10 Problems With Constantine That Got It Cancelled

Did the Hellblazer deserve to be snuffed out?

Another day, another cult TV show with a small but dedicated audience cut down before it could achieve its full potential. Despite attempts to try and resurrect it with another network (or possibly a streaming service like Hulu or Netflix), it appears that NBC cancelling Constantine after its first season was the only nail needed to close the coffin. What, exactly, went wrong? Whilst Constantine never set the ratings alight €“ which is the main factor in these decisions for the most part €“ it did manage to do a better job adapting the source material than previous attempts, and it quickly earned itself a fandom that were as distraught by the show's end as they were delighted by its existence. Based on the long-running DC Comics series Hellblazer, the show managed to take the built-in audience from the source material and expand to to... well, not as many regular TV viewers as they needed to keep going, but still a fair few. There were some major speed bumps along the way which may have sealed its fate, however Besides the low ratings, of course, there were also some casting decisions that may have spoilt thinks slightly, choices made about the translation from page to screen, and some lingering ill will from a certain previous Hellblazer adaptation. All factored into the ten problems with Constantine that (probably) got it cancelled.

10. Not Letting Him Smoke

A considerable amount of things changed about John Constantine in the translation from page to screen. An early paragon of DC's mature readers Vertigo line, the Hellblazer comic book allowed writers and artists to get away with a lot: the characters smoked, drank, gouged people's eyes out, swore a lot, that sort of thing. So the sort of things that apparently don't translate so well to the small screen, at least if you're a regular network (i.e. not HBO or AMC or something). Despite being the same channel that airs Hannibal on a weekly basis, NBC were apparently cagey about some of the more grown-up affectations comic book Constantine had. Such as, say, smoking. It seems like a small thing, but the Hellblazer's several-packs-a-day habit was a good visual shorthand for his devil-may-care attitude and self-destructive streak, and its effects on his health provided good fodder for storylines in the comics later on. This early lack of commitment to the character's core qualities didn't bode well.

9. A TV Budget

The beauty of Hellblazer is that John Constantine lives in both the squalor of derelict inner cities as he does in the phantasmagorical otherworlds from which demons, vampires, ghosts and all other manner of supernatural beings leap from. He's a regular Liverpudlian in a trenchcoat, using his street smarts to banish monsters to Hell. Doing the former is extremely easy to achieve on screen. You just go to a city (in most cases Vancouver, for those sweet sweet tax breaks) and you film there. For John and his human friends, you just need to cast regular people, too. When it starts to get tricky is when the bad guys begin bursting out of pentagrams and the like. It costs money to do somebody up like a devil, or stick a pair of angel wings on Michael from Lost. Money that doesn't really get thrown around a lot in television productions, meaning whenever the bizarre sight of something supernatural burst through into the real world the reaction wasn't so much shocking as €œerm, is that it?€

8. The Last Live Action Constantine

It gets a lot of stick, but the previous live action adaptation was a decent film. It was just a terrible Constantine film. Whilst the TV series simply abandoned his smoking habit, the movie starred Keanu Reeves as a dark-haired, suit-wearing, American magician-for-hire who hangs out with his cabbie sidekick Shia LaBeouf and fancies Rachel Weisz. The film basically carried over nothing from the comics - there was even a half-hearted swipe in the comics, with derisive mention of an alternate-reality Constantine being a handsome yank. As with the TV show, the film boasted the name Constantine rather than Hellblazer, which is still considered too close to the Clive Barker series Hellraiser. That means that most audiences will have associated the Constantine series with that film, which they either thought was naff, and avoided, or liked and were disappointed to find this wasn't the same.

7. Ignoring Stories From The Comics

Whilst it made considerable changes, the Constantine film at least drew on the source material for its basic plot: specifically, the €œDangerous Habits€ and €œOriginal Sins€ story lines from the Hellblazer comics. For the most part, the TV show decided to come up with its own stories, foregoing the 300-odd issues it had to draw upon. Now, obviously not all of those comics were that good. In fact some of them were downright clunkers, with Brian Azarello and Andy Diggle's runs writing Hellblazer most commonly singled out for being a bit naff. They were still a damn sight better than some of the stuff Constantine's writing team came up with over the first season, though. In the Hellblazer comics, con artist John Constantine has his ups and downs, but mainly downs €“ most people hate him, he has to make difficult decisions, and deals with horrors both inhuman and frighteningly familiar. In Constantine, he listens to haunted records and chases after magical MacGuffins like €œantediluvian crystals€. Less than inspired.

6. Not Being Supernatural

That major change might very well be down to the how the genre that Hellblazer helped define has evolved over the years. It was John Constantine's influence that practically set the rules for modern occult detective fiction, and you can see that influence in basically everything in that sub-genre that's come since. Especially in Supernatural. The constant stream of devilish baddies to deal with, the sexual tension, the propensity towards suits and tan trenchcoats? Yeah, almost everything the Winchester brothers have dealt with in their ten seasons (wow, has it really been ten seasons?) has been very much inspired by aspects of the Hellblazer mythology. Constantine, meanwhile, tossed aside the Hellblazer influence in favour of chasing the Supernatural one. That's why it makes John more of a loveable rogue than an actual bastard, why it centralises his relationship with Zed and why Manny is basically Castiel. But Constantine isn't Supernatural and, well, Supernatural already exists. We don't need another.

5. Or Grimm, For That Matter

Whilst NBC obviously didn't explicitly state Constantine was supposed to follow the template set down by Supernatural, they very much did push the show as a companion piece to their other mystical procedural series. Grimm debuted in 2011 and, unlike Constantine, it's currently gearing up for its fifth season. How come Grimm gets to live when Constantine was on the chopping block after its first thirteen-episode run? Well, for one thing, as much as they tried and beat Hellblazer into a recognisable Grimm/Supernatural shape (and thus with a wide enough appeal to bring in a big audience), there's still enough in the original source material that resists that reformatting. For another, the fact that Grimm existed meant that Constantine was surplus to requirements. Fans only have room for so many supernatural dramas in their life (and on their DVR). Between Grimm, Supernatural, Once Upon A Time, the Once Upon A Time spin-off, and Sleepy Hollow... well, it didn't bring all that much different to the table.

4. The Curse Of NBC

That blame can't all be laid at the door of the people who made Constantine, though. They were just a group of people out to make the best show they could; it was NBC who didn't realise that perhaps the market for brooding men surrounded by demons and angels is perhaps a little over-saturated at the moment. Tumblr can only hold so many gifs. NBC isn't really in the business of making good decisions as of late. Or ever. The network's fortunes have been slowly nosediving since the turn of the millennium, occasionally buoyed by surprise hits like the US adaptation of The Office, but just as often dragged down by decisions like carrying that show on for about four seasons too long. At times, NBC seems like it's simply a cursed network. They cancel shows like Community, the likes of Parks And Recreation struggle on for their entire existence, whilst the powers-that-be greenlight obvious duds like Animal Practice, about a monkey who works in a hospital. That is a real show that happened. Constantine never stood a chance.

3. No Politics

One of the most surprising things about reading the early Hellblazer comics is quite how politically charged they were. An early story line from Jamie Delano's run, written at the height of Thatcher's government in the UK, had John Constantine fighting Tories who were demons literally stealing the souls of the working classes. Very subtle. Something so brazen coming out of a major US publisher €“ and something so specific to British culture coming out in a different country €“ remains a coup. But Constantine's lefty leanings have shot through the entire run of the comics, speaking to his empathetic nature that leads him to helping those in need, even when he'd rather not. The Constantine TV show, meanwhile, was loathe to mention any hot-button topics. The politics are yet another thing that differentiate John Constantine from other occult detectives, and losing that meant he lost one of his defining characteristics.

2. Hiring A Welshman

With apologies to Matt Ryan, who did the best he could with the material and certainly looked the part, he appeared to spend a lot of his time on-screen in Constantine trying to mask his natural Welsh accent. The Hellblazer has always been a scouser, through and through. It was commendable they didn't follow the film route of making him American, but plumping for an actor from Wales felt a bit like, €œwell, he's from the United Kingdom. That's close enough, right?€ As much as they took great pains to do Ryan up like the comic character €“ bleaching his hair, putting him in the classic trenchcoat get up, albeit looking a little too clean €“ they fell at the final hurdle. It was difficult to ever quite buy Ryan as John Constantine. Not that his accent was bad, just that it felt a bit €œgeneric English€ that any specific dialect, and it was always clear that it wasn't his natural form of speak. Where the rest of his performance was fine, it was always at odds with the voice he was delivering it in.

1. Making John Constantine Boring

Translating John Constantine from the page to the screen seemed to involve a lot of unexplained, unnecessary tweaks and changes. Some things were kept in tact, but his misanthropy, scouse accent, smoking habit, and even his bisexuality all went out the window. You know, all the things that made him interesting. The latter change was especially egregious, given the lack of representation for bisexual characters in almost any popular fiction. The whole point of John Constantine is that he's a bit of a self-destructive sort who will give into carnal pleasures whenever he can. And, honestly, a guy who's seen some weird stuff isn't going to be your vanilla hetro hero. As with the smoking, all of these changes were symptomatic of a larger problem: sanding down all the character's rough edges to make him a palatable TV star. But John Constantine without the rough edges isn't anything at all. It's the rough edges that made him a compelling character in the first place. He's kind of an asshole who only helps people begrudgingly, is a total slut, and who will just as likely condemn a good soul to Hell if it means he can knock off early. Without that he's just Dean Winchester. And you can't blame viewers for preferring to watch him. Why do you think Constantine was cancelled? Share your thoughts down in the comments.

In this post: 
Constantine
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/