10 Problems With The X-Files Revival Nobody Wants To Admit
The truth is still out there, but it won't be easy to find
One of the most popular shows of the 90s is returning to network television in early 2016. The X-Files makes its long awaited return in a format no one expected: a six episode "revival" on FOX. While many were eagerly awaiting a third X-Files movie to tie up the loose ends the show (and second film) left dangling, or a Next Generation-style second series, few expected Fox to outright launch a continuation of the show.
Yet in a pleasant surprise, that's exactly what they're getting: six new episodes with all of the original cast intact, much of the writer's room, and series creator Chris Carter at the helm. It's not the large pick-up of episodes that another cult hit, Twin Peaks, got for its new season, but The X-Files was always one of the most expensive shows on the air, and it's likely this new, shortened season won't come cheap for FOX.
However, FOX is motivated by profits, and a new season will make one of their most beloved franchises even more valuable in syndication, especially on streaming services like Netflix.
And so a new batch of adventures for Mulder and Scully await - but beware, the comeback is not without its share of problems. Here are ten that could put a damper on the festivities.
10. The Smoking Man Is Dead
The Smoking Man is dead. Gone. Done. Fin.
CGB Spender, the Cigarette Smoking Man, was the Darth Vader of The X-Files. One of the greatest TV villains of all time, his portrayal by William B. Davis was near-perfect, giving fans an iconic antagonist for Mulder. And while he had more lives than a cat, surviving several assassination attempts carried out by his fellow conspirators, in the finale of the series, he died.
Without question. Even if Chris Carter claims that no one really dies on The X-Files.
Simply put, a rocket launched from a helicopter hit him square in the face. Fans watched the flesh burn from his bones, leaving a maniacally evil grinning skull behind.
Why, then, has William B. Davis been added to the cast of the revival? While he was a huge part of the show, his story is, frankly, over, and any return by the Cancer Man would seem forced. Davis is still an active participant in genre fare even as he approaches his 80s, so there's no question about his abilities, but short of flashbacks, how would he even take part? IMDB (not the most accurate at times) has him listed as taking part in all six episodes, which seems unlikely, but anything more than a cameo in a flashback becomes problematic.
9. Six Episodes Are Not Enough
The X-Files left a lot of loose ends when it went off the air, and 2008's I Want To Believe didn't exactly clear anything up - though it did pave the way for Mulder and Scully to return to the FBI.
Still, you have an alien colonization plotline. The fate of baby WIlliam. Super soldiers. The did they/didn't they, are they/aren't they relationship status of Mulder and Scully. The fate of the Lone Gunmen (revealed in the X-Files comics to still be alive, something many fans are eager to see on-screen).
Not to mention one off episodes like Home, which were open-ended and could be revisited during the revival.
That's a lot of ground to cover. A whole lot. And every little segment of the fanbase has its own idea of what the show should focus on in the six hours (minus commercial breaks) the series will air in 2016.
You can't please all the people all the time however, and the producers have a heck of a balancing act to pull off here.
8. The Colonization Storyline Will Get Even Less Time
As already confirmed by none other than David Duchovny himself, the X-Files revival will feature a mix of Monster of the Week episodes (shortened to MOTW, basically standalone supernatural tales) and mythology episodes - the driving force behind the show. The mythology features the ongoing story of alien abduction, colonization, and the conspiracy the keep the truth from the public at large.
Not to mention a plot by shadowy government figures to aid in colonization in exchange for their survival, a secondary plot to create a vaccine against the virus that will eventually come to enslave humanity (before it gestates, turning the human host into an incubator as a living extraterrestrial biological entity grows inside it), the replacement of key human figures by alien replicants (who are passed off by some as human super soldiers), the creation of alien/human hybrids as something of a slave race, and an alien rebellion by other extraterrestrials working to fight the colonists.
And all that barely scratches the surface of the colonization storyline.
Think that can all be wrapped up neatly in under six episodes? Think again. Even with the full six, which the show won't get since it will feature Monster of the Week outings, it would be a stretch. That's a big problem for mythology fans, of which there are many.
7. There's No Pleasing X-Philes
Sadly, the X-Files fanbase - known as X-Philes - is a kingdom divided. That goes back to the early years of the show, but the conflict between "sides" really reared its ugly head towards the end of David Duchovny's run as a series regular. Season 7, his last as a full-time player, happens to generally be regarded as the low point of the show. The tone changed, from dark and moody to lighthearted and comical in more than a few episodes. Duchovny looked bored, mailing it in for many an episode. Fans were growing tired of the "will they or won't they" Mulder/Scully dynamic.
The problem: the two sides - Shippers (those who wanted a Mulder and Scully relationship, and the origin of the term 'shipping') and NoRomos (those who wanted nothing to do with the romantic side of the show) wound up in heated battles over the course of the show. As events onscreen were drawn out, fans began to drop off on both sides. By the time the mostly-Duchovny-less season 9 rolled around, viewership was at its lowest levels since the early years. A shame, since Robert Patrick did an excellent job as Agent Doggett in seasons 8/9, but fans of the romance (the aforementioned shippers) attacked the character, and actor, in posts online.
The revival will have a hard time catering to both sides.
6. Fans May Need A Refresher
It's been a long time since the X-Files, as a series, was in its original run on television. While 2008 saw the second film, The X-Files: I Want To Believe, it was buried in the wake of the massive hit that was Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight.
On top of that, it was a standalone movie that picked up years after the show left off, and didn't really revisit a lot of the show's history. If you weren't an up-to-date fan of the series, you'd probably feel a little lost in the film. If you were a brand new fan? Then who the heck was the bald guy making the save at the end?
Well, that won't fly on TV these days. The X-Files aired its final episode May 19th, 2002. While it has been available on DVD for ages (early sets sold especially well), and can be streamed, the show will have to gamble that enough fans will take a little refresher course prior to tuning in - otherwise, with just six episodes and little time for recaps, those who haven't got caught up may quickly tune out.
5. It May Try To Ignore A Lot Of Late Season Developments
The final X-Files seasons took a lot of criticism over three things: the lack of David Duchovny, the Baby William storyline, and the addition of new characters.
The WIlliam storyline was the most valid complaint. Any time a show adds an infant, it feels like a ratings grab. In this case, it was also a distraction - something to keep the focus on Mulder and Scully without Mulder even being there.
Duchovny, meanwhile, was clearly bored of the show, and as much as it may seem sacrilege, his presence probably wouldn't have helped things. Which leaves the addition of new characters: John Doggett. Monica Reyes. Brad Follmer.
While Follmer was never really developed, Doggett and Reyes were. Production company 1013 no doubt hoped they would be a new Mulder and Scully. Robert Patrick's Doggett, in hindsight, was exactly what the show needed - but fans at the time weren't ready to accept him, despite a Saturn Award winning portrayal. Reyes (Annabeth Gish), meanwhile, was a little too new-agey: a character who made Mulder seem grounded.
Given the misguided distaste for these new characters, the revival may try to bury all mention of them - which would be a mistake. If nothing else, Robert Patrick earned his place in The X-Files cannon, and was the highlight of many late-season episodes (including the spectacular ninth season episode John Doe).
4. The Lone Gunmen Are Not Dead
Tech News stalwart Slashdot posted one of the most infamous spoilers in the history of the web by running with the headline "The Lone Gunmen are dead" prior to the season nine episode featuring their fate aired back in 2002. While they would later try and rectify that with a "The Lone Gunmen Are Not Dead" headline, that merely referred to a vision/hallucination Mulder was having in which they would appear.
However, a key part of the extended universe of The X-Files has been their return: they, in fact, faked their deaths.
While actor Dean Haglund has said he expects to get a call from Chris Carter, there's no word on the popular trio's return, there has been no official word as of yet, and no on-set sightings. The Lone Gunmen, in addition to having their own short-lived spin-off, were a big part of the show, always popular with fans, and were there from season one all the way to the end.
Not having them turn up, especially since the comics tell us that they're alive, would be a big problem for many fans.
3. The Writers Were Never That Great At Providing Closure
One of the great failings of the show (which, it should be noted, remains as one of the greatest sci-fi/paranormal television series of all time, and was hugely influential both inside and outside of its genre) was its inability to wrap things up and provide closure.
Take, for example, the Samantha storyline - the abduction of Fox Mulder's sister by aliens, an event he witnessed as a young boy, and which led him to take up his crusade against the government conspiracy to keep the existence of aliens under wraps.
The show dragged this story on for seven long years, bringing in multiple alien clones of Samantha as red herrings, eventually revealing Mulder's father, Bill Mulder, had been somewhat complicit in her disappearance, and then throwing a last minute curve ball in season seven's Closure, where it was revealed that Samantha had been dead for years. Oh, but not before her spirit somehow escaped/was rescued by beings of starlight called walk-ins, or something.
Closure, as an episode, offered anything but. Other than proving that the writers didn't really seem to know where they were going. That's not something that will fly in the new revival. Modern audiences have come to have a higher standard thanks to HBO dramas and the like.
2. Television Viewing Habits Have Changed
In a world where binge watching is the preferred viewing method of many genre fans, will a weekly revival of a classic show really work?
Or will the six episodes of The X-Files due to air in 2016, which are currently filming in Vancouver, B.C., where the first five years of the show and both movies were shot, wind up leaking online? You know, similar to how the first four episodes of Game of Thrones' fifth season did?
Are audiences patient enough to go back to watching a show like this week after week? Will eager fans wind up spoiling the coming out party for the 90s sci-fi juggernaut?
There are a lot of problems with doing a six week series: it's not a one off, so there is some commitment, but it's airing at a time that will take it into February sweeps. Viewers who are set in their habits may not tune in, while viewers who really want to see it may wait and binge (or not wait, and binge, if the show does leak). Meanwhile, new viewers may not care if they're not hooked from the very first episode.
How will the Netflix generation take to the series? That's may be a huge factor in the show's success.
1. There Are Too Many Stories To Tell
It's been said before, just a few pages back really, but it bears repeating: six episodes aren't enough.
However, it's not just a matter of existing storylines from the original series. There are also simply too many stories to tell beyond that. Stories that include the comics, which have been relatively successful, the X-Files novels (of which there are six originals), plus several juvenile/young adult series. Some of those would make for great television.
Not to mention all the story ideas the U.S. government (and others) have served up on large platters in recent years with actions like the NSA wiretapping scandal, something that can easily tie in to future X-Files episodes.
The greatest problem the show may face, in the end, is deciding what to focus on for the series' return.
Fans, however, will find out soon enough: the first episode, My Struggle, premieres on January 24, 2016.