10 Great TV Shows With Awful First Seasons

Proof that a great TV show can be a marathon, not a sprint.

The Office Pilot Michael Scott
NBC

Now more so than ever, there is a quite ridiculous amount of impatience in the world of both movies and TV. If a franchise or a series doesn't hit the ground running immediately, chances are it will be cancelled without even a second thought.

It almost feels as though cutting losses and moving onto the next project in line is the expectation here, as TV shows are regularly cancelled after a less-than-stellar first season, before they were even given a fighting chance.

But the thing is, series often take time to truly find their audience and their market. They will evolve and become better as time goes on, and if a sub-par first season is the price that has to be paid, then isn't it worth the risk to pay it? The expectation for perfection straight away has culled what could have been great projects before they had the chance to be great.

There are plenty of examples, before such trigger happy cancellations became the norm, of how a bad first season could still be built on and turned into something special. Just imagine if any of these ten had been axed before hitting their stride.

10. Buffy The Vampire Slayer

Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Mutant Enemy

There was once a time that campy supernatural stories made for great TV. Within the same span from the late 1990s through to the early-mid 00s ran the likes of Sabrina the Teenage Witch, Charmed, and of course Buffy the Vampire Slayer.

All encapsulated what made the 90s so cheesy and fun, with Buffy arguably going on to be the most popular. Still to this day the show has a loyal fanbase, equally both excited by its would-be return and outraged by its subsequent cancellation in 2026.

Buffy certainly left an impression, but it is largely the later years that are most fondly looked back on, with season one being the most forgettable of all. It was closer to half a season in reality, boasting just 12 episodes before moving into the more typical 22-entry seasons, and Joss Whedon's creation was far from reaching its peak in that time frame.

In what will be a recurring theme on this list, characters that went on to be incredibly popular were either underdeveloped or missing entirely, the writing was nowhere near as honed as it would become over the years, and it was let down by incredibly shoddy CGI, even for the time. Thankfully things got better very quickly, and though there were certainly some episodes worse than others in the following years, the quality never stooped to season one levels again.


9. BoJack Horseman

bojack horseman
Netflix

When looking at the best original TV shows and movies produced by Netflix, there has been some outstanding pieces created, but among those at the top of the list has to be BoJack Horseman. 

It wouldn't have been expected of an animated show about a talking anthropomorphic horse, and the ridiculous hi-jinx of Todd (Aaron Paul), but rarely has there been a story that has taken a deeper and more profound look at serious issues, the likes of addiction, anxiety, loss, and the struggle to find happiness, while still maintaining an impressive level of entertainment at the same time.

As the years went by, and the lives of BoJack (Will Arnett) and those around him were dissected even further, it just got better and better, with the penultimate episode, The View from Halfway Down, being not only one of the strongest episodes of BoJack Horseman, but one of the greatest episodes in TV history.

To call the first season awful may be a little harsh, but it is lightyears away from the peerless masterpiece it would ultimately become. There were some deep moments to be sure, but it leant far more into the goofy and the wacky than the powerful storytelling it achieved in the later years.


8. American Dad!

American Dad Homeland Insecurities
Fox

Much like Futurama did with The Simpsons, American Dad! had a big shadow to emerge from in the shape of Family Guy. Seth MacFarlane's controversial cartoon was already iconic by the time his second project released, and unlike Futurama, it did not hit the ground running.

Sub-par animation can certainly be forgiven as a product of the times, like the majority of such shows, but it was other areas where it fell short. One dimensional characters didn't help, but by far the worst aspect was Stan Smith (MacFarlane).

American Dad!'s entire premise was built around a post-9/11 fear in America, but what this led to was Stan being nothing short of horrifically racist. In one episode he hated his new neighbours because of the colour of their skin, and the less said about his time in Saudi Arabia the better. Once the series allowed Stan to grow as a character past such xenophobic ideas, he became a much more likeable protagonist. 

Arguably the biggest change made in American Dad!'s favour however, was Roger's evolution into the master of disguise. Here there have been literally countless wonderful and hilarious characters, with the alien overtaking Stan as the most valuable part of the entire thing. This was something completely absent from the first handful of episodes.


7. It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia

It's Always Sunny
FX

When Friends finished in 2004, there followed something of an influx of American sitcoms, with The Office, How I Met Your Mother, and It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia debuting just one year later in 2005. The only one of these still running, impressively is the latter.

Still going to this day, the show is barrelling towards the release of its 18th season, based around the tried and tested premise of a bunch of friends hanging out, but this time they are largely awful people. 

Looking back at season one, it's amazing how far things have come. The production values throughout the seven episode season, the shortest of the show's typically already short seasons, were incredibly low, but the biggest difference is the hole left by a character who, like Roger in American Dad!, has arguably become the best since season two.

It's not that often that a single character can affect a series quite so much, but from the moment Danny DeVito joined the fray as Dee and Dennis' (Kaitlin Olson and Glenn Howerton) dad, Frank, in the opening scenes of season two, it was put onto a path with a much higher trajectory.


6. Lucifer

Lucifer Ty
Fox

Though not necessarily the first character that may be thought of in terms of DC comics, Lucifer earned itself quite a following to the point that fans campaigned for its return after a season three cancellation.

Tom Ellis as the titular character was an absolute stand out, and while the final season may not lived up to quite what may have been expected, it was a solid end to a phenomenal series. The same couldn't have been said if things had carried on as they began in season one.

The concept of having the literal Devil working with a detective was certainly intriguing, but it was the latter aspect that the show leaned into more so than the former. It became something of a fairly standard cop show with a few flashes of the Devil, rather than the other way around.

Once the supernatural side was further embraced, as more and more people around Lucifer began to see the truth and the stories became more intertwined with his life as a former angel, things got much, much better. It's no surprise there are still calls for a season seven.


5. Parks & Recreation

Parks and Recreation Ron Swanson Leslie Knope
NBC

It feels strange to say it, as the show is one of the best and most rewatchable sitcoms of all time, but there was a time when Parks and Recreation just wasn't very good, and for a number of reasons, yet again many of them come down to character development.

If you look at the later years of the show, there is an entire cast of wonderful characters, with years of experience and relationships to draw from, but this was not the case in season one. Most were largely one dimensional, while certain popular figures weren't around yet, and others may as well not have been.

Add this to the fact that Mark (Paul Schneider), who would later be replaced and upgraded in season three by the Ben and Chris (Adam Scott and Rob Lowe) tandem, always felt like a square peg in a round hole. Leslie's infatuation with him only held her back, which brings us neatly onto Amy Poehler's now classic character.

Once free from the combination of a being love sick puppy that also came off as something of a cringy Michael Scott imitation, she grew into the kind of character that could lead a brilliant and funny show. She remained incredibly cringeworthy, but this was largely down to her untameable enthusiasm, something that made it impossible not to love and root for her. She was the unmitigated and unquestioned MVP, it just took a little while for the character to get there.


4. Star Wars: The Clone Wars

Star Wars: The Clone Wars
Lucasfilm

The Star Wars prequels have never been particularly well received with the majority of fans, though it's fair to say such judgement has largely been reassessed in the wake of the sequels' release. However, a TV series set between episodes II and III was always likely to be a tough sell.

In particular, the fact that season one followed The Clone Wars movie, which was truly awful, didn't help. The episodic installments of the Clone Wars improved on the small screen, but not by much.

The stories rarely carried much weight, and too many of the episodes felt like filler. Thankfully however, the story was continued, and the series ultimately became one of the most beloved properties in the entire Star Wars catalogue.

A deeper look at the Wars in general, and much of Anakin Skywalker's (Matt Lanter) life that was glossed over in a time jump between films, as well as his relationship with Obi-Wan (James Arnold Taylor), the development of Ahsoka Tano (Ashley Eckstein), and the return of Darth Maul (Sam Witwer), among many other things, made The Clones Wars worth sticking around for after a rocky start. In fact, there are few better things to watch in all of Star Wars than the final four episodes of the seventh season.


3. Blackadder

blackadder
BBC

Mr. Bean may be Rowan Atkinson's most widely known role, but it could be argued that his best is that of Edmund Blackadder. For four seasons the actor played four different iterations of the character across history, and three of them are outstanding.

The exception here is the painfully unfunny first season, almost unrecognisable against what followed.

It wasn't until Blackadder the Second that the series began its path to becoming a British comedy classic, with the introduction of Blackadder's pompous arrogance, and his relationship with the ever-stupid Baldrick. The third season, though not necessarily an outright improvement on the second, was a great success, before Blackadder Goes Fourth, the best outing of the lot.

It's no coincidence that things began to improve when Ben Elton joined as a writer, elevating the series at least ten-fold against a pedestrian and forgettable first effort. Much like The Clone Wars, the final episode is Blackadder's crowning moment, in what was its only real emotional beat, and one of the finest in the history of British comedy. Imagine being robbed of that because of a bad first season.


2. The Office

The Office Pilot Michael Scott
NBC

Remakes of classic movies can be tricky, and the last thing that anybody wants is a boring retelling of the same story, which is why the likes of Psycho (1998), The Lion King (2019), and Moana (2026) just weren't that good. It's rarer in the world of TV, but The Office has proven that it can happen.

Season one of the US Office featured six episodes that were basically as close to the UK Office as possible. It was soulless, drab, completely devoid of its own personality or voice, and absolutely nobody would have watched nine seasons of it.

In fairness, there wasn't yet time to truly develop the characters into what they would become, with the likes of Dwight, Michael, and Kelly (Rainn Wilson, Steve Carell, and Mindy Kaling) in particular becoming vastly different and layered as the show went on, but season one didn't put any effort into that, only the recreation of exactly what Ricky Gervais and Stephen Merchant had already done.

Luckily, things got brighter (quite literally) starting with season two, as the show became more its own entity. This allowed for better stories, better characters, and a sitcom that would arguably surpass Friends as the most beloved and iconic of all time.


1. The Simpsons

homer's odyssey the simpsons
Fox

It is almost universally accepted that the day of The Simpsons has long since passed. The show has, at the time of writing, completed its 37th season, and it could be argued that it hasn't been good for over two decades at this point. However, it's not like it started out great either.

The Golden Age, depending on who you speak to, runs roughly from between season two or three to around eight, or at a stretch nine. Season one is never included here, as The Simpsons was unrecognisable as the animation juggernaut it would become.

Based on the Tracey Ullman Show sketch, the future favourite family of America was yet to find its footing among shoddy animation (which could be forgiven on its own as discussed before), bland stories, and inconsistent characters. Looking back now, who wants to see Homer (Dan Castellaneta) as the serious dad who is embarrassed of his own family?

What made him, and the rest of the Simpsons, and in turn the series so popular, was that he was the incompetent oaf, relatable even when fighting for the Heavyweight Championship in boxing or going to space. The Golden Age of The Simpsons is some of the best television there is, with a deep and rich cast of characters to call upon, but it took time and hard work to get there.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor

This standard nerd combines the looks of Shaggy with the brains of Scooby, has an unhealthy obsession with the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and is a firm believer that Alter Bridge are the greatest band in the world.