10 Characters From Famous TV Shows Who Were Swept Under The Carpet

Disappeared into limbo when the writers realised they served zero purpose. Awkward.

In the world of popular culture, a dreaded disease exists called the Chuck Cunningham syndrome, named after the oldest son on Happy Days who tragically disappeared from the series without explanation. This disease often ravages innocent characters whose only crime was not being useful enough to the progression of a plot. On television, some characters suffering from Chuck Cunningham syndrome are major characters whose absence we notice and puzzle over (for example, Judy Winslow in Family Matters). More often than not, they are characters who, for one reason or another, just did not work when production of a series began. Of course, Chuck Cunningham syndrome is actually the result of lazy writers who hope we will not remember these minor characters and will focus, instead, on the more well known and loved characters of a series. But some of us do remember, and we puzzle over what could have been the fate of poor characters, like those in this list, who were written out without explanation and largely forgotten by all but the most die-hard fans of the shows they were on. So, here are 10 characters intended to be regulars you probably don't remember from famous shows, in no particular order, starting with the namesake of the disease himself...

10. Chuck Cunningham - Happy Days

Happy Days was a spin-off from Love, American Style, and, in the episode "Love and the Happy Days," we were introduced to the three child Cunningham family. Oldest child Chuck Cunningham (Ric Carrot) was intended to be kind of an older mentor to Ron Howard's middle child Richie, whom the latter could count on for sagely advice. When ABC picked up Happy Days for its own run, Gavan O'Herlihy was cast as Chuck. Chuck didn't work so well as a character on Happy Days, though, and the writers found it hard to find ways to include him in episodes. Many of his appearances were brief exchanges with his family before he went to basketball practice and, out of all the first season characters, Chuck received the least development. To make matters worse, O'Herilhy left the show before the season was up, and Randolph Roberts was cast to play the character for the last few episodes of the season. By this time, Henry Winkler's Fonzie had become a breakout character on the show and assumed the role intended for Chuck. Chuck was written out at the beginning of the second season with the explanation that he had gone off to college. The character was never heard from or mentioned again after the second season, and it became sort of a running gag among the cast that a Cunningham child had just been completely forgotten to time, with Marion Ross even asking in a blooper of the final episode, "Where's Chuck?"

9. Dr. Spearchucker Jones - M*A*S*H

Observant viewers may realize that there was an empty bed in the Swamp for most of M*A*S*H's run. This is because originally there was a fourth surgeon-in-residence, Spearchucker Jones, played by Timothy Brown. Spearchucker was the unit's sole African-American surgeon and, since the character appeared in both the book and film versions of M*A*S*H, the television producers saw no problem with bringing him over to the small-screen adaptation. For the first eleven episodes, Spearchucker was a regular presence at the 4077th, even getting some fairly respectable airtime in some of the early episodes. The problem? Someone pointed out to the producers that there were no African-American surgeons stationed in M*A*S*H units during the Korean War. Though the writers and producers were very willing to tackle issues of bigotry and did a number of episodes doing just that, they did not want to become so politically correct that they completely threw historical accuracy out the window. The unfortunate truth is that segregation was still in full force during the Korean War, and a doctor like Spearchucker would have faced numerous problems in operating on mostly white patients. Spearchucker was quietly dropped after the eleventh episode and never mentioned again.

8. Most Of The First Season Cast - The Facts Of Life

The Facts of Life started out as a very different show than the one most people remember. During the first season, Mrs. Garrett was the housemother to a group of seven girls at Eastland Academy. In addition to Blair, Natalie, and Tootie, Cindy (Julie Anne Haddock), Sue Ann (Julie Piekarski), Nancy (Felice Schachter), and Molly (Molly Ringwald, yes, that Molly Ringwald) were part of the cast, as well as the school's headmaster, Mr. Steven Bradley (John Lawlor) and a teacher, Ms. Emily Mahoney (Jenny O'Hara). As you can guess, with a ten-person cast, finding stuff for all of them to do could be difficult, to say the least. It didn't help that most of the actresses had been cast before their characters had been fully fleshed out in a rush to get the show to production. The producers were quick to realize that this was not working, especially when the show did terrible in the ratings the first season. O'Hara was the first to be cut from the cast. After only four episodes, it was apparent that the writers had nothing for her to do. Lawlor lasted through the end of the season when he was written out of the series. At the beginning of the second season, the show was completely overhauled to focus on only Mrs. Garrett and four of her students, including new bad girl Jo. Haddock, Piekarski, Schachter, and Ringwald would continue to make occasional cameos through the second and third season, and all but Ringwald would return for a special reunion episode in season eight. But the four girls have never been remembered in the same light as their three co-stars who were retained for the remainder of the series.

7. Coco - The Golden Girls

The original premise of The Golden Girls was to feature three women, Dorothy, Rose, and Blanche, living with their flamboyant gay housekeeper, Coco, played by Charles Levin, a role that was pretty radical for a mainstream sitcom in the mid-eighties. Coco was intended to be a huge comedic part of the show and it was thought that Coco would work well in connection with his three co-stars. Coco appeared in the pilot episode of the show in a large role but was subsequently dropped without ever being mentioned again, which puzzled many die-hard fans of the show. After all, it was quite apparent that Coco was living with the girls in the pilot episode. What happened was Estelle Getty. Sophia, Dorothy's mother, was originally intended to be more of an occasional, recurring character, But, after the pilot, it was felt that Getty had stolen the show with her very matter-of-fact delivery. Sophia was quickly written into the series as a full cast member living with her daughter. But, with the promotion of Sophia to regular character, Coco's role on the show became redundant. The decision was made to cut Coco out of the series, and he was never heard from again beyond his initial pilot appearance.

6. Grandma Tanner - Full House

One of the first characters to appear on Full House was Grandma Tanner, played by Alice Hirson. In the pilot, Grandma had been living with the family following the death of her daughter-in-law and was preparing to move out as the other characters moved in. There was a strong implication that Grandma Tanner would be a recurring character on the show. After all, she wasn't moving out of San Francisco, meaning she would be close by if they needed her help. But Hirson only made one additional appearance as Grandma Tanner when she sees how horribly the three men are doing at maintaining the house and threatens to move back in if they don't straighten out their act. With the success of the three men on the show, Grandma Tanner would have been a very redundant character. But, to make things even more complicated, a new Grandma Tanner showed up during season three. This Grandma Tanner was played by Doris Roberts and it was implied that she had lived out of the area for some time and was visiting for the first time in years. Of course, the real reason behind this is the writers of Full House had absolutely no sense of continuity (just ask Jesse Cochran... uh, Katsopolis), so they probably simply forgot they not only had Grandma Tanner as a character but had also intended her to be recurring.

5. Luke Ventura - Married... With Children

In the early episodes of Married...With Children, Al Bundy had a co-worker at Gary's Shoes and Accessories named Luke Ventura, played by Ritch Shydner. Luke was a womanizer who was intended to fill the role of Al's friend and confidant, and Shydner was listed as a regular in the script for the pilot episode. Once the series began airing, producers realized that Al's daughter, Kelly, was a much more popular role than they had originally anticipated. In addition, the role Luke was originally meant to fill ended up being taken by Al's neighbor, Steve Rhodes, who was able to play much more of a straight man to Al's dysfunctional life. As a result, the decision was made after seven episodes to drop Luke entirely without explanation. Unlike most of the characters on this list, Luke was brought back off-screen during the ninth season of the show when Al finds out that Luke was given an award in the shoe industry after he left his job at Gary's and became Al's rival. The reference was very subtle and Luke was never seen, thus meaning it was one of those blink and you'll miss it moments. Of course, only the most die-hard fans of the show realized that the Luke being referenced in this episode was a regular character during the first season. As such, it was quite a clever nod to television geeks who know way too much useless trivia about the shows that they love.

4. Dr. J. Loren Pryor - The Simpsons

The Simpsons creator Matt Groening originally intended Dr. J. Loren Pryor, the school psychologist at Springfield Elementary, to be a major part of the series. He thought that the series would focus almost exclusively on the antics of the young trouble-maker, Bart Simpson. Pryor, voiced by Harry Shearer, was slated to team up with Principal Skinner on multiple occasions as the two conspired to find ways to remove Bart from the school, essentially making Pryor a sidekick to Skinner. Pryor was written as a know-it-all who didn't really know much at all and even once mistakenly read Millhouse's file believing it was Bart's. Pryor only made a few appearances during the first season before being written out of the series when it was realized the writers wouldn't be able to do as much with him as they initially thought. The Simpsons was already seeing a change in direction, especially as Homer became more of a focus character, and the running subplot of Skinner looking for ways to have Bart expelled was forgotten. The role Pryor was intended to fill was largely taken over by Superintendent Chalmers in later episodes. Pryor would later make a minor appearance during the ninth season, but fans have mostly forgotten him.

3. Max - Saved By The Bell

When Saved by the Bell premiered in 1989, there were actually two adult regulars on the show. Magician Ed Alonzo played Max, the proprietor of the restaurant where the gang often hung out when they weren't at school, aptly called The Max. It was thought that Max would be the antithesis to the other adult character, Bayside High principal Mr. Belding, kind of acting as a wise sage and mentor for the kids and providing advice when they needed it. This could have been a good idea with the right character, writers, and direction, but,as with many of the other ideas on this list, things didn't go as planned in the actual execution. In fact, Max ended up being one of the most useless characters on the show. Writers just didn't have anything for him to do. Most of his appearances during the first season were relegated to Max doing a few magic tricks for the kids and telling a few of the more lame jokes of the season. Max would make one appearance during the second season when The Max was threatened with closure, but he was afterwards quietly written out. The gang would continue to hang out at The Max for the next three seasons (and seven additional seasons on the spin-off, Saved by the Bell: The New Class), but Max would never be heard from again.

2. Mr. Wainwright & Mrs. Partridge - Last Of The Summer Wine

Given its thirty-one series run, it's only natural that the long-running BBC sitcom Last of the Summer Wine would shed cast members over the years. But there are two cast members who were shed very early on. In the original treatment for the series, it was thought that one of the regular haunts of Compo, Clegg, and Blamire would be the town library. As such, the two resident resident librarians, Mr. Wainwright and Mrs. Partridge, played by Blake Butler and Rosemary Martin respectively, would be regular cast members. A running gag was to be that Wainwright would be constantly pursuing a clandestine love affair with the married Partridge, seemingly unaware that everyone else in town knew what was going on. Writer and creator Roy Clarke struggled to find ways to include the duo in episodes, though, and the decision was made after the first series to drop them as characters. No explanation was given, but one episode in the second series did feature a new set of librarians, seemingly confirming that Wainwright and Partridge were gone for good. Wainwright returned for a few episodes during the third series but was dropped again at the end of the year, and the library was eventually phased out as one of the regular settings on the show.

1. Lana Shields - Three's Company

When the Ropers left Three's Company for their own spin-off at the end of the third season, producers decided to go a different direction with replacement characters, casting two very different characters to replace them. The first was Ralph Furley, played by Don Knotts, who acted as the bumbling, clueless landlord for Jack, Chrissy, and Janet. The second was Lana Shields, played by Ann Wedgeworth, who was an older divorcee living in the same building as our main characters. Lana was an extremely sexualized character, and most of her character traits revolved around rebuffing Mr. Furley's advances or attempting her own advances on neighbor Jack Tripper. The addition of Lana caused tension between John Ritter and the show's writers. Ritter believed it was out of character for the sex-crazed Jack to turn down the advances of an attractive woman, though the writers reasoned that Jack would turn her down because she was older. But it was Wedgeworth herself who asked to be released from the character, as she did not appreciate her diminishing role on the series. As a result, Lana was written out before the fourth season was even half over and was never mentioned again. Did I miss one of your favorite forgotten characters? Let me know in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Christopher A. Rothbauer is a freelance writer who specializes in nostalgic television and B-movies. His current project is the blog Saved by the Bell...Reviewed!, which reviews every episode of the Saved by the Bell franchise one week at a time. He lives in the southern Indiana suburbs of Louisville, Kentucky.