10 Craziest Fan Theories About American Dad
Wait, so Roger really isn't from outer space?
American Dad is one of the most successful series to come from Seth MacFarlane. The animated comedy focuses on the Smith family as they live out their crazy and wacky lives as a middle class family in Langley Falls.
However, while MacFarlane voices the two main characters in CIA agent Stan Smith and the alcoholic alien Roger, the show has a different creative direction to its sibling series. Focusing more on storylines rather than cutaway gags, American Dad centres around the characters going on wild adventures and dealing with often outlandish takes on real world issues.
From Stan Smith's exploits as an agent for the CIA, to Roger's wild personas wreaking havoc on the town of Langley Falls, there is always a sense of adventure and fun to be had with the diverse cast of colourful characters.
Like every television series, there are a number of fan theories surrounding the series. While some theories may be extremely unlikely, others are so crazy they may be true. From theories explaining the wackier episodes, to those that suggest Roger is not who he claims to be, these are the some of the craziest theories about American Dad.
10. Avery Bullock Is Susie Swanson
Family Guy and American Dad have consistently showcased that they are within the same universe. This would indicate that Stan Smith, Avery Bullock and the CIA as depicted in American Dad exists within the Family Guy universe. As discussed by WickedBinge, it is highly possible that Susie Swanson (the daughter of Joe and Bonnie) is actually an avatar from the CIA used by Avery Bullock.
In American Dad's seventh season episode titled Virtual In-Stanity, (Season 7, Episode 5) the show explores the CIA's use of avatars. Avatars are motion controlled by the CIA, with Bullock even revealing that one of his avatars is a baby that he poses as for personal reasons.
While that may not be enough to believe the theory to be true, the voice of Susie's inner monologue is none other than Patrick Stewart, who also voices Avery Bullock. It also is not very hard to believe then that Bullock would have more than one baby avatar to utilise in order to meet his sexual desires.
9. The Family Still Uses The Vacation Goo
In the episode titled The Vacation Goo, (Season 3, Episode 1) the family discovers that all their vacations as a family have been fabricated by artificial memory chambers from the CIA, hired out by to program a vacation that the family believes is real while he enjoys his own personal time. After a series of events that results in the family going on a real vacation that turns out horribly, the family is eventually shown using the goo once more by the end of the episode.
This makes it easy to speculate that the season three episode is not the last time the family has used the goo, which according to Redditor u/Hugho22y47 explains the crazier American Dad episodes such as the Christmas episodes and the Two Hundred episode.
According to the theory, the family uses the goo once a year, with each member taking a turn creating a storyline for the family to partake in, with the Two Hundred being Roger's choice, as he wondered what it would be like if he caused a world wide apocalypse. Talk about a crazy way to spend a family vacation!
8. Roger Is Basically Superman
Roger has been showcased to have many abilities which has led many to theorise that he is in fact basically Superman. It is discussed in WickedBinge's fan theory video that Roger is very much like the Son of Krypton, as he has a variety of special abilities which make him an incredibly powerful being.
This has been proven throughout the series, with episodes such as Jenny Fromdabloc (Season 6, Episode 16), Great Space Roaster (Season 5, Episode 18) and Cops and Roger (Season 5, Episode 14) all showcasing that Roger has otherworldly traits, such as super speed, strength and the ability to breathe without oxygen.
Much like Kal-El, Roger has also been shown to not age as he is revealed to be at least 1,000 years old, providing a case that he could be immortal. No matter what the case is, it is certain that Roger is a special and powerful being that should be feared by all.
7. Roger Is A Hive Mind
American Dad has often revolved around plots involving personas created by Roger, as he loves to play dress up. The majority of American Dad episodes have the Smith's deal with problems often caused by characters that are merely extensions of Roger himself.
However, Redditor u/SexyShafter believes that Roger's personas are more than just an alien who loves to play dress up. He argues Roger's personas are all extensions of a hive mind, with there being one main Roger that lives with the Smith family. All the personas are living separately and at the same time as the main Roger, explaining how the alien seemingly escapes certain death, and how his personas are able to live full lives as if they are real people.
He believes the personas are created through Roger's ability shown in Deacon Stan, Jesus Man (Season 1, Episode 7) where he can impregnate a person simply by kissing them. With Roger's sexual nature, it explains how there are so many characters in Langley Falls that look like Roger in a wig, which are actually extensions of the hive mind.
6. Stewie Controls American Dad
This American Dad/Family Guy theory stems from the Family Guy episodes titled Stewie Kills Lois (Season 6, Episode 4) and Lois Kills Stewie (Season 6, Episode 5). As discussed in an article by Michael McCarrick, Stewie believes he has killed Lois, only to wind up being killed by Lois after he has assumed world domination in a two part episode that is a simulation, revealed to the audience in the final moments of the two parter during an interaction between Brian and Stewie.
During the simulated storyline, Brian and Stewie travel to the CIA in order to further Stewie's evil plans where the pair meets meets Stan Smith and Avery Bullock, who fail to stop the infant. While the encounter is only brief, the scene has left fans from both series speculating as to whether American Dad may be a creation from the intelligent infant using his simulation software.
Imagine the closing moments in American Dad's final ever episode being Stewie simply ending the simulation. Minds would be blown.
5. The CIA Knows Where Roger Is
Ever since Roger saved Stan's life at Area 51, Roger has been living with the Smiths under their protection. It is a common plot thread that the CIA will kill Stan and his family if they are discovered to be housing Roger. However, what if the CIA already know of Roger's location?
Reddit user u/abaker74's theory states that the CIA do happen to know where Roger is situated, and that housing Roger with the Smith family was planned by the government organisation as a way of monitoring the alien. The reasoning behind this is that the CIA could not keep Roger contained due to his ability to move at super speed, ands that giving him an emotional attachment to a family is the best way to keep Roger hidden and in the eye of the CIA.
The theory also states that the CIA only continue to "search" for Roger in order to indulge Roger's need to feel important, and to keep the Smiths from revealing that Roger is an alien to the general populace, revealing that Stan is unaware of the scheme. This would explain why the government did not question Stan over his escape of Area 51 with the alien they have been hunting.
4. All The Characters Are Roger Personas
According to Reddit user u/The_FactSphere, Roger is in fact every character in the show, as they are all his personas. The user argues that while the audience does not see this due to being an outside perspective, they believe that all the characters were unleashed after a traumatic event.
This event is in fact Roger destroying all life on Earth, hence why his spaceship cannot destroy all life on Earth in "Weiner of Our Discontent (Season 4, Episode 18), where Roger revealed that he was sent to Earth as 'The Decider' who was tasked with deciding whether humanity should live or perish. Roger believed he could end all life on Earth in the episode due to his psyche blocking any knowledge of destroying all life on Earth from due to the trauma it caused him.
Even the creator of the theory admits it is a bit of a stretch, however it is one of the more outlandish theories from the series and would certainly take the show in a dark direction if proven true.
3. American Dad Is A TV Show In The Family Guy Universe
Another popular fan theory circling around the internet is that the events of American Dad are all part of a television series filmed within the Family Guy universe. While the Cleveland Show and Family Guy both have had numerous crossovers, American Dad has barely crossed over with the other MacFarlane shows.
Many believe this is due to American Dad being a television series within the Family Guy universe. There is proof to support the theory as American Dad consistently breaks the fourth wall, with episodes such as Bar Mitzvah Hustle (Season 4, Episode 14) showcasing Stan walking off a set after refusing to read his lines.
The Family Guy episodes Stewie Kills Lois and Lois Kills Stewie" also support the claims, as Stan and Bullock appear in Stewie's simulation. The infant is a major Star Trek fan and Patrick Stewart is confirmed to be an actor within the Family Guy universe in Not All Dogs Go To Heaven (Season 7, Episode 11). Stewart and Bullock have the exact same character design, which makes it easy to believe that the Family Guy universe Patrick Stewart portrays Avery Bullock in the series that Stewie has watched.
2. Roger Is The Smith's First Born
Yes, you read the title right. A popular theory spawned from Reddit user u/youtbuddcody that Roger is actually not an alien, but the Smith's first born child.
The theory claims that Roger was abducted by aliens and experimented upon as a child. This resulted in Roger suffering from depression and turning to alcohol as he alienates himself from his family, considering himself 'an alien' due to his inability to function in society.
The theory goes on to explain Roger has schizophrenia, as he begins to hear voices and creates personas to express the voices. It also deals with the idea that Klaus cannot actually talk and Roger uses his most feared voice (one of the scientists who operated on him) as the fish's voice to make him feel more in control, hence why the family can communicate with Klaus.
It is a fascinating theory that explains a multitude of Roger's characterisation including the creation of Dr Penguin and more. While the theory is unlikely to be true, it provides an incredibly detailed story that has an explanation for every facet of Roger's character.
1. Stan Is Dead
The 'Stan is Dead' theory is the most popular American Dad theory, and one with a high probability of being true. As discussed by Emily Carson in her Cartoon Conspiracy series, the theory centres around the events of the classic episode Rapture's Delight (Season 5, Episode 9).
By the end of the episode, Stan helps Jesus save Francine from the Anti-Christ, but at the cost of his own life. In the closing moments of the episode, Stan is seen being escorted to his own personal Heaven. As he opens the door, the audience is taken back to the start of the episode as if the rapture and end of the world had never occurred.
Many believe that the events of the episode are canon and that Stan is really dead, with the events of the series from the end of Rapture's Delight onwards taking place in Stan's personal afterlife. This provides an explanation the crazier episodes such as the Christmas battles and the events that feel less grounded.
While this theory is crazy and certainly not concrete, it is very plausible which makes it one of the crazier and more intriguing theories, which would be insane if the show decided to tackle the concept.
Watch Next
Quiz: How Well Do You REALLY Know American Dad?