10 Potential TV Castings We’re SO Glad Didn’t Happen

Matthew Broderick as the one who knocks? Nah...

Matthew Broderick Breaking Bad
AMC/WC

Following on from the recent film 10 potential castings we’re so glad didn’t happen, the world of TV is littered with alternate castings which could have tanked hit shows too. Now that we’ve seen what a success these ten shows were, it’s interesting to look back on where they might have gone very wrong.

Not that all these castings would have been awful, per se. In some cases, the actor not cast was kept on hold, eventually getting a part elsewhere in the series which they nailed into the floorboards. Other times though, the near miss is so bizarre you’ll be thanking your lucky stars.

There’s several TV shows which have been carried by their performances; great acting can make poor scripts decent. Some of these shows though are amongst the most critically acclaimed of all time, so messing with that formula is definitely something to avoid.

Also, with the likes of Game Of Thrones and Friends auditioning so many stars they could each fill the list on their own, it’s limited to one per series here, just to keep things a bit more interesting.

10. Pamela Anderson As Dana Scully (The X-Files)

Pamela Anderson Cj Parker
Paramount

Kicking off with a weird one, and a rare example of studio meddling being a universally positive move. When Chris Carter wrote the original first script, Pamela Anderson was the only woman on his mind; the script was specifically written for her.

This draft focussed more on her struggling to be taken seriously, the sexism and misogyny in the FBI and Scully’s supermodel looks. A mixture of discrimination, blonde jokes and the glass ceiling saw her promising career derailed when she was paired with Spooky Mulder on The X-Files.

Fox (the studio, not Mulder) didn’t think Pamela Anderson was the right person for the project though, and insisted on Carter auditioning other actresses. Once he saw a different Anderson, Gillian, read for the role, he changed his tune immediately.

The script was retooled to be grittier, focussing on Scully’s medical training and tenacity. Scully became less of a caricature, and evolved into one of the most well rounded characters in sci fi television history.

Gillian Anderson’s brilliant deadpan delivery proved to be the perfect partner with David Duchovny’s dry sarcasm, and the pair developed one of the best dynamics on television.


9. Matt LeBlanc As Phil Dunphy (Modern Family)

Joey Hugsy
NBC

Modern Family isn’t for everyone. It’s a throwback TV sitcom, with classic setups, cheesy wit and ridiculous set pieces. It follows on from the ‘90s laugh track comedy of Friends, mixing it with a mockumentary style storytelling which they use and avoid in equal measure whenever necessary.

If you can look past the slightly camp, almost dated vibe of the jokes through, it’s a seriously funny show with a great cast. With bagfuls of Emmys to its name, it’s one of the most successful TV comedies ever too.

With this ‘90s inspiration, it’s no wonder they turned to a superstar of the era when casting. Matt LeBlanc was offered the role of goofy dad Phil Dunphy, but turned it down, thinking he was wrong for the part.

Phil has well meaning childishness, unstoppable enthusiasm and lack of common sense, so it’s a role with a lot of similarity to LeBlanc’s Joey from Friends. Considering the huge success Ty Burrell had in the role, his decision to turn it down was probably for the best.

In the end, Ed O’Neill as Phil’s father in law Jay ended up being the sitcom veteran who held the cast together.


8. Ray Liotta As Tony Soprano (The Sopranos)

narc ray liotta
Paramount

Given that Ray Liotta’s career hasn’t exactly sparkled in the past 25 years or so, you have to wonder if the Goodfellas star regretted his decision to turn down seminal TV drama The Sopranos. The show is hailed with ushering in the golden age of high quality television drama, but Liotta wanted no part of it.

He was scouted by producers for the crime drama, but decided against even auditioning, fearing playing Tony Soprano so soon after Goodfellas would see him typecast as a one note guy. It’s an understandable decision; typecasting has stalled many a star’s career. In Liotta’s case though, he might be wishing he’d let himself be typecast now.

After Liotta turned them down, showrunner David Chase changed tactics. He decided to go for a relatively unknown actor, one without typical Hollywood good looks, and cast James Gandolfini. This decision paid off handsomely as The Sopranos became a huge hit off the back of Gandolfini’s performance.

Sopranos writer Matthew Weiner would later repeat this trick of casting an unknown star with Jon Hamm as Don Draper in his own show, Mad Men; another decision which turned out to be genius.


7. Richard Lewis As Mork (Happy Days/Mork & Mindy)

Richard Lewis Robin Hood Men In Tights
20th Century Fox

Nothing against Richard Lewis with this one. The New York comedian has had a strong stand up career and did a fantastic job in Robin Hood: Men In Tights amongst many other things.

However, considering the role of Mork went to Robin Williams and ended up launching his career, it’s hard to see Lewis as anything other than a downgrade. With so much comedy talent, it’s likely Williams would have gotten his big break elsewhere even if he had missed out, but it’s better not to take that chance.

Without Williams playing Mork, we might not have gotten his Genie, his Mrs. Doubtfire, his Patch Adams, his Teddy Roosevelt and countless other hilarious roles. Playing Mork in Happy Days before spinning off into his own show, the role was only Williams’ sixth ever credit.

He went on to have a huge standup career was well as breaking into Hollywood for major roles, moving on to more serious films later in his career. Had Richard Lewis been able to do an alien voice, he might never have gotten the chance though.

Lewis’ unconvincing space accent (it sounded Danish, Lewis admits in his autobiography) saw producers look elsewhere, giving Williams a chance to shine.


6. Hank Azaria As Joey (Friends)

Friends Hank Azaria
NBC

There were quite a few notable actors who auditioned for Friends. Courtney Cox initially read for Rachel, as did Leah Remini and Jane Krakowski, while Ellen DeGeneres auditioned for Phoebe and Vince Vaughn for Joey. Jon Cryer also turned down the role of Chandler, so it could have been very different bunch.

Arguably the best casting not to happen though was voice of Moe Szyslak: Hank Azaria as Joey. Not because Azaria would have been bad in the role, but because him missing out allowed him to be later cast as David the Scientist, one of the best recurring love interests in the show.

Azaria was so interested in the role he auditioned twice. The first time he felt he blew it, so when he heard they were still looking a couple of weeks later, tried again. It was this second go around which kept producers interested and eventually got him a phone call about the role of David.

Azaria has since admitted feeling a little bitter watching the first series; on a rewatch, most fans would admit the earliest season doesn’t hold up. He was turned around by the second season though, and ended up playing a fantastic part.


5. Adam Scott As Jim Halpert (The Office)

Twilight Zone Nightmare At 30 000 Feet Adam Scott Headphones
CBS

Just like Hank Azaria previously, this is a great example of a strong audition getting you a part further down the road, even if it’s not the one you auditioned for. Unlike Azaria though, in Adam Scott’s case, it wasn’t even on the same show.

John Krasinski ended up getting the role of Jim, and with how iconic his role in The Office has become, it’s clear the casting directors made the right call.

Nobody could’ve Jim’ed the camera as well as Krasinski, when all’s said and done, and its difficult to imagine Scott and Jenna Fischer’s Pam building as good a dynamic as Fischer and Krasinski did.

Not that Scott can’t build dynamics well. The audition for Jim ended up getting Adam Scott cast in a lead role in The Office’s pseudo sister show, Parks & Recreation.

On that, he connected with Amy Poehler’s Leslie Knope as well as Krasinski did with Fischer. It’s not so much that Adam Scott would’ve been a bad a Jim, more that by skipping over him we got a great Jim in John Krasinski and got to see Adam Scott do a fantastic job in Parks & Recreation to boot.


4. Chris Rock As George Costanza (Seinfeld)

The Week Of Chris Rock
Netflix

This one is just an absolute mismatch. Seinfeld is one of the greatest sitcoms ever, and Chris Rock is one of the funniest comedians around when he’s on form. Considering Jerry Seinfeld and Larry David set out to make a show about standups coming up with bits for their act, he seems like a perfect fit.

The fact is though, he just isn’t. Maybe it’s because Jason Alexander was irreplaceably hilarious in the role, but Chris Rock’s energy just seems completely wrong for the part. He’s far too up there; all excitement, drama and body language. He wouldn’t be the worst Kramer in the world, come to think of it. But as George? He’s practically the antithesis.

With Seinfeld’s dry delivery, Kramer’s eccentricity and Julia Louise-Dreyfus’ Elaine’s wit, throwing Chris Rock’s hyperactivity in there just rocks the boat. Jason Alexander’s subtler brand of humour beds into the cast much more naturally.

As well as Rock and Alexander, Danny DeVito was also in the running. He feels like he’s much closer to what the show needed, but it still feels like Alexander was definitely the way to go.


3. Katie Holmes As Buffy Summers (Buffy The Vampire Slayer)

Katie Holmes Batman Begins Rachel Dawes
Warner Bros.

Katie Holmes is best known for two things: marrying Tom Cruise and getting recast in Batman. Neither are things to be especially proud of, and now she can add a third to that list of lowlights; just missing out on the lead in one of the most iconic shows of the late ‘90s.

Katie Holmes was in the frame to play Buffy in Buffy The Vampire Slayer, a role which went on to be played fantastically by Sarah Michelle Gellar. It would have been Holmes’ first screen role ever, but by missing out she was able to star in Dawson’s Creek instead.

She followed up Dawson’s Creek with good performances in flawed movies, like Phone Booth, Pieces Of April and Wonder Boys.

Once she met (and seven weeks later, got engaged to) Tom Cruise though, her career pumped the breaks almost immediately. Between ‘05-‘08, she didn’t act at all.

Gellar’s career has floundered somewhat since then, starring in relative misses like Scooby Doo, Ringer and The Grudge. Still, Buffy is a character with a massive legacy, and it owes a great deal to Sarah Michelle Gellar’s performance.


2. Matthew Broderick As Walter White (Breaking Bad)

Matthew Broderick Breaking Bad
AMC

A lot of the entries here offer interesting alternate universe castings. LeBlanc in Modern Family, Scott in The Office and Azaria in Friends would all have still been enjoyable, even if the casting we actually got was far superior.

With Matthew Broderick as Walter White though? We can consider this a serious bullet dodged.

It’s true that both Broderick and eventual castee Bryan Cranston made their names in comedy, with Broderick best known for things like Ferris Bueller’s Day Off, The Cable Guy and Inspector Gadget. He did have some serious experience, but it was severely limited.

The Stepford Wives is one of the few standouts of his career, and The Cable Guy was originally much darker until he and Jim Carrey combined to give it a comedy tilt. Cranston meanwhile was best known for Malcolm In The Middle, though he had featured in the likes of Saving Private Ryan previously.

The decision to go with a comedy actor did lull audiences in and made Walter’s transition to Heisenberg all the more compelling. Broderick though didn’t want to play a bad guy (neither did John Cusack, also scouted) so Cranston stepped in and delivered an irreplaceable masterclass.


1. Iwan Rheon As Jon Snow (Game Of Thrones)

Game Of Thrones Ramsay.jpg
HBO

Like Adam Scott and Hank Azaria before him, Iwan Rheon is a fantastic actor who was saved for the perfect role after a stellar audition where he just missed out. Rheon initially auditioned for Jon Snow on Game Of Thrones, but ended up making a name for himself as arguably the show’s best villain, Ramsay Bolton.

There’s stiff competition from Tywin Lannister and Joffrey Baratheon, but Ramsay more than holds his own.

As the evil Bolton bastard, Rheon took delight in torturing Theon Greyjoy, managing to be comically manic and devilishly sinister all at once. His every appearance on screen made your skin crawl, with Rheon stealing the show every time.

As well as Rheon’s fantastic turn as Ramsay, you can’t discuss this casting without bringing up Kit Harington too.

Despite Game Of Thrones having a huge cast, it was clear as it reached the latter stages that Harington’s Snow and Emilia Clarke’s Daenerys Targaryen were in the driving seat. Though the final season saw him saddled with poor, flat, repetitive lines, that shouldn’t sully the magnificent performance he put in over the course of the series.

He was a brilliant Jon Snow, and it’s hard to imagine anyone else in the role.


Watch Next


Breaking Bad Quiz: Who Said It - Walter White Or Jesse Pinkman?

Walt Breaking Bad
AMC

1. I Did It For Me. I Liked It. I Was Good At It. And I Was Really… I Was Alive.

In this post: 
Breaking Bad
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Self appointed queen of the SJWs. Find me on Twitter @FiveTacey (The 5 looks like an S. Do you get it? Do you get my joke about the 5?)