5. Eddie Kaye Thomas
--> -->
Best known for his role as Finch in the raunchiest of teen comedies Eddie Kaye Thomas became personified as the class geek. That was until he banged Stifler's mom and his geek status quickly elevated to cool. But Thomas was cool years before American Pie hit theaters having made his acting debut in a 1994 episode of Are You Afraid of the Dark. In "The Tale of the Curious Camera," Eddie's character comes across an old Polaroid whose pictures foretell misfortune for its subjects in a plot eerily similar to a popular Goosebumps tale. The episode isn't entirely original and follows a rather predictable plot but if you're a fan of Thomas it's one you'll definitely want to check out. It's interesting to note that another entry on our list, Ryan Gosling, starred in the very episode of Goosebumps this one resembles. Thomas recently appeared in American Reunion alongside former castmates and currently voices Barry on American Dad. His next film, The List, is currently filming and set to premiere next year.