10 Insane TV Plots That Almost Happened

Crazy TV plots that almost happened! Breaking Bad, Firefly & more were nearly so different.

Doctor Who/Harry Potter
BBC/Warner Bros.

Since the dawn of television, writers have been coming up with all kinds of crazy plots and story arcs to keep audiences engaged. Just look at daytime television, and you’ll discover a plethora of amnesiac half-siblings coming back from the dead to reveal they were the real killer all along.

Daytime TV sure has its fair share of insane TV plots, but Primetime has plenty too. There was that time on Friends when the gang crafted a long poking device to make sure “Ugly Naked Guy” wasn’t dead and let’s not forget the time Issie Stevens got it on with a ghost on Grey’s Anatomy.

However, for every whacky TV plotline that makes it to the small screen, there are tons that don’t. They might get laughed out of a writer’s room, or something that seemed appropriate during the show’s planning stages doesn’t work when it comes time to film.

Whatever the reason, some of the craziest TV plots never made it to film… but they almost did. These ten plots are insane, and there’s a good chance they might have worked at the time, but it’s probably good they never saw the light of day.

10. Sam Malone Came Close To An HIV Scare On Cheers

Sam Malone Cheers
CBS Television Distribution

If you go back and binge-watch all of Cheers, you're going to find a few episodes and story arcs that delve into controversial subjects for the time, but ultimately those episodes didn't dig too deeply into anything that might have enraged the censors at NBC.

There were a few mentions of topics related to abortion, teenage pregnancy and the like, but one topic that didn't make it into the final series was HIV/AIDS. Cheers ran from 1982 to 1993, so it was right smack-dab in the middle of the AIDS crisis as it was developing.

There were plans to touch on the subject at the end of season six, and while it would have been controversial, that wasn't the reason the episode never made it to air. The 1988 Writers Guild of America strike put a damper on the planned story arc, which would have ended season six.

The plan was to have Sam learn that a former girlfriend had tested positive for HIV. The cliffhanger ending would have ended the sixth season, leaving the show's fans the entire summer to worry about Sam's fate. The Writer's Strike made that impossible, and the concept was scrapped.


9. Inara's Magic Drug Kills A Band Of Reaver Rapists On 'Firefly'

Firefly Inara
20th Century Fox

Firefly was never given a chance, with its episodes airing out of order, and Fox cancelling it before the first season properly ended. Still, with only 14 episodes, the show garnered a massive following that resulted in a feature film.

Of course, that wasn't enough for most fans, many of whom would still love to see Firefly return to the airwaves. Since the show's cancellation, details of un-made episodes have emerged, but one scrapped hour in particular is one many are glad never got to see the light of day.

In the tossed episode, it would have revealed that Inara is both dying and a drug addict, and also that she can inject herself with a "magic syringe" that somehow kills anyone who rapes her.

In this story that's shown because Reavers kidnap her, and by the time Mal manages to rescue her, he finds her aboard a Reaver ship, with all the Reavers dead.

Inara has been "horribly brutalized, and he comes in, and he gets down on his knee, and he takes her hand. And he treats her like a lady." Yikes.

So, the TL;DR is that Inara is kidnapped and horribly raped. Her rapists all die, and Mal manages to stop slut-shaming her for a moment.


8. Arrow Was Never Meant To Last More Than Five Seasons

Oliver Queen Arrow Island
Warner Bros. Television Distribution

Arrow was the beginning of the current era of the DCEU on television. The series ran for eight seasons and 170 episodes from 2012 until 2020, but it was never meant to run for that long.

Arrow's original plan was to have the series run for only five seasons, and the overarching plot for that plan was a bit insane, given what actually happened as the show progressed.

In the pilot, Oliver Queen is shown being rescued from an island after an apparent five-year stint on his own. Season one also showed numerous flashbacks that corresponded to the first year he was marooned there.

Each subsequent season would continue along that line for five years, each with corresponding flashbacks that fleshed out this island storyline.

The fifth season would see him return to the island, and the series finale was meant to see him rescued as a flashback to the pilot episode.

The whole story was designed to come around full circle, but the overall plotline didn't come to fruition as the show became unfathomably popular and extended long beyond this initial sketch.


7. Carol Was Never Meant To Make It Out Of Season Three Of The Walking Dead

Carol The Walking Dead
Disney–ABC Domestic Television

AMC's The Walking Dead has its fair share of detractors, many of whom feel the series' quality has waned as it continues. Despite those complaints, many fans still have a great deal of love and interest in the show's many characters, with Carol standing as one of the most beloved.

She's had one hell of a character arc with a ton of development over the years, and it's hard to imagine the show's success without her.

As it happens, she should have died a long time ago, back in season three. Special Effects Artist Greg Nicotero explained how it almost went down in an interview with SFX:

In the episode where T-Dog died, there was a moment where Carol was going to die in lieu of T-Dog’s character. At that point, there was some concern in the writers’ room that they didn’t know where to take her character.

That was back in season three, and now, there's no way Carol will be killed off the series. Creator Robert Kirkman came out and said as much, though that was back in 2015, and as time has demonstrated, there's no real guarantee of safety for any of the characters of The Walking Dead.


6. Dr. Bailey & George Nearly Got It On In Grey’s Anatomy

George Dr. Baily Grey's Anatomy
Disney Platform Distribution

Grey's Anatomy has always been a show that focuses less on medicine and more on the characters who practice it.

Fans love these characters, and above that, they love their relationships. Granted, audiences don't love every pairing the show has thrown their way, but one that almost happened might have pushed them away the most.

That's because at one point, Dr. Miranda Bailey and George O'Malley were meant to get together.

This was back in the show's planning stages when Dr. Bailey's character was called "Deborah," and the writers envisioned an entirely different personality for her. She was described as "surly, quirky, and sorely lacking in people skills." On top of that, she was meant to become involved with George in an "odd but hot" relationship, whatever that means.

Given how Dr. Bailey's character development saw her turned from someone known in the show as "The Nazi" before becoming a far more sympathetic person, it's probably for the best this didn't happen. Such a pairing would have been antithetical to her character and how she interacted with the interns early on in the series.

Additionally, It would have derailed George's character arc surrounding his relationship with Meredith, so most fans would agree that this plotline's abandonment was best for the show.


5. Carol Was Meant To Die Of An Overdose In ER’s Pilot

Carol Hathaway ER
Warner Bros. Domestic Television Distribution

Julianna Margulies' performance as Carol Hathaway helped put her on the map, and it's next to impossible to imagine ER without her. Her on-screen chemistry with George Clooney's Doug Ross is one reason the series was so successful, but it almost never came to be.

Originally, Carol Hathaway was destined to die in ER's pilot episode. When Margulies took the job, it was as a limited guest role — not as a series regular. Clooney believed the character might endure, but there was no guarantee of that because, according to the script, she was meant to die.

Halfway through the pilot, Carol leaves the hospital with some drugs only to return as a patient. Her diagnosis is grim, and all indications are that she will die of a drug overdose. Medically, that's what should have happened, but in the end, she survived.

Ultimately, the pair's onscreen chemistry worked well with test audiences, so Margulies was allowed to stay. She was switched from a guest star to a starring role, which she kept for six seasons. She won an Emmy Award for her performance but ended up walking away from a $27 million offer to remain for two more.


4. The Janitor In Scrubs Was A Figment Of J.D.’s Imagination

Scrubs Janitor
Disney–ABC Domestic Television

The Janitor from Scrubs is enigmatic to a fault, and that's no accident. Neil Flynn portrays him, but the character doesn't have a name of his own. He's simply referred to as "Janitor" by the characters he comes in contact with throughout the series.

Of course, it was a bit different in the first season, as he only ever interacted with the series' protagonist, JD. This was intentional, and if you go back and binge the first season, you'll see that he only ever speaks to JD, and when JD mentions him to others, he's met with confusion.

The reason for this is simple, and it's also the result of a plotline that never made it into the series. The Janitor was meant to be nothing more than a figment of JD's imagination. This explains why nobody else interacted with him in the first season.

The abandoned plotline was revealed in the series' DVD commentary. The truth of the Janitor would have been revealed in the series finale if Scrubs was canceled after the first season. That didn't happen, so the plotline was dropped, and the Janitor was promoted to series regular.


3. Friends Nearly Put Monica And Joey Together

Friends Joey Monica
WB

If you've binged your fair share of Friends, you know all about Ross & Rachel and Monica & Chandler, but those are hardly the only romantic relationships the series explored. At its core, Friends is all about relationships, and this was explored in the episode "The One With The Flashback."

The episode looked back on how the group met and knew one another before Rachel came storming into Central Perk wearing a wedding dress. In the episode, Ross & Phoebe nearly slept together on a pool table, Rachel had a fantasy about Chandler, and Monica and Joey nearly banged one out in Monica's apartment.

Ultimately, that didn't happen, and the two never got together. It's difficult to even imagine them as a romantic couple, but in the series' planning stages, that's exactly what was meant to happen.

Series co-creator David Crane explained, "When we were originally conceiving the show, we actually thought that Monica and Joey might become a thing and then we cast it, and just went ‘that’s not the right energy’ because now they’re faces and they’re people."

Ultimately, the plotline was abandoned before the series started filming because seeing Courtney Cox and Matt LeBlanc together didn't work.


2. The Tenth Doctor Almost Made It Into Hogwarts

Doctor Who Midnight David Tennant Tenth Doctor
BBC Studios

Doctor Who has always been a science-fiction show sprinkled with a bit of fantasy. The series can get away with just about anything, and it has. Still, there are a few plotlines that never made it out of the planning stages, including one that saw the Doctor meet J.K. Rowling.

It was meant to happen in the 2008 Christmas Special, which was intended to be written by the author. Ultimately, she declined, so series Showrunner Russel T Davies thought of approaching Rowling with a different angle. Instead of writing an episode, he wanted to have her star in one.

It would have seen Rowling bitten by a "Space Bug" that transforms her imagined world of Harry Potter into reality. The Doctor arrives and finds a world filled with witches and wizards! He must fight his way to the center, where he would find and save Rowling, returning the world to its proper state.

Ultimately, the plan was scrapped, but it wasn't because Rowling wasn't interested. Instead, David Tennant, who was playing the Doctor at the time, felt that the concept sounded like a spoof. Davies backed off to keep his star happy, and the plotline never manifested.


1. Jesse Pinkman Was Meant To Die In Season One Of Breaking Bad

Breaking Bad Jesse Pinkman
Sony Pictures Television

Breaking Bad may seem like it's all about the fabrication of a Meth empire, but at its core, it's more of a character study. Central to the series is Walter White, but he doesn't go through his metamorphosis alone. Jesse Pinkman follows White from beginning to end.

It's difficult to imagine Breaking Bad without Pinkman, but the series nearly played out completely differently. When Vince Gillian pitched his ideas to studio execs at AMC, his concept saw Pinkman die before the end of the first season, and that idea wasn't received well, and it's good that it never manifested.

In the pitch, White was so filled with rage after Pinkman's death; he kidnaps the drug dealer responsible. He locks him up in the basement and tortures him every day, removing pieces of him, one by one. He gives the man a way out in the form of a trip-wire connected to a shotgun, but he never took it.

Instead, the torture continues for weeks until Walter Jr. discovers him. The tortured man then trips the shotgun, killing Walt Jr. and himself. When Gillian pitched it, the execs said, "Eww, you are seriously f**ked up."


Watch Next


How Well Do You Know Netflix TV Shows?

Stranger Things Barb
Netflix

1. Name This TV Show

Contributor
Contributor

Jonathan is a graphic artist, illustrator, writer, and game designer. Jonathan retired from the U.S. Army in 2017 and enjoys researching and writing about history, science, theology, and many other subjects. He writes for ScreenRant, CBR, NerdBastards, Listverse, Ranker, WhatCulture, and many other sites online. You can check out his latest on Twitter: @TalkingBull or on his blog: jonathanhkantor.com