10 Most Messed Up Deaths In Star Trek: TOS
Sometimes on Star Trek, setting phasers to kill just isn't gruesome enough...
There’s a good reason Captain Kirk says “to boldly go where no man has gone before” rather than just “to go”. Indeed, a man (or woman!) would need to have balls of steel to volunteer for a position on the USS Enterprise, on which even the strangest of deaths are all in a day’s work.
Ironically, it’s Q in The Next Generation who best described the wonders and perils of outer space in the Star Trek universe; “if you can’t take a little bloody nose, maybe you ought to go back home and crawl under your bed. It’s not safe out here.”
That’s all very well and good for an omnipotent being, but needless to say, the large numbers that comprise the body count in The Original Series would surely take a bloody nose any day compared to the weird and wild fates they suffer in service of the Enterprise.
A good old fashioned and simple death from wayward phaser-fire would be a dream come true next to the array of bizarre and messed up mishaps that are, sadly, part of the job description for Star Trek’s redshirts and miscellaneous crewmen (and women!). Sure, come the next show, Kirk and co may act as though everything’s back to normal, but it’s hard for us to forget the sorry saps that follow.
10. A Pinch Of Salt - The Man Trap
What better way to start off than a gnarly fate seen in "The Man Trap", the very first episode aired in Star Trek’s original run? Clearly, freakish fatalities were to be a mainstay on the show, and they had no issue raising the curtain with among the most grotesque.
The Original Series begins with the Enterprise visiting the planet M-113 to deliver supplies, conduct routine medical exams… the usual. What’s also established as “usual” however, is the doomed fate of whichever poor schmuck happens to accompany any combination of Kirk, Dr McCoy, and Spock on a new planet.
In this case it’s Crewman Darnell, who falls for what he believes to be a beautiful woman, but is in fact a shape-shifting, salt-sucking monster. Standard Star Trek fare. After Darnell is disposed of, the chameleonic killer proceeds to stalk the corridors of the Enterprise, relieving the unlucky crewmen it encounters of both their salt and their lives.
It turns out to be not so much a rampage as it is a simple matter of the creature’s survival, but that’s of little comfort to the salt-devoid corpses of those unlucky enough to come across a pretty woman.
9. Speared - The Galileo Seven
No, that’s not a reference to any kind of wind-knocking wrestling move; it’s quite literal. A wandering redshirt (well, technically it’s more yellowy) gets impaled by an almost comically oversized spear, and falls to his death with it still sticking out of his back.
When the shuttlecraft Galileo is pulled off-course, the crew is marooned on Taurus II, a desolate and dreary planet. Clearly, a perfect choice for an emergency landing. Immediately, Lieutenants Latimer and Gaetano are sent on that cruel death sentence of a duty; scouting the area.
Sure enough, they quickly encounter the planet’s monstrously aggressive and primitive inhabitants, who greet their new visitors by way of throwing a very large and unwieldy spear at the first intruder they see.
Thus, poor Latimer meets his end via the pointy end of an obscenely large stick. If that wasn't enough, the weapon remains lodged in his corpse, sticking absurdly high in the air as he lays lifeless on the ground. You have to think that in most cases, Kirk leaves the cause of death out when breaking sad news to the families of his hapless redshirts.
8. For The Love Of A Trike - Miri
After the gang encounters an apparent duplicate of Earth, their curiosity is piqued enough to beam down to the surface en masse and explore. Once there, they’re almost immediately attacked by a disfigured and quite deranged resident, whose main dispute with them seems to be that they’ve approached his broken tricycle.
Kirk promptly delivers a beat-down on the disturbed fellow, who nonetheless remains more concerned with the trike. At this point, Kirk notes that he seems to have “the mind of a child”, and is doubtless feeling a little guilty for having punched him in the face repeatedly.
The sight of a full-grown man breaking down in heartbreak over a trike is unsettling, to say the least, but it gets even worse as he then suffers a fatal seizure while gibbering hysterically. It’s not much of a welcome for the Enterprise crew, and their fortunes wouldn’t improve as they’d spend the rest of the episode trying to avoid the same grisly fate.
Later on, Kirk is held hostage by a group of kids(!) who administer on him the dreaded “bonk, bonk, bonk on the head.” Thankfully he’s not killed, or this would warrant its own place in the list.
7. Blood Drained By A Cloud - Obsession
The regrettably red-clad crewmen of the Enterprise rarely get to live long enough to rue their choice of colours. Anytime they’re beamed down to a strange planet for even the most routine surveys, the only certainty is that there will be blood. Or, in the case of “Obsession”, there won’t be!
The terribly unlucky redshirts scouting Argus X are hardly pleased to make the acquaintance of a seemingly intelligent, gaseous cloud. In fact, they end up looking like they’ve seen a ghost. “Not a ghost,” they might say, “it’s a monstrous vampiric entity that drains every red corpuscle from the blood of its victims.” At least, they might if they weren’t bone-cold, pale corpses.
The being is sadly well-known to Captain Kirk, and the episode details his obsessive quest for vengeance against the bloodsucking billow. Deep space offers the wonderful, the weird, and the worrying, and the chilling sight of those snow white redshirts is very much the latter.
Having their blood drained by a hungry, hungry haze likely wasn’t what they signed up for, but on Star Trek, someone’s gotta do it.
6. Unnatural Causes - The Deadly Years
Here’s one, shockingly, not suffered by a calamitous redshirt.
Indeed, perhaps Kirk was feeling some sympathy for his ever-ending security teams when he chose to give them a break in "The Deadly Years", instead personally beaming down to a research station on Gamma Hydra IV along with his key personnel. Well, plus Chekov.
It’s Chekov who goes on to make the rather horrible discovery of a desiccated, wrinkled corpse that somewhat resembles the grandpa from the original Texas Chainsaw Massacre. Setting aside the macabre nature of a dead body just laying around in a darkened room, we soon learn that the cause of death wasn’t nearly as natural as it seems.
In fact, it’s low-level radiation from a comet that’s causing rapid ageing, which has now affected almost the entire landing party, plus the surviving station crew. The nasty effects of growing old become evident as various victims of the radiation are shown to succumb to weakness and senility in a very short time, before passing. As Kirk puts it: “what a way to die.” And what an appropriate entry for an article like this.
5. Burned To A Crisp - Devil In The Dark
It’s a well-known Trek trope that caves are always bad news.
From the risk of sudden collapsing walls to antagonistic androids and the miscellaneous bizarre space creatures that lurk within, the appearance of a cave on Star Trek normally indicates that someone, somewhere, is going to meet their maker. Especially those wearing a red shirt.
In “Devil in the Dark”, Kirk and co face off against a subterranean slayer known as the Horta, who’s not-so-silently picking off miners and engineers on Janus VI. For investigative purposes, they don’t have a lot to go on when examining what’s left of the victims, who are reduced to simmering chunks of charcoal.
We’re fortunate, however, to witness a typically ill-fated redshirt wandering the caves on his lonesome (always a bad idea), before being ambushed by the blazing blob that is the Horta and getting summarily burned to a crisp.
And if that wasn’t enough, the later revelation that the Horta is simply protecting its eggs renders it wholly sympathetic, and the barbecued remains of the redshirt are never avenged.
On a happier note, thanks to the Horta, there’s no need to go to the trouble of cremation.
4. Beam Me Back, Scotty - And The Children Shall Lead
Most redshirts probably brace themselves for potential calamities as soon as they’re informed they’ve been called up for one of those dreaded away missions. Even the most pessimistic of crewmen, however, would expect to stay alive for longer than the poor saps in “And The Children Shall Lead” managed to.
Believing the Enterprise to be orbiting the planet Triacus, Kirk orders a routine transport of his away team to the surface, each of them prepared for the worst. Unfortunately, the worst arrives far sooner than anyone expected; it turns out that the planet’s apparent presence is merely a visual illusion, meaning that Kirk has unwittingly beamed his loyal men into outer space.
It’s largely left to the imagination, but the very thought of being instantly teleported from safety to death via the cold vacuum of space is chilling. Who needs fancy execution machines when you have the transporter? Still, although it’s certainly a horrific death, at least they, unlike viewers, were largely spared the pain of watching this infamously awful episode unfold.
3. Into Hell's Mouth - The Doomsday Machine
Though the mission of the Enterprise was to seek out new life, there are certain cases in which they’d have probably rather not. Take the horrific planet-killing device in The Doomsday Machine, which plays the proverbial Moby Dick to guest starring Commodore Decker’s Captain Ahab.
Once rescued by the Enterprise crew, the maniacal Decker spends the duration of the episode obsessively trying to conquer the relentless and seemingly indestructible titular automaton. Eventually, the tragic Commodore seems to realise that enough is enough, opting for a suicide run by way of steering a shuttlecraft directly into the machine’s flaming maw.
It would be quite understandable if Decker slightly regrets his decision as the gaping inferno grows ever closer, and the sheer terror on his face wholly conveys his looming oblivion. The very image of the tiny craft flying into the mouth of hell is staggeringly bleak.
Not to add insult to injury, but his noble sacrifice ended up doing almost no damage to the juggernaut-like machine whatsoever. Were there anything left of poor Decker to bury, his tombstone might read “at least he tried”.
2. Psychedelic Mind Attack - The Lights Of Zetar
Even the most routine missions never seem to go to plan on Star Trek; not even a trip to the library.
Arriving at Memory Alpha, the galaxy’s central information outpost, Kirk and the landing party would expect the place to be relatively quiet, but the dead silence they’re met with is eerily ominous.
In one of Star Trek’s most terrifying moments, the crew finds a darkened room full of corpses, and a Zetarian scientist on death’s door. On approach, she emits a series of garbled, guttural sounds that would put The Grudge’s famous ghost to shame. If that wasn’t enough, her face contorts unnaturally in all of horror, agony, and panic, all the while shifting in weird colours to provide pure nightmare fuel.
Only after all this does she finally expire, and McCoy helpfully lists all her ailments: “severe brain haemorrhaging due to distortion of all neural systems”, “dissolution of autonomic nervous system” and so on.
Put like that, it certainly doesn’t sound like much fun, and despite all the bright colours, it doesn’t look it either. To boldly go where no man has gone before? It’s enough to make a man want to go straight back where he came from, and fast.
1. Cubic Crush - By Any Other Name
Evidently, then, the infamously unlucky redshirts and miscellaneous crewmen of the Enterprise met their ends in a wide variety of ways, ranging from violent, to disturbing, to just plain weird. Some lucky officers, however, got to experience a death that encompassed all of these qualities.
So it was for poor Yeoman Thompson in “By Any Other Name”, an ill-fated victim of the oddly specific powers demonstrated by the Kelvans and their nifty control belts.
Punishing Kirk for his attempt to escape the clutches of the dastardly Kelvans, they use their belts to transform two of his landing party (including Thompson) into small, chalky cubes. Q from the 007 franchise has been trying to develop this feature for years, but the best he’s managed so far is a belt-powered grappling hook.
Perhaps sensing that Kirk was rather desensitised by then to his male crewmen being offed, the Kelvans opted to hit him where it really hurts by choosing the unfortunately feminine Thompson for execution - namely by crushing her cubic stand-in into dust. Ashes to ashes...