10 Dumbest Decisions Made By Supernatural Characters

Some decisions just can't be justified...

Supernatural Sam Gun
The CW

For a show that went on as long as it did, we saw our favourite hunters, angels and demons make some pretty hard-hitting decisions in Supernatural, with many characters finding themselves stuck between a rock and a hard place when deciding on the right thing to do. While these characters usually made the right choice (though we may judge them for it) there are some decisions that made us want to rage quit the show entirely.

Ultimately, no matter how bad of a decision was made, the Winchesters seemed to make things work for themselves, constantly saving people and hunting things. There are many decisions characters could’ve made differently that would have spared them a lot of heartache and pain. Unsurprisingly, it’s the stupid decisions made that caused the biggest domino effect for the characters and impacted them in ways that could’ve been entirely avoided if they just thought about it for a second.

From constant lying, to abandoning a brother, and almost causing the apocalypse more than once, here we look back at the ten dumbest decisions made by Supernatural characters.

10. Sam Trusting Ruby

Supernatural Ruby
The CW

Introduced in Season 3, Ruby was always a mysterious character that many fans and the Winchesters were hesitant to trust at first. As obvious as it is now, Ruby had been playing Sam from the very beginning, manipulating and gaining his trust, eventually starting an awkward sexual relationship with him.

Ruby never had Dean’s stamp of approval as, after all, she was a demon. Even when Sam promised Dean he would never drink Demon blood again, it was Ruby who egged him on trying to turn Sam against Dean in making him believe that Dean was just jealous that he doesn’t have powers of his own.

In the decisive moments of Season 4’s final episode, it is revealed that Ruby was playing Sam all along (surprise, surprise), working under Lilith's orders to release Lucifer from his cage and jumpstart the apocalypse. All throughout Season 4 she was manipulating Sam, pretending to be on his side and “helping” him gain strength and control of his powers so he could ultimately be the one who set Lucifer free.

However, it’s ironic that Ruby was killed by the two brothers with her own demon-killing knife she introduced to the brothers to gain their trust.


9. Sam Shooting Chuck

Supernatural Chuck Shurley
The CW

In Season 14’s climatic episode, Chuck presents the brothers with one of the most deadly weapons ever to be created, the Equalizer, a gun that could harm or kill anything but also harm or kill the person that shot it.

Originally created to take out Jack after his powers become too strong and overbearing, Dean offered to take out Jack and himself to save the world from any impending doom Jack may put on it. Sam figures out it was Chuck’s plan all along to take out Jack and that he had been behind everything the boys have been through. Annoyed that his plan didn't go the way he wanted when Dean last minute decided not to kill Jack, Chuck does the deed himself.

Due to this Sam took the gun and shot Chuck himself which did nothing but caused him to get angry. It was this decision that made Chuck cut all ties with the Winchesters and bring back all the monsters they have defeated over the years, undoing all the strenuous work the brothers did throughout the years.


8. Dean Saying Yes To Michael

Supernatural Dean
The CW

Did Dean really think Michael was going to stay true to his word after he said yes to letting him possess his body?

After Dean finds out in the early seasons that he was the Archangel’s true vessel, he makes the correct choice by saying no to Michael back in Season 5. However, Dean decides to go back on that decision in Season 13 saying yes to Apocalypse-world Michael so he could do what he was meant to do years ago and defeat Lucifer.

After years of not trusting archangels and following the rules because he believes they can make their own, Dean decided to throw away everything he believed in and trusted Michael to use his vessel as the Michael Sword. After Michael uses Dean to defeat and kill Lucifer, in an unsurprising twist everyone saw coming, Michael locks Dean in a mind prison and uses his body to commit terrible acts.

Many fans had a problem with Dean saying yes to Michael as it felt so out of character for the hero who would rather choose any other option than having someone use his body as a weapon.


7. Dean Letting Gadreel Possess Sam

supernatural tv deaths
The CW

A big part of Dean’s character and personality is his overprotective nature when it comes to Sam. Playing the big brother role a little too well, Dean always makes sure that Sam is safe from any harm no matter what.

Due to this, Dean makes the dumb decision to let an angel called Ezekiel (later to be revealed as Gadreel) take over Sam's body when he was on the brink of death after going through the trials to close the gates of hell. Although Sam had accepted his death, Dean could not and tricked Sam into saying yes to the angel so he could repair Sam from the inside.

The decision ultimately caused a rift between the brothers as Dean betrayed Sam’s trust by lying to him and manipulating him into letting an angel take control of his body. This decision also caused the untimely death of Kevin Tran as Gadreel had orders from Metatron to use Sam's body and get rid of Kevin. Sam was rightly mad at Dean for this blatant violation of not only his trust but his mind and body as well, that fans had to watch for half a season the brothers awkwardly working and living together as Sam stated they weren’t brothers anymore, only workmates.


6. Mary Working With The Men Of Letters

Mary Winchester Supernatural 11
The CW

When Mary Winchester was returned to the show in Season 13 fans were more than excited to see the Winchester’s mother in action, however, she quickly became one of the most hated characters on the show. It’s understandable to need time to adjust after being dead for almost 40 years, but for Mary to up and leave her sons who have been missing her for decades and then decide to work for the British Men of Letters instead felt like a huge slap in the face.

Not only did Mary willingly work for the British Men of Letters after knowing how they tortured and tried to kill her youngest son Sam, but she was quickly manipulated into becoming the perfect weapon for them to get rid of American hunters. Her decision to join almost led to the death of Castiel after a hunt gone wrong at a demon's den when the brothers and Castiel, along with their friend Wally (who unfortunately was killed in the hunt), join Mary thinking it’s an average hunt but she was really there to steal The Colt from the demon, using everyone else as distractions.

For as good and as strong of a hunter Mary was said to be, she was easily manipulated and brainwashed by the British Men of Letters to wipe out many hunters and friends she met along the way.


5. Not Saving Adam From The Cage

Adam Milligan Supernatural
The CW

One of the most hated and meme'd storylines on Supernatural is the Winchester brothers not saving their half-brother Adam from Lucifer’s cage. Despite both Sam and Dean preaching constantly how important family is to them, this importance doesn’t seem to arise when it comes to Adam, who they completely forgot about and left in Hell. It seems that the family importance only applies to the two of them and no one else.

Although it is true that the brothers weren’t very close to Adam in the first place, he was still family at the end of the day and the Winchesters should’ve tried to rescue him from Hell especially with Sam knowing the trauma he would’ve been going through down there. Although Adam is mentioned in the show's 300th episode, Adam was seemingly forgotten again until he returns in the show's final episode as a vessel for the original Michael the brothers fought in Season 5.

Sam and Dean’s decision not to save Adam from Hell caused a big plot hole in the show as it didn’t make sense for the brothers to preach about family and brotherhood all while forgetting about their third brother who is stuck in Hell.


4. Dean Wipes Lisa And Ben's Memories

Lisa Supernatural
The CW

As much as we all love Dean, we can admit he developed a God-like ego where he thinks he can control and make the decisions for those around him. This becomes most apparent when he asks Castiel to wipe all memories Lisa and Ben have of him so they can remain “safe.” Luckily, this decision didn’t backfire on him as many monsters could’ve still targeted Lisa and Ben to get back at Dean, but it just made him seem like a huge dick.

Dean spent a year with Lisa and Ben retiring from hunting for good when he thought Sam was dead. Apparently, throughout the year Dean thought he had the right to make life-altering decisions for the two without consulting them about it. In this case, they both lost a year of their lives and will never know the reason for it and Lisa would’ve had gaps in her life when she would’ve been with Dean when she was younger but now has no memory of this at all. Even Sam knew it was a bad idea, calling him out for the decision he should never have made.

However, it’s apparent to viewers of the show that erasing Lisa and Ben’s memories wasn’t about protecting them (as they would’ve been more protected by knowing who the Winchesters were) but an excuse to write the characters off the show.


3. Castiel Absorbing Souls From Purgatory

Castiel Leviathans
The CW

In Season 7 we see Castiel absorb the souls of Purgatory in an attempt to make himself God so he can defeat Raphael and take over Heaven for himself. Quickly, the souls he consumed were slowly influencing his morals and disintegrating his body to a point of no return. The souls led Castiel to kill any angel and human who didn’t support him. While Castiel calls himself a new God, Death claims him to be a "mutated angel".

Once he realised the souls were influencing his decision, he tried to do the right thing by releasing them back into Purgatory, but in doing so Castiel accidentally released the Leviathans into the world and killed himself in the process. The Winchester brothers found themselves in the middle of Castiel’s mess and yet again stopped another apocalypse from happening.

Releasing the Leviathan's onto the world caused a massive domino effect with many innocent people losing their lives, Sam and Dean being put back onto the FBI’s wanted list after faking their death and the brothers losing their father figure Bobby Singer in the process.


2. Everytime Sam And Dean Lie To Each Other

Supernatural Sam And Dean
The CW

The show is beloved by fans all over the world because of the special brotherly bond Sam and Dean have with each other, but there have been many times throughout the show fans have been shown the cracks in the brothers’ relati0nship. Sam and Dean are notorious for lying to each other throughout the show, making them the biggest hypocrites as they constantly promise to have each other’s back and never keep a lie from one another, yet that’s all they seem to be doing.

They are always seen talking to each other about how lying is bad, and they should always be open and honest no matter how terrible things can get, yet they never seem to learn from their past mistakes. A lot of the brothers' problems could’ve been completely avoided or resolved easily if they just put their egos aside and told the truth to one another.

There were many ways the writers of the show could’ve progressed storylines without Sam and Dean keeping some secret from one another but they choose to do the same thing every season which eventually got old and frustrating to the fans watching.


1. Dean Accepting The Mark Of Cain

Supernatural Cain And Dean
The CW

Despite the constant warning from Cain about the Mark and the burden that comes along with it, Dean was adamant about taking the Mark of Cain for himself so he could have the strength in killing Abaddon with the First Blade - which could only be used by the one who held The Mark.

The Mark, as an aside, is used as a key to lock the Darkness away and whoever bears the deadly scar becomes the ultimate killer. While Dean was successful in killing Abaddon, The Mark turned Dean into a ruthless, aggressive killer as he was slowly becoming influenced by the Prince of Hell's power and couldn't fight off the evil that raged inside him from The Mark.

Dean's decision to accept The Mark proved to be one of the worst things that not only happened to Dean himself but also to those around him. After almost killing Sam and Castiel (plus many, many more), indirectly causing Charlie's death, killing an innocent Cyrus Styne, turning himself into a demon and unleashing the Darkness after killing Death himself, Dean's choice to bear The Mark of Cain caused a tumultuous domino effect on every person in the universe.


Watch Next


You'll Never Get 100% On This Supernatural Quiz

The CW

1. What Year Did The Show First Air?

In this post: 
Supernatural
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Writer. Loves films and tv shows. Obsessed with Doctor Who, Supernatural and DC.