10 Casting 'What Ifs' From Buffy The Vampire Slayer

Katie Holmes, Nathan Fillion and Ryan Reynolds almost made it to Sunnydale High.

Buffy Kendra
Mutant Enemy

The cast of Buffy The Vampire Slayer feel irreplaceable, particularly the leading trio of Sarah Michelle Gellar, Alyson Hannigan and Nicholas Brendon. To many, they are Buffy, Willow and Xander - it is as simple as that.

Others, such as David Boreanaz, Anthony Stewart Head and James Marsters also all make their characters unforgettable in their own ways. Such is the way that they made those roles seem so memorable and made for them, it is easy to forget that the show could have turned out very differently.

A whole host of actors were considered for major roles in the series that, ultimately, all fell through. Others who did appear in the show did so not in the roles they originally auditioned for, instead being offered different supporting roles throughout the series. Many of these characters became fan favourites in their own right, but even still, enough of these 'what ifs' exist to make you think quite seriously about what could have been if history had played out differently.

Some of these feel plausible, others seem ridiculous, and one or two feel like casting choices that would have been looked back on with some fondness.

Here, are ten actors who were either almost cast in Buffy, or who were cast in roles other than the ones they had hoped for.

10. Ryan Reynolds

Adventureland (Ryan Reynolds)
Miramax Films

Ryan Reynolds is a big star today, having brought Deadpool to life in all his profanity-fuelled wonder, but in the 1990s he was right at the start of his career. Looking for roles, he auditioned for the role of Xander Harris - one of the Scooby Gang along with Buffy and Willow - and he impressed the producers enough to be offered the role.

However, he turned it down. In a 2008 interview, Reynolds explained that he couldn't deal with playing a high school student after his own years were so full of torment. He said at the time "I love that show... but my biggest concern was that I didn't want to play a guy in high school," Reynolds said. "I had just come out of high school and it was f**king awful".

Eventually of course the part went to Nicholas Brendon. What Reynolds' take on him would have looked like is anybody's guess, but given his flair for mixing gut-busting action with comedy, it seems entirely possible that his Xander would have been more of a front-and-centre action hero, more akin to the likes of Riley - albeit with a mischievous comedic streak.


9. Bianca Lawson

Buffy Kendra
Mutant Enemy

Bianca Lawson is best known to the Buffyverse as Kendra Young, a second slayer from Jamaica who appears at the end of Season Two following Buffy's (temporary) death. However, Lawson's involvement in the show could have looked very different if she had taken up the first role offered to her by the producers. Initially, they wanted her to play Cordelia Chase - the "queen bee" of Sunnydale High and reluctant ally to the Scooby Gang.

In a 2012 interview with MyFanBase, Lawson explained that she had to turn the role down because of her ongoing work on Goode Behaviour, and accepted the smaller role of Kendra instead. It was reported in June last year that The WB also had concerns about the planned interracial relationship between Cordelia and Xander - a concern that is unthinkable today. The show's producers resisted the studio's imposition at first, before deciding that it wasn't worth fighting for at the time.

While Buffy was a show that in so many ways pushed into new frontiers of on-screen representation and diversity, Lawson's casting is proof that it could have gone even further. We can only imagine what her version of Cordelia would have looked like.


8. Danny Strong

Danny Strong Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy

Danny Strong has enjoyed a high-profile career since his time on Buffy. He created the multi-award-winning Empire, one of Fox's most popular shows during its run. He also co-wrote the final two entries in The Hunger Games series, films that have made almost $3 billion worldwide. It is his time in Sunnydale, though, for which he is most fondly remembered by Buffy fans. Nobody could have captured the timid geekiness and eventual mean streak of Jonathan Levinson - but that was not the first role that Strong went for.

His first encounter with the show was when he auditioned for the part of Xander in the pilot presentation. However, he wasn't offered that role, and Nicholas Brendon claimed the character instead. In an interview from 2017, Strong reminisces (somewhat jokingly) that "to this day, I say I was robbed. I think I would have made a great Xander".

Strong's take on Xander, based on his performance as Jonathan at least, may have been slightly less brass and outlandish. Perhaps somewhat more timid. It is certainly a stretch to imagine him in any other role asides Jonathan. Likewise, nobody else could have captured Xander's boisterous behaviour quite like Brendon.


7. Nathan Fillion

Buffy The Vampire Slayer Caleb
Mutant Enemy

Fillion is already a familiar face and name to genre fans, his starring role in Firefly still what he is best known for. He also managed to appear in the final season of Buffy, in the relatively small role of Caleb the Preacher. What could have been, though, if he had been given the role that he originally auditioned for - Buffy's love interest and moody boy supreme, Angel.

In 2011, Fillion told Backstage that his Angel audition didn't get particularly far, but there weren't any hard feelings, especially after Fillion brought such gravitas to the big baddie of Buffy's final season. The suave actor - once named one of the sexiest men alive - has enjoyed a distinguished career since.

The decision to go with David Boreanaz instead had massive implications on the show. Last year, James Marsters revealed that the Buffy-Angel romance pairing was not originally a factor in the vision for the show. What swayed it was the obvious chemistry that Boreanaz and Sarah Michelle Gellar shared on set. There's no guarantee it would have been the same with Fillion - and just how differently could the first three seasons in particular have played out?


6. Katie Holmes

Katie Holmes Batman Begins Rachel Dawes
Warner Bros.

Holmes is an accomplished actor. Her roles in Dawson's Creek and Batman Begins are what she is best known for, as well as her marriage to Tom Cruise which ended in 2012. Historically she has kept a low profile, and has turned down a number of prominent roles throughout her career. Two in particular stick out; Piper Chapman in Orange Is The New Black, and - most fascinatingly - Buffy Summers.

It is of course impossible to imagine anybody else apart from Sara Michelle Gellar in the role today. And yet, as unthinkable as it seems, Gellar was not the first choice. Holmes was originally offered the part, but turned it down so that she could attend and finish high school - she was only 19 at the time. Shortly after, she auditioned for Dawson's Creek via videotape.

Buffy Summers would not feel like the same role without the effortless charisma and heart that Gellar brought to the character, but the prospect of Holmes taking on the slayer's mantle is enough at least to get you thinking. It is also a mystery as to what Holmes' own career might have looked like had she accepted the part.


5. Selma Blair

Hellboy Selma Blair
Columbia Pictures

Selma Blair famously shared the screen with Sarah Michelle Gellar in the 1999 cult hit Cruel Intentions, their shared kiss winning them an MTV Movie Award. The pair have remained close friends ever since, but once upon a time they both auditioned for the same role.

Blair revealed in an Instagram post in 2018 that, shortly after being replaced by Katie Holmes on Dawson's Creek, Blair auditioned for the role of Buffy. In her own words, she "didn't even come close." Holmes, Gellar, and Blair are now all very good friends.

Blair went on to star in Legally Blonde and both of Guillermo del Toro's Hellboy movies. In the world of TV, she is best known for her roles as Kate Wales in Anger Management, and as Kris Jenner in American Crime Story. What alternate direction her career might have taken if she had bagged the part is a fascinating question.

Buffy would almost surely have gone in a different direction without Gellar's mixture of solemn reflection and a more happy-go-lucky approach. Blair's Buffy may have proved to be a colder, more ruthless take on the slayer - but in reality, we will never know for sure.


4. Charisma Carpenter

Buffy The Vampire Slayer Buffy Cordelia
The WB

Carpenter's involvement in the Buffyverse is of course tied to one character and one character only - perfect princess Cordelia Chase. She brought her to life in all of her detestable high school narcissism and, eventually, begrudging heroism. It was a perfect piece of casting, but if Carpenter had got her way, it would never have happened. Originally, the actor went for the biggest role on the show. She auditioned to be Buffy herself.

In what with hindsight seems like a peculiar role reversal, Carpenter originally went for the role of Buffy while Sarah Michelle Gellar auditioned to play Cordelia. When it dawned on the producers that they were better off the other way round, the pair were convinced to trade roles - and we wouldn't have it any other way.

Cordelia played a prominent role in Buffy's first few seasons, before emerging as a major heroic character in the spin-off Angel. She comes a long way from the cheerleading popular girl obsessed with petty problems, and it becomes clear that there is far more to her character than meets the eye. Carpenter brought wit and heart to a role that could have very easily been a throwaway part.


3. Natasha Lyonne

Russian Doll Natasha Lyonne
Netflix

Natasha Lyonne has cemented her stardom with roles in Orange Is The New Black and Russian Doll, and was emerging into the limelight in the late-1990s when, in her own words, offers were coming at her left, right and centre. Among these were, as she revealed in 2013, a role in Buffy - although which one remains a secret.

Soon after, it was hinted very strongly that Lyonne had in fact turned down the role of Buffy Summers. She talks about how she compared herself to Sarah Michelle Gellar - which surely only lends itself to one conclusion. Prior to this, there had been some debate as to what role she may have ended up taking had she accepted the offer. Some, including Slate TV critic Willa Paskin, believed that it could have been Willow.

To Lyonne's credit, part of the reason she turned down this role among others is that she wanted more control over the direction that her career was going in. In her own words, she takes to "exploring the messy, unhappy lives of young women," a trend that certainly shows in her more recent work. Lyonne's Buffy would have been markedly different, but in its own way incredibly appealing.


2. Freddie Prinze Jr.

Freddie Prinze Jr She S All That
Miramax

Freddie Prinze Jr. and Sarah Michelle Gellar are one of Hollywood's dream couples. They met in 1997, during the filming of I Know What You Did Last Summer, married in 2002, and have been together ever since, having had two children together.

Asides the handful of times they have shared the screen together, another on-screen pairing so very nearly came to fruition. Prinze Jr. came close to starring in a one-off appearance in Buffy at the beginning of Season 5 as the ultimate vampire, Dracula.

The season opener 'Buffy vs. Dracula' sees Buffy lock horns with the dark prince (which could have been the dark Prinze, as it turns out), prior to the main season arc involving Glory and Dawn getting properly started. Prinze Jr. was seriously considered for the role, but eventually the part went to Rudolf Martin. Martin also stars as Dracula in the 2000 TV film Dark Prince: The True Story of Dracula.

Given the dark and romantic attraction between Dracula and Buffy, which becomes a flash point of tension between her and then-boyfriend Riley, to see Prinze Jr. in the role would have been memorable, to say the least. Then again, perhaps he was just too charming for the part.


1. Britney Spears

britney spears
Jive Records

One of Season 5's more peculiar episodes was 'I Was Made To Love You,' which saw future Trio-member Warren construct a robotic girlfriend for himself known as April. However, he grew bored of how perfect she was and abandoned her - which April did not take kindly to.

At the time, the producers had one very high-profile casting choice in mind: the pop star of the moment, Britney Spears.

Spears pulled out of the role at the very last moment, citing scheduling conflicts. At the time it was a closely guarded secret what kind of role Spears was going to fill. Now we know it was April. Some fans speculate now that part of the real reason is that for Britney turning down the gig, is Spears wanted a more central role rather than a one-off appearance as a love-bot.

Co-executive producer Marti Noxon, though, made clear at the time that the plan for the episode Spears would have appeared in did not have to change.

Shonda Farr eventually landed the April role. In a chance happening, Farr also lent her voice to the 2002 video game Britney's Dance Beat, a game in which players have to pass 'auditions' to join Spears on an in-game tour.


Buffy The Vampire Slayer - Can You Remember These 'Before They Were Famous' Guest Stars?

Bela Lauren Cohan 18448713 2000 1328
Warner Bros.

1. Lauren Cohan?

Contributor
Contributor

I write regularly about all things pop culture, and am an individually approved critic on Rotten Tomatoes. I am the Film News Editor for FILMHOUNDS Magazine and a Senior Writer for Starburst Magazine UK. My other credits include bylines in The Guardian, The Quietus and The Indiependent.