10 Plot Twists That Totally Ruined Awesome TV Shows

It was all going so well for these TV shows... until somebody decided to throw an unwanted, twist-shaped spanner into the works, that is.

A plot twist can be a wonderful thing, or it can be a facepalm-inducing kiss of death for a TV show. When writers get it right, it can breath new life into a tired formula and catch even the most devoted fans off guard, but if they screw up, longtime fans may end up feeling alienated and ultimately end up abandoning the show as a result. For every brilliant twist out there, there are some iconically awful ones which have been the mockery of fans and non-fans alike ever since. These twists failed for a variety of reasons, though the main reason is simple implausibility. The writers asked audiences to suspend their disbelief to such a ridiculous degree that the show ultimately collapsed under its own weight and was never the same again. Of course, if you disagree or feel that I've missed any major twists, let me know in the comments or forever hold your peace!

10. Prison Break - Everyone Goes To Sona (Season 2)

The first season of Prison Break was a superbly taut, intense depiction of prison life, as one man, Michael Scofield, desperately had himself inserted into a prison with the intent of breaking his brother, Lincoln Burrows, who is soon to be executed, out of the jail. The second season sees the Fox River escapees on the run, a surprisingly decent continuation of what came before, as William Fichtner is thrown into the mix as Alexander Mahone, a determined FBI Agent who stalks the gang like a Terminator. However, this was all promptly undone at the end of Season 2 when Michael, Mahone, Bellick were captured and sent to the PenitenciarĂ­a Federal de Sona, essentially sending the series back to square one in a lame attempt to drag things out further. Though the idea of Michael being imprisoned alongside his foes like Mahone and Bellick was refreshing, the jail scenario felt like a stop-gap while the writers caught their breath to figure out what to do next, and the show never really recovered. Additional twists in Season 3, such as Sara being dead (and as it turns out later, not being dead) indicated a writing team who didn't know what the Hell they were doing.

9. Nip/Tuck - Quentin Costa Is The Carver (Season 3)

Season 2 of the deliciously decadent Nip/Tuck introduced a serial rapist, disfigurer and occasional murderer in The Carver, an individual who disagreed strongly with the McNamara/Troy plastic surgery practice, and particularly how they would fix Carver victim's faces for free (he had a habit of cutting their face). This creepy ass figure made for an extremely compelling antagonist, a mystery which dominated the second and third seasons, culminating in the third season finale. Regrettably, FX accidentally leaked the spoiler by posting a picture on the press section of their website the day before the finale was to air, revealing that plastic surgeon Quentin Costa was the Carver, and cop Kit McGraw was his accomplice. Though fans such as myself dismissed the picture as a trick, it turned out to be true, and low and behold, the very next day Costa was revealed as the Carver. It was a disappointingly zany reveal, even for the standards of the show, largely because of the attempts made to convince us that it wasn't him, even declaring that he had no penis in the prior episode, to make us believe that he wasn't possible of being a rapist (apparently, he used a dildo). The shadow of The Carver hung over the show for a while, and in my opinion it never really found its footing again despite its best attempts to be as brilliantly scandalous as possible.

8. Roseanne - The Show Is Roseanne's Story (Season 9)

The final season of Roseanne begins with the Conner family winning the lottery, and the first half of the finale has the family discussing how their life changed following that win. Part 2, however, shifts the tone considerably, as Roseanne explains that it never really happened, and the show has essentially been the book she has been writing, based on her life but altered for parts she didn't like. For instance, the lottery win never happened, and rather than cheating on her, Dan actually died of a heart attack, and the couples throughout the show were actually swapped around, and it was in fact Mark and Darlene and Becky and David who were together. The show ends with Roseanne looking wistfully at the book and heading upstairs, ending on a curious downer and serious WTF that essentially undid much of what we knew and loved about the show. It's clear that the lottery storyline was a bit outlandish, but Dan's death just made everyone feel crappy, and the relationship switch-a-roo falsified too much of the course of the show.

7. Twin Peaks - Leland Palmer Killed Laura (Season 2)

David Lynch's Twin Peaks was one of the most talked about shows of the 1990s, wrapped in a compelling enigma about the murder of a beautiful young woman, Laura Palmer, and all of the local weirdos in the sleepy town of Twin Peaks who could have committed the crime. It set the standard for many lesser shows that followed, yet Lynch's constant back and forth with network ABC meant that his enthusiasm for the show began to wane, as was clear in the second season, where the mystery was dragged out for a seemingly interminable period before a sloppy resolve. It would have been easy to include the show's final twist, where Agent Cooper appears to have been taken over by demonic entity Bob, but at least that had the benefit of being vague, whereas the reveal that Laura Palmer was killed by her own father, Leland, while possessed by Bob, just came too damn early in the season and drained the audience's enthusiasm. By this point, much of the fanbase had already begun to abandon the show, and this was the final straw, really, yet the show ambled on for another 15 episodes despite the central mystery being resolved. It's not so much that the revelation itself was bad by any means, but that it was placed so poorly in terms of pacing. Or better yet, why wasn't Season 2 just 8 episodes long as well?

6. Sex And The City - Carrie Reunites With Big At The Last Minute (Season 6)

I appreciate that Sex and the City might not be on many people's "awesome TV show" lists, but the show was undeniably popular and connected with a lot of people. The back and forth over the course of the show's history was protagonist Carrie Bradshaw's relationship with a suave businessman known only as Mr. Big, who fleeted in and out of her life in between her various other relationships. The final season sees Carrie meet Aleksandr Petrovsky, a Russian artist and a man who appears to be everything that Big is not, yet just like Big, he too cannot pay attention to her when all-consuming work gets in the way. During a trip in Paris, Carrie breaks it off with Aleksandr, at which point, Big oh-so-conveniently arrives in Paris and finally commits to Carrie for good. A final montage also reveals that Big's real name is John. The problem I had with this twist is that a) it was extremely predictable, even though we were meant to be surprised by it and b) I never really felt like Carrie belonged with Big. The two of them seem so different, and frankly, Big seems like a bit of a douche, so why would I be happy that they got their happily ever after (which was then dragged out again over two feature films)? Not that I really wanted Carrie to get with Aleksandr either, mind.

5. Buffy The Vampire Slayer - Buffy Has A Sister (Season 5)

Season 5 of Buffy the Vampire Slayer saw the extremely sloppy introduction of Buffy's sister Dawn, as the series' history was retconned and all of the characters acted as though Dawn had basically been there the whole time. While I can't knock Michelle Trachtenberg's performance in the role or the relationship developed between Dawn and Buffy, the matter of fact audacity of blatantly shoving this down the audience's throat didn't sit well with me or many of the show's fans. Eventually we came to deal with it, but for me it did taint the rest of the show in a negative way, for she was a constant reminder of the power writers have to talk down to their audience and do things "just because". Though Whedon apparently added Dawn to the show to give Buffy an emotional connection that wasn't rooted in romance or sex, surely there was a more subtle and less destructive way to do this?

4. 24 - Tony Isn't Dead (Season 7)

In 24's fifth season, beloved Soul Patch himself, Tony Almeida, was stabbed through the heart with a needle by series baddie Christopher Henderson and dies soon thereafter. However, Season 7 takes a drastic measure even for the standards of the show, by announcing that Tony was alive and well, and had aligned himself with a terrorist group. Henderson intentionally missed stabbing Tony in the heart and somehow managed to turn him, despite us seeing Jack cradling Tony's body in said season 5 episode. Henderson's people took Tony's body and revived him from death, turning him, but it's revealed later that Tony is in fact a double agent, and has been working with Bill Buchanan and Chloe O'Brian the whole time to uncover corrupt American officials. Hilariously, once Jack and Tony then destroy some chemical weapons, it's revealed that Tony was in fact working with the terrorists, although we find out later it was only in order to kill the man who caused his wife Michelle Dessler (and their unborn son) to be killed in season 5. Though season 6 is the creative low point of the show, season 7 indulged one too many twists for its own good, and as much as I love Tony, I wish he had stayed dead rather than be tampered with in such a careless fashion. He will, apparently, be returning for Live Another Day, though.

3. Lost - The Island Has A Cork That Stops It From Sinking (Season 6)

I don't think any show in TV history has hinged on plot twists as much as Lost, for almost every episode featured a shocking twist or revelation of some kind. The final season seemed to be wrapping up nicely, and though many found the final twists and turns to be unsatisfactory, the one that annoyed me the most was the revelation that the metaphorical "cork" that had been discussed throughout the show's history was in fact a physical cork in the "heart" of the island. The finale reveals that there is a giant cork in the heart of the island, and is about as silly as Lost ever got (with the "tunnel of light" being a close second), with Desmond removing it and bringing the island within moments of sinking, which would cause a global catastrophe. Jack manages to re-insert the cork and save the island, but by this point I had given up on the show giving us a satisfactory reveal and I just started laughing at what was an abject failure of resolution. Because of the tunnel, the cork and the hug-fest in the church at the end, Lost was forever tainted to me as a show that couldn't live up to its own lofty ambitions and hype.

2. Dallas - Season 9 Was All A Dream (Season 10)

At the end of Dallas season 8, Bobby Ewing dies of massive internal injuries after being hit by a car, yet the end of season 9 completely retcons this by revealing Bobby alive and well in Pam's shower, the almighty WTF of twist endings. Season 10 reveals that Bobby's death and the events of season 9 were all a dream, creating an iconic moment of TV history and easily one of the most maligned and famously joked about twists of all time. The absurd nature of the show's melodrama had reached an all time high, and for many fans and critics, this simply proved too much to handle. The problem with a twist this manipulative is that the writers lose the trust of the audience, because now how can the audience believe anything they see? If the writers feel like it, they could try another rug pull, and so it's difficult to become as invested in the drama with that fear. Still, the show ambled on up to season 14 before finally concluding.

1. St. Elsewhere - The Entire Show Takes Place In The Mind Of An Autistic Kid (Season 6)

Though Dallas' twist is more famous, St. Elsewhere's twist wins for its sheer, hilarious contempt for its audience, as though the writers thought, "How can we upset our audience so much that they'll hate the show forever more?" The final scene shall go down in history as the most aggressive middle finger to an audience in TV history, as it is revealed that the entire show's events appeared to have taken place inside the mind of Director of Medicine Donald Westphall's autistic son Tommy. Furthermore, Donald is in fact a construction worker rather than the Director of Medicine, and the character of Daniel Auschlander turns out to be Donald's father. The most famous imagery involves Donald placing a snow globe that Tommy was holding on top of their TV set, at which point we see that the globe contains a replica of St. Eligius, the very hospital in which the series is set. Minds the world over were blown, and even if you can appreciate the darkly comic merit of such a twist, it has ultimately overshadowed the serious quality of the show, particularly as far as acting and writing are concerned. Are there any other horrendous plot twists I missed? Let me know!

Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.