10 Funniest Sherlock Moments

From harpooning pigs to throwing Americans from windows, the Great Detective can be pretty darn funny. Just don't get him drunk.

Sherlock is a show about a sociopath who runs around London solving grisly murders using his vast intellectual skills. Not really the stuff comedies are made of. But when you've got a show with subject matter that serious, you have to find the humor. Otherwise it will be too dark, too heavy, and a long way from entertaining. A lot of the best dramas are also the funniest, and Sherlock certainly fits that bill. In the midst of crazy intense situations where tension builds towards astonishing climaxes, a good laugh makes everything better. It defuses tension, humanises the situation. And humour on Sherlock also serves a very important character function. Sherlock himself is a very dark person, in a set of relationships that are similarly dark and possibly vaguely unhealthy. But when the characters laugh together, we believe them as friends. When they crack jokes at or about each other, they make one another more real. Whenever Sherlock makes us laugh, he seems a bit less remote, less inhuman. So, without further ado, the 10 funniest moments from the nine episodes of the BBC's Sherlock.

10. Sherlock Becomes Mute €“ 'The Sign Of Three'

Sherlock was obviously going to be John's best man. He's John's best friend, and the two's relationship is the heart and soul of the show. If we got to see John's wedding, this is the role Sherlock would play in it. But it didn't even occur to Sherlock that John would want him as best man. He is so utterly oblivious that, when John brings up "the best man," he responds by describing of a serial killer he once met as "the best man I ever knew." When John does, finally, give up with the hints and subtlety in favor of actually asking Sherlock to be best man, Sherlock's brain freezes solid. He's left completely speechless. This is the man who will "outlive God trying to get the last word," and he just stands there with his mouth shut. Then he drinks the tea he dropped an eyeball into. This moment illuminates the gulf that still stretches between Sherlock and John, how strange Sherlock is and how relatively normal John is. John sees a wedding and a friendship as straightforward, but Sherlock is baffled by the very idea. He cannot imagine himself in a role like "best man" until John tells him straight, and trying to contemplate being a best man makes his 'hard drive' crash. Sherlock may be a genius, but the viewers should always keep in mind that he's a total idiot about other things.

9. Sherlock's Deduction-O-Matic Breaks €“ 'The Sign of Three'

Every single scene from this sequence could be on this list. There's Sherlock calculating how many milliliters of beer should be drunk at each murder stop. There's his app to track when and how much he and John should be peeing. There's John's surreptitious application of shots to Sherlock's carefully planned formula. The game where John asks "am I a pretty lady," then the two fall asleep in the middle of a case's opening €“ basically, all of it is unbelievably funny. But the best is saved for last. Sherlock's deductions are the core of his talent, the main function of his character. They're what he does, everywhere, all the time. They're also a staple of the show, and innovating around them is a challenge for every director. So when the deductions break, it's unbelievably funny. Instead of complex deductions on the wood type, the drinking and sexual habits of the owner, and the character of visitors, Sherlock is barely able to register he's looking at a "table." When he sees a chair, it's a toss-up between "chair" and "egg." He manages to fall asleep looking through his iconic magnifying glass. As far as finding humour in the show's own tropes, this is unquestionably the peak.

8. Janine Is Sherlock's Girlfriend €“ 'His Last Vow'

When we found out that Sherlock and John hadn't seen each other for a month, it was weird. When John found Sherlock in a drug den and made him go pee in a cup, it was funny and ridiculous. But it all made sense. Married life happened, Sherlock was apparently left out, he'd started using again to distract himself from being bored. Then a woman wearing only Sherlock's shirt walked out of the bedroom. She was a woman who it seemed Sherlock was getting along well with at the wedding, but in a 'might have been way,' not a 'get it on' way! She pointed out where Sherlock was keeping the tea now. She went and joined him in the bathtub. They snuggled, for god's sake. This is Sherlock Holmes. No one's ever been able to figure out if he's even gay or straight. The people closest to him have no idea if he's ever had any relationship ever. And suddenly, there's this sexy woman with an accent and apparent total command of his affections, talking about dinner parties! It was so un-Sherlock that when you found out he was just being a horrible person and manipulating her, you were almost relieved that the character you knew hadn't been totally re-written.

7. "Mrs. Hudson's Been Attacked By An American: I'm Restoring Balance To The Universe" €“ 'A Scandal In Belgravia'

Mrs. Hudson is very much a background character in the stories, but in the show she's been given real life. She's got a history we don't know about at all (something about running a drug cartel in Florida while moonlighting as an exotic dancer), but as far as we know, she's a little old lady who owns a flat. She insists that she isn't their housekeeper, but she keeps bringing food and cleaning up, probably because if she didn't, they'd live in squalor eating nothing but beans. She's one of the few people with a real role in Sherlock's life, and like most people he's close to, Sherlock treats her badly. He shuts doors in her face, he screams at her, he shoots at her wall. But he hugs her in the very first episode, and he shouts at Mycroft for being rude to her. She's one of the three people Moriarty threatens to murder to "burn" Sherlock. It's in 'Scandal in Belgravia' that we really see how much Sherlock cares about her. When he comes home €“ already in a raw emotional state €“ and sees that she's been attacked and beaten, he really freaks out. He becomes very, very cold, and throws her attacker out the window onto the bins. The whole scene is hilarious and wonderful, both for what it reveals about how much Sherlock really cares about Mrs. Hudson, and for the pleasure of seeing the bad guy get his just desserts.

6. The Ring Bearer €“ 'The Sign Of Three'

There's never really been a child on 'Sherlock' until this kid. And it's not until you see Sherlock interact with a kid that you realize how incredibly childlike he is in some ways. His total immunity to the gruesome, his ignorance of social norms and his endless desire for attention and praise are all very childish. So is his immunity to morals. This lack of a conventional moral compass comes in handy when convincing kids to behave, because to get this kid to cooperate he's perfectly happy to show him X-rated photos that would make any mother faint. They both end up ogling the maggots in his computer, the kid fascinated, Sherlock probably pleased at the attention. So, for the second time, we see Sherlock make a friend. This brings his count of real 'friends' up to two, one a normal man, the other a 10-year-old who really wants to see beheaded nuns. Only on Sherlock.

5. I Always Hear "Punch Me In The Face" When You're Speaking €“ 'A Scandal In Belgravia'

This whole sequence is both brilliant and hilarious. Sherlock Holmes and Irene Adler get dressed, preparing to do battle, albeit in different ways. Sherlock runs around the house and tries on a bunch of costumes while John watches in bewilderment. Irene plays around with some dresses and makes fun of her secretary. In the end, Irene and Sherlock both default to what they feel most comfortable in. But first they "add a splash of color" with the help of their friends. Irene gets her friend to put perfectly drawn make-up on her. Sherlock punches John in the face and accidentally starts a fistfight with his very angry friend as Watson takes the opportunity to vent). So, at the end, we find Sherlock bruised and a bit bloody, and Irene sees straight through him instantly. We end up with Irene naked but completely immune to Sherlock's deduction machine. It's maybe the first time we see someone really turn the tables on Sherlock and totally disarm him, and it's ridiculously fun and funny.

4. "He Made Me Wear The Hat" €“ 'His Last Vow'

Women are a lot of things on Sherlock, but they're rarely simply victims. Janine is one of many women (and men) Sherlock has manipulated, has lied to and led on, and has hurt. Sherlock faked an entire relationship to gain access to her office, which culminated in a faked proposal that made John fume. A weaker character would fall apart, would be furious and vicious, or would just melt and cry endlessly. This lady skips the silly over-the-top drama immediately and goes right for revenge. She doesn't cry and doesn't let him make her into a victim. Instead, she humiliates him in newspapers across the country and makes a tidy profit off it, enough to retire early. The scene is funny not only for it's ridiculousness, but for its authenticity. Janine never seemed like a woman who could be jerked around like that by a man, and she responded to his manipulation by pulling herself up and getting even. She knows the score, she knew Sherlock much better than he ever quite realized, so she didn't even seem mad at him. Just a bit disappointed. And Sherlock reacts to her humiliation by shrugging and basically saying "I believe I've earned something like this." The two part on good terms. Again, it's a frankly ridiculous situation €“ the kind that could only happen with these characters, on this show.

3. "Where Are They?" €“ 'Hound Of The Baskervilles'

Sherlock's drug habit remains pretty subtext in most of the episodes. Instead, what comes up is his smoking habit. Smoking is bad for you, and in London it's very difficult thanks to various legislation. So, when we see Sherlock having a craving, it's for cigarettes. Nicotine patches just aren't as good as having a good smoke. When faced with boredom €“ even after spearing a pig with a harpoon €“ Sherlock desperately needs a cigarette. But he, and his friends, have outsmarted the craving. So he's reduced to bouncing around the flat looking for a smoke, to screaming at Mrs. Hudson and Sherlock, and almost to playing Cluedo. The entire scene is bonkers, compounded by his insane intensity when his client starts smoking. The man's stoicism is pretty impressive, given that a crazy man is invading his personal bubble to inhale desperately. We see Sherlock get nutty several times, perhaps most memorably when he stole John's gun and attacked the smiley face in the wall. But this one is definitely the funniest example of how Sherlock's way of looking at the world can result in a person who is clearly freaking insane.

2. "John, I'm Flattered By Your Interest" €“ 'A Study In Pink'

Watson and Sherlock Holmes have been the subject of gay speculation literally since the first novel appeared in the 1800s. There are critics who say that Irene Adler and Mary Morstan were created solely to refute rumours that Watson and Holmes were homosexuals. People have written thesises on the gay undertones of the story. Today, we see it as a kind of ultimate bromance, which is a main selling point of Sherlock's renewed popularity. So obviously, any modern update would have to deal with those homosexual implications. Two men, very close friends, sharing adventures, a bathroom, and a flat? Add to that the modern understanding of sexuality as a spectrum, where a person isn't necessarily either gay or straight. Then throw in a dash of determined tolerance in liberal societies, and what you have is speculation so self-evident it often ends up in the show itself. Irene Adler, Mrs. Hudson, newspapers, and random strangers make assumptions about John and Sherlock that John, at least, is really uncomfortable with. Still, nothing beats the moment in the first episode when Sherlock himself speculates on the nature of their relationship. John fails to dispel awkwardness in asking Sherlock if he's in a relationship, or if he's gay. Unfortunately, flailing around in such a personal conversation, he manages to give Sherlock the wrong impression, and Sherlock tries to let him down easy. Which is nice of him, I suppose, but still utterly hilarious.

1. "A High-Functioning Sociopath. With Your Number" €“ 'The Sign Of Three'

The entire 'Sherlock Holmes: Wedding Planner' sequence is a piece of comic genius. Youtube-ing napkin folds, I ask you... The genius in these scenes is the juxtaposition of the ordinary €“ a wedding and the mess of relationships that comes with it €“ with the extraordinary, namely Sherlock. John and Mary put a sociopath in charge of negotiating the complicated histories that come up between wedding guests. Sherlock, faced with the stuff of romantic comedies, cuts through it all with intellect and threats. The funniest moment comes when Mary reaches to hug a friend who responds by leaping backward in terror. We then flashback to see Sherlock applying his skills at deduction to accuse Mary's friend of having a crush on her. Sherlock puts the man on trial, running through his social media activity and demanding a defence. When the man doesn't offer one, he explains the new rules that social situations with Mary will follow from now on. It's a yet another example of Sherlock entering a 'normal' situation and doing something only he would do. And it's best for "normal people" not to cross him, because he's "a high-functioning sociopath €“ with your number."

In this post: 
Sherlock
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Rebecca Kulik lives in Iowa, reads an obsence amount, watches way too much television, and occasionally studies for her BA in History. Come by her personal pop culture blog at tyrannyofthepetticoat.wordpress.com and her reading blog at journalofimaginarypeople.wordpress.com.