10 Most Disappointing TV Shows Of 2017

The shows that didn't live up to the hype.

The Defenders
Netflix

With big budgets, large action sequences, A-list talent, and dazzling cinematography, TV shows are increasingly comparable to movies. Perhaps nowhere is this more evident, though, than with the levels of hype attached to series long before they actually hit the air.

It's standard practice now for films to be marketed over a year away from release, and we're used to getting excited for things well in advance. TV shows have typically operated differently in that regard, with the calendar being more seasonal, but things have started to change in recent years - and 2017 was a great example of that.

We're now looking ahead to the whole year of TV, rather than just the fall season, with some over a year in the waiting. Stranger Things, for example, become a phenomenon last year, and fans spent 15 months waiting, wondering, and getting very excited. Twin Peaks goes even further, with a 25-year gap between seasons, and both somehow managed to deliver on the huge levels of hype.

Others, however, didn't fare so well. Where there's excitement, there's also a chance of being let-down, and a number of the year's most anticipated releases and hyped-up shows sadly ended up disappointing.


10. Game Of Thrones

Game of Thrones Jon Snow
HBO

To clarify: disappointing does not necessarily mean bad. Sometimes disappointing things can just be average, and on occasion, they can be really f**king good - it's all relative to expectations.

At this point in its life, Thrones is the single biggest show on TV, with any claimants to its, er, throne either falling by the wayside (The Walking Dead) or still too young to tell for sure (Stranger Things). More than that, though, is that Thrones is typically one of, if not the, best shows on television. And with Season 7 being slightly delayed and also its penultimate, there was a lot to be expected - and it didn't fully deliver.

Yes, there were great moments. The spectacle was as grand as ever, with the dragons and White Walkers unleashed to great effect, and some lovely character moments too (the first meeting of the Eastwatch Seven, Arya and Brienne, Gendry's return and so on). And that makes it all the more frustrating that this season was only seven episodes, and as a result almost everything felt rushed.

Storylines that would've taken whole seasons zipped by in a couple of episodes, certain motivations and conflicts didn't quite fit with the characters experiencing them, and the show took Wun-Wun sized leaps of logic in order to cram everything in and establish the endgame. It was still very good, but rushed storytelling and big logical gaps shouldn't be a feature of Thrones, and it's ultimately a disappointing year for the show because of that.


9. 24: Legacy

24 Legacy
Fox

Disappointing does not necessarily mean bad - but a lot of the time it actually does; case in point, 24: Legacy.

After the reasonably well-received mini-series Live Another Day, Jack Bauer entered a hard-earned (and probably overdue) retirement, and the 24 franchise lay dormant as Fox figured out what to do with it. A movie? Another revival starring Kiefer Sutherland?

Instead they opted to go with spin-off Legacy, which offered a chance to truly reinvent the series and bring something fresh, and it made a good start by casting Straight Outta Compton's Corey Hawkins in the lead role. With the current political climate in the U.S. especially, there was a chance for a relevant series with a strong message, but even failing that it could've been an exciting thriller in its own right.

Unfortunately Legacy didn't deliver on its potential at either end. The show falls into the same narrative traps as its predecessor, except that hit in the post-9/11 wave and felt timely, whereas here it feels tired and rote, relying on old stereotypes and 00s action cliches. Corey Hawkins does his best, but isn't given good enough material to work with - and can't elevate it in the way Sutherland did either - and the show was unsurprisingly cancelled after just one season.


8. Powerless

Powerless Vanessa Hudgens
NBC

While DC have had their struggles on the big screen, things had been going much more swimmingly on TV. The CW has its ever-burgeoning Arrowverse, Fox has Gotham, and NBC decided to get in on the action too.

Their idea was to mix things up, bringing a workplace sitcom set in the world of superheroes, with one of the employees being a relative of Bruce Wayne. A talented cast, including Alan Tudyk, Vanessa Hudgens, and Danny Pudi, was assembled, the premise was intriguing, and then it started to fall apart.

While it did show some promise - largely thanks to the cast - the writing was extremely uneven and it simply wasn't funny enough to survive. The premise, while interesting, became overly generic, and NBC pulled the plug before the season had even finished airing.


7. Inhumans

Marvel's Inhumans
ABC/Marvel

Another big new network superhero show, this time from the side of the comics divide, Inhumans was a property a long time coming to the screen. The Inhumans was initially planned as a movie release to be part of Marvel's Phase 4, then pushed back a year, then they were introduced on Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D., then the movie was removed from the schedule but not fully cancelled, and then it was announced as a TV show instead.

It was not worth the wait.

It's easy to see why Marvel wanted to get the Inhumans on screen, in lieu of having the rights to the X-Men, but the saga of the Royal Family just became an eight-episode soap opera. It never fully utilised its unique characters or settings, with the former thin and the latter dull, and not even a giant CGI dog could save it.


6. 13 Reasons Why

13 Reasons Why Hannah Baker Poster
Netflix

Unlike a lot of shows here, 13 Reasons Why wasn't being massively hyped months before its release on Netflix, but it did start garnering it in the week or so before it dropped. That only intensified post-release, when it became the most tweeted about series of the year.

There was (and is) a lot of conversation to be had around the series, which sees a teenage girl commit suicide and leave tapes for her classmates outlining the part each played in her life, but it's not necessarily a positive one.

The series has a solid cast, some interesting direction, and it does get people talking about important issues, but it doesn't do enough with those. Its handling of suicide is mixed at best, with ideas of victim blaming and revenge fantasies, with little focus on mental health or Hannah Baker herself.

Outside of those topic-driven issues, though, the show has a few flaws in both setup and execution: the idea of Clay not listening to the tapes exists only as a plot device, and feels overly contrived, and this in turn makes the show feel too long and repetitive.


5. Sherlock

sherlock final problem
BBC

Sherlock started declining in Season 3, and continued that slide with the Christmas Special The Abominable Bride, which was great until it stopped pretending to be Victorian and became a total mess.

Those warning signs should've been clear ahead of Season 4, but the trailer for the latest run of episodes promised something different. The show was going darker, looked refocused and re-energised, and the indicators were good. Plus, these episodes come around so infrequently it's difficult not to get excited.

But then they aired, and it was a reminder of where the show left off, rather than what had been in Seasons 1 & 2. The Six Thatchers was a middling return, turning from a Holmes & Watson detective show into a James Bond-esque espionage drama centred around Mary.

The Lying Detective fared better, with some actual detecting and a truly creepy turn from Toby Jones, but that goodwill was lost in the finale, The Final Problem, which piled dumb plot twist upon silly narrative turn to the point nothing made any sense.


4. Gypsy

Gypsy Naomi Watts
Netflix

2017 was a big year for the great Naomi Watts on TV, with the actress having a main role on Twin Peaks: The Return and leading her own Netflix series, Gypsy.

While she was one of the real gems of Twin Peaks, the first Watts-led TV show since 1997's Sleepwalkers did not fare so well, despite its star lead and interesting plotline, with the show billed as a psychological thriller about a psychotherapist who infiltrates the lives of her patients.

What could (and should) have been a thrilling exploration of power and desire instead falls totally flat. There are no thrills to be found here, with cliched dialogue, empty, uninteresting characters, and a plot completely boring narrative.


3. Taboo

Tom Hardy Taboo
FX

Tom Hardy starring in his own TV show, created by the actor and his Locke director Steven Knight? That alone was enough of a hook for Taboo, and the premise - Hardy's James Delaney returns home to England after 13-years in Africa, along with 14 stolen diamonds - promised strong material for its lead.

Add in a great supporting cast, including Oona Chaplin, Mark Gatiss, Jonathan Pryce, and Stephen Graham, and things looked good for Taboo. And then it aired.

The show wasn't the great star vehicle it had once seemed, with Hardy and co mumbling through some wince-inducing dialogue and a glacially slow plot, which dredges across its East India Company story mired in darkness with little to drive it forwards. Hardy brings his usual intensity, but it's not enough to elevate things.


2. Star Trek: Discovery

Star Trek Discovery Sonequa Martin-Green
CBS

The first new Star Trek series in over a decade, Discovery had a bumpy road to the small screen. There were a number of delays, and the unfortunate departure of creator Bryan Fuller, but there was still a lot of excitement before it aired on CBS (later moving to All Access).

The show does boast some strong visuals, and there were some hints of potential with its characters and plot in the first episode, but sadly they were never fully built upon.

Discovery attempts to do something different with the Trek mythos, not just in having a protagonist who isn't a captain, but one who commits treason, and is decidedly darker than we're used to from the franchise.

It's just not that it 'isn't Star Trek' though, because judged on its own terms there's little excitement to the plot, some cliche stock characters (most egregiously the odd couple pairing of Michael and Tilly), an unlikable lead, and some horribly clunky dialogue.


1. The Defenders

Defenders Netflix EW
Netflix/EW

The Defenders isn't the worst Marvel show of the year, nor is it even the worst Netflix Marvel show (people really need to stop hiring Scott Buck to run their series), but it is the most disappointing.

Announced back in 2013 when Marvel revealed their deal with Netflix, this was four years, four series, and five seasons in the making, in-effect serving as Marvel's small screen, street-level version of The Avengers.

The Defenders did have some good elements, like whenever it actually allowed its four heroes to be together, but such moments were too few and far between. Jessica Jones and Daredevil also came out of it well, but the show took far too long in bringing everyone together.

That slow pacing would continue throughout its eight-episode run, meaning even a shorter season suffered from many of the same storytelling issues as its predecessors. It was another series bogged down by the Hand, there was a surprising lack of action, poor direction, and it never did enough to justify its existence beyond being corporately mandated four years ago.

What TV shows disappointed you this year? Let us know down in the comments.


Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.