10 Completely Insulting TV Plot Twists
Swing and a miss, TV writers.
Anybody remember St. Elsewhere? The medical drama/black comedy combination ran for six seasons in the 1980s. Of course, what it's really remembered for is its ending. The whole series actually happened entirely within the imagination of an autistic child, essentially slapping the faces of every devoted viewer in one fell swoop with a horrible and completely unnecessary plot twist.
It likely wasn't the first TV show to feature a moment designed to shock the audience but instead enrage them, and it certainly wasn't the last. The rise of the "golden era" of television has meant that shows have, in many cases, reached the same level of quality as the highly revered film industry.
Obviously filling up anywhere between ten to twenty five hours of air time is no easy feat. So it's certainly understandable that creators and writers might resort to a shocking twist in order to hold their viewer's attention.
Of course, for every awesome plot twist, there's a dozen that just aren't all that shocking. And then there's the select few that straight up insult the fans.
Whether it be through underestimating their intelligence, an unsatisfying payoff, or a complete subversion of the entire show, the entries on this list never should have made it past the brainstorming phase.
Also, massive spoilers are incoming. You have been warned.
10. It Doesn't Matter How Sherlock Survived His Fall - Sherlock
BBC's Sherlock managed to sidestep one controversial twist ending by revealing the world's second most iconic detective (Hey, Batman!) was alive at the end of the same episode where he "commits suicide" by jumping off a building.
Obviously, the main character that the show was named after isn't going to actually bite the bullet at the end of the second series, so at least there was minimal attempt to get us to actually believe it. However, this actually fed into a new problem.
For the two years between series 2 and 3, the main focus was on a single question: just how did Sherlock manage to survive his fall and fool an actual doctor into believing he was dead at the scene?
The answer? It doesn't matter.
No, seriously, that's the answer we were given.
Truthfully, it stinks of painfully lazy writing. Sure, there is some truth to the fact that no matter how he survived, it wouldn't really live up to the wild expectations that fans had. But you can't really ignore the fact that the show wrote itself into a corner with zero strategy on how to get out.
No, it isn't the show "being clever," and no, people that focus on how Sherlock survived are not "missing the point." It's laziness, pure and simple.
We're still waiting, BBC.
9. Armin Tamzarian - The Simpsons
There's a reason that The Principal and the Pauper, the second episode in The Simpsons' ninth season, is often heralded as the point in which the popular animated sitcom began its decline.
Long time character Seymour Skinner, who had undergone quite a bit of character development in his time on the show, was revealed to be an imposter named Armin Tamzarian that had stolen the identity of his former army sergeant. Even worse yet was the lack of an interesting motivation, in which Tamzarian takes on Skinner's life in order to avoid upsetting the latter's mother with news of Skinner's death.
Taking one of the best characters on the show and completely retconning their background for a single episode only really signaled to everyone that the show was running out of ideas.
Yes, you read that correctly. A single episode. The show went out of its way to hit the reset button, with the entire town (including the real Seymour's mother) refusing to accept Sergeant Skinner, and instead insisting that Tamzarian go back to assuming Skinner's identity full time. The real Skinner is shipped out of town, and Springfield is ordered to completely forget it ever happened "under penalty of torture."
The return to the show's status quo is galling at best and insulting at worst.
The Simpsons has never exactly been a show bound by logic, but the existence of Kang and Kodos is nothing compared to this blunder.
8. Julian Albert Is Doctor Alchemy - The Flash
If you're going to introduce a new character and a new villain at the same time, it's best to make sure you're not doing it in a way that makes it painfully obvious that they're one and the same.
First of all, if you don't want people to automatically think a new character is the villain, don't cast someone like Tom Felton as Julian Albert, who, despite being pretty great in the role he's been given, will forever be branded a villain thanks to the Harry Potter franchise. It would be like casting Willem Dafoe or Jason Isaacs: the bigger twist would be if they WEREN'T playing the villain.
The main argument against Albert being Doctor Alchemy, the menacing new villain, was that it would be too obvious. That's not a great sign.
While not every obvious plot twist is a bad one, the fact that the Alchemy reveal was so drawn out had fans hoping that the man behind the mast would be literally anyone except Julian, the man that had been antagonizing Barry Allen from the second he had been introduced.
The reveal stings particularly hard in the light of the context. Arrow, in the same year, had prevented Prometheus' identity from being obvious through some stellar character work and writing. Additionally, the slow burn to Savitar's reveal later the same season was also handled much better.
Honestly, the best option here would have been to reveal Alchemy's identity to the audience much earlier to prevent the inevitable disappointment.
7. Cottonmouth Isn't The Main Villain - Luke Cage
Wow, the first half of Luke Cage's freshman season was phenomenal. Much of this was due to House of Cards veteran and eventual Oscar winner Mahershala Ali, who brought a nuanced and menacing villain to the table in the form of Cornell "Cottonmouth" Stokes, matching the likes of Wilson Fisk and Kilgrave.
Then Stokes was killed off halfway through the season to make way for Willis "Diamondback" Stryker."
Cottonmouth's death in itself was a fantastic plot twist. However, replacing Cottonmouth with Diamondback felt like when the Genie was recast in the Direct-to-DVD Aladdin sequels.
Gone was character development, intrigue, or any level of subtlety. Erik LaRay Harvey devoured the scenery in every single scene he was in, and not in a good Nicolas Cage or Jim Carrey way.
But wait, there's more.
Stryker is actually Cage's long lost illegitimate brother, just in case you felt like the MCU was missing some soap opera cliches. Coupled with a cringe-worthy outfit and some terrible dialogue (he quoted "The Warriors" in what was supposed to be a serious scene), Diamondback was not worthy to sit among the likes of Kingpin and Kilgrave. Even Iron Fist's Harold Meachum outranks this guy.
The laughably terrible final showdown between Stryker and Cage, ending with Cage coming out on top, was less of a case of "Yes! Good has triumphed over evil!" and more "Finally, we don't have to deal with this clown anymore."
6. Brian Gets Brought Back To Life - Family Guy
In the twelfth season of Family Guy, Seth MacFarlane made the controversial decision to kill off Brian, the Griffin family dog, and absolute main stay of the program, which had been dealing with staleness in recent years.
It featured a poignant goodbye to the character, and even though there was some fan backlash, MacFarlane made a bold choice to liven up the series. With Stewie destroying his time machine earlier in the same episode, the journey of Brian and Stewie came to a close, and Brian was truly gone from the show for good.
Just kidding! The dog was back in two weeks.
Yes, through the use of some time traveling mumbo jumbo, Stewie is able to save Brian's life and completely reset the monumental changes that had just been made.
The worst part about this was just how blatant it was at being a ploy to stir up buzz, and therefore, ratings. Brian's resurrection wasn't a result of the wishes of fans, the whole plot was there from the very beginning.
At the very least, the three episode arc may have backfired, as fans slowly began to wane. By the finale of that same season, Family Guy aired its first ever episode to gain fewer than four million viewers in the U.S. And it was all downhill from there.
5. Travis Marshall Is The Doomsday Killer - Dexter
So, Season 6 of Dexter was terrible.
The "iconic" serial killer, and main villain, of the season was the "Doomsday Killer," nicknamed DDK, who would recreate scenes from the Book of Revelations in preparation for the end of the world. It was all rather mundane.
Because this is Dexter, the serial killer is actually "revealed" right away as Professor James Gellar, played wonderfully by Edward James Olmos. He is aided by his meek and somewhat reluctant assistant Travis Marshall, played by Colin Hanks, who at one point realizes the error of his ways and tries to help Dexter take down Gellar.
Then it's revealed that Gellar has been dead the entire time, and Marshall, the real serial killer, has been hallucinating Gellar's existence. If that sounds familiar, then you probably watched any horror movie during the 2000's that received less than a 10% on Rotten Tomatoes.
The plot twist was incredibly obvious and cliched, and a show as smart as Dexter should have absolutely sidestepped such mediocrity. Sticking with Olmos would have salvaged the season, if even slightly.
Furthermore, no disrespect to Colin Hanks intended, but much like his father Tom, the man absolutely cannot and should not play a villain. Marshall tried to poison a police department and sacrifice Dexter's son, but thanks to Hanks' portrayal, there isn't a single second in which we should think he's a believable threat.
4. Black Siren - Arrow
In the midseason finale of Arrow's fifth season, Laurel Lance made her shocking return to the show after surprisingly being killed off the previous year.
It took approximately 5 minutes for logic to set in.
With the Lazarus Pit destroyed, there was no longer a method for bringing characters back from the dead, so there must be another in-universe explanation.
For fans of The Flash, there was. Shortly after her character's death in Arrow, Katie Cassidy returned on the sister series as the villainous Black Siren, brought from Earth-2 by Zoom. Given how memorable evil Laurel was, she was still fresh in the memories of viewers, and the reveal that Lance was actually working with Prometheus was obvious.
For people that don't watch the Flash, however, it was horribly manipulative. Laurel didn't start the series as a fan favorite, but she grew over time into a powerful badass, and was one of the best parts of the otherwise maligned Season 4. The prospect of a former character taken too soon returning to the show, only to have that hope ripped away, was really not worth the twist it came packaged with.
Instead of saving face by having the reveal happen right away, viewers were manipulated into thinking Laurel was back for way too long, before Siren's deception was uncovered by Felicity of all people.
Cassidy is returning to Arrow full time for Season 6, so hopefully she can build back the goodwill the show's writers robbed her of.
3. The Terrorists Are The "Good Guys" - Quantico
Attempting to unravel Quantico's plot is like trying to solve a Rubik's cube underwater while blindfolded after having your hands chopped off.
Alex Parrish, a former FBI agent, is recruited by the CIA to infiltrate the CIA training program. Parrish's goal is to root out a group of rogue agents that have been forming from within the CIA. She ultimately fails her mission.
Cut to a few months later, when Alex, and most of the main characters, are attending the G20 summit with hundreds of world leaders and dignitaries. The summit is taken hostage by a group of terrorists, who immediately execute the First Lady of the United States on live television. Parrish and her allies quickly surmise that the terrorist group is the rogue faction of the CIA she had previously failed to find.
Nope.
It turns out that the terrorists are comprised of "patriotic" FBI and CIA agents (including several major characters) that are trying to find members of the rogue faction who are attending the summit, which was lead by the First Lady. This was honestly their best plan. We're also expected to support them for some reason.
Then the crisis ends, ISIS takes responsibility, and everybody goes home, free of criminal charges. No, really.
Quantico, like many other series, never attempted to be particularly grounded in reality, but the sheer lack of logic involved in... anything... is simply mind-blowing. It certainly appears that the writers tried to cover up their lack of thinking by shrouding everything in utter confusion.
2. The Dumpster - The Walking Dead
When people think of "insulting twists" and "The Walking Dead," it's natural to think of the end of Season 6, in which the build-up to the identity of Negan's victim is paid off with a cut to first person and six more months of waiting. However, that was less of a twist, and more of a direct kick to the testicles.
No, The Walking Dead's most insulting twist came earlier that same season, with the shocking supposed death of long time character Glenn Rhee.
After Glenn and his rival Nicholas find themselves surrounded by a massive herd of zombies, the latter shoots himself in the head, sending both tumbling into a sea of walkers to be chowed down upon. And that was that.
The writers really went all out with this one, even removing Steven Yeun from the opening credits. For viewers, this was a show that always subverted expectations. Just a few years prior, main character Lori Grimes was killed off in a random episode way before she died in the comics, so there was even precedent.
Then, several episodes later, it's revealed Glenn survived by... crawling under a dumpster and using Nicholas's body as cover.
Seriously? What was the point of all this? To make Glenn a less obvious candidate for Negan's bat?
Death fake-outs do NOT belong on The Walking Dead. Keep that soap opera crap on daytime television where it belongs.
1. The Ending - How I Met Your Mother
If the words "How I Met Your Mother" inspire a deep-seated rage within you, then you're probably one of many that followed the show from its beginning, only for it to end in tatters.
For nine years, the show had been a build-up to the meeting between Ted and titular Mother (revealed to be named Tracy McConnell). For most of those years, Ted Mosby and Robin Scherbatsky were shown as romantically incompatible. And for the entire final season, Ted learned to let go of Robin and allow her to get married to Barney Stinson, with the focus of said final season being entirely on Barney and Robin's wedding.
All of this was undone in a montage.
Robin and Barney get divorced, Tracy dies, and Ted and Robin get back together.
Some plot twists are a slap in the face. Some plot twists happen at the very end of the series. This one was both, except if Conor McGregor was the one doing the slapping.
In an instant, the creators showed not only a massive amount of disrespect for their longtime fans, but a fundamental lack of understanding on what it is they wanted. Ted and Robin's reunion is treated as a happy ending, but fans had moved on in the literal seven years since they were an official couple. Ted and Tracy. Barney and Robin. It was so simple.
Do yourself a favor and treat the alternate ending as canon.
What other TV plot twists completely offended you? Let us know in the comments below.