10 TV Shows That Wanted To Be Doctor Who

Doctor Who? You may be a Doctor Who-ey show but WE are Doctor Who. The original, you might say!

Primeval
ITV

They say that imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. And whoever "they" are, they're kind of right. Just ask Doctor Who!

With a show running as long as Doctor Who has, it's no surprise it's served as some form of inspiration for other TV shows over the years.

The classic series served as an enviable template to many writers and producers in the 1970s, desperately wanting to emulate Doctor Who's mainstream popularity. During the peak of NuWho's cultural relevance in the late 2000s, some rode the coattails of Doctor Who’s success in that Saturday teatime slot, and, to their credit, held their own in the inevitable ratings battle.

Others, meanwhile, have failed about as miserably as Professor Lazarus in their Doctor Who experimentations, thanks to some glaringly obvious copy-and-past elements that led to unfavourable comparisons.

So, let's dive into the good, the bad and the ugly of Doctor Who's most notable TV copycats...

10. Survivors (2008)

Survivors 2008 TV show
BBC Studios

In the late 2000s when Doctor Who was the top dog of British TV, it's no surprise the BBC wanted to try and emulate its success by scouring their back catalogue for other TV shows ripe for a revival.

2008's Survivors is one such example. Creator Adrian Hodges admitted that a large reason the show got made was because the BBC was looking for another big revival hit. He said:

"The BBC had this great success with reviving Doctor Who, so they were looking at some of their old shows and saying, 'Well, that one wouldn't work, but maybe this one would.' And Survivors was one they thought might work again, so they basically came to me and said, 'What do you think?'

Across its two series, Survivors followed a group of people struggling to stay alive in a world where a devastating virus has wiped out most of the planet's population. The usual post-apocalyptic scenarios involved them dealing with gangs of armed thugs who laid claim to the supermarkets. Thank God we were all civilised and queued patiently for loo roll!

Interestingly, the original version of Survivors from the 1970s was created by Dalek creator Terry Nation, while the 2008 version starred familiar NuWho faces like Shaun Dingwall, Paterson Joseph and Freema Agyeman.

It goes without saying that Survivors didn't come anywhere close to replicating the success of Doctor Who's revival, and it was cancelled due to poor viewing figures.


9. Rick And Morty

Rick and Morty
Adult Swim

Imagine the Doctor as an alcoholic curmudgeon who undertakes wild and wacky interdimensional adventures with their companion. Damn, they really missed a trick with William Hartnell. Fortunately, we do have Rick and Morty. Basically Doctor Who on acid.

Co-creator Dan Harmon has made no secret that our quaint British sci-fi show served as a major inspiration for the adult animated series, admitting that "there's a heavy dose of Doctor Who in there."

And heck, if you needed any proof that Doctor Who was on his mind when crafting a timey-wimey show with a Doctor-companion dynamic at its heart, in the Season 3 episode The Rickchurian Mortydate, Rick explicitly refers to himself as "Doctor Who".

It's one of those rare times we can forgive – and more importantly, laugh – at the Doctor being referred to in that way.

There's also The Ricklantis Mixup, where Farmer Rick's robotic dog bears strong resemblance to K9, and Season 5's Rick & Morty's Thanksploitation Spectacular, where a character calls Rick a "spiky-haired Doctor Who in a lab coat."

It's the kind of situation where you can picture Harmon getting a Doctor incarnation to cameo in Rick and Morty, voiced by their actual actor.

Or, you know, the Doctor Who production team can make the next Doctor an alcoholic curmudgeon who undertakes wild and wacky interdimensional adventures with their companion. Either or.


8. Blake's 7

Blakes 7 Cast
BBC

A science-fiction show with wobbly sets due to a tight production budget and the lead actor having disputes with the higher-ups – now, where have we heard that before?

Another creation by the God of all Daleks Terry Nation, Blake's 7 centres on Roj Blake and his fellow rebels leading the resistance against the tyrannical Terran Federation. Nation described the show as "The Dirty Dozen in space". And that was no joke either. It's got those edgier, darker hues that would be a welcome injection to Doctor Who when it returns to our screens! However, given the budget constraints you sometimes struggled to believe the world was set in another part of the galaxy.

Releasing in 1978 in the wake of Doctor Who's astronomical early success, the BBC clearly developed Blake's 7 in the hope they would generate another Whoniverse-sized sci-fi hit.

Alongside Terry Nation, the crew was a who's who of Doctor Who creatives, including producer David Maloney (who had directed Doctor Who serials like The War Games and Genesis of the Daleks), script editor Chris Boucher (writer of several Fourth Doctor stories) and composer Dudley Simpson, who had also created the music for Doctor Who. And Nation even wanted the Daleks themselves to appear!

Naturally, there's been talk of a Blake's 7 revival over the years, and it was revealed in January 2026 that Doctor Who director Peter Hoar is spearheading the reboot – which means that, after more than 40 years, both Roj Blake and the Doctor will be sharing the small screen once again.


7. Jekyll And Hyde (2015)

Jekyll and Hyde 2015
ITV

The huge success of Doctor Who's 2005 revival spawned a massive wave of shows aiming to replicate its scary family teatime viewing, with rival network ITV having several attempts.

2015's Jekyll and Hyde was one of the more unsuccessful. Starring The Great Intelligence and two-time Doctor Richard E. Grant, ITV's mandate for the show was for it to be edgy and mature, yet still appeal to a broad family audience that would watch shows like Doctor Who.

However, to try and avoid unflattering comparisons to Doctor Who (and to not be overshadowed by it), ITV wisely chose to air Jekyll and Hyde on Sundays, rather than Saturdays, as explained by ITV exec Steve November:

"It is a long time since ITV [ventured into] a genre so synonymous with the BBC. But we are back. It took a long time to find the right show. We settled on Sundays, not wanting to be directly competitive to Doctor Who. We did not set out to make kids’ shows, we wanted something pre-watershed but sophisticated enough to appeal to the broad family audience."

Translation: "Doctor Who lives rent-free in our heads."

In the end, it was all for nought. The show was cancelled after just one series, and hilariously, the first episode drew a whopping 459 complaints from viewers for being too scary for its Sunday early evening time slot.

To be honest, you're better off sticking to Steven Moffat's superior Jekyll from 2007. Not that we're biased or anything.


6. Timeslip

Timeslip TV show 1970
ITV

Broadcast in the early 1970s on ITV, Timeslip sees young friends Liz and Simon stumble upon a portal called the Time Barrier, that leads them to various adventures across World War II, an Antarctica scientific research base in 1990, and an alternative tropical England in the '90s.

It's a show about slipping through time – you can see where they got the title from.

You can also see how Doctor Who might have inspired it, and Timeslip writer Bruce Stewart has made no secret of the fact that he created the show as a direct rival for Doctor Who, explaining that:

"I was approached in the late '60s by Renee Godard, at that time a children’s producer at ATV, and asked to think about something that could challenge Doctor Who over on the BBC. We entered into talks immediately, and this basic notion emerged about two children who can break through the time barrier."

However Stewart also wanted Timeslip to carve out a more serious tone in order to differentiate itself from Doctor Who, which he believed was only getting "wackier and wackier" at the time.

Despite only airing for a single series between September 1970 and March 1971, Timeslip has garnered a cult following over the years. In an SFX Magazine poll in 2005, it came in at 28 on the list of Top 50 British Telefantasy Shows, while Big Finish actually released a Timeslip audio series in 2020.


5. The Librarians

The Librarians Doctor Who TARDIS
TNT

The Librarians. Ring a bell? Anyone? Anyone?! It's amazing that a show that ran for four quite well-received seasons has all but disappeared into the wormhole of collective consciousness.

The fantasy adventure follows a group tasked with protecting the world from supernatural threats. Think of it as a whimsical Torchwood. It's pretty much universally acknowledged by fans that The Librarians rips off Doctor Who in many ways, from the character of Flynn feeling quite Doctor-esque, to the Library itself being this bigger-on-the-inside alternate dimension just like the TARDIS, to a TARDIS literally showing up in the Season 2 finale.

These links aren't accidental either, as Librarians showrunner Dean Devlin is the self-proclaimed "biggest Doctor Who fan" in the world, and has stated that:

"The influences are absolutely intentional and really just a way for me to express my love for my favorite show on television."

Devlin even sought out Doctor Who writers Tom MacRae (Rise of the Cybermen, The Girl Who Waited) and Gareth Roberts (The Lodger, The Shakespeare Code, and others), to write episodes of The Librarians, in order to further harness that Doctor Who feel.

Recently, Devlin even threw his hat into the ring to win the Doctor Who tender for his production company Electric Entertainment, by posting an awful AI video of several Doctors on his social media pages.

Um, yeah, no offence mate, but we'll tell you exactly where you can stick that tender!


4. The Tomorrow People (1973)

The Tomorrow People
ITV

1970s sci-fi series The Tomorrow People was similar to the X-Men concept – adolescents begin exhibiting powers such as telepathy, telekinesis and teleportation, thus becoming the next step in human evolution.

The show's creator Roger Price recalled a conversation with an ITV executive, where he explicitly said that he wanted it to be ITV's answer to Doctor Who:

"One of the first things [the ITV executive] said was, 'We're really looking for an answer to Doctor Who.' I said, 'Well, Doctor Who is an old man. Why don't we do something with young kids?'"

They even copied Doctor Who's notorious budget problems, with Price mentioning that The Tomorrow People only had about a fifth of the budget of Doctor Who. Rough. Cues were also taken from how regeneration gave Doctor Who a huge shot in the arm whenever it occurred, by having a new Tomorrow Person debut at the start of each series.

Despite its budget limitations and fierce competition from the BBC's flagship, The Tomorrow People ran for eight successful series between 1973 - 1979, with a much shorter-lived revival series beginning in 1992.

The title sequence is also very Doctor Who-ey, as we journey through some weird and wonderful trippy randomness. Perhaps that's where the budget went.


3. Merlin

Merlin TV
BBC

Hot on the heels of the 2005 revival, Doctor Who producer Julie Gardner magicked up another Saturday teatime show in 2008.

Based loosely on the Arthurian legend and starring a number of Who alumni including Colin Morgan, Anthony Head and Richard Wilson, Merlin was a blatant attempt by the BBC to capture the same family audience that had flocked to Doctor Who.

Interestingly, star Colin Morgan is one of those names that's constantly in the conversation to be cast as the Doctor. Though you do have to wonder if the traumatic events on Midnight have put Jethro off piloting the TARDIS.

Merlin's more concrete Doctor Who connections are buried in its foundations however, with Gardner confessing that the show was directly shaped by Russell T Davies' approach to Doctor Who. She said:

"I learned so much about the 7pm slot from Russell T Davies' Doctor Who scripts and from his approach as an executive producer to that particular slot. Russell's been a huge supporter of Merlin. He immediately saw its potential and proved invaluable in early discussions about how to shape the series for Saturday night."

Merlin follows Morgan as the young whippersnapper version of the iconic sorcerer, who has to keep his magical abilities hidden otherwise he'd face execution. Merlin initially dislikes the unlikable and arrogant Arthur Pendragon but they eventually form a trusting friendship. So it's a bit like the Second Doctor being punished for breaking the Time Lords' most important law of non-interference, and the grumpy First Doctor mellowing towards his companions!

Merlin Reveals Magic
BBC

Though it never quite scaled the heights of Doctor Who, for a time Merlin certainly did prove wildly popular, consistently averaging over six million viewers across five series between 2008 - 2012, making it one of the more successful attempts at replicating the Doctor Who model.


2. Crime Traveller

Crime Traveller
BBC Studios

Desperate times call for desperate measures. BBC One announced Crime Traveller as "something new and something very different for Saturday nights". You can also add something borrowed to that list.

Airing in 1997, Anthony Horowitz's Crime Traveller revolved around maverick police detective Jeff Slade, who travels in time solving crimes. He does this with the help of forensic scientist Holly Turner, who just so happens to have a time machine her late father built handily knocking about.

Unsurprisingly, this results in Slade's crime-solving statistics skyrocketing. Oh Yaz, think of the career you could've had in the police using the TARDIS! Sadly for Slade though, his time-travelling fight for justice only lasted one series. And more disappointingly, it robbed us of Michael French's heartthrob heyday.

Still, with Doctor Who off the air in the 1990s you can see how it made sense for the BBC to try and bring back time travel to Saturday nights. If you didn't know any better, you'd actually think you were watching Doctor Who from the opening titles, with a clock face exploding then revealing the actors' names in the vastness of space. And there’s even a TARDIS easter egg clearly visible in the sixth episode, for good measure.

Crime Traveller TARDIS
BBC Studios

Though a bit of a flop overall, Crime Traveller remains a cult favourite, and feels like something of a trailblazer for more successful detective time travel shows like Life on Mars and Ashes to Ashes that arrived a decade later.


1. Primeval

Primeval
ITV

With Doctor Who in the midst of its triumphant return to our screens, the folks over at ITV (yep, them again) glanced longingly over at their BBC counterparts and thought: we want a slice of that successful sci-fi show pie.

Their answer was Primeval, the action-packed series about anomalies in time, and the terrifying creatures that emerge from them. Funnily enough, it actually started life over at the BBC before execs deemed it too similar to Doctor Who, forcing creators Tim Haines and Adrian Hodges to jump ship to ITV.

And the reason it was deemed too similar to Doctor Who is because, well, that was sort of the point. As Haines recalled when reflecting on Primeval in 2021:

"When we started, there was no Doctor Who, and we thought it was time for something like Doctor Who. But then Russell T Davies started Doctor Who, and we were deemed to be too [similar], so after what must have been about four or five years, the BBC finally turned it down. ITV had seen the success of Doctor Who and thought, well, maybe [we have] to try this out."

In his Doctor Who tell-all book The Writer's Tale, RTD – despite liking Primeval – couldn't help having a mischievous dig at the show's overnight viewing figures of 2.7 million, compared with 8.4 million for Planet of the Dead!

Nevertheless, Primeval's prehistoric creatures actually fought their way to pretty decent viewing figures, considering they were constantly being compared, unfairly, to peak NuWho. It aired during that same Saturday teatime slot and was smartly scheduled during Doctor Who's off-season, targeting families who wanted that fantasy sci-fi fix.

And though there was a sharp dip in quality (and viewers) past the halfway point, Primeval provided a tremendous amount of fun over five series. Respected dramatic actor Douglas Henshall excelled as Nick Cutter, lending a sense of credibility to the project not unlike what Christopher Eccleston had brought to Doctor Who.

Nick Cutter Primeval Douglas Henshall
ITV

Due to financial reasons ITV canned the show after three series, with series four and five later being scraped together thanks to a co-production deal.

But by then it had started to feel like the steam had ran out – for all its time travel, prehistoric creatures and monster-of-the-week action, Primeval never truly felt like it had enough to be a serious long-term Doctor Who competitor.


Contributor

The name's Colbourn, James - yeah, doesn't quite have the same ring to it.