yet so little actually happens during his sub-plot. You could practically fast forward through his scenes and not lose out on much. The same can be said (to a lesser extent) about Claire Underwood...and what was that whole book biography sub-plot about? At times it felt like absolutely ages before the main plot would resume moving forward, but then it was always interrupted by boring distractions.

8. Happyish

Happyish is a prime example of a show that's success was clearly wrapped up in its lead actor. The show is a dark, satirical comedy-drama that centres on a depressed middle-aged man named Thom Payne, who finds it increasingly difficult to deal with having to work under his new, much younger bosses. Over the course of the show, Payne begins to believe that he needs to find contentment in merely feeling €œhappyish€. The show's writer and creator Shalom Auslander was desperate for Philip Seymour Hoffman to play the main character. After several years of courting Hoffman and navigating various legal obstacles, a pilot was shot starring the legendary actor. Unfortunately, after Hoffman sadly passed away in 2014, it seemed like the project would be cancelled €“ but the network decided to try and find a new star, and they cast Steve Coogan in the lead role. When the show finally aired, then, there was a tremendous amount of expectation. The Hoffman version of the show was reportedly brilliant, and many hoped Coogan could carry the show to greatness. Unfortunately for audiences, the result was one-note and at times condescending, relying heavily on profanity and coming across as terribly superficial. What was meant to satire the search for happiness became a sure-fire way not to find it.

7. Mr Robinson

Craig Robinson is hilarious €“ his deadpan delivery is matched by very few comedy actors working today. Over the years he's provided audiences with innumerable laughs throughout various television shows and movies €“ a few of his most notable roles include his brilliant performance as Daryl Philbin on The Office, and Nick in Hot Tub Time Machine. Despite his hilarity, Robinson has never really had a starring role. He generally performs as a side or bit character, which is why many people were excited when it was announced Robinson was getting his very own television show, NBC's Mr Robinson. Not only that, but he was set to portray himself as a struggling Chicago musician €“ just the kind of blend of reality and comedy that seemed like the perfect match for Robinson's deadpan demeanour, calling to mind the likes of Curb Your Enthusiasm. Sadly, the result was far, far from the brilliance of Larry David. For a start, it's cringe-worthy as hell. These days, laugh tracks in a comedy are something of a red flag, and that's exactly the case with Mr Robinson. The dialogue is frankly terrible, and it tries to shoehorn in the catchphrase €œAw, hell no!€ at every conceivable opportunity. If that's not bad enough, it also features lines like €œOnce you go white, you're gonna be all right€ and €œShe's like a gremlin €“ just add booze and she goes crazy.€ Craig Robinson is a talented comedic performer, so it's just disappointing to see him wind up doing something so terrible. Looks like it's back to bit roles in stoner comedies for a while.

6. Game Of Thrones Season 5

Now wait just a minute €“ before you burn me at the state like I'm Stannis's beloved (or not so beloved) daughter, let me explain. Game Of Thrones season five was on the whole still wildly entertaining television, and contained some truly brilliant moments, but...it's the first real instance where the show has shown significant cracks. It's no secret that at this point, HBO's television adaptation of A Song Of Ice And Fire has all but caught up with (and in some instances surpassed) George R. R. Martin's source material. What this ultimately led to was a season that struggled to find its identity. Not a huge amount happened during the first few episodes, and there were much fewer €œnotable€ moments when compared to previous seasons. And who can forget the hilariously terrible Sand Snakes debacle? Not only that, but the season attracted controversy from fans and critics during some of its more questionable moments, like the graphic depiction of Sansa Stark's rape and the burning alive of Stannis's daughter. The show was accused of creating shock for shock's sake. With all that said, the season picked up towards the end (even if Stannis's downfall felt incredibly swift and anticlimactic) but by the time it gained steam, the season had ended. It might have been good €“ sometimes even great €“ but it didn't stop many fans from ultimately feeling disappointed.

5. Community Season 6

When Yahoo! picked up Community for its much wished for sixth season, fans were ecstatic. The show's creator Dan Harmon made all sorts of lofty promises about a return to the show's roots: no more wacky storylines, no more bizarre caricatures, and the long-absent exterior of Greendale was set to make a triumphant return. What fans ultimately got was something of a mixed bag. Yvette Nicole Brown was gone, and season five's Buzz Hickey was also notably absent. On top of that, John Oliver's Professor Duncan was nowhere to be seen. Though the show picked up towards the end of the season, and capped off the series in a frankly beautiful way, much of season six struggled to find its identity, unsure what the reason for its existence was, but just sort proud to be alive. Though there were a few more exterior shots, and a few comparatively normal episode plots, the tone of the show was as bizarre as ever, and certain characters seemed trapped in a sort of limbo between who they had become and who the fans wanted them to be. The sixth season of Community wasn't bad by any stretch, but it was disappointing €“ not just in terms of its content, but also because it failed to really benefit Yahoo, who claim to have lost forty-two million dollars on Community and two other original shows that aired on its streaming service Yahoo! Screen.

4. The Muppets

The premise sounds amazing. Place the hilarious and diverse cast of characters featured in The Muppets into the tight confines of an everyday office and watch as they drive each other crazy. There's one thing, however, that the creators must have missed the memo on: Don't make them legitimately hate each other. Don't make it adult. And please, for the love of god, don't make it cynical. Cynicism is practically the antithesis of everything The Muppets stands for. The Muppets premièred in September on ABC. What we expected was a ton of hilarious stand-offs, conundrums and sight gags, wrapped up in a sweet cocoon of genuine emotion. What we got was details about Kermit's sex life, a plot about Fozzie internet dating and the revelation that Zoot from The Electric Mayhem is actually an alcoholic. Once you've heard the loveable Kermit The Frog describe his life as €œa living hell€, it's tough to keep watching.

3. Dr. Ken

Maybe you aren't surprised this show turned out terrible. You're probably right not to be. But if you've followed Ken Jeong's trajectory as a performer, it's tough not to feel slightly (okay, very) let down. Jeong is most widely known to mainstream audiences for his performance as Leslie Chow in the (someone has to say it) terribly unfunny Hangover trilogy. In these films, Chow's humour basically relies on doing a borderline racist accent and getting naked. Not long after, however, Jeong starred in NBC's Community, playing the much funnier and more interesting character of Ben Chang, a community college Spanish teacher. Over the course of his run on Community, (especially after season three) Jeong's performance as Chang became much more nuanced and sympathetic. Jeong also began to note in interviews his desire to work on shows that don't look down on him as a performer. With all said, the announcement of Dr. Ken seemed like poetry. Not only was Jeong hoping for more serious work, but he'd also previously worked as a physician in California. It was like a career-based homecoming. Then the show aired, and it was immediately slammed by critics. Jeong's performance was obnoxious and at times psychopathic. Dr. Ken was full of terrible, exaggerated performances, gross humour and dull, rote storylines. So much for serious acting.

2. The Brink

Political satire has always been ripe for television. Whether it's Peter Capaldi's The Thick Of It or Jeff Daniels' The Newsroom, if there's one thing audiences are hungry for its a middle finger being humorously raised to politicians and the government at large. Another HBO political satire, then €“ what could possibly go wrong? Okay, so Jack Black can be a little goofy, but he's got great dramatic chops when he needs them. Coupled with Academy Award winner Tim Robbins, you'd think The Brink had all the constitute ingredients to be brilliant. Sadly, the show was anything but. The humour wasn't very humorous and the satire just didn't have enough bite. Despite strong performances by Black and Robbins, the tone of the show is often fast paced to the point of genuine exhaustion, and it just doesn't have enough laughs to make the ride worthwhile. The show was briefly renewed for a second season by HBO before they backtracked and threw it in the trash.

1. American Horror Story: Hotel

At its best, American Horror Story makes you fear for its characters. At its worst, it tries to make you fear in a much vaguer sense, by throwing creepy images and creepy figures in ghoulish make-up and hoping they'll stick. When the show first began with Murder House, it took time to establish its characters and their relationships before gradually building up, episode by episode, to the truly eerie stuff. Many fans consider Asylum to be the best blend of story, characters and horror, with the balance shifting gradually during subsequent seasons. Before it aired, many hoped American Horror Story: Hotel would be a return to form. Long-time star Jessica Lange was leaving, paving the way for an exciting reinvention. Though the season hasn't finished (we've reached episode ten, with the remainder of the season set to resume in January) it seems it's already showed its hand. Hotel is all style and no substance. It's flashy, and so concerned with frightening the audience that it never manages to first make them care. At this point, the show has had plenty of time to establish its main players. If we don't care much about them now, we certainly won't in the last few episodes.

Contributor
Contributor

Commonly found reading, sitting firmly in a seat at the cinema (bottle of water and a Freddo bar, please) or listening to the Mountain Goats.