10 Most Inappropriate Doctor Who Moments

The moments from Doctor Who we can't forget. All for the wrong reasons...

Doctor Who The Doctor Amy Pond Flesh And Stone
BBC Studios

Doctor Who is a show with so many unforgettable moments spread across its near 60 year history.

From the very first regeneration transforming William Hartnell into Patrick Troughton, to the meeting of David Tennant and Matt Smith in the Day of the Doctor and beyond, every Whovian can recall plenty of scenes that they love and perhaps a couple that they hate as well.

But alongside all these great moments, there have been plenty of episodes that have caused controversy. Something as small as a dirty joke or a character doing something very off-putting, can clash with the tone and deeper themes of the show and greatly affect how we see an episode or character. While some of the examples on this list are only minor, they left a big impact on the fanbase - and not in a good way. In fact, some of these were so inappropriate they'll live on forever in Who infamy...

10. Complaints About The 'Gay Agenda' - Deep Breath

Doctor Who Vastra Jenny
BBC

So the moment in question here isn’t inappropriate, but the response from several viewers was.

Ever since the show was revived in 2005, Doctor Who has featured multiple LGBTQ characters, most notably companions Captain Jack Harkness and Bill Potts. Yet despite this being the case, some people couldn’t stand watching a lesbian couple kiss on television.

In Peter Capaldi’s debut episode as the Twelfth Doctor, Deep Breath, Madame Vastra and Jenny Flint, a married couple who had already made several appearances on the show prior, share a kiss (or technically an exchange of oxygen). It was a seemingly harmless moment in a rather forgettable episode.

Yet some out-of-touch viewers found it to be deeply offensive and Ofcom received six complaints that the BBC were promoting a: “Blatant gay agenda.”

Whatever that means.

While the show does occasionally knock you over the head when it’s trying to make a point, this moment certainly wasn’t one of them. Television should be inclusive and those that criticised this moment and others like it, were deeply in the wrong.


9. The Master Flirts With Missy (AKA Himself - The Doctor Falls

Doctor Who Master Missy death
BBC Studios

There a couple of moments in Who that at first are just a bit weird to watch. But later when you think back on them, they're also a bit inappropriate.

This very small moment from the Series 10 finale, The Doctor Falls, is a perfect example of this. When John Simm’s Master and Michelle Gomez’s Missy are planning their escape, the Master admits he’s a bit turned on by Missy.

Of course, when you remember that Missy is in fact a future incarnation of the Master, it becomes a little creepy.

Admittedly it is probably in character for the Master to love himself and the show does seem self-aware of the inappropriateness of this moment, when Missy shuts down the Master’s advances.

Nevertheless, this was very odd, unnerving scene.


8. Trivialising Hitler - Let's Kill Hitler

Doctor Who Hitler
BBC

Let’s Kill Hitler is one of the more unpopular episodes of NuWho. Whether it be because of the convoluted story, unlikeable versions of Melody Pond/River Song or the rushed conclusion to what ought to have been the pivotal moment of Series 6.

But there was also the small matter of one Adolf Hitler. The TARDIS crashes into the office of history’s most notorious dictator, which opens up a world of possible stories for the writing team. But instead Steven Moffat opted to treat the whole situation as a joke, with Hitler acting more as a comic relief character, for the brief seconds he’s on the screen, eventually getting locked in the cupboard by Rory Williams.

The scene is intended to be played for laughs but given who Hitler was, what he did and what he stood for, that seems rather inappropriate.

It was a serious misstep and one that really degrades the quality of an otherwise great series.


7. The Doctor And Graham's Failed Heart-to-heart - Can You Hear Me?

Can You Hear Me? Doctor Who
BBC

You’d be forgiven for not remembering this as it is a very short moment, but it left rather a bitter taste in the mouth.

In Series 12’s Can You Hear Me?, Team TARDIS are forced to confront some of their worst fears. Chief amongst these is Graham O’Brien having a nightmare that his cancer has returned. At the end of the episode he goes to the Thirteenth Doctor for support, in what ought to have been a very emotional and poignant scene.

Except that’s not how it goes down.

The Doc simply shrugs her shoulders, claims she’s socially awkward and will try to think of something to say later- and that’s it.

Now being socially awkward is totally in character for Thirteen, and it could be argued that this scene is meant to represent the difficulty that close friends and family can have talking about sensitive subjects. But it’s just not handled at all well here.

It’s almost played for laughs and completely undermines the whole message of the episode, which up to that point had handled the subject of mental health pretty well.

If following episodes had followed up in this, with the Doctor or even someone else chatting with Graham, then all would be forgiven. Alas, it isn’t. And with Bradley Walsh leaving the show at the end of the year, it probably never will be.


6. Amy Seduces The Doctor - Flesh And Stone

Doctor Who The Doctor Amy Pond Flesh And Stone
BBC Studios

Companions falling in love with and kissing the Doctor became the norm during the Tennant/Smith years. The idea of a Doctor/Companion relationship wasn’t entirely a popular one when it was first introduced, but most were handled well enough not to cause any offence.

That was until Amy Pond came along. Having taken her on several death-defying adventures, it wasn’t so surprising to see Amy make her move on the Eleventh Doctor at the end of Series 5’s Flesh And Stone.

What was surprising was that she did it on the eve of her wedding to Rory Williams. While the trio have always had a love-triangle of sorts throughout their tenure on the show, this scene definitely took it a bit too far. More-so because Amy is clearly intending to have a one-night stand with the Doctor, asking him if: “It’s been a while?”

The Doctor put a shutdown on the whole situation before it went too far, but the scene still received several complaints from viewers and even then-showrunner Steven Moffat admitted years later that he regrets the scene:

“It’s a very good idea for a scene, because she’s been through this traumatic experience and she doesn’t quite know who or what the Doctor is, and she doesn’t quite know what his interest is.

“And there’s a brilliant scene to be written there, and I entirely avoided writing it. I played it for laughs, and it was so wrong.”


5. The Body Swapping - New Earth

Doctor Who Rose New Earth
BBC

Truth be told, body swap stories are always a bit weird, but somehow Doctor Who managed to make theirs especially awkward.

In the Series 2 opener, New Earth, the Tenth Doctor and Rose Tyler are reunited with the villainous Lady Cassandra, who enacts her revenge on the pair by possessing Rose’s body.

Nothing too inappropriate initially, but things quickly take a turn to the ridiculous, as we’re subjected to multiple scenes of Cassandra admiring her new features, stroking her bum, flaunting her cleavage and attempting to seduce the Doctor.

Furthermore, she eventually possesses the Doctor and remarks that he has: “So many parts, and hardly used.”

He/she even claims that Rose has been, “looking”, which can only mean one thing. Looking back on it, it’s hard to believe that Russell T. Davies managed to get away with this in a ‘family show’.

While it must be said that Billie Piper and David Tennant are clearly having a lot of fun, it is very, very cringe-worthy and feels completely at odds with the tone of the rest of the episode.


4. The Murderous Sixth Doctor - Vengeance On Varos

Sixth Doctor Costume
BBC

Heading back in time to the classic era, Colin Baker’s portrayal of the Sixth Doctor had few fans at the time and even though his reputation has improved a bit, thanks largely to the Big Finish audio dramas. But there are a couple of moments that even his most ardent defenders cannot justify.

One of them comes in the 1985, two-part story Vengeance On Varos, where the Doctor kills two Varosian guards by dumping them in an acid bath, cracks a smile and quips: “Forgive me if I don’t join you.”

One of the best parts about the character of The Doctor, is that he/she is an action hero who condemns violence and would never, ever kill, let alone take pride in doing it. This moment was completely out of character and very inappropriate for a show that prioritises brains over brawl.

While complaints about violence in Doctor Who had always been voiced, this was the first time that the general public and fans were as appalled as long-time critics.

It remains one of the worst and most disliked moments in the history of Who. Although not quite as bad and hated as…


3. The Sixth Doctor Strangles Peri - The Twin Dilemma

Doctor Who Colin Baker The Twin Dilemma strangle Peri
BBC Studios

Yep, sticking with the Sixth Doctor here. In his very first story, 1984’s The Twin Dilemma, Colin Baker set the tone for his instantly dislikeable incarnation.

After regenerating and donning the absolute worst Doctor outfit of all time, he starts behaving erratically, accusing his companion Peri of being an alien spy before suddenly strangling her. He manages to stop himself before he can kill her, but the damage was already done.

As introductions to a new character go, this has to be among the worst of them. As mentioned before, the Doctor being violent for no reason just isn’t right.

We have since learned that the idea was always to introduce Baker’s Doctor in a harsh light, with the character becoming kinder as his tenure progressed, something that Peter Capaldi would end up doing more successfully with the Twelfth Doctor during the revival era.

But going as far as to try to choke someone close to you to death, this was very, very misguided. It’s this scene alone that made the Sixth Doctor so unlikeable, and the primary reason why The Twin Dilemma is considered one of, if not the worst Doctor Who story of all time.


2. The Blowjob Gag - Love And Monsters

Doctor Who Ursula Blake Love & Monsters
BBC Studios

It should come as no surprise that one of the most reviled episodes of Doctor Who ever has a spot on this list. Series 2's Love And Monsters is truly terrible in every way, but one moment right at the end takes the cake.

After being absorbed by the Abzorbaloff, the character of Ursula Blake suffers an even worse fate when she's partly resurrected by the Doctor to live the rest of her life as a face on a concrete slab. Terrible right? That isn't even the worst part.

Her boyfriend, Elton Pope, reveals that despite not having a real body the two have started a relationship and do have a sort-of love life, which implies, well just re-read the title.

Doctor Who is no stranger to adult jokes of course but this took things to a place too uncomfortable to imagine.

Thankfully, Ursula stops Elton from discussing the matter further, but the damage was already done.


1. Actors Wearing Yellow Face - The Talons Of Weng Chiang

Doctor Who The Talons Of Weng Chiang
BBC

By far the worst and most inappropriate moment in Doctor Who history has to be the portrayal of Chinese people in The Talons Of Weng-Chiang.

This Fourth Doctor serial from 1977, is actually considered one of the best by fans and critics alike, especially because of its Sherlock Holmes-style setting and story.

Unfortunately, that does not forgive its depiction of its Chinese characters, who strongly conform to racist stereotypes. Furthermore, when other characters in the story make racist remarks towards them, the Doctor, who has a long history of standing up for marginalised groups, does nothing.

But worst of all was that many of the Chinese characters were portrayed by white actors wearing yellow face. At the time of this release, it aired without any controversy as, unfortunately, white actors portraying non-white characters was commonplace.

Looking back on it now though, it was incredibly wrong and taints the legacy of the show. It’s one of the shows darkest hours.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

22-year-old journalism graduate from Croydon. When I'm not moaning about or singing the praises of Doctor Who or a great film or two, I'm (unsuccessfully) looking for a job or setting up a podcast. Again usually unsuccessfully.