10 Most Underrated Doctor Who Episodes
Those moments of Doctor Who brilliance that don't get the love they deserve.
Since Doctor Who returned to our TV screens in 2005, there have been over 170 episodes of the show for fans to enjoy.
Some episodes from this NuWho period have gone down as some of the best in the show's history. Blink, Heaven Sent, the Library two-parter, and many more are held up as shining examples of Doctor Who done right.
But what about the great episodes that don't get shouted out all that often? The ones that get forgotten by the likes of, say, Internet list-makers?
With 13 series and counting (not to mention the specials), there are plenty of stellar stories that haven't been given the accolades they deserve.
Until now.
This list contains a mixture of episodes from across NuWho, and tries to include as many different Doctors and companions as possible. Of course, "underrated" is a subjective term, but overall, it's fair to say that these episodes rarely (if ever) get talked about in the same breath as the established greats.
They might not be ten-out-of-ten perfect episodes themselves, but we think they deserve a lot more love.
10. The Unicorn And The Wasp
Out of David Tennant's three series as the Doctor, his one spent travelling with Catherine Tate is looked back on with the most fondness.
The relationship between the Tenth Doctor and Donna Noble was totally different to anything else NuWho had seen up to that point; two bickering friends, as opposed to the dashing hero and his love interest. It was a refreshing, much-needed change.
Donna was the companion for the much-loved Library saga and the epic Series 4 finale The Stolen Earth/Journey's End, but quite possibly her most enjoyable adventure involved the most famous detective writer of all time.
In The Unicorn and the Wasp, the Doctor and Donna travel to 1926, where they meet Agatha Christie. Then, people start dropping dead under mysterious circumstances. What are the chances? That'd be like meeting Charles Dickens and he's surrounded by ghosts at Christmas.
Tee-hee.
This episode transplants our lead characters into a Christie-style mystery and has tons of fun with it. The giant wasp monster is memorable, if a little non-frightening, and there are plenty of twists and turns as the mystery unfolds. Also, the scene where the Doctor is doing charades in the kitchen is a classic.
In many ways, it's the perfect setup for a Doctor Who story: an intriguing mystery, a dash of sci-fi, a cast of interesting cannon fodder, and plenty of silly comedy.
9. Last Of The Time Lords
When it comes to series finales, NuWho has a lot of good ones to choose from.
There's the aforementioned Stolen Earth/Journey's End combo, the battle of Satellite Five from Series 1, and Peter Capaldi's return to Gallifrey in Heaven Sent and Hell Bent.
And then, there's the three-part send-off to Series 3 - Utopia, The Sound of Drums, and Last of the Time Lords.
Utopia gets praised for the reveal of Derek Jacobi as the Master, The Sound of Drums is bigged up for John Simm's unhinged portrayal of the same character, and Last of the Time Lords, well... Space Jesus.
The bit at the end where the Doctor is transformed from Dobby the house elf to his original form - though the power of prayer and magic - is rightfully slated. It's hokey nonsense that almost derails the entire episode.
However, there's a lot of good stuff outside this moment.
Freema Agyeman gives her best performance as Martha Jones, from her journey around the Earth, to walking away from the Doctor. And Ten's emotional goodbye to the Master as he cradles him in his arms is melodrama at its best.
It's not perfect by any means, but are any of us? Well, Tom Baker is, actually.
8. Amy’s Choice
Rory Williams was originally portrayed as a bumbling idiot who was about as useful as a see-through bathroom door. Even his fiancée showed him little to no respect, going as far as to hook up with the Doctor the night before her wedding.
Poor Rory.
This all changed in the brilliant Series 5 episode Amy's Choice, where the Doctor, Amy, and Rory are caught between two worlds - one where they're stalked by evil pensioners, and one where the TARDIS is about to crash into a cold star.
Rory ends up being killed in the old person reality, prompting Amy to proclaim that this is the fake one. As she puts it, any world without Rory isn't worth living in.
This genius bit of writing from Simon Nye completely changed Amy and Rory's dynamic and made their relationship much easier to invest in. The uncertainty over which version of events was real was also really well-done, as you genuinely believe that either reality could be true.
We also get some of the best character interactions and memorable one-liners in all of NuWho:
"I'm surprised you haven't got a little purple space dog just to ram home what an intergalactic WAG you are."
"If we're going to die, let's die looking like a Peruvian folk band."
Top marks for dialogue! And come on, anything with Toby Jones in it is automatically great.
7. Knock Knock
Landlords are among the most evil creatures in the known universe, so it's hardly surprising that one was made into a Doctor Who villain.
Series 10's Knock Knock begins with Bill Potts moving into a grand old house (which, fun fact, was also used for the Wester Drumlins house in Blink), owned by guest star David Suchet. The kindly old gent is hiding something though, as his tenants begin to go missing.
They're definitely not getting their deposit back, are they?
Enter the Twelfth Doctor, who discovers that the house is home to various wooden creatures who are out to cause harm to its human occupants. But instead of being a simple good guys versus bad guys narrative, there is more to this story than meets the eye.
Bill's time on Doctor Who seemed to come and go without much fanfare. She was following on from Jenna Coleman's Clara, which was a tough task, and was often overshadowed by Matt Lucas' Nardole whenever he was around.
She gets a great showing here though, as does Suchet in his guest appearance. Having an actor of his quality paired up with Capaldi was always going to yield good results, as is evident in their eventual confrontation.
Spine-tingling stuff.
6. It Takes You Away
Falling linear TV ratings and a perceived drop in quality following Chris Chibnall taking over as showrunner will likely dominate how most people remember Jodie Whittaker's run as the Doctor.
That's a real shame, as her time on the show did yield its fair share of strong episodes, including the penultimate episode of Series 11, It Takes You Away.
Here, the Doctor and her fam travels to Norway to help a young woman find her missing father. But as is always the case with Doctor Who, things are not that simple.
Everyone ends up in an alternate dimension, where they see and hear things that would be impossible in the real world. There are also flesh-eating moths and a memorable one-off villain in Ribbons, who is soon devoured by said moths.
As well as the fantastically atmospheric set design that brings the buffer zone to life, this episode has plenty of emotional highpoints in the alternate dimension too, such as Bradley Walsh's Graham encountering a spectre of his dead wife.
Full credit to writer Ed Hime for creating such a full and engaging world. If only this triumph had come during a time where more people were watching. And if only that frog hadn't been so laughable.
5. Last Christmas
From The Christmas Invasion to Twice Upon A Time, the Doctor Who Christmas specials have usually provided good to great stories of the Doctor fighting some sort of holiday-themed menace.
One that doesn't get discussed nearly enough is 2014's Last Christmas, which paired the Time Lord up with Santa Claus himself.
Played by Nick Frost, this Santa is actually a subconscious creation used by our heroes to escape the Dream Crabs, a race of telepathic, copyright-skirting facehuggers who eat their victims' brains while they're in an induced sleep.
Cue a story that takes place across multiple different dreams, as the Doctor and Clara must question what is real, what isn't real, and if they even want to know.
While this story has some of that Moffat overcomplicated stink on it, it's a runaway success all things considered. It's probably the most ambitious Christmas special storyline-wise, which really must've confused people who were just tucking into their turkey and sprouts.
Frost's Banter Claus is hilarious, the facehuggers - sorry, Dream Crabs - are nightmare fuel, and the emotional wallops come thick and fast, from Clara's goodbye to Danny, to the Doctor pulling a Christmas cracker with a much older version of his beloved Impossible Girl.
4. Resolution
A Doctor Who Christmas special is one thing, but a New Year's Day special? Get out of town!
Although The End of Time Part Two was initially broadcast on 1 January, the practice of regular, one-off Who specials on New Year's Day was established by 2019's Resolution.
After a pair of archaeologists discover a strange artefact in Sheffield (which inexplicably became the centre of the universe from Series 11 onwards), their lives become endangered when a case-less Dalek possesses one of their bodies. The Doctor must stop the squidgy beast before it can grow to full power.
In the middle of all this, Ryan's absentee father also reappears. Cue some nice acting from Tosin Cole (who is finally given something to sink his teeth into) as the conflicted son.
These two competing storylines mesh together nicely, leading to a big climax that ties everything together. This episode also gives us a unique look at the Doctor's most famous foe: just how dangerous is a Dalek without its battle armour?
Very, as it turns out. Very scary too.
Despite being a largely forgotten episode, it's the best use of the Daleks we've seen in ages, and one of the stronger Doctor Who specials to air since 2005.
3. A Town Called Mercy
The Eleventh Doctor and the Old West - a match made in Stetson-loving heaven.
The Doctor, Amy, and Rory all arrive in a town called, well, Mercy, which is quite the dilly of a pickle. An alien cyborg named the Gunslinger is holding the town hostage, unless it hands over another extra-terrestrial hiding there.
This giant monster with a gun for a hand is clearly the baddie, right? Actually, not quite.
As A Town Called Mercy unfolds, the audience learns more about each side of this conflict, and how first impressions may have been somewhat deceiving. Eleven is forced to make a difficult moral choice, one that pushes him right to the edge. This leads to a fabulous moment where Amy talks him down, and helps her Raggedy Doctor make the right decision.
Companions aren't just in Doctor Who to ask stupid questions and help move the plot along. They should serve as the Doctor's conscience, their humanity, guiding them to the best possible outcome. Amy serves that function brilliantly here.
A Town Called Mercy is thematically rich in other ways too, and touches on the ethics of war, which ties nicely into the ongoing (at the time) Time War arc, and makes the whole story feel that little bit more resonant.
Throw in some really entertaining cowboy stuff ("Tea... leave the bag in"), and you've got yourself a dang fine episode, partner.
2. The Idiot’s Lantern
Doctor Who is versatile enough to be grim and serious one week, and light and fluffy the next. Sometimes, it's little more than a bit of light Saturday evening entertainment about a flying telephone box and badly made-up aliens. It's pure pantomime sometimes, and that isn't always a bad thing.
For example, The Idiot's Lantern.
Set during the coronation of Queen Elizabeth II, the Tenth Doctor and Rose Tyler must figure out how newly-installed televisions are stealing people's faces. This brings them face to stolen face with the Wire, an intergalactic entity played stupendously by Maureen Lipman.
Lipman hams it up to the nines for this part, going full-on camp villain complete with an overzealous evil laugh. She puts everything into her performance, and it is a joy to behold.
The Idiot's Lantern is also one of David Tennant's best Doctor performances too, running the gamut from cheesy American accents to intimidating rage to despair at the loss of Rose, with a pinch of action hero thrown in to cap things off.
It doesn't bring anything philosophical to the table or put your favourite characters through a meaningful arc, but The Idiot's Lantern does provide a solid 45 minutes of well-crafted entertainment, and that's more than acceptable.
1. Boom Town
All that stuff about Doctor Who not being serious?
Forget it.
Boom Town has some of the best-written dialogue in the show's history. If you didn't know it was about aliens, this stuff could've come straight from the highest-quality watershed drama.
The Doctor, Rose, Mickey, and Captain Jack have to deal with the surviving Slitheen from earlier in the series. "Margaret Blaine" is attempting to destroy Cardiff, but this episode becomes about way more than a plot to blow up Wales.
Margaret reveals that she will be executed if she is returned to her home planet. This leads to a fascinating exploration of the rights and wrongs of the Doctor's heroic antics: would he go as far as to condemn someone to death in the name of the greater good?
The apex of the drama is the fantastic dinner scene between Christopher Eccleston and Annette Badland. Both actors are at the top of their game, as they go back and forth and ponder her redemption, with the Doctor cutting to the heart of the matter with a single brilliantly-written line:
"You're pleading for mercy out of a dead woman's lips."
Round of applause for Mr. Davies.
Boom Town has very little boom and quite a lot of talking, which is likely why it isn't often thought of alongside the more whizz-bang popular episodes in the modern Who pantheon. But go back and watch it and you'll realise how good it really is.
Watch Next
Doctor Who Quiz: How Well Do You Know Series 1?