10 Mind-Blowing Facts You Didn't Know About Smallville

Was Adam Knight ACTUALLY meant to be Bruce Wayne?

Smallville Supernatural Crossover
The CW

It's a little crazy to think that it's been over ten whole years since Smallville aired its fist-pumping final episode. Running for ten seasons from 2001 to 2011, this series about a young Superman went on to become a major favourite of so many genre fans during its run.

While Smallville has been a little in the headlines in more recent years thanks to Tom Welling and Erica Durance's Clark Kent and Lois Lane turning up in the Arrowverse's Crisis on Infinite Earths crossover, or even in the shocking real-life revelations about Chloe Sullivan actress Allison Mack, there's still so much about the series that many fans have no idea about.

Every heard the one about the Supernatural and Smallville crossover? Or the planned Smallville spin-off shows? Or the fact that Batman was intended to have a major part to play in Smallvile? Or even who else was close to landing the role of Clark Kent that ultimately went to Tom Welling?

Here then, dear reader, are all of the juicy nuggets and tidbits that you could ever possibly need to know about the dearly-missed Smallville.

10. It Was Originally Intended To Be A Batman Show

Batman Begins Christian Bale Bruce Wayne
Warner Bros.

Before Smallville became the Smalllville that audiences knew and loved for ten seasons, the original plan for the series was for it to actually be an exploration of the younger days of Bruce Wayne and his ascension towards becoming Batman.

Of course, that series would not have been called Smallville, for Smallville is a Superman-driven title. Regardless, loose plans were in place for a show shining a light on Bruce's journey to the cape and cowl. Those plans, however, were shelved after Warner Bros. decided to move forward with a new Batman film.

At this point in time, Warner Bros. and DC Comics put in place restrictions that become known as the Bat-embargo. Basically, with plans afoot for a silver screen return for the World's Greatest Detective, the powers-that-be didn't want to muddy the waters by having several different versions of the Dark Knight in play across different mediums. So much so, that even animated series The Batman was restricted in the use of certain characters.

With the Caped Crusader off the table, Alfred Gough and Miles Millar would take the concept of a hero's younger days and spin it into what became Smallville. And the rest, as they say, is history.

As for that new Batman movie, that would eventually go on to be Christopher Nolan's Batman Begins. For a look at the formative years of Bruce Wayne and his taking on of the Batman moniker, that idea would be revisited over a decade down the line with Gotham.


9. The Adam Knight Mystery

Adam Knight Smallville Ian Somerhalder
The CW

Despite the young Bruce Wayne series being scrapped in favour of Smallville, that didn't stop rumblings and speculation that Smallville's producers at one time had plans to make Bruce a part of the show.

In fact, when Ian Somerhalder was cast in Smallville, he was under the impression that he would be playing Bruce Wayne. An orphan who had travelled the globe and was an expert in many martial arts, Somerhalder instead played a character called Adam Knight - a character who was ultimately a Lionel Luthor-resurrected sort with a dependency on a Lazarus serum.

Smallville producers have often played down that Adam Knight was intended to be Bruce Wayne, but Somerhalder himself has publicly stated numerous times how the arc for his character was changed at the last minute. In fact, the actor has even claimed how he'd actually shot three episodes of Smallville thinking he was a different character, before it became clear that Adam Knight was different to what had initially been promised to Somerhalder.

Was Ian Somerhalder promised that he would be playing the Dark Knight in waiting? Was it merely implied that Adam Knight might actually be Master Bruce? Was Adam Knight's story always planned to play out how it did?

Only a select few people know the complete truth on this matter, but the end result was a largely disappointing one for audiences as Knight went from mysterious, intriguing character, to just another run-of-the-mill villain.


8. The Green Arrow Spin-Off That Never Was

Justin Hartley Green Arrow Smallville
The CW

Way before The CW launched Arrow in 2012, plans were afoot for Justin Hartley's Green Arrow to get his own Smallville spin-off show.

Hartley was a part of Smallville for a whopping 72 episodes across five seasons, but the plans for an Emerald Archer spin-off began after just two appearances from the Green Arrow. That was back towards the end of 2006, with producers opening dialogue with Hartley over spearheading his own series which may or may not end up becoming a full-on Justice League show.

The reason for this show not moving forward past the idea stage, was down to Justin Hartley. The actor politely shot the idea down, with him believing that any such Green Arrow series could take away from what Smallville had achieved in its previous five seasons. Basically, Hartley didn't want to steal any of Smallville's spotlight.

Instead, Hartley's Master Bowman would remain a semi-permanent part of Smallville up until the show came to a close in 2011. And with a Green Arrow itch still to scratch, it came as no surprise that The CW moved forward with an Oliver Queen show barely a year after Smallville's final episode aired.

Additionally, Hartley actually headlined an Aquaman pilot before landing the Green Arrow gig in Smallville. That Aquaman offering, which is widely available to watch online, didn't get picked up for a full series order largely due to bad timing - with the potential show falling victim to the merger of The WB and UPN that saw The CW created.


7. Brandon Routh Was Up For Clark Kent

Crisis On Infinite Earths Brandon Routh Superman
The CW

Brandon Routh went on to play the Man of Steel in Bryan Singer's Superman Returns and more recently in the Arrowverse's monumental Crisis on Infinite Earths crossover event, yet Routh was actually up for the Superman role a couple of years before Singer's 2006 movie.

As revealed by Routh at 2019's Motor City Comic Con, he auditioned for Smallville's Clark Kent role that would ultimately go to Tom Welling.

Direct from Routh, "So when Smallville came around, I had an audition for that. This was 2000, 2001. I had that audition, and then I had a callback and I was like, ‘oh, this is gonna happen, right?’ Very naive. Then it didn’t go any further and I was pretty crushed.”

Skip ahead a couple of years, and the actor would land the Boy Scout gig for Superman Returns. While that film was a mixed bag, Routh's performance at the centre of proceedings was largely well received. As such, fans geeked out upon hearing the news that Brandon - who by that point was playing Ray Palmer in the Arrowverse - was to suit up once more as Superman for Crisis on Infinite Earths.


6. Jensen Ackles Was The Second Choice For Clark

Jensen Ackles Smallville Jason Teague
The CW

Jensen Ackles is these days synonymous with Supernatural, yet the star's pre-Supernatural days saw him have a memorable one-season stint in Smallville as Jason Teague during the show's fourth year.

While it's not exactly a major revelation to say that Jensen Ackles was in Smallville, what's less known is the fact that he - much like Brandon Routh - was at one point in the mix to play Clark Kent. But not just that, for Ackles was reportedly the second choice to play CK.

By all accounts, Tom Welling was a little unsure of even auditioning for the Clark role, let alone committing to playing the character. And if Welling had opted to pass on playing this iteration of Kal-El, the minds behind Smallville had Jensen Ackles lined up as their second choice to play Clark.

Interestingly, Eric Johnson was another name who was under consideration to play Clark Kent. Not just that, but Johnson had also auditioned for the role of Lex Luthor. While he wasn't successful in landing either of those major parts, Johnson would end up playing Lana Lang's boyfriend Whitney Fordman in Smallville's debut season.


5. The Comic Book Continuation

Smallville Season 11
DC Comics

Total die-hard Smallville fans will likely be aware that the series continued on in comic book form when Season Ten of the show came to a close in 2011, but the more casual Smallville fans amongst you may be a little surprised to hear that the adventures of this incarnation of the Big Blue Boy Scout carried on away from the TV screen.

There had already been Smallville comics and novels during the show's ten-season run, but April 13, 2012 saw a straight-up follow-on comic released. Dubbed Smallville Season 11, Smallville story editor Bryan Q. Miller penned a tale that picked things up six months after the events of Smallville's final episode.

That comic would go on to run for a couple of years, and it gave fans the chance to see Clark Kent fully in his Superman guise as the hero we'd spent a decade watching Clark become. And not just was this Tom Welling-inspired Superman joined by familiar faces from Smallville, but Season 11 also brought the likes of Batman, Wonder Woman, Green Lantern, and so many other DC heroes and villains into the world of Smallville.


4. Record Ratings

Smallville Season 1
The CW

While the ratings for Smallville admittedly weren't the greatest by the time the series came to a close after ten seasons, what most people don't realise is that the series initially set record ratings for The WB upon its debut.

For the October 16, 2001 premiere of the show, Smallville pulled in an incredible 8.4 million viewers. That premiere was record numbers for The WB in the famed 18-34 demographic and the also sought-after 12-34 bracket.

To go further, many Warner Bros. higher-ups have credited Smallville with bringing fresh life to the network's Tuesday nights and for making The WB a must-see location for viewers. Even better for the show, Smallville's second season spun even greater figures - with the Season Two premiere pulling in 8.7 million viewers, and with show highs for the season finale (7.5 million) and the average season viewing figures (6.3 million).

In contrast, the final season of Smallville would premiere with just shy of 3 million viewers, with a similar figure for the show's final episode, and a final season average viewership of 3.2 million viewers for each episode. But despite those low numbers, it's easy to forget just how hot Smallville's beginnings were when it came to cold, hard figures.


3. The Reason Why Margot Kidder Quit

Smallville Margot Kidder Bridgette Crosby
The CW

For longtime fans of the Superman mythos, Smallville often put a major smile on the face by how it brought in certain names previously associated with the larger world of Superman.

Two such examples are Christopher Reeve and Margot Kidder, who portrayed Dr. Virgil Swann and his assistant Bridgette Crosby. Of course, the pair had previously played Superman and Lois Lane in the four-movie Man of Steel franchise that ran from 1978 to 1987.

At one point in time, the plan was for Kidder's Crosby to step up and become one of the main villains of Smallville's Season Four. Instead though, the actress quit after just two on-screen appearances.

The reason for Kidder's decision to walk away from Smallvile came after the tragic death of Christopher Reeve at the age of just 52. Following Reeve's passing, Smallville producers decided to kill off the Dr. Swann character. For Kidder, she thought that this was tasteless and only serving to try and benefit from the loss of Christopher Reeve - and thus, Margot quit the show in disgust at this decision.

As a result of this, the Bridgette Crosby character was quietly killed off off-screen.


2. There Were Plans For A Supernatural Crossover

Supernatural Season 1
The CW

In more recent times, Supernatural famously had a crossover episode featuring Scooby-Doo, but back in 2005 there were initial plans to have Smallville cross paths with Supernatural.

Said crossover was to actually take a meta approach, and have the Sam and Dean Winchester characters sharing the screen with Tom Welling. As in, Welling would be playing himself, rather than necessarily playing Clark Kent.

This crossover would look to explore the famed Superman curse that has become synonymous with the Man of Steel over the decades. Many conspiracy theorists claim that any and all Superman movie or TV projects have a mysterious curse attached to them - as highlighted by the tragic demise of George Reeves, the paralysis and death of Christopher Reeve, or even the death of Lee Quigley at the age of just 14.

Reeves played Superman in the 1950s, Reeve took on the Last Son of Krypton role in four movies, and Quigley played the infant Kal-El in the 1978 picture in which Reeve headlined as Superman.

This Supernatural-meets-Smallville offering would have seen the Winchesters on a mission to save Tom Welling from the mythical Superman curse that has affected so many others who have been involved with the Big Blue Boy Scout.


1. The Show Was Nearly Cancelled To Make Way For A Movie

Tom Welling Superman Alex Ross
Alex Ross

For years, Smallville fans clamoured for Tom Welling to land the Man of Steel gig in Warner Bros. long-gestating new Superman movie in the early-2000s. What those fans maybe didn't realise at the time, is that Welling signing on for that picture would've meant the end of Smallville.

As Welling himself has discussed over the years, he had some serious talks in 2004 about headlining a Superman film that was to be directed by Rush Hour helmer Brett Ratner. Tom flew out to Ratner's LA home, where the pair discussed the reality of Welling signing on to play the big-screen Big Blue Boy Scout.

Things even got to a point where legendary artist Alex Ross was tasked with drawing a couple of mock-ups of Tom Welling in the full Superman garb.

During those talks, the pair both realised that Tom Welling signing on for this Superman picture would've meant that there would be no way Welling could still keep up with the hectic Smallville schedule - meaning the TV show would've had to have been scrapped in order to push forward with the Welling-fronted movie.

From there, Welling opted against any silver screen outing as Supes - instead focusing on Smallville and continuing that show on for a further seven years.

Where that proposed Superman movie is concerned, Ratner would eventually depart the project, the film would become Bryan Singer's Superman Returns, and Ratner would find himself taking over from Singer on X-Men: The Last Stand.


Watch Next


The Ultimate Smallville Quiz!

Warner Bros

1. What Was The Name Of The Season 5 Christmas Episode?

Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.