10 Exact Moments These TV Shows SHOULD Have Ended

The perfect ending.

The Office Goodbye Michael.jpg
NBC

Having a hit TV series is one thing, but knowing when to end it is a whole other matter.

You can probably count on two hands the number of shows that actually found a perfect departure point from a dramatic perspective and actually took it, as there are many, many more that were either cancelled before their time was done, or worse still, limped on for a season (or ten) past their natural end.

And there are no more egregious examples than these 10 popular series, all of which gave fans an emotional, gratifying send-off...but misguidedly decided to keep going.

Driven by strong ratings and the easy potential to cash-in, these series were all milked past their organic conclusions, with results ranging from acceptable, to disappointing, to straight-up terrible.

For many fans, these are the real finales in their head-canon, and nobody's going to be able to tell them otherwise. If you haven't started these shows yet, just stop watching once you reach these episodes...


10. "My Finale" (Season 8, Episodes 18 & 19) - Scrubs

Scrubs My Finale
ABC

While it was being written and filmed, the finale to Scrubs' eighth season was actually intended to be the series finale, with more than 50 prior cast members returning for J.D.'s (Zack Braff) big send-off.

And indeed, "My Finale" was about as perfectly fitting a finale as Scrubs could've given fans.

J.D. leaves Sacred Heart, but not before viewing a film which hints at his happy future with Elliott (Sarah Chalke), where their son gets engaged to Turk (Donald Faison) and Carla's (Judy Reyes) daughter, and J.D. even gets a reluctant hug from Dr. Cox (John C. McGinley).

But ABC made a last-minute decision to renew Scrubs for a ninth season, effectively undoing that sweet and conclusive ending, with a final batch of 13 episodes focused on a new cast of medical students at another hospital, with only Dr. Cox and Turk remaining regular cast members.

Creator Bill Lawrence actually asked ABC to rename the ninth season to "Scrubs Med", considering My Finale to be the end of Scrubs as we knew it, but for branding reasons, ABC refused.

With almost all of the original series' writing staff gone, the quality of season nine evidently suffered, adding a wonky post-script to a beautiful finale that tied everything off terrifically.


9. "The Getaway" (Season 4, Episode 12) - Dexter

Dexter Rita Dead
Showtime

The finale of Dexter's fourth season is one of the series' best-ever episodes, concluding with Dexter (Michael C. Hall) offing the Trinity Killer (John Lithgow), and deciding that his desire to live a normal family life is finally overcoming his desire to kill.

But tragedy strikes in the episode's final moments, as Dexter returns home to find his wife Rita (Julie Benz) slain in the bathtub, with their son Harrison lying in a pool of her blood nearby.

This wasn't just a shocking ending, it was a thematically brilliant one that brought Dexter's journey full circle, given that he himself was rescued from the scene of his mother's murder as a child.

And though Rita's death certainly had the potential to shake up the show's formula and give audiences a fiercely unrestrained Dex moving forward, ultimately it signalled the series' creative high point, with the remaining four seasons proving wildly uneven.

This culminated in the near-universally despised series finale, where Dexter's sister Deb (Jennifer Carpenter) dies in woefully unsatisfying fashion, and Dex ends up faking his own death, hiding out in Argentina as a grizzled lumberjack. Right.

While there was virtually zero chance of Showtime agreeing to end Dexter at the height of its popularity, season four's ending is so perfect compared to what followed that you may as well just stop watching right there.


8. "The Gift" (Season 5, Episode 22) - Buffy The Vampire Slayer

Buffy The Gift
Warner Bros

Buffy's season five finale feels like a pretty natural end for Joss Whedon's hit fantasy series, and served as the "WB Finale" for the show as it moved to UPN afterwards.

"The Gift" brought the show's strong fifth season to a close with the sacrificial death of protagonist Buffy Summers (Sarah Michelle Gellar)...which was immediately undone at the start of the sixth season with her resurrection.

It totally undermined the emotion and stakes of the season five finale, and it's not much of a coincidence that the two subsequent UPN seasons are without question the show's weakest.

There were certainly worthwhile moments after Buffy's death and revival, but this felt like the right departure point for the character and, ultimately, the show itself.


7. "You're Getting Old" (Season 15, Episode 7) - South Park

South Park You're Getting Old Stan
Comedy Central

The mid-season finale of South Park's fifteenth season, "You're Getting Old", totally threw fans for a loop, both with its unexpectedly emotional ending, and also the fact that it felt like a concrete ending for the hit animated series.

The episode focuses on the onset of Stan's depression, where he views everything around him as crap (literally), and was written to reflect creators Matt Stone and Trey Parker's own existential angst as they entered middle age.

In what's probably the least-funny South Park episode ever, Stan's parents separate and the episode concludes with Stan's cynicism worsening, defying the show's typical formula of conflict resolution.

Immediately after the episode aired, there was intense speculation from fans that it served as a meta-commentary on Stone and Parker being fed up with making the show, and even that it may have been a surprise series finale.

But of course it wasn't, and the show quickly returned to its typical formula, with its 23rd (!) season set to air later this year.

As a result, You're Getting Old was a brilliant one-off that, all things considered, probably should've been saved for whenever Stone and Parker decide to wrap the show up for good.

Nobody comes to South Park for its heart-wrenching emotion, and that's precisely why this deeply dramatic and personal episode was so damn effective.


6. "Closure" (Season 7, Episode 11) - The X-Files

The X-Files Closure Mulder
Fox

The X-Files gave itself many, many dramatic off-ramps to end on a high note throughout its run, and though the show's best days were long behind it when its seventh season aired, the mid-season episode "Closure" delivered exactly what its title promised.

Closure concludes the long-standing mystery surrounding the disappearance of Fox Mulder's (David Duchovny) sister Samantha, who was kidnapped when they were children.

Mulder learns that Samantha is indeed dead, and gets a brief ethereal reunion with her before the episode ends with Mulder telling Scully (Gillian Anderson), "I'm fine. I'm free."

Despite the potential for the imagery to come off as cheesy, it resolved Mulder's primary motivation throughout the series in an emotional and satisfying manner, with a bittersweet undercurrent to prevent it feeling overly sentimental.

The show now has eleven seasons under its belt and there are murmurs of a twelfth, but its water-tight storytelling and meaningful character drama left many years ago. Season seven was already pretty trying for many fans, but Closure would've been a fine stopping point.


5. "Goodbye, Michael" (Season 7, Episode 22) - The Office (U.S.)

The Office Goodbye Michael
NBC

"Goodbye, Michael" is considered by many fans and critics to be the best-ever episode of the U.S. version of The Office, as Michael Scott (Steve Carell) leaves Scranton for Colorado with Holly (Amy Ryan) and says his goodbyes to his Dunder Mifflin co-workers.

This was about as neat and tidy an ending as The Office and the character of Michael was ever going to get.

Between Carell's terrific performance and his poignant final silent goodbye to Pam (Jenna Fischer), it was a brilliant culmination of seven seasons of character development.

And Michael's departure is precisely where the show should've left fans, dishing up an improved seventh season after the more hit-and-miss sixth.

But money being money, NBC allowed The Office to limp along for two more seasons sans-Carell, which demonstrated just how instrumental Carell was to its success.

Despite a bevy of guest stars being roped in to try and fill the void left by Michael's exit, the show never regained its dramatic or comedic footing, save for an hilarious cameo appearance from Carell in the series finale.

Michael Scott was the heart and soul of The Office, and without him, it just wasn't the same.


4. "The Devil's Hands Are Idle Playthings" (Season 4, Episode 18) - Futurama

Futurama The Devil's Hands Are Idle Playthings
Fox

For almost five years, Futurama's season four finale was actually the show's series finale, being originally written as such.

The brilliantly operatic "The Devil's Hands Are Idle Playthings" finally gave fans open-ended "closure" regarding Fry and Leela's romance, and though fans were sad to see the series go, it marked a dramatic high point for the series and its characters.

Futurama was eventually revived in 2008 with four feature-length TV movies, which while not bad, felt like a far cry from the series' best output, and failed to build on season four's ending in a meaningful or interesting way.

Two more seasons followed before the show ended for good in 2013, with a good-but-not-great finale that used time travel to recontextualise the nature of Fry and Leela's relationship - and the show itself.

But the season four finale marked the end of Futurama's golden run, and while fans were certainly glad to have more episodes no matter the decline in quality, this bittersweet, just-ambiguous-enough ending was surely the right one.


3. "6am-7am" (Season 4, Episode 24) - 24

24 Season 4 Jack Bauer
Fox

24's fourth season ended with by far the most dramatically satisfying and emotional conclusion to any of 24's nine seasons.

Jack Bauer (Kiefer Sutherland) ends up faking his own death in order to placate the blood-thirsty Chinese government, after which he literally walks off into the sunset to start a new life.

Ending the show here would've been the integrity move: it gave Jack a neat dramatic out and left audiences to ponder on what he would get up to away from CTU, but given the show's popularity, that was never going to happen.

And in fairness, 24's fifth season was arguably its best, even if the quality quickly took a nosedive thereafter, only earning redemption with the surprisingly solid London-set mini-series Live Another Day.

After season five, it was painfully clear the show was running out of dramatic juice, with increasingly recycled and outlandish plot lines, not to mention season finales which strained to match the drama of the earlier ones.

And as great as season five was, if the show ended at season four, fans wouldn't have had to deal with the brutal deaths of David Palmer (Dennis Haysbert) and Michelle Dessler (Reiko Aylesworth). It still hurts, dammit.


2. "Moving Up" (Season 6, Episodes 21 & 22) - Parks & Recreation

Parks and Recreation Leslie Ben
NBC

Much like Scrubs, Parks and Recreation really felt like it arrived at a near-perfect ending a season before it actually concluded, with the season six finale "Moving Up."

If a cameo from Michelle Obama wasn't awesome enough, the episode finally saw Leslie (Amy Poehler) rewarded for her tireless hard work, getting the job she always wanted - and being damn good at it - while raising a family with Ben (Adam Scott).

It was a neat ending that moved most of the principal characters on in interesting ways that made sense, while refusing to lay the sentiment on too thickly or over-indulge in fan service.

The same can't really be said for the actual series finale a season later, though, which was just a little too tidy and treacly for its own good, coming at the end of an uneven season that felt more like an overlong epilogue than an actual episodic volume of TV.

Season seven could've probably just been a one-off, hour-long special at best, honestly.

It wasn't a bad season, but it felt largely unnecessary, and from a storytelling perspective the sixth season said all that really needed to be.


1. "Behind The Laughter" (Season 11, Episode 22) - The Simpsons

The Simpsons Homer Behind the Laughter
Fox

The Simpsons is unquestionably the most iconic TV series on this list, but it's also the show that's most egregiously outstayed its welcome, continuing on long after its best days were behind it.

Though the answer differs from fan to fan, the general consensus is that the legendary animated series began to decline in quality during its tenth season, and so with season thirty-one due to start in September, an argument can be made that there are now more mediocre-to-bad Simpsons episodes than great or even good ones.

And while the show has, bar a few exceptions, kept its characters more-or-less frozen in time, there is one episode in the eleventh season that's by far the closest The Simpsons has ever come to a kayfabe-destroying series finale-type episode.

Season eleven's finale, the Emmy-winning "Behind the Laughter", was a meta-narrative experiment of sorts, a mockumentary that examined the lives of The Simpsons, the "real" family, through the lens of a Behind the Music parody.

A deliciously creative satire of the entertainment industry and of The Simpsons itself, there's a fair argument that it's the show's best post-Golden Age episode, and its distinct break with "reality" would've made it an incredible way to end the show for good.

When The Simpsons does finally end, one has to imagine how it can possibly pay-off a decades-long legacy, but had Fox actually let it bow out gracefully before complacent rot set in, this would've been a wonderful playful ending.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.