10 Great Characters Game Of Thrones Ruined

At least Ned Stark got out while the getting was good.

Game of Thrones  Euron Greyjoy
HBO

It's been almost two years since the last episode of Game of Thrones fouled our screens. For some, the pain is still too near, but with House of the Dragon set for release in August 2022, fans are tentatively preparing to dive back into Westeros.

So much of went wrong with Game of Thrones boiled down to the fact the show got ahead of the books. The creators simply ran out of source material to pull from. Showrunners David Benioff and D.B. Weiss went from adapting some already great content, to essentially winging the conclusion to one of the most complex and in depth fantasy stories ever written. There's a reason George R. Martin still hasn't released the sixth novel in his series (a decade after the last instalment), as he's got a lot to wrap up.

Even with Martin giving pointers, we can perhaps be sympathetic to the showrunners making a few questionable choices, given the difficulties tying up such an expansive tale. What is unforgivable, is the inexplicable decision to butcher so many loved characters.

At first, character action and motivation drove the plot, but in the later series the opposite became true. People like Tyrion, Jon Snow and Dany started acting out of character in order to fulfil certain plot points, and it sucked...

10. Sandor Clegane

Sandor Clegane
HBO

This is what happens when show writers pay too much attention to what folks are saying on the internet. The fan-dubbed "Clegane-bowl" became the epitome of what GOT represented by the final season: spectacle over plot, every time.

Sandor "The Hound" Clegane, was a fan favourite. Starting out as a gruff and cynical henchmen to the Lannisters, he seemed ambivalent to death and violence, would follow (most) orders blindly, and didn't appear to have any strong ideology or moral compass. But he wasn't innately cruel.

As the show started exploring the Hound, it was obvious he had little love for his masters, and certainly didn't share in their perverse cruelty. Sure, he killed the Butcher's Boy in season one, but the man was complicated; his arc mirrored that of Jaime's. Someone we had every reason to hate, but over time couldn't help but have affection for. By the time Clegane told Joffrey to go f*ck himself, he'd won us over.

Even when the writing was going to pot in season 7, Clegane still gave us some of the best moments in the show - particularly his interactions with Tormund. But, considering the show writers loved throwing around the line "we wanted to subvert exception", they could have come up with a different ending for the Hound, rather than the predictively obvious "Clegane-bowl".


9. Night King

Game Of Thrones Hardhome Night King
HBO

After almost ten years pondering the sinister and mysterious nature of the White Walkers, what did we get for it? Zero explanation about their origins, zero explanation about their motivations and a thoroughly unsatisfying ending to their reign of terror.

In the books there is no Night King. The White Walkers don't have a leader (that we know about). But it made sense for the show to have an omnipresent representative of evil, orchestrating all the horror our characters encounter. It was also a good idea to give Jon Snow an antagonist to play off.

We can all agree the resolution to the Night King plot line was s**t, but it didn't have to be. The writers had everything in the source material to at least give this character some background.

In the books, there's a character called "Night's King" who existed thousands of years before the main story. Legend goes he was Lord Commander of the Night's Watch. He sacrificed a bunch of babies, married a female White Walker and committed untold atrocities across the North. Eventually the Starks and the Wildlings overthrew him. But there was a possibility, Night's King had been a Stark and that his White Walker child survived.

Martin has hinted at, but not confirmed, the link between Night's King and the Night King. Conspiracy theorists will tell you the writers didn't include any of these details to save content for the planned Game of Throne prequel 'Bloodmoon'. But now that's dead in the water we'll never know.


8. Arya Stark

Game of Thrones Arya Stark
HBO

Arya was one badass little she-wolf. Her natural distain for all things 'ladylike' set her up as an interesting character in a world of archaic gender roles. Sure, we had other strong female characters - Cersei and the Queen of Thorns weren't to be messed with - but they acted within the confines of a female role at court, scheming and plotting to get their ends rather than using outright force or action.

On the other side of the coin we had Brienne of Tarth and Yara Greyjoy, who it was clear were outliers in Westeros. Arya was another such character. Her story arc essentially showed her breaking off the shackles of a male dominated society, transitioning from a lady of court to a dominating force in her own right.

Given the plot swamp she fell into during her time in the House of the Undying, it was necessary to give her a significant role to play in the latter series... , but killing the Night King? Come on, that just came out of the blue. Nothing in the show had been building towards that moment. "Subverting exceptions" is one thing but throwing out seven seasons of foreshadowing for the sake of surprising people is just cheap.

Arya should have had some major role in the downfall of House Lannister, her whole story had been building to that. Hell, that's why she trained with the faceless men and kept referring to her 'kill list'.


7. Petyr "Littlefinger" Baelish

Little Finger Aiden Gillen Game Of Thrones
HBO

The change in appreciation for Game of Thrones, came with the dramatic change in tone during the later seasons. It wasn't the talk of dragons, the ice zombies or even the gratuitous sex and violence that got us all hooked - though these tropes certainly helped - it was the political scheming and clever plotting that drove the narrative. The plot holes started appearing around the season five mark, and by season six those holes were so wide that not even an ice dragon could hide them. Clever writing made way for CGI driven spectacle and lazy fan service.

Littlefinger was one of the primary schemers of the story. One way to interpret the books is that the central conflict revolves around the interactions between Littlefinger and Lord Varys. As the writers started running out of source material (or diverging from the source material) they began to write characters into dead ends.

How do you resolve seven seasons of plot for a character, whose story no longer has any baring on the wider narrative? Apparently you don't. They devised a forced conflict between Arya and Sansa, in an attempt to give Littlefinger one last moment of glory. Littlefinger's final plot, however, fell flat - much like his final scene.


6. Jaime Lannister

Game of Thrones Jaime Lannister
HBO

Although Jaime's story started getting bogged down after his nonsensical rescue mission to Dorne, his character arc remained one of the most engaging. This was the guy that all but started the trouble between Stark and Lannister. He pushed a helpless child from a window, crippled him and showed next to no remorse for his actions... yeah, we all agreed early on, he was a piece of s**t. Somehow, however, he turned into one of the most empathetic characters of the whole show.

Say what you like about the writers, they did a fantastic job when it came to making audiences do a complete turn around with Jaime. His narcissism, ego and ambivalence towards everything was intrinsically wrapped up with his love and devotion to Cersei. With their separation - and his humbling after losing his hand - Jaime began to see the world in a different light, and as an audience, we even sympathised with him, despite his previous actions. I'll say it again, GREAT writing.

So what happened? Well, put simply, the writers ran out of steam. Anything would have been better than his death under the rumble of King's Landing. Even killing him off at the Battle of Winterfell would have been more impactful, it might have actually given that episode some emotional weight.


5. Jon Snow

Jon Snow Death
HBO

Jon Snow's entire character arc was built around the conflict with the White Walkers. All his personal development and military training had been leading to a showdown with them. During the early seasons, he was depicted as the only one with the foresight to prepare for the real enemy - the Walkers. After his betrayal, death and resurrection the show didn't know what to do with him, though.

For book fans, Jon's fate still remains unknown. The last we heard of him he was riddled with stab wounds. Since then fans have been theorising all manor of possibilities for what might happen next. He will likely warg into Ghost and then be resurrected somehow. But there's also a darker possibility...

The Night's King character in the books may have been a Stark ancestor who bred with a female White Walker. If that was true, then the Stark children likely had some relationship to the Walkers. Several clues laid out by Martin suggest Jon's body will be resurrected not by Melisandre but by the Walkers. He might even be the one to lead the Walkers into Westeros.

Already your writer can hear you shouting, "Why didn't they include all this stuff? Is Jon literally the living embodiment of Fire & Ice, with his Targaryen/Walker blood? Are the Starks actually the bad guys?". Regardless of what will play out in the books, this would have been far more interesting trajectory for the show character.


4. Roose Bolton

Roose Bolton Game of Thrones
HBO

Although there were certainly worse endings for characters, Roose Bolton was painfully under used in the show. His cold, calculated and remorseless betrayal of the Starks secured him a spot among the most hated villains, but his demise was anti-climactic

This all came down to the decision to focus on Ramsay as a primary antagonist, outside of the Lannisters. The writers did a great job with Ramsey, right through until his death you always believed just how ruthless and calculated he was. It did have the effect of messing up the later narrative, though. This was an example of the show writers diverting from the books to their detriment.

In the books things are very different. Aside from Euron (we'll get to him later), Roose is the primary threat in the North. Ramsay is certainly a key player, but he's not pulling the strings. He's far more cruel, but far less wise. His father (who isn't dead) knows this and uses him as a puppet to do his dirty work. His role is not unlike the Mountain's: he is Roose's wildcard. As it stands, Roose might outlive his son. Currently he's shacked himself up in Winterfell and Ramsay is heading for a near certain trap laid out by Stannis.


3. Tyrion Lannister

Game of Thrones Tyrion
HBO

The witty cynicism of Tyrion Lannister, coupled with his underdog character and aptitude for humour, made him a quick fan favourite. Testimony to George R. Martin's writing and the acting chops of Peter Dinklage, Tyrion stands among the greatest characters, both in the fantasy genre, and television, period.

But the character's reputation is certainly not without its stains. Seasons one through to four were almost flawless when it came to depicting this guy. From starting off as a carefree, booze-soaked intellectual with a penchant for ladies of the night, he was soon thrust outside his comfort zone. But with the use of his mind, Tyrion was able to avoid execution in the Vale, befriend a bunch of savage clansman, use political guile to secure his position in King's Landing, and help defend the city from Stannis.

Things started going downhill for him after that though. By season four his position in King's Landing was less certain, and by the time his trial came around, things looked bleak. The character was still making decisions that made sense though.

The writers put Tyrion through so many trials and tribulations, that he had all the experience required to become an affective advisor to Dany. His whole character story had been building up to this moment, finally he could prove himself. But nope, every decision he made after arriving in Meereen proved that his father's feelings about him were justified: he was a useless drunk.


2. Benjen Stark

Game of Thrones Benjen Stark
HBO

The TV show answered a long pondered question by fans: what happened to Benjen Stark? Well, according to the writers, he was in fact the mysterious character Coldhands. Although this has not been confirmed in the books - and is in fact unlikely - it made sense to bring Benjen back as this character. There were already too many characters for all the writers to wrestle with by season six, so Benjen = Coldhands was easier then establishing and introducing someone else into the narrative.

The trouble was, the character didn't do anything. Benjen's time beyond the wall could have been used as a plot device to give Jon and the others key information about defeating the White Walkers. Hell, by this point Benjen was half a Walker himself. Surely this was the obvious way to help resolve a major plot point.

But nope, despite Benjen presenting the writers an opportunity for a little exposition, they just brought him back to rescue Jon after his ridiculous venture beyond the wall. It was a meaningless scene, with a wasted character.


1. Euron Greyjoy

Euron greyjoy game of thrones
HBO

Euron was never all that great in the show. He was just a wise-cracking pirate with some outrageous mutton chops and a penchant for violence. In the books, however, he is arguably the main antagonist and one of the most calculated and sinister villains ever written.

Martin had already given the writers everything they needed when it came to a character bio. Book Euron is presented as a mystical and sinister harbinger of doom. He seems to have knowledge of the Walkers, and links to the Three-Eyed Raven. He has a horn that can summon dragons and a ship crewed by mutes and monsters. He's also constantly tripping balls from drinking 'The Shade of the Evening'. His plans are not only to conquer Westeros and marry Dany, but to bring the apocalypse and become a god. What else do you need in a villain?

As it stand in the books, he's been named King of the Iron Isles and the North, invaded and sacked the Southern coasts of Westeros, and sent a fleet to go bring back Dany and her Dragons. He's about to perform some ritualistic kind of blood magic - which involves killing a bunch of holy men and women - and will possibly summon an army of krakens. Much of the fandom theorise his actions will trigger the invasion of the Walkers.

By the gods! This guy's a badass. The Euron we got in the show was a poor substitute...


Contributor

Before engrossing myself in the written word, I spent several years in the TV and film industry. During this time I became proficient at picking things up, moving things and putting things down again.