10 Problems With Westworld Nobody Wants To Admit
The Next Game of Thrones? Err....
Game of Thrones has 6 episodes to go, which will air in 2019, and then it will go away forever. Given that GOT is the biggest TV show in the world, HBO obviously needs another program to fill in the gap, and they appear to have chosen Westworld for that formidable task. And, thus far, everyone has overwhelmingly praised Westworld and has described it as the next big TV show.
Here's the thing: Westworld is a three-star show at the most. It's not bad at all, but it certainly isn't a masterpiece. One can fall in love with its often masterful acting, stunning visuals, perfect score by Ramin 'Game of Thrones' Djawadi and big questions all they like, but there are a huge number of issues with Westworld that it gets away with.
Westworld is overdone, self-indulgent, overly slow and nowhere near as smart as it thinks it is. Are people just desperate for a new TV obsession now that Thrones is nearly gone?
There are many valid problems with Westworld that shouldn't be ignored. Mysteriously few reviews of the show have actually bothered to mention them.
Be warned, spoilers ahead for Westworld Season 1.
10. It Never Topped The Pilot
Initially it seemed like Westworld was going to live up to the hype, with its first episode, The Original, a very strong pilot episode on the whole.
It introduces the characters in all their brilliantly performed glory, establishes the world of the show with ease, and then drops some tantalizing hints about the direction in which Season 1 was going to go. Everyone will have been pulled right in by this intelligent story-telling, not to mention the great visuals and sheer epic scope of the entire thing.
While getting the pilot right is highly important, not topping the first part of a show is often fatal. That is exactly what happened with Westworld. The pilot episode kept things simple and had a more spectacle-based approach.
That would've been a good tone to stick to throughout Season One, since all the complexity and different layers ultimately became hugely exhausting. The excitement felt watching the pilot disappeared from memory as watching the show became a struggle to remember all the incomprehensible plot threads.
9. It's Bloated And Pretentious
One of Westworld's biggest plot elements was the Man in Black's search for the Maze... whatever that is. Eventually, it turned out the Maze wasn't even real and was more a symbol for the path of the hosts finding their consciousness within. This was a huge plot thread, which was one big red herring that led nowhere and didn't really say anything. That's a perfect metaphor for Westworld in general.
It's just a load of twists and puzzles that only lead to either nothing, or more twists and puzzles. Westworld insists on telling its audience ideas about AI and man playing god that they've heard many times before in the slowest and most convoluted way possible. Worst of all, the observations Westworld makes aren't even particularly deep or interesting. The observations about how being in the park can bring out the worst in people and the Hosts finding consciousness feel ideologically one-note and thematically predictable.
Nevertheless, these are interesting themes and always have been. Unfortunately, the show insists on smothering them beneath layers of flashbacks, arty visuals, red herrings and twists. It's so insistent on being arty and deep that it becomes painfully off-putting. There's just far too much material to absorb, and the show is so pretentious at times comparisons with Terrence Malick feel justified.
8. William Being The Man In Black Makes No Sense
The internet worked out that William was the Man in Black impressively quickly. For those who didn't read all the fan theories, this was a big shock and undeniably a clever rug pull. It's also a huge tragedy that such a gentle man turned into such a cold-blooded killer... or it would be, if it made any sense.
Given the ever-shifting timelines and incoherent storytelling, this was very confusing from the off. Given how convoluted it all is, it's surprising people on the internet were able to figure this out at all.
How could that mild-mannered guy turn into Ed Harris' brutal and at times terrifying villain? There should have been more hints in William's character to explain the darkness within him. When he did abruptly become a monster, it felt rushed. The biggest problem of all, however, is his motivations for breaking bad: his love for Delores.
People turning evil because of love is such a predictable and familiar plot device, and given that he didn't know Delores for very long and that she was just a robot he hung around with for a bit, this just felt like William being hugely immature and completely over-reacting. This character transition was simply ridiculous.
7. It's Actually Familiar In Regards To The Themes
Westworld may seem like it's going over things that are very thematically unique, but in fact all the ideas it goes over have been covered in too many other fictional works to count. It's merely going over its themes in a different way.
So many other stories about the dangers of technology, about AI, about the darkness within man, and about men playing God have been covered in far superior science fiction works. For example, Charlie Brooker's Black Mirror is full of painfully brilliant meditations on humanity and technology, and that show does it with developed characters and emotional story-telling, something Westworld sorely lacks.
A Clockwork Orange, Her, 2001 A Space Odyssey, Blade Runner and its sequel, Jurassic Park, the Planet of the Apes reboot trilogy and so many other science-fiction films cover these sorts of themes. They do so just fine without all the narrative madness Westworld insists on.
Most notably of all is Alex Garland's Ex Machina. That film goes over extremely similar thematic material to Westworld and does it in a far more interesting way with a far smaller budget and only a few characters talking. Therefore, at times watching Westworld feels redundant since we can get everything it's telling us from better material.
6. Some Of The Acting Is Really Bad
Westworld does have some incredible performances. Evan Rachel Wood, Anthony Hopkins, Jeffrey Wright, Thandie Newton and Ed Harris are all Emmy-worthy performers in Westworld. That does not extend to all the actors though.
Someone seemingly no-one acknowledged as being weak was Jimmi Simpson as William. Not only did he not portray a convincing younger version of the Man in Black, but he was often bland and samey in his acting throughout the show. As a result, it was difficult to get invested in his character at all. Next to Evan Rachel Wood and with Ed Harris playing an older version of the character to perfection, this became embarrassingly clear. Simpson is evidently talented; he did a good job in Black Mirror, but here his performance really missed the mark.
He's not the worst though. For example, Simon Quarterman is hugely irritating and wooden as Lee Sizemore and every moment with him on screen was awkward. Many of the other performers fail to make much of an impression, in stark contrast to shows like Game of Thrones and Breaking Bad, where nearly all the actors threatened to steal the show from each other.
The worst offenders were the two incompetent actors playing the technicians. Those two - Leonardo Nam and Ptolemy Slocum - were extremely underwhelming as performers and how they were even let on the set of a big-budget show like this is anyone's guess. Speaking of them...
5. Maeve's Story Was Pretty Ridiculous
Obviously, Thandie Newton's performance as Maeve was fabulous and the character herself was interesting. So, yeah, Maeve is great. Her story wasn't.
Her story essentially comes down to her blackmailing two of the world's dumbest technicians for help repeatedly. Although, to be fair to them, apparently everyone else at the company is also insanely stupid. Despite all the CCTV and surveillance in this futuristic facility, no-one is aware of what's going on. It's wonderful that Maeve has managed to escape and everything, but once you start to think of it in terms of actual logic, it falls apart immediately.
It's never clear why the technicians were helping her and what exactly their motivations were. As well as this, as if both the technicians being boring and wet characters wasn't enough, the relationship and interactions between them and Maeve isn't even compelling either.
In general, Maeve's story-line of self-discovery wasn't massively interesting and everything that happened to her wasn't entertaining at all. There was a general feeling of "Do we have to?" every time the show went back to her and those scientist buffoons.
4. It's Hard To Care About The Characters
It certainly isn't the case that Westworld's characters are bad. They are, after all, often interesting. But as for whether or not one can truly care about them, that is a different matter entirely.
There are three main issues as to why the characters are hard to engage with. Firstly, most of the characters in Westworld are, at least to some extent, A-holes, and since they're unlikable it's harder to get invested in their stories. Secondly, it was always very noticeable how much more interesting the scenes in the park were than the scenes in the control center, and the hosts are usually more interesting than the humans, which is rarely a good sign.
Anthony Hopkins' Robert Ford was a mesmerizing figure in many ways, as was Ed Harris' Man in Black, but since it was never clear who they were and what they were doing, it was difficult to become invested in them as people. That leads on to the third point.
Every character was wrapped up in a convoluted mystery and many times their true nature was only revealed in the finale. As a result, you probably spent more time wondering what was going on than feeling interested in them as characters. Yet in the end, there wasn't very much to reveal; most of the characters are just symbols and motifs, and thus largely lack development. If you tried to describe the character's actual, you know, character from memory, you'd probably fail.
3. What Was Going On?
Seriously, what happened in this show?
Try to recount the general plot of the show off the top of your head. You can try all you like, but you'll fail miserably. Even over a year later, it's hard to work out what actually went on in Westworld.
Throughout the show, watching it became more about trying desperately to figure out what the hell was going on.
What is the maze? Who is Arnold? What's the deal with Bernard? What's Ford's big new narrative? What's up with Dolores and all her visions? What... you get the idea. There are simply too many questions to count and many of them weren't even answered in a satisfactory way.
There is nothing wrong with mysteries and puzzles, but with Westworld it was all so convoluted it was difficult to get truly invested in the story. Admittedly, it is a cleverly constructed show in many ways and there is a lot of intelligent layering in the mysteries. That's undeniable. However, if one doesn't like such a puzzling approach it'll be impossible to get into Westworld.
By the way, if you haven't watched it yet, binge it. Because, if you have too big a gap between watching each episode or forget anything at all, you're screwed. You'll never know what's happening in Westworld again.
2. It's No Game Of Thrones
Westworld represents a Game of Thrones copy in more ways than one. It has the same composer, a similar budget, some of the same directors, a very similar title sequence, a similar reliance on plot twists and a similar mix of genre thrills and deep themes. It's poised to take over as HBO's big-budget tent-pole. The trouble is, Westworld is so desperate to be like GOT that, with its epic scale and endless twists, the show is actually undermining itself.
Compare the two: Game of Thrones is a complex political drama with living, breathing characters, all with interesting arcs and meditating on fascinating themes. It's a human drama which happens to feature dragons and battles, with the show's twists actually feeling earned. Westworld is more simple and one-note ideologically, and the show plays more like a 10-hour video essay on AI than a show that's actually trying to tell an engaging story.
Westworld simply isn't Game of Thrones and that's fine. Game of Thrones is lightning in a bottle and it's unlikely there'll ever be anything like it again. It's already perfect, so why try to copy it? If one needs evidence, look how many producers tried to copy Harry Potter... and most of these attempts didn't make it past the first movie.
1. The Only Thing It's Ever Focused On Are Plot Twists
Finally, the biggest problem of all with Westworld: it doesn't care about the humans or the hosts. It just cares about delivering plot twist after plot twist, puzzle after puzzle. It's a show which seems so desperate to spawn fan theories, generate internet debate and mystify its viewers that it forgets to come up with a coherent story, standout spectacle or a proper exploration of its thought-provoking themes.
Everything wrong with Westworld really comes down to this one thing. The characters eventually turned out to be nothing more than props to get the next big puzzle into position and it was so in love with its own cleverness that the show was often seriously off-putting.
A lot of the time, the best plot twists will occur naturally as the story is being written. Developing the plot twists and then building the story around it (let's face it, that's what they did with Westworld) is not a good way to write a TV show.
To improve in the future, Westworld needs to focus on its characters more and make all the twists and in-your-face thematic musings a secondary and natural element. As well as this, get rid of those wretched technicians.
Agree with this list? Have any other problems with Westworld, or want to defend the show? Share your thoughts down in the comments section.