10 Star Trek Episodes They Should Have Made (It's Never Too Late)

It's time for these untold tales and hidden gems to take centre stage.

Star Trek Cardassian Fall of Betazed
CBS Media Ventures

One of the joys (and frustrations) of a sprawling franchise like Star Trek is that for every story we watch, there are dozens more left off-screen. And sometimes, they really like to tantalise us with them.

A thrilling drama relegated to a few lines of dialogue...a character turning up with an alluring backstory...a point of view that would make for a compelling counterpoint...an episode that ends just as another fascinating story begins...there are literally hundreds of tales teased but not shown. And occasionally, it leaves us sulking about why we didn't get to see that episode too.

In a streaming era of sequels, prequels, spin-offs, minisodes, films and flashbacks, there are plenty of ways and means to pick up pretty much any loose thread and give it a tug to see what happens.

Beyond that, the spectacular rise of digital wizardry means we may never have to say never again. The OTOY project and the 765874 series have proven it's possible to return to any moment in Star Trek history and breathe new life into it. The short films being created through a meticulous blend of practical filmmaking and CGI techniques are nothing short of wondrous.

With so many untold stories to choose from, there's no doubt that everyone's wishlist will look a little different. But here are ten episodes we would have loved to see...and are still holding out hope for.

10. The Fall Of Betazed

Betazed
CBS Media Ventures

There were countless battles and milestones in the Dominion War that we only heard about on the Deep Space Nine grapevine. But there was one moment we'd have liked to have seen for ourselves: the capture of Betazed.

The homeworld of Deanna and Lwaxana Troi wasn't just a notable Federation planet; it provided a significant foothold for the Dominion to launch further attacks on key Federation targets. And yet, this critical battle became little more than a conversation between Sisko and his command staff.

We understand the limitations of a television show trying to portray a galactic war. However, the fall of Betazed was not only important enough to show us in real time, but also a tailor-made snapshot. With the fleet protecting Betazed out on a training exercise, and the planet's defences having seen better days, the entire invasion was over in under ten hours. A perfect, self-contained war story that could have fit neatly into a single episode. And yet, we were left wanting.

Clearly, we're not the only ones to be inspired by this lost chapter. A short story from Tales of the Dominion War and the novel The Battle of Betazed help to fill in some gaps surrounding the aftermath. But this is one visual spectacle that could have helped the war feel tangible and closer to home. It would have shown the cost to actual people rather than just statistics, and emphasised how dire the situation was for the Federation.


9. A Klingon Encore

Subspace Rhapsody
CBS Media Ventures

Almost everyone on the Enterprise got their time to shine during Subspace Rhapsody... except for a few not-so-discreet absences among the soloists. Rude.

But let's be honest: that brief but unforgettable Klingon appearance really stole the show. When they appeared on screen to add their voices to the finale's crescendo, we gave a knowing roll of the eyes and settled in for some Klingon opera...only to spit our tea clear across the room when they burst into K-pop instead. Complete with savage dance moves.

And that got us wishing, hoping and praying for a musical episode entirely from the point of view of that Klingon vessel. Not only would we be living the ultimate K-pop dream, but it would answer a few other questions.

What on Qo'noS did the Klingons think was going on during the musical fiasco, considering they had virtually no context for what was happening? Was their entire ship afflicted with boy band fever, or was there at least one dramatic opera diva? Did anyone belt out the now famous Klingonese version of Total Eclipse of the Heart? And who was the poor crewman who started singing first and most definitely got a d'k tahg to the chest because he couldn't stop?

Seeing how Rogers: The Musical has high-kicked its way into a life of its own since the snippet shown in Hawkeye, it's not beyond the realms of imagination that Subspace Rhapsody: The Klingon Cut might still happen...


8. The Equinox Five

Equinox
CBS Media Ventures

By now, it's no secret that many Voyager fans felt there wasn't enough friction between the Maquis and Starfleet crews when they became one big blended family. But there was another set of crew members who were in for a tough time when integrating with Voyager's crew. And they sort of just...vanished.

When Janeway crossed warp trails with another Starfleet ship in Equinox, she was forced to put a stop to Captain Ransom's horrific exploitation of nucleogenic lifeforms. Despite the Equinox's destruction, five officers were saved and absorbed into Voyager's crew.

The end of the epic two-parter made their difficult path ahead all too clear. Janeway stripped them of their rank, curbed their privileges and warned them they'd be working under supervision until they earned her trust. She wasn't angry; she was just disappointed.

Who are we kidding? She was both very angry and very disappointed.

It set up a promising journey for at least a couple of these characters; slowly earning Janeway's trust through dangers untold and hardships unnumbered, before some suitably dramatic event completed their redemption arc. But...no...apart from a couple of background appearances, the Equinox five all but disappeared.

And it's an almighty shame, because at least one episode in the style of The Next Generation's Lower Decks would have been a fascinating watch. Showcasing a day-in-the-life down the line, maybe some of them have managed to move on, but others are still convinced they hear whispers behind their backs. And it would all end with a make-or-break crisis that would test their mettle and earn their Voyager pips once and for all.


7. Lost In Time

USS Bozeman
CBS Media Ventures

If being stuck in a time loop was a bizarre day at the office for the Enterprise crew in Cause and Effect, imagine what it must have been like for Captain Bateson and his crew on the USS Bozeman.

One minute, they're minding their own business; the next, they're pulled 90 years into the future. To put that into perspective, that would be like someone from the 1930s walking into our time and coming face to face with TikTok and AI.

What have we done?

Which raises the question: after the initial existential crisis, what came next for Bateson and his crew? Thanks to a couple of on-screen nods, we get the impression that the Bozeman and its crew may have still been out there, serving the Federation. And we love that Bateson played a small but crucial part in the Lower Decks episode Grounded.

But...how? How did the crew of the Bozeman go from temporal refugees to actively serving again? A Bozeman adventure or two set in The Next Generation era would have made for a compelling drama, charting the captain coming to terms with a new world.

Did he initially feel obsolete like the misplaced Scotty? Or was he filled with a sense of determination? Did all of his crew stay with the Bozeman, or did some retire after the culture shock? In which case, were contemporary officers assigned to help acclimatise any original crew members still left? And was there any debate at all about the ramifications of sending them home versus keeping them out of time? So...many...questions...


6. Meanwhile, In The Alpha Quadrant...

Alpha Quadrant
CBS Media Ventures

The bittersweet flavour of Voyager's story wasn't just in their spirit of exploration while lost in space...but also in the consequences for their loved ones back home.

While Voyager continued to boldly go in the Delta Quadrant, Starfleet had no idea whether they were alive or dead until The Doctor made contact in Season 4. Indeed, he confirms that Voyager had been declared lost.

Although we appreciate the stylistic choice to stay strictly with Voyager, it's interesting to think about a storyline that follows the initial search efforts in the Alpha Quadrant, whether it be a single episode or snippets laced throughout Season 1.

It would have given us the chance to see the hopes and fears of the loved ones left behind. As well as Starfleet's fruitless search for the ship that vanished without a trace. Did Harry Kim's parents refuse to give up hope, just like their son? Was it the loss of Kathryn that saw her fiancé, Mark, find comfort with another woman? (Yeah, don't think we've forgotten about that, Mark...) Did Admiral Paris quietly accept Starfleet's verdict that it was time to declare Voyager lost with dignity, or did he demand more time?

Eventually, hope would fade, and they would be forced to face the fact that Voyager was gone, bringing the Alpha Quadrant storyline to a natural close...until contact is re-established in Season 4. And once those glimpses of the Alpha Quadrant disappeared, it would leave the saga with a real sense of finality. Voyager's on her own.

Still, not knowing what was happening with the search for Voyager did help put the viewer in the same emotional space as the remote crew. So this one is just a matter of taste.


5. 8 Years In Survival Mode

Thomas Riker
CBS Media Ventures

Yes, we're talking about Thomas Riker again. No, we're not letting this go. You can't give us a tantalising transporter clone and not expect us to want more.

One of the most intriguing aspects of Thomas was his backstory. When we meet him in Second Chances, he's been stranded, alone, for eight years. Most laptops don't even last that long these days.

Imagine something along the lines of Castaway, an episode that chronicles Thomas' struggle to survive across those long, hard years. From the moment he appears back on the surface after the transporter accident, his initial sense of relief gives way to the cold reality of his situation. Then onward, through the trials and tribulations of his survival, until one day, he finally hears the voices of the rescue team...and comes face to face with himself.

This seems like one of the more achievable stories for an OTOY style revisit. Perhaps a montage with little or no dialogue, showing Thomas' gruelling quest to stay alive and well. Or even a script based on his log entries across those years, as his situation became ever more desperate.

And when that's sorted out, we can talk about the sequel...


4. Decker's Glory Days

Decker
CBS Media Ventures

The Doomsday Machine can be a tough watch. It's a great episode of Star Trek, but the demise of Commodore Matt Decker is heart-wrenching. Watching him break down after losing his crew to the planet killer, only to throw his own life away in an attempt to quiet the pain and deliver vengeance...it's brutal.

Even sadder is that we never got the chance to meet him as the fine officer we're sure he once was. The respect Kirk shows him...the mettle he finds even in crisis...his loyalty to his crew...his regard for the burden of command...Decker seems like a good officer who was dealt a horrible hand.

So it would be nice to have at least one adventure with Decker set before The Doomsday Machine, where we can see him at his best rather than as the broken man Kirk discovers in the wreck of his ship. Yes, it would be a poignant watch, knowing what his future held, but at least we'd have spent some quality time with him before tragedy strikes.

And the beauty of this one is that Strange New Worlds or any future spin-off that might arise (fingers crossed) could legitimately make this happen. A joint mission with the Constellation isn't all that hard to imagine. We just ask that Decker be treated kindly...he's got enough to contend with later down the line.


3. Sito Jaxa’s Final Mission

Sito Jaxa
CBS Media Ventures

From one tragedy to another, Sito Jaxa's story is one of the most moving redemption arcs in Star Trek. Given a second chance by Picard after her near disgrace at the Academy, Sito arrived on the Enterprise with a lot to prove. And to all intents and purposes, she seems to be thriving in the episode Lower Decks.

But then Sito is asked to take on a fateful mission, posing as a prisoner to help a Cardassian informant return home. And with the same courage she used to stand up to both Worf and Picard, she volunteers. Picard waits, and waits, for her return, but only debris is discovered. Finally, a report is intercepted that claims a Bajoran prisoner was killed trying to escape.

In an ideal world, Lower Decks would have been a two-parter, the second episode focusing on Sito's mission. They could have made an entire thriller out of the covert operation itself rather than make us wait with Picard for news.

However, because it's not healthy for us to always get what we want, we'll have to settle for a retrospective fix. Any new series that might launch in the Star Trek: Picard era could easily pick this up. Bring Sito back and show us the escapade from her point of view in a captivating flashback, complete with the revelation that reports of her death had been greatly exaggerated.

Because we still refuse to believe that her story ended with a bit of debris and some sus report. In the words of our very own Seán Ferrick: no body, no death. And we're sticking to it.


2. The Home The Children Of Time Built

Children Of Time
CBS Media Ventures

Children of Time is one of those episodes that's easy to overlook given its timing. But it's a touching 'what if' story that leaves you thinking long after it ends.

Thanks to Dax using her best 'pretty please' voice, the Defiant passes through an energy barrier to survey a mysterious planet...and gets damaged in the process. When the inhabitants below make contact, Sisko is shocked to find they're descendants of his crew. It seems that the Defiant's destiny is to be thrown 200 years into the past, resulting in the crew founding the very colony they've just made contact with.

As time travel conundrums go, it's deceptively simple, but it creates a very Star Trek moral dilemma. Now they know their fate, they can try to avoid it...but that would mean 8000 people and their flourishing colony would cease to exist.

When we meet these descendants, they've had 200 years to build something remarkable. But how satisfying would it have been to see the founding of the settlement? The recovery of the Defiant crew after the crash. Their first steps in building the future, falling in love and starting families. Worf teaching the way of the warrior to a new clan. The Dax symbiont passing from one generation to the next. And Odo watching on as the years passed.

Seeing those original crew members and their descendants actually build the colony would have been beautiful, no matter the fate that awaited them at the end of the journey.

And if Wesley Crusher taught us anything in Prodigy, it's that every thread of reality matters in the delicate tapestry of time and space.


1. Yesterday's Daughter

Sela
CBS Media Ventures

Speaking of time travel conundrums...

When Tasha Yar from an alternate universe went back in time with the Enterprise-C to fight a battle that was integral to restoring the timeline, it spawned a very unexpected sequel.

With the ill-fated Enterprise-C destroyed, Yar and a handful of survivors were captured by the Romulans. They were all to be executed following their interrogation, but a general became enamoured with Yar and offered her a nauseating deal. Become his consort, and the lives of the other survivors would be spared.

The courageous and duty-bound officer agreed, and a year later, she gave birth to a little girl. Sela. A child that would cry out for help when her mother tried to escape with her. A child that would become as fierce and cunning as any Romulan of the Star Empire.

And we learn all of this from a few lines of dialogue in the superb two-parter Redemption.

But this backstory is as delicious a drama as any Romulan epic shown on screen. Why is it little more than a footnote in another story? Well, we think it's time this oversight was put right.

Cards on the table, we're not really talking about just one episode here. Let's go all out and demand a limited mini-series, say...six episodes. Opening with that final battle of the Enterprise-C we've heard so much about, it would chart the fate of Yar and the rise of Sela. Although, can we at least flirt with the idea that Yar managed to escape somehow, please?

What would follow is a tale swathed in Romulan political intrigue, revealing the perilous past of the half-Romulan woman who claimed everything human about her died with her mother. Perhaps she was manipulated to turn against Yar and humanity, or maybe she saw it as her only path to survival...until she no longer remembered feeling any other way.

Full of hardcore Romulan scheming, twists and turns, and just the right amount of scandal, the story could take us to the eve of Redemption, to the moment a fully formed Sela finally steps out of the shadows.

Now, you have to admit that doesn't sound half bad.


Contributor

Katherine has been boldly going since childhood, when the BBC Two 6pm Star Trek slot changed her life. She was drawn in by the franchise's optimism, compassion and flair for character-driven storytelling. She's been writing stories since she could pick up a pen and has spent far too much time immersed in television, films, books, music and theatre. She loves any chance to talk or write about her favourite fandoms, of which there are many. When not busy writing, she can usually be found playing video games or explaining why the concept of a transporter is actually terrifying.