10 Moments That Almost Killed Star Trek

Star Trek is invincible, regularly sidestepping death knells at warp speed!

Star Trek Nemesis
Paramount

Star Trek is one of the world's most beloved franchises, not only that, it's one of the longest running and most diverse (both in terms of cultural representation and the sheer volume of entries in the franchise). The series is going through a hell of a renaissance right now with the launch of Picard, Discovery, Short Treks and the upcoming Lower Decks. Star Trek has gathered juggernaut momentum and is flying into the 2020s at maximum warp.

But it hasn't always maintained a course towards success. In its almost 55 year run Star Trek has had its ups and downs. In moments it's found prime-time success with mainstream audiences, at other times it's been a byword for social outcast nerdery (it defiantly still is, but being a nerd is a good thing now).

It's hardly surprising that across six decades, nine different TV series (including the anticipated Lower Decks), thirteen movies and a web series; not to mention a vast expanded universe and fan-fiction entries, Star Trek has had its wobbles. Star Trek has successfully navigated more than a few franchise killers in its long run. And thank god, right!

At each of these ten moments, Star Trek could have disappeared forever…

10. The First Pilot

Star Trek The Original Series The Cage
NBC

In 1965, Gene Roddenberry completed The Cage, the pilot episode for Star Trek. Problem was the network wasn’t interested and rejected it. A fairly standard occurrence. Like many pilots before, it didn’t find its place and Star Trek wasn’t to be. Unbelievably, in a practically unheard of move, NBC who funded the pilot, decided to pay for another one.

The story and the cast were overhauled. It was in this second pilot that we were introduced to Kirk, Bones and most of the rest of the crew we know and love. The only remaining central cast member from the original pilot was Spock; Gene Roddenberry was so enamoured with him that he fought the studio to retain the character. Of course, Roddenberry was right; Spock quickly became a cultural icon.

The network loved the new crew and the new pilot and Star Trek was a go, ready to manoeuvre around certain demise time and time again in the years to come.

Most of the original pilot was retconned into the first episode of Star Trek but fans didn’t see the original episode in its entirety until 1988. It took a long time but characters and events from that ill-fated pilot finally made their way onto the centre stage of Star Trek, with the kelvin timeline movies and Discovery expanding on them to great effect.


9. Near Cancellation After Season 2

Kirk Rock Star Trek
NBC

Throughout its first season, Star Trek's ratings were never enough to fill the studio execs with beaming confidence. Then in season two, the ratings slipped even more. Rumours of cancellation were inevitable and most of the cast were so convinced that they weren't getting a third season they started looking for other work.

Thankfully, though not enough in number to bolster those ratings, the fans were vocal enough to swing the series' fortunes. On hearing the rumours that the show was in line for cancellation, fans, supported by the press, launched a massive letter-writing campaign and inundated the studio with pleas to renew the series.

The studio received so many letters that they basically had to ask fans to stop by placing an announcement in the closing credits of one of the final season two episodes which stated that Star Trek would be returning

Star Trek fans have been a determined bunch since the start.


8. Cancelled, But For Real This Time

The Apple (Star Trek, 1967)
CBS Studios, Inc.

After just one more season, of dubious quality, the show was cancelled. Star Trek was over. But it’s short, three-season run had been enough. Star Trek hadn’t made megabucks, but it had a lasting impact in the minds and hearts of its fans. More importantly, enough episodes had been made to allow the studio to sell Star Trek into syndication to local TV stations.

It was in syndicated re-runs where it found more and more fans, as families tuned in to see the ongoing mission of Captain Kirk and crew. Over the next decade those fans developed an unprecedented dedication to the show. Organising themselves into a community of ‘Trekkies’; fans founded conventions and fan clubs across the world. This was the beginning of what we now call fandom and we have Star Trek to thank for that.

Due to syndication and the fans, Star Trek never fully left the limelight, remaining in the popular consciousness while Gene Rodenberry plotted new voyages. It would be ten years before Star Trek did offer anything new, but in that time its fan base grew and grew, and though the franchise was essentially dormant, its influence was rocketing.


7. A Decade In Development Gre'thor

Star Trek Phase Ii Enterprise
Paramount

Thankfully, for all of us, Gene Rodenberry really bloody loved Star Trek and just couldn’t let it lie. By the early ‘70s, with some backing from Paramount, he was working on a Star Trek movie. Though the studio’s confidence was bolstered by the show’s success in syndication, they still weren’t going to bet the farm on Star Trek. The support they were willing to provide was on the low budget TV movie end of the spectrum.

A couple of scripts were developed, one concerning a god-like race of artificial beings and the other revolving around a god-like creature trapped on a planet. They may sound familiar; ideas from both ultimately made their way into the Star Trek movies, but this time around Paramount rejected them.

The studio then decided that it didn't want a movie and asked for a new TV show instead. Once a new ship had been designed and scripts written, as well as roles cast and sets built for the new show, Star Trek Phase II, Paramount changed their minds back and decided they wanted a movie again.


6. Movie Misfire

Star Trek The Motion Picture Cast Photo
CBS

In 1977 Paramount execs saw Star Wars and asked, 'what have we got that's like that?' (thanks Star Wars). Star Trek: The Motion Picture was greenlit, and this one was no low budget TV movie. Star Wars changed everything. Suddenly sci-fi projects commanded big budgets and big releases.

Unfortunately, The Motion Picture was so plodding that it felt like it was happening in real-time. Some of it actually did, like the solid five minute sequence of Kirk and Scotty taking the slowest shuttle in the Alpha Quadrant from the space dock to the Enterprise.

Fans have a real soft spot for The Motion Picture these days, but for years it was among the least loved entries to the Star Trek cannon. Mockingly dubbed The Motionless Picture, the slow pace, lengthy run time and beige colour palate left audiences anaesthetised and once again the future of Star Trek was uncertain. Paramount had to think carefully about what to do next.


5. The Death Of A Legend

Kirk Spock
Paramount

After The Motion Picture, the studio cut the budget and sought a new creative team. That team made the best Star Trek movie ever. At the end of the movie, they killed the best Star Trek character ever.

Fans were so mad that they started sending death threats to Leonard Nimoy. Impeccable logic right, you so passionately want the charter to live that you threaten to kill the person who plays him. Zachary Quinto was only five at the time, so, he couldn’t have replaced him. Nor Ethan Peck, who was yet to be born.

Eventually, the death of Spock got so much negative press that the name of the next film, which has Spock in the title, was put on the end credits of Star Trek II.

Star Trek fans always seem to get what they want. Are we that scary?


4. "Mean Gene"

Gene Roddenberry 1976
Wikipedia/LarryDMoore

Star Trek was really precious to Gene Roddenberry and this sometimes led him to be aggressively protective of it and what it should represent. When he didn’t like something, he let everyone know it; he openly slated any element of the property that he didn’t approve of.

He hated Star Trek VI and forced significant rewrites; he hated the piolet for TNG and rewrote the whole thing himself. He argued viciously with the cast and crew, going so far as to hire a private lawyer to spy on and intimidate them.

Roddenberry wanted his own way and when he didn’t get it, he kicked off. He created Star Trek and understandably thought it was his. As Star Trek grew, naturally, more and more people were involved, more and more people were making the decisions. At the same time, due partly to misfires like The Motion Picture, Roddenberry was edged slowly out of the captain’s chair. Despite this, he always managed to maintain significant influence over the franchise.

Even though new directions were often the right way to go, it was never a good idea to go against Roddenberry because he’d let you know. Then, he’d let everyone else know and when the beloved creator takes issue, there's a real problem.


3. The Unwanted Next Generation

Star Trek The Next Generation Season 1
CBS

It's hard to image now, but when TNG was announced people were pissed off. The fans were fiercely loyal to Kirk, Spock, Bones and crew and didn’t want to see anyone attempt to fill their shoes.

Once again, the fans had to take things into their own hands, they rushed to their writing desks and poured their grave concerns onto paper. The post office worked round the clock to make sure the studio got the letters.

The almighty voice of the fans had spoken. Kirk's shoes could not be filled. The studio listened, but only to the ones who wrote in to say, 'Cheers is brilliant, please makes six more seasons'. The ones who wrote in objection to Star Trek TNG were wrong, so, they were ignored. And the golden age of Trek dawned.

What followed in the wake of TNG cemented Star Trek as a pop-cultural powerhouse. Suddenly there was a vast shared universe of concurrent running shows and movies. The twenty-fourth century had never seemed more tangible as it did during the fifteen years that followed the pilot of TNG.

In the nineties, everyone was watching Star Trek.


2. Fatigue and The End

Star Trek Nemesis Picard Shinzon
Paramount

In the first half of the ‘00s, audiences had begun to tire of a market that had been saturated by Trek. In 2002 Nemesis, the last of the TNG era movies, got a thrashing from critics (it really wasn't that bad) and only just edged into profit at the box office.

In 2005 Enterprise aired its final episode, which also got a thrashing from critics and fans (it was really bad). Like TNG, DS9 and VOY, Enterprise kicked off with a couple of shaky seasons but by this point, the fans were less forgiving, and people just weren't watching anymore.

So, in 2005 it was over and Star Trek was off the air. For the first time in its history, there were no plans to bring it back.

The party was over and thus began the dark times.


1. Discovery

Trek Discovery
CBS

It seems the writers of Discovery set themselves up for a hard job right from the start. With a franchise of such breadth and complexity and fans so forensic in their attention to detail, it was always going to be impossible to protect and respect continuity in the time period Discovery is set. Retcons galore. Controversy ensued.

The first season was beleaguered by problems from the start. There were constant production delays caused by problems with casting and re-writes. Then the co-creator and showrunner, Bryan Fuller, a man of fine Star Trek pedigree, having worked on Deep Space 9 and Voyager, was mysteriously fired before filming was completed. The next hurdle came after it was released; the fans hated it. True to form, they were extremely vocal about their distaste; this time on the internet rather than via letter. Their grievances were numerous but the most resounding issue was that the show just did not feel like Star Trek. It was dark, gritty and many of the characters were outright nasty. Not at all Starfleet.

The internet certainly amplified the hatred. Rumours were rife that the show wouldn't make it past the first series. Really though, this should have all been expected. It's a strong tradition, perhaps a franchise curse, that most Star Trek shows get off to a rocky start. It's true of TNG, DS9, Voyager and Enterprise.

History repeats itself and just like in decades past, the studio listened to the vocal and passionate fans. Series two of Discovery acted as a soft reboot which addressed many of the fan's concerns. The tone of the show changed notably and writers went to some effort to offer an in-universe explanation for the previous darker tone.

In series two, Discovery became Star Trek. That's not bad going, it took all the others two seasons.


Watch Next


Contributor

Bowen Revill hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.