10 Insane Rules TV Shows Weren’t Allowed To Break

Some rules are made to be broken, but these shouldn't have been made at all.

Gotham Joker
Warner Bros. Television

The Golden Age of Television has seen the rise of a diverse collection of series pushing the boundaries of television-based storytelling. These series and miniseries are reflecting audiences' cravings for more thought-provoking and emotionally stirring content.

This medley of TV-based narratives was not always at this level though. Storytellers have struggled for decades to work around censorship rules and the puritanical tastes of more conservative audiences. However, this is rarely an issue these days and most shows are able to tell stories that would have been considered taboo only a few years/decades ago.

That said, some networks and streaming services still impose the rule here and there on their series. Some are the result of rights issues (especially if the show is based on a pre-existing property) or production limitations/specificities. Other rules are a bit more... zany. It goes without saying that most network executives wish to stamp their individual tastes on these properties and this is often at the expense of the series' quality.

These rules are yet another reminder of how out of touch these bigwigs are, and it is a miracle that some of these shows are able to transcend their restrictions and actually be good.

10. Contestants Can't Be Shorter Than Pat Sajak - Wheel Of Fortune

Pat Sajak and Vanna White Wheel of Fortune
CBS Media

Game shows are a staple of television, and have been so for several decades. Their enduring nature has allowed for a variety of these shows to emerge, and one of the most prolific examples is Wheel of Fortune.

The nearly 50-year-old show's premise is straightforward yet appealing, and has seen dozens of contestants and winners over the years. In addition to this, hosts Pat Sajak and Vanna White make for an affable hosting presence.

All this said, the show has an odd rule that, while not harmful, is strange yet functional. Players shorter than Sajak would stand on risers to appear to be the same height as the host. Before this, shorter players would stand on boxes, and this most likely made for an amusing sight behind the scenes.

It might help level out the contestants on screen but is also weirdly specific (and unnecessary). Despite this, this requirement is one of the show's unseen staples and adds to its charm.


9. An Unsettling Lack Of Privacy - Jersey Shore

Jersey Shore
MTV

Reality TV is one of the more baffling trends that have emerged from 21st century television, and it does not seem to be dying down anytime soon. The idea of following people around as they live their lives (however scripted may be) seems trite and invasive in some cases.

The latter is the case with Jersey Shore, one of MTV's most enduring (and not in a good way) reality shows. Its premise and characters are well-known at this point, so they will not be the focal point of this entry. The show's cast was not allowed to use cell phones in its early days, and in their place the Duck Phone was used.

The duck-shaped phone was the primary communication device in the castmates' house and all their conversations bar one were recorded. The latter was a strange mandate and made some newbies to the show wonder why the cast's private conversations were recorded.

This was probably a means to manufacture tension or big reveals but it was still odd to see these (sometimes) personal conversations play out onscreen.


8. Referencing The Movie Was Forbidden - Hannibal

Hannibal Promo Mads Mikkelsen
Sony Pictures Television

The short-lived but much beloved Hannibal prequel series worked due to its captivating lead performances, unique visual style and brutal but well-crafted storytelling. Its nature as a prequel meant that the series was not going to touch key elements of The Silence of the Lambs, at least not in its earlier episodes.

This was further compounded by various rights wrangles surrounding the ownership of the film and the book that it is based on. This meant any character who originated in the above-mentioned story could not appear in the show as well and the only characters available to the showrunner and writers were from relatively lesser known books such as the Red Dragon.

Therefore, its overall plot had to be structured around the book and adapt a rather convoluted timeline (at least for those who have read the books). Despite this, the show worked on its merits, and was able to deliver a captivating tale in its brief time on-air.


7. No Tights, No Flights - Smallville

Smallville Finale Part 2
The CW

Smallville was a massive success, especially in its earlier seasons. This paved the way for modern superhero television, with the Arrowverse owing a lot of its narrative genetics to the superhero drama.

Its stripped back nature meant that audiences did not get a chance to see iconic pieces of Superman lore onscreen (at least initially), such as his ability to fly and his costume.

These particular aspects of the character were part of a rule created by the showrunners Alfred Gough and Miles Millar because they wanted to strip Clark to his bare essentials and showcase who he was before he became the legendary hero.

The rule made sense for a while, but as the show went on and began to introduce numerous pieces of DC mythos, it began to lose its narrative significance and became a source of frustration for the show's fans. Ultimately the payoff promised by this rule was lacklustre, as we never got to see Superman in his full-costumed glory bar a brief, CGI-driven sequence at the very end of the show's final episode.


6. '90s Sitcom Tropes

90s American sitcoms
Warner Bros. Television/Buena Vista

The '90s saw a number of sitcom tropes rise to notoriety, as well as arguable overuse. Some of these tropes were established in previous decades, but shows such as Full House, The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air and Friends made them very prominent.

An avid sitcom fan in that era would be hard pressed to find a sitcom that did not feature a nuclear family or a group of friends in their 20s/30s, a very special episode (often a massive tonal leap from the rest of the show), and overachieving family members.

Granted, they were not network-enforced for the most part, but encouraged as their popularity made them easy sells in households in the US and worldwide. Despite their appeal, their ubiquity made their use tiresome and indicated a lack of creativity in their production.

It was probably for the best when their use declined at the turn of the millennium in favour of more eclectic sitcom archetypes.


5. He Wouldn't Even Hurt... A Pigeon? - Spider-Man

90s Spider-Man animated series
Fox Kids

The 1994 Spider-Man animated series is considered to be one of the best superhero animated shows, and with good reason. It was a faithful adaptation of the classic tales featuring Spidey, and handled the characters and arcs with a reverence that was not even found in live-action comic book adaptations.

Despite all this, Spider-Man's action set pieces were a bit wanting due to censorship rules. This meant that punches could not be thrown by characters, breaking windows and fires were seen as taboo, blood could not be shown onscreen, and that the Sinister Six oddly had its name changed to the Insidious Six.

However, none of these rules even hold a candle to the weirdness that is pigeon censorship. For some inexplicable reason, Fox Kids could not show Spider-Man imperilling the bird on screen, and his landing on rooftops could not disturb a group of pigeons.

This request, as amusing as it is, makes one wonder, who would want to show ol' Web-head duking it out with pigeons?


4. The Walking Dead And Its Odd Choice of Language

The Walking Dead
AMC

AMC's The Walking Dead is one of the goriest and most violent shows on cable television and with good reason. It does not shy away from zombie and human carnage, often lingering on what surviving in such a world takes.

Despite being on cable and featuring disturbing content, a particular swear word has almost never been uttered by the show's cast. The F-word is admittedly one of the more vulgar expletives out there, but it seems that it would feel at home in a show such as this, yes?

Not quite, as AMC regulations stipulate that the F-word is off limits, but other curse words can be used. This is odd due to the aforementioned mature content of the show and that another, more dehumanizing word was used in the show's earlier seasons. It also makes for clunky scenes where intense conversations between characters feel oddly sanitized compared to the violence surrounding them.

It just goes to show how no one is safe from absurd rules and censors; not even gory, nihilistic zombie shows.


3. The Curious Case of Jerome and Jeremiah Valeska - Gotham

Gotham Joker
Fox

Gotham served as a weird and wonderful (mostly weird) origin story for the infamous DC city and its iconic inhabitants. Told from a young Jim Gordon's perspective, the show gradually introduced characters such as Penguin and Poison Ivy.

Its introduction of the Joker was a bit strange, to say the least. At first, it was thought that mass murderer Jerome Valeska was set up to be the Clown Prince of Crime before he was killed off and his twin brother Jeremiah seemed destined to become the villain. Jeremiah even took on an appearance reminiscent of Mr. J himself and shared many of the character's psychotic mannerisms.

The latter eventually came to pass in the show's twilight years, but Valeska was never referred to as the Joker by anyone in the show. This was due to the higherups at DC and Warner Bros. mandating that the name be reserved for the DCEU incarnation of the character, forcing the show to work around explicitly referencing the character by his famous moniker.


2. A Pregnancy Scare, Just Not In The Way You Would Expect - I Love Lucy

I Love Lucy
CBS Television Distribution

If you ever want a reminder of how prudish mainstream TV was (and sometimes still is), look back in time to 8 December 1952. That day saw the release of the tenth episode of the second season of I Love Lucy.

The beloved black-and-white sitcom was a mainstay in American households for the better part of the 1950s and placed its cast in era-appropriate hijinks. The aforementioned episode saw Lucy discovering that she was pregnant, and hilarity ensues from her attempts to tell her husband of the good news.

What was supposed to be a wholesome episode had the weirdest behind-the-scenes wrangles, as CBS executives balked at the idea of saying the word pregnant on air.

This led to terms such as 'with child' or 'expecting' being used in place, and while this did not detract from the episode's overall narrative, it is an amusing peek into the absurdly conservative sensibilities of studio executives back in the day.


1. Heroic (And More Child-Friendly) Turtles In The UK - TMNT

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles poster
CBS Television Distribution

At the height of its popularity, the 1987 Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles animated series encountered a most peculiar challenge across the pond. Its UK release saw the beloved toon change its name to Teenage Mutant Hero Turtles and had scenes where Michelangelo wields his iconic nunchucks replaced by random clips from the show.

This was due to BBFC director James Fernan imposing strict guidelines on British film and television, specifically on the display and use of weapons in movies and series. It turns out that Fernan (and many others of his ilk) were worried by the weapon's rise in popularity following the release of Enter the Dragon 14 years prior.

The ironic bit is that more dangerous weapons featured in the movie, but future shows and films never censored the use of guns or swords in their action set pieces.

Ultimately, the series' animators had to replace Mikey's nunchucks with a grappling hook known as the Turtle Line for the show's fourth season. It did not detract from the series as a whole, but in hindsight stands out as an example of how impactful one person's sensibilities can be.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Gotham
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

David Ng'ethe hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.