10 Greatest Modern Doctor Who Episodes

The Doctor Who episodes from the modern series that stand head-and-shoulders above the rest.

Doctor Who Silence in the Library Tenth Doctor River Song
BBC Studios

It goes without saying that there are a lot of episodes of Doctor Who. The revival era alone has seen more than 150 episodes hit our screens, with hundreds more having aired during the original classic run too.

There are some obvious duds in the mix (Love & Monsters anyone?) but there are also so many gems. As such, it's almost an impossible task to determine which are the absolute greatest – everyone's tastes are different, and no-one is ever going to fully agree – but we're up for giving it our best shot!

From calculated risks that totally paid off, to monsters of the week that traumatized an entire generation of kids, these episodes are, for our money, the greatest achievements in Doctor Who's modern era.

Two quick disclaimers before we begin: we're counting two-part stories as one entry, because counting purely standalone episodes would take some deserving two-parters out of the running, and that's unfair! We've also decided to include at least one episode from every NuWho Doctor, in order to better represent the modern series as a whole.

10. The Haunting Of Villa Diodati

Doctor Who The Haunting of Villa Diodati
BBC Studios

The Haunting of Villa Diodati is a jump-scare-filled ghost story with a Doctor Who twist. Something Doctor Who does well is putting a sci-fi spin on a real-life historical moment, and this episode is one of the best to do it.

The implication that the Lone Cyberman was the inspiration for the famous story of Frankenstein is a fascinating idea, and the Cybermen have never felt as formidable and ruthless as they do here – they truly are a monster to be feared. That's not to say they haven't been scary before, but with Ashad driven by volatile emotions and the unwavering belief that he is right no matter what, he seems much more brutal and unpredictable.

It's funny that, for a monster that's all about stripping emotions away, it was the decision to make Ashad a bit more emotional than usual that gave us one of the most interesting looks at the Cybermen we've seen to date.

The Haunting of Villa Diodati also feels like a coming out party for the Thirteenth Doctor. Jodie Whittaker is finally given something compelling to chew on – her bubbly personality starts to chip away, and we see a darker, deeper side to the character which ultimately leads to a noticeable shift in the dynamic between our hero and her companions as she reminds them (and, frankly, the audience) that she is the Doctor:

"This team structure isn't flat! It's mountainous, with me at the summit, in the stratosphere, alone. Left to choose."

Throw in a fantastically atmospheric setting and an impressively fleshed-out supporting cast, and The Haunting of Villa Diodati is easily the Thirteenth Doctor's finest outing.


9. The Girl Who Waited

Doctor Who The Girl Who Waited Karen Gillan as Amy Pond
BBC Studios

The Girl Who Waited is one of the most morally-challenging situations the Doctor has ever faced. Because they're so powerful and clever, it's always difficult to find situations that actually test the Doctor – usually it's "Oh no, aliens!" followed by some cannon-fodder deaths and a reset button – which makes for a thoroughly engaging story whenever that does happen.

There are several stories in the modern era which see the Doctor face these intense moral decisions – The Fires of Pompeii and The Beast Below, to name but two – but the scenario presented in The Girl Who Waited is much more personal, and that gives it much more weight. How will the Doctor handle the appearance of a second, older version of his companion, knowing full well he can't take both of them with him?

Karen Gillan's performance as an older, more hardened Amy Pond is some of her best work in the entire show. The contrast between the young, optimistic Amy and the Amy who has lost hope carries the story beautifully, culminating in a heartwarming reconciliation between the pair en route to a tragic ending that leaves a lasting mark on your Doctor Who-loving soul.

The Girl Who Waited completely and utterly emphasizes rule number one: the Doctor lies. They might seem all cool and fun, but here we're reminded how alien they actually are – cold and calculating, emotionally distant, and unpredictable.

Stunning production design in this one too. "Apalapucia" – beautiful word, beautiful place!


8. World Enough And Time/The Doctor Falls

Doctor Who World Enough And Time Master Missy
BBC Studios

Peter Capaldi's final series finale hits all the marks that make a perfect Doctor Who story, beginning with a dramatic cold open (no pun intended!), before jumping to a much lighter, comedic scene between Missy, Nardole, and Bill, and then unfolding into a tense, high stakes dilemma full of mystery, surprises, and sacrifice.

Plus, a healthy dash of Moffat wibbly-wobbliness.

Michelle Gomez and John Simm brought such wit and villainous charm to their respective Masters, and so bringing both incarnations together onscreen results in some of the most entertaining and enjoyable chaos the show has ever seen. While the secret of John Simm's return had been a poorly-kept one, it was still absolutely thrilling to once again hear that evil laugh and watch him wheel the Doctor around – just as he did in Last of the Time Lords!

The Doctor Falls also provides one of the Doctor's greatest speeches as he tries to appeal to both Missy and the Master. His revelation that his attempts to save lives is simply an act of kindness, an attempt to make even the slightest difference regardless of winners or losers, is such a powerful scene, and highlights Peter Capaldi's unparalleled acting abilities as the Doctor.

Add in a powerful fall for Doctor number twelve and a gripping cliffhanger that leads directly into his swansong, and World Enough and Time/The Doctor Falls is captivating from the very first frame to the very last. It's easily Capaldi's best finale, and quite possibly Moffat's best too!


7. The Waters Of Mars

Doctor Who The Waters of Mars Adelaide Brooke
BBC Studios

The Waters of Mars explored a darker side to the Tenth Doctor that had nary been seen up to this point. We were so used to seeing the Doctor as the embodiment of virtue and pacifism and so it was an interesting flip to explore the consequences of him rising above such restraints.

The entire "Time Lord Victorious" speech between the Doctor and Adelaide Brooke is one of the most powerful scenes in the show. The performances from David Tennant and Lindsay Duncan, the powerful score by Murray Gold, the severity and intensity of what the Doctor has come to believe – everything in these final five minutes contributes to making it such a memorable and poignant moment.

This made for an ambitious penultimate outing for the dashing Tenth Doctor, and everything about the episode rose to the occasion, from Russell T Davies and Phil Ford's propulsive script, to the supporting performances, to some of the most convincing makeup and prosthetics (and scariest villains) in the show. Seriously, just look at how good this is.

Doctor Who The Waters of Mars Flood zombie
BBC Studios

But above all else, The Waters of Mars is so special because it's a rare Doctor Who tragedy, and a damn good one at that. There's no easy way out here. There's no "Everybody lives!". People die. Horribly. There's loss, grief, loneliness. A single person holding the power to decide who lives and who dies. It's poetic and dramatic and moving and every other adjective you can throw at it.

Not bad for that old show about a spinning blue phone box eh?


6. The Day Of The Doctor

Doctor Who The Day Of The Doctor
BBC Studios

It's important for any anniversary special to stand out and emphasize the success of the show, but for the 50th anniversary, it was even more vital that The Day of the Doctor exceeded all expectations... and that it did!

Not only were we treated to the return of fan-favourite David Tennant as the Tenth Doctor alongside Matt Smith's starring Eleventh, but we were also introduced to an entirely new incarnation of the character. Now, this could have failed. Fans could've easily rebelled against this or viewed it as a cop-out for such a significant milestone, but through the superb casting of John Hurt, the seamless way the character was integrated into existing Who lore, and the intriguingly strained relationship between all three incarnations, it was instead a captivating addition to the story that was very easy to invest in.

Centering on the the Time War was also a smart move. As the greatest mystery in the modern era and something that had been mentioned since Christopher Eccleston first appeared in 2005, it was deeply emotional to watch the Doctor reconcile with all that history, while viewers at home were doing the exact same thing.

And then, of course, there's the fan service. Tom Baker as the Curator. The Room of Easter Eggs – sorry, the Black Archive. Ten and Eleven's sass-off. "No sir, all thirteen!" We couldn't not list The Day of the Doctor as one of the greatest modern episodes, could we?


5. The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances

Doctor Who Empty Child
BBC Studios

The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances is an iconic story for various reasons, not least of which being the enduring, nightmarish image of a child in a gas mask, stalking the dark streets of London with a single phrase on its lips: "Are you my mummy?"

Here, Steven Moffat began something of a trend by turning something ordinary (like a gas mask or a statue) into the most feared thing in the universe to every child who was watching. Including poor Ellie. That aforementioned phrase, repeated in the most innocent yet terrifying child's voice... these episodes are practically a horror film.

The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances was Moffat's debut as a writer for Doctor Who (not counting the 1999 charity skit The Curse of Fatal Death) and he immediately proved that he was something special, demonstrating a keen understanding of what made this new iteration of Doctor Who tick. A complex yet easy-to-grasp sci-fi concept, witty dialogue, and scene-stealing characters.

The unexpected twist that the entire gas mask zombie situation was not a malicious alien attack but actually a misunderstood act of kindness from the Chula nanogenes is also such a Doctor Who thing. As the First Doctor would note in Moffat's final episode Twice Upon a Time, good always prevails.

These are also the episodes that introduced the enigmatic Captain Jack Harkness, a character who makes every story he appears in that little bit better.


4. The Eleventh Hour

Doctor Who The Eleventh Hour Matt Smith Karen Gillan
BBC Studios

The Eleventh Hour casts a spell on you right from that opening shot of Amelia Pond's lonely old house. It's a different kind of spell to what we'd seen under Russell T Davies and David Tennant – a different flavour of Doctor Who for a brand-new era. But it's no less magical.

The score, the lighting, the Peter Pan and Wendy-esque relationship between the Doctor and little Amelia Pond. The mad energy in Matt Smith's eyes. The wonder, the humour, and the weird food combinations! The Eleventh Hour sings on a special frequency that's entirely its own, and yet is distinctly Doctor Who. It's a remarkable reinvention that propelled the show to international success the likes of which it had never seen, and props must go to Smith, Steven Moffat, and director Adam Smith for pulling off what many at the time felt was an impossible task.

As you'd expect, anticipation (and skepticism) was high in the build-up to Matt Smith's debut, but he set aside all doubts in lightning-quick fashion with his lovable, boundless energy, as well as his ability to flip that switch and become the almighty Oncoming Storm that was feared across the universe.

"Basically... run."

He also managed to make tweed jackets cool, which is no small feat!

The Eleventh Hour demonstrated the changes the show would see under new leadership, but also maintained – and in many ways, improved – all the fundamental elements that make Doctor Who such a successful show. Geronimo indeed.


3. Silence In The Library/Forest Of The Dead

Doctor Who Silence In The Library River Song David Tennant Alex Kingston
BBC Studios

Shock horror... Ellie put a River Song episode in the top five!

Series 4 is full of brilliant episodes, and its second half is among the most consistently high-quality streaks in the modern era. But even with so much competition, Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead stand out.

Doctor Who villains are at their scariest when they take something familiar and give it a horrifying spin. The Vashta Nerada are the best example of this we've seen to date, taking that fear of the dark and adding fuel to that fear by introducing a shadow monster that eats you alive! Thanks Moffat.

Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead also introduces the mysterious River Song, and you're damn right that she's a big reason why this story is so great! It was fascinating to meet a character who knew so much about the Doctor, without him having any clue who they were. It made the Doctor as confused as the rest of us, and yet, there were also moments of genuine tenderness between the two characters that alluded to a deeper connection than either he or we understood.

The relationship between River and the Doctor was played so well that we joined in his heartbreak and pain when she (Spoilers!) died at the end of the story. Little did we know that this was only the beginning of this complicated character's journey!


2. Heaven Sent

Doctor Who Heaven Sent Peter Capaldi Twelfth Doctor
BBC Studios

Heaven Sent is one of the most unique episodes in Doctor Who's 60-year run. All the usual hallmarks of the show are stripped away. No TARDIS. No companion. No campy alien or colourful planet. And yet, it works.

It's important for shows that have run for as long as Doctor Who has to experiment and push their boundaries. This might result in something divisive like Sleep No More, but it can also result in a diamond. Many will argue that Heaven Sent is Steven Moffat's magnum opus, and that's because he was bold enough to take a swing with the show he adored.

It's much darker than audiences have come to expect from Doctor Who, but this allows for an exploration of grief and loss that's both compelling and harrowing in equal measure. Peter Capaldi carries the episode on his back and gives one of his greatest performances as the Doctor, and one of the greatest performances of any Doctor ever.

The Groundhog day structure could've got really old really fast, but accompanied by Murray Gold's clever score that ramps up as the episode progresses, plus Moffat's ability to drip-feed you just enough answers and new information to keep you hooked, it never does.

This culminates in a staggering montage sequence that, fun fact, was comprised of several minor variations of the same shots in order to make each cycle feel slightly different (more about that in the video linked above).

Heaven Sent had already secured its place as an all-timer Doctor Who episode, but its barn-storming final reel elevated it to a great piece of sci-fi television, full stop.


1. Blink

Doctor Who Blink
BBC Studios

Like Heaven Sent, Blink was a risky episode that could easily have gone wrong.

Following a Doctor-lite structure after the disappointment of Love & Monsters, would people respond to a Doctor Who episode without the Doctor in it? Well, yes! The risk paid off, resulting in one of the best Doctor Who episodes of all time, and the best episode in the modern series to date.

It helped immensely that, unlike the previous Doctor-lite attempt, the absence of our hero was woven into the plot in a more interesting manner, adding to the tension and thrills of the episode. The Doctor is always there in the background, spewing out cryptic dialogue and orchestrating events like an unseen wibbly-wobbly puppet master.

Even when he isn't around, Carey Mulligan gives such a powerful performance as Sally Sparrow that you barely even notice that the Doctor is missing.

And of course, there's the Weeping Angels. Effortlessly one of the most compelling monsters in the show, they hold you in a firm grip, daring you to look away, but knowing that you're too scared to do that for fear of what might happen. The whole concept of "Don't blink" is thrilling, and the idea that these creatures kill you with time is, like the Angels themselves, oddly beautiful.

Ultimately, Blink has it all. It's scary, dramatic, tense, sad, and even funny at times. All crammed into a 45-minute episode of telly. It thoroughly deserves its place as the greatest episode of modern Doctor Who.


Watch Next


Doctor Who: Can You Fill In The Gaps Of These Tenth Doctor Quotes?

David Tennant
BBC

1. "Don't You Think She Looks ____."

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Ellie has been part of the WhatCulture team since 2021 where she began as a freelance presenter for the WhoCulture channel. As a diehard Whovian with a BA (hons) degree in Drama and Acting, this role was the perfect opportunity for her to combine her screen presence training with her extensive Doctor Who knowledge. From there, she branched out to various other WhatCulture channels, including TrekCulture, and became a full time Content Producer/Video Presenter in 2023. Ellie is now a regular fixture on both WhoCulture and TrekCulture and has become a well respected public figure within both fandoms, building up a substantial following across her social media platforms and being given the opportunity to represent the channels and the wider communities at several industry events. Her favourite Doctor Who character is River Song and her favourite Star Trek character is Captain Janeway - which tells you everything you need to know about how she approaches her role within a generally male dominated field.