10 Plot Holes You Haven't Noticed In The Arrowverse

Crisis Of Infinite Logics...

Arrowverse Supergirl Batwoman Flash Arrow
The CW

The Arrowverse is undoubtedly the measuring stick when it comes to modern-day superhero television. Though some will argue with that statement, it's hard to deny all that it has accomplished over the past decade as its success paved the way for a renaissance of comic book-inspired shows and ultimately proved that superheroes belong on the small screen just as much as they do on the silver one.

Arrow's success eventually led to the birth of the even more successful spin-off The Flash. Soon afterwards, the shared universe grew with Supergirl and DC's Legends of Tomorrow joining in on the action. And now, we have Batwoman and two more potential projects all ready to ensure that the Arrowverse lives on when its originator concludes.

That being said, eight years of storytelling is hard to keep up with - and not just for us viewers. Thus, some of the Arrowverse shows will often encounter some, well, storytelling blips. Yes, there are occasions were certain developments don't necessarily reflect what we had been told before. And whether the logic is genuinely overlooked or it's done intentionally for plot convenience, it happens... even if it isn't always obvious.

10. The Green Arrow Of Earth-2

The Flash Robert Queen the hood Earth Two
The CW

Arrow's eighth season has been the closest the show has come to perfection since its acclaimed second offering, but there was one moment that left a few of the Arrowverse's more clued-in fans a little confused. That moment came in the season premiere 'Starling City' in which Oliver Queen traveled to Earth-2 to procure Dwarfstar particles for The Monitor.

While there, he was confronted by the Black Canary herself, Laurel Lance. But she wasn't alone, as she was receiving help from that earth's Hood Adrian Chase. Though the pair made a formidable team, it didn't make sense with what he we had been told before.

All the way back on The Flash's second season, a news bulletin revealed that the Hood had already been unmasked and that his identity was Robert Queen - Oliver's father who had been driven to crime-fighting after the death of his son on the Gambit.

While it's always possible that Chase was Queen's successor, this was never explained and thus, came off as a plot inconsistency more than anything else. Though the showrunners have since attempted to explain away the fan queries with the 'multiple Green Arrows' philosophy, it would have made more sense if those lines were actually in the show.


9. Where's Cat Grant?

Supergirl Cat Grant Season 3
The CW

Calista Flockhart's Cat Grant was undoubtedly one of the highlights of Supergirl's first season. Unfortunately, the show's move to The CW resulted in the veteran actress moving to a recurring role instead. And as a result, the character had to be written out.

Her return in the second season's final two episodes saw her form a close relationship with President Olivia Marsdin before the third season's premiere revealed that she had become the official Press Secretary for the White House. A great role for the former CEO of CatCo Media no doubt, but it's one that has since cast a shadow over her whereabouts.

You would think that Marsdin's removal from office in Season 4 would have resulted in Cat also stepping down from her position as Press Secretary. Not only would her knowledge of 'fake news' have ensured that she wouldn't have remained on under President Baker's horrible administration, but the show never referenced her at all throughout the entire anti-alien debacle - so it's pretty much certain that she no longer holds that role.

Why hasn't the show referenced Cat (in the present tense) since? She's no longer the CEO of CatCo and she's obviously no longer the Press Secretary, so where is she?

It goes without saying that the show is in desperate need of her return. Great as Lena Luthor, James Olsen and Andrea Rojas are when running CatCo, they are not Cat Grant.


8. Felicity The Hypocrite

Arrow Felicity Screensaver
The CW

"Don't think of it as lying," Felicity Smoak told a torn Eddie Thawne - who was struggling to keep Barry's identity as the Scarlet Speedster a secret from Iris - during her time on The Flash, "Think of it as protecting her from getting hurt... with a fib." And, you know what, that captured the joyous and lovable essence of Felicity to perfection, reinforcing what kind of a hero she was.

A few months later, she discovered that Oliver Queen had a secret son from a one-night stand a decade beforehand and lost it. Finding out about William's existence when the young boy was kidnapped by Damien Darhk, she single-handedly made the whole thing about her, delaying the search for him so that she could berate her other half with endless monologues about how he lied to her. And sorry, how is this any different from the advice she gave Eddie over on The Flash?

First off, William's existence had nothing to do with Felicity whatsoever. If you really wanted to delve into the history, the person he lied to years ago was Laurel (with whom he was in a relationship at the time), not her. But more to the point, he promised William's mother that he would keep their son's existence a secret in order to protect him. And that's exactly what he did.

If we learned anything from this, it was that The Flash writers understood the original Felicity far better than the Arrow Season 4 writers did - because this self-obsessed monster they created (whose behaviour they even attempted to justify) went against the character that had been established. And it was one of the many moments in that season in which they turned their back on the established order.


7. The Titular Hero MUST Take Down The Bad Guy

The Flash Arrow Crossover Oliver
The CW

The problem with having characters from multiple Arrowverse shows interact with each other is that it makes them obvious solutions for major problems... obvious solutions that none of them can see.

Take the Season 4 finale of Arrow for instance, as Damien Darhk threatened to blow up the entire world with a ton of nuclear missiles. He didn't just want to destroy Star City, but the whole freakin' world... including Central City. With that in mind, wouldn't The Flash have been the perfect man for the job? Not only could he have taken down Darhk (and saved Felicity's ex) in an instant, he could have saved his own city from a nuclear apocalypse.

Speaking of The Flash, you know who would've been a great asset in the fight against Savitar? Supergirl. The Girl of Steel would have been almost as fast as the mechanical speedster and could have destroyed him with a single punch. And to top it all off, she could have done so without Savitar being able to anticipate her moves (because, being a time remnant of Barry, Savitar knew exactly what the Scarlet Speedster would do).

These are only two examples of a wider problem in the Arrowverse that all center on the fact that the shows can't undermine their titular hero by having another one swoop in to save the day. Sure, they'll occasionally rely on them for secondary heroism (Oliver reaching out to The Flash in Arrow's Season 3 finale) but it renders the whole thing redundant when they could literally stop the whole thing in a heartbeat and save a ton of lives in the process.

This is a somewhat understandable plot hole given that the shows need to rely on their own heroes, but as these are supposed to be some of the smartest characters in the multiverse, it does come off as baffling that they wouldn't call in the heavy artillery for the heavy-duty missions.


6. The Slowest Man Alive

The Flash Barry
The CW

One of the main problems with The Flash having 22-23 episodes a week is that it runs the risk of highlighting some of its biggest recurring problems. This is usually quite prevalent in the villain-of-the-week episodes as the reliable format is used to allow Barry to learn something about himself or pick up a new skill. But in order to do that, he must lose - something that, most of the time, just comes off as contrived.

There's a reason that the show has relied so heavily on evil speedsters like Thawne, Zoom and Savitar as its main villains, and that's down to the fact that they all possess the same (and in some cases superior) abilities to Barry. But with villains like Peek-A-Boo, Captain Cold, Heat Wave, Golden Glider, Rag Doll and even King Shark, Barry should be able to defeat them in seconds - especially when you factor in how long he's been a hero now.

But The Flash isn't just a tenured speedster, he's the fastest man alive, which means that no amount of ice blasts, punches or even a freakin' banana peel should be able to take him down as long they're directly in his path (or even if they're behind him). At the rate at which he moves, he would easily be able to see, react and dodge anything coming his way... because he's The Flash, damn it!


5. Damien Darhk's Magic

Arrow Damien Darhk
The CW

Damien Darhk's powers may have been mystic (instead of magic) but they could magically disappear and reappear whenever the plot required them to. Okay, so remember how Season 4 went down the corny route of Oliver's Felicity-induced positivity and light magic being strong enough to overcome Darhk's dark magic? Well, that was executed somewhat better in the finale when the citizens of Star City showed faith in the Green Arrow - allowing Oliver's pure magic to negate Darhk's powers.

As a hand-to-hand combat between the two foes ensued, Darhk suddenly realized that Cooper Seldon had done the right thing and stopped attempting to destroy the world. And in one quick swoop, he used his powers to send the bullet that had been slowly travelling to his spine to its destination - killing Felicity's ex-boyfriend from a distance.

The only problem is that the positivity of Oliver's light magic had already negated Darhk's powers, so how on earth did they suddenly come back when he conveniently needed them? You could argue that this wasn't directly related to Darhk's fight with Oliver but, given that Seldon was supposed to destroy the world that Oliver was trying to protect, you'd have a hard time proving that one.

Arrow should never have gone down the magic route because it allowed for a multitude of narrative discrepancies and plot conveniences. This right here was an episodic example of both.


4. The More You Time Travel, The Less The Rules Apply To You

The Flash Savitar Future Barry Allen
The CW

The Flash's third season relied rather heavily on time travel and, as a result, some of the logic that the show applied to that concept began being rewritten for the convenience of the plot - something we also saw on Legends of Tomorrow that year (but we'll get to that later).

Yes, the introduction of Savitar suggested that events were fixed in time and couldn't be altered no matter how much Team Flash tried - and yet, that completely contradicted the basis upon which Season 3 was built. The season opened with Barry saving his mother in the past, creating an alternate timeline known as Flashpoint before he ultimately put her back in place and created a slightly altered version of the original timeline.

More to the point, the new logic may have made sense if it wasn't Savitar that was spouting it. "That's the thing about time travel Barry, the more you do it, the less the rules apply to you." An interesting statement that, looking back on the show, certainly carries weight, but it's one that doesn't feel right coming out of Savitar's mouth.

The evil speedster was determined to kill Iris on a specific date at a specific time so that he could live in the present. How could he live in the present, you ask? Why, Iris' death would drive present-day Barry mad and result in him becoming Savitar of course! And yet, the villain was also willing to allow Barry to kill himself because, according to him, the timeline had been so messed up already, it wouldn't have an effect. Sorry but how, how does that correspond with the logic? How can Barry become Savitar if he's dead?

Moreover, if Savitar's ascension was so fixed, why was the present-day version of it (Iris' supposed death) a different event than his original birth as a time remnant in the future? And if it was so fixed, how was it that Team Flash were ultimately able to thwart it and erase him from existence?

The time travel logic was all over the place in Season 3 and resulted in what had been, for the most part, a thoroughly compelling season coming off as unnecessarily confusing.


3. Where Are All The Time Wraiths?

The Flash Barry Time Wraith
The CW

The Flash established relatively early on that if you mess with the timeline too much, you'll end up encountering a horde of nasty Time Wraiths. The Dementor-like creatures showed up in Season 2 to exact revenge on Barry for his time-traveling shenanigans before destroying Zoom in the finale for his atrocities on the timeline. And even though they (and Black Flash) have shown up multiple times since, why is it that they're never around when the logically should be.

Barry's actions in Season 3 created Flashpoint and there wasn't a Time Wraith in sight and, ever since they were replaced by Black Flash (who was eventually disposed of by Killer Frost), the Arrowverse uses them more sparingly than ever - in spite of a whole lot of time travel shenanigans.

Now, don't get this writer wrong, sometimes the shows have gone to the effort to explain why they don't show up. For example, Nora West-Allen's actions in Season 5 never alerted them because she was taking pointers from the Reverse-Flash who knew how to navigate timelines using the Negative Speed Force so that the creatures would never know. But what about the Legends who inadvertently destroy the timeline multiple times each season?

Sure, the Arrowverse's outcasts and misfits don't use the Speed Force (but instead make use of the time stream) but shouldn't the creatures go out of their way to protect the timeline from any and all threats (heroic or not)? Granted, with a Time Master like Rip Hunter in charge during the first season, they would have known how to dodge the creatures, but as the Legends' actions have gotten more outrageous in later years, they're far more likely to incur the wrath of the Wraiths. And yet they haven't.

So, one more time this writer asks you: Where are all the Time Wraiths?


2. It's Conveniently IMPOSSIBLE To Resurrect Laurel Lance (Because They Said So)

Arrow Laurel Lance death
The CW

Arrow had such a habit of resurrecting characters that the writers attempted to imbue their "Who's in the grave?" narrative with some legitimacy by removing the Lazarus Pit from the equation. The only problem was that the woefully under-planned storyline killed off one of the few characters the show needed in Laurel Lance/Black Canary.

But what about time travel, you ask? Well, over on Legends of Tomorrow, Rip Hunter spewed some hilariously ridiculous monologue about how if Sara attempted to save Laurel, she'd end up getting killed by Damien Darhk instead and that the timeline was fixed and that Laurel was meant to die and yada, yada, yada...

The ironic thing about about all of this is that the Arrowverse's attempts to be realistic and legitimate only made it come as more far-fetched. Suddenly, everything we knew about the show was conveniently no longer true. Rip's dialogue didn't match with what we had been told about time travel logic over on The Flash (again, Barry was actually allowed to save his mother at one point) while the convenient discovery of more Lazarus pits (on both Earth-1 and parallel dimensions) later down the line rendered the whole thing pointless.

It all came off as a desperate attempt by the showrunners to justify their show-destroying decision to kill Laurel and, looking back on it now, it painfully showed. A decision that rightfully kick-started huge backlash (including a sharp ratings drop), it also completely undermined the logic of the entire Arrowverse - something that not even the almighty Arrow should have had the power to do.


1. The Many Faces Of Harrison Wells Aren't Recognized By The Public

The Flash Harry Wells
The CW

Due to the Reverse-Flash's heinous shenanigans in Season 1 of The Flash, Earth-1 has deemed the dearly departed (and innocent) Harrison Wells a criminal. This was something that impacted Earth-2's Harry Wells, as multiple Earth-1 folk mistook him as the evil speedster. And then you have Earth-19's H.R. Wells - who actually had to use an Earth-19 facial transmogrification device to give him a new appearance in order to avoid the comparisons (even though we still saw Tom Cavanagh's face).

However, since then, there has been no explanation as to whether or not subsequent Wells have had to come up with a plan to conceal their appearance.

In Season 6, Nash Wells was recognized by Allegra Garcia - proving that Harrison Wells is still a presumed criminal. Now, with Joe as the new captain of CCPD, we know that nobody will prosecute an innocent Wells, but that doesn't explain away the situation or answer how the likes of Harry or Sherloque got by before that.

How did Harry - who looked identical to Earth-1 Wells - get around during Season 4? And was a hat, long hair and a mustache enough to conceal Sherloque's Wells-like features?

An alternate 2024 timeline in Season 3 revealed that H.R. had become a published author without explanation as to why his face was able to appear on books and how he could host public readings of his novels without any repercussions (did the facial transmogrification device extend to authors photos too?). And that right there is a microcosm of the show's treatment of the Wells situation post-Season 3.

-

Are there any other Arrowverse plot holes that you noticed? Tell us in the comment section below.


The Flash Season 6 Quiz: How Well Do You Remember The First Half?

The Flash The Void
The CW

1. On Which Date Did The Flash Season 6 Premiere?

In this post: 
Arrowverse
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.