10 Rebooted TV Shows That Were Better Than The Original

A reboot can either be a heartless cash-grab, or it can improve on the original in every way.

The Office David Brent Michael Scott
BBC/NBC

We’re living in an age of remakes, revivals, and reboots. A lot of the time that means having to put up with sad rehashes of The X-Files or tedious nostalgia-fests like Fuller House. It seems that no TV executive has ever heard the phrase “just because you can, doesn’t mean you should.”

Every month a new TV reboot or remake is announced, dragging a property out from decades in the grave or adapting a successful show from another country simply because it’s possible. Sure, it’s easy to complain about bad TV, but what’s hard is sifting through the pile of endless reboots to find something watchable.

Even better than watchable though, is great, and sometimes a TV reboot can be just that. Mixing the right behind the scenes talent with the right cast could actually elevate a TV reboot to the point where the original version looks like a pale imitation. This type of TV reboot doesn’t come along very often, but when it does it’s the job of us as television fans to sit up and take notice - and then binge every episode over the course of one sickening weekend.

It’s true that OG TV is usually your best bet, but when it comes to these 10 shows it’s safe to skip the original and follow the old saying: out with the old and in with the new.

10. Mighty Morphin’ Power Rangers

Mighty Morphin Power Rangers
Fox Kids

So “reboot” may not actually be the right word to use when describing how the Japanese TV series Kyoryu Sentai Zyuranger became Mighty Morphin’ Power Rangers, but it’s pretty close. Essentially, the Power Rangers series we all know and love from our childhoods wouldn’t exist without the original Japanese show, and in many cases the footage from Sentai Zyuranger was outright reused for the US Power Rangers series. So let’s call it a reboot and then say that Mighty Morphin’ Power Rangers was a lot better.

By toning down some of the more insane Japanese elements of the original, which included witches and humans that evolved from dinosaurs, Mighty Morphin’ Power Rangers actually invested in regular characters and played with the classic trope of giving them superpowers. As delightfully cheesy and dated as the show now appears, by smartly reusing Japanese footage the US series was allowed to show the badass Japanese martial arts that we all loved, while still giving us a semblance of story that kept us coming back week after week.

While Kyoryu Sentai Zyuranger is by no means a bad show and certainly has its appeal, there’s a lot to be said about how Mighty Morphin’ Power Rangers took its legacy and kept it going to this day.


9. Homeland

homeland 5
Showtime

Showtime’s Homeland was a phenomenon when it first debuted, sweeping the Emmy awards and promising a future of smart, grounded television. In the next few seasons that followed, sadly Homeland got away from that before returning to it as of late, but at the centre of Homeland’s faults was always its greatest strength – Claire Danes as Carrie Mathison. And that’s why Homeland is better than the original Israeli series it was based on, Hatufim.

Hatufim – like Homeland’s inaugural season – focused on the story of a prisoner of war coming home and potentially being a brainwashed terrorist, and it was gripping, compelling television. What it wasn’t, however, was well-rounded, because outside of a few select scenes the show was never about more than its main mystery.

Homeland, on the other hand, brilliantly shifted the series’ action onto Carrie’s shoulders and made things even more complicated by making her one of television’s first complex bi-polar characters. This allowed for the season – and series as a whole – to spiral into thrilling and tense directions, and it proved that Homeland the reboot is always better when it remembers who the star is, and when it focuses on Claire Danes’ infamous crying face.


8. 90210

90210 TV
The CW

The original Beverly Hills, 90210 ran all throughout the 1990s for nearly 300 episodes. It was a teen sensation and it spawned a generation of similar teen shows, where wealthy, beautiful, and privileged teens date and then break up with other wealthy, beautiful, and privileged teens throughout high school. It was a look into the drama-filled lives of the super-rich, and while the show was very popular at the time, it doesn’t exactly hold up to today’s standards of teen shows.

When the show was rebooted as 90210 in 2008, the series kept the wealthy, beautiful, and privileged teens aspect, but it brought with it a new sense of realism that made the show less cheesy and more rewarding than its predecessor. Freed up from the strict family-focused nature of 90s television, the new 90210 was able to focus on real issues without resorting to wrapping everything up neatly at the end of each episode.

While the show still isn’t for everyone, those looking for a good teen-focused show could do worse than this well-shot, well-acted drama that proves every pool party in a mansion has its own dark underbelly.


7. The Killing

The Killing US
AMC

Everyone who’s browsed on Netflix way too late at night knows about the draws of a really good Danish crime series. Bleak and full of subtitles to make you appear smart, Danish TV is often spectacular, and Forbrydeslen – translated to The Crime – is no different. It’s a well-made police-thriller with a fascinating crime at its centre. The only problem with it is that the US remake – The Killing on AMC – was at one point one of the best shows on television.

For everything that Forbrydeseln did well The Killing did better – at least in its first season. Moody and atmospheric like nothing else on TV, The Killing featured television's two best performances in Joel Kinnaman and Mireille Enos with incredible, tightly-wound writing to boot. Every single episode was essential viewing as the show followed the Twin Peaks-esque mystery of Who Killed Rosie Larsen? For that first season, there was no doubt that The Killing took what Forbrydelsen gave it and spun it into storytelling gold.

The problem, then, lies in the fact that after season one the show went downhill greatly because it dragged out the central mystery. Eventually the show course corrected in Seasons 3 and 4 and was still filled with some great things, but the recovery was a shaky one, thus bringing The Killing down a few notches in Peak TV’s pantheon of greatness.


6. In Treatment

In Treatment HBO
HBO

When In Treatment aired on HBO it was a grand experiment in daily television. Yes, just like daytime soaps of vastly inferior quality, In Treatment aired five episodes a week – but it did it in spectacular fashion. Borrowing from the format of Israeli series Be Tipul, In Treatment followed Gabriel Byrne’s Doctor Paul Weston as he treated a new patient at his psychology practice every day. And while Be Tipul’s format was innovative and its episodes occasionally stunning, what In Treatment did is adapted the series for American audiences and gave viewers a tour de force acting performance in every single episode.

Dialogue driven like no show before or after it, In Treatment was quite simply a psychologist and a patient talking in a room every episode. Featuring a roster of incredible actors like Josh Charles, Mia Wasikowska, Blai Underwood, Dianne Wiest, Alison Pill, Hope Davis, Irfan Kahn, Dane DeHaan and Amy Ryan, the show took what Be Tipul started and made it better. By adding in elements of Dr. Paul Weston’s family life, like his own problems that he should have probably seen a psychologist for himself, In Treatment gave us a complicated main character that the original show never had.

As such the show kept viewers coming back every day, and the innovative concept was outmatched by the writing staff and actors who brought every episode to life in gripping, thought-provoking ways.


5. Battlestar Galactica

Battlestar Galactica
Sci-Fi

Battlestar Galactica – like a lot of current sci-fi properties – got its start in the 1970s. Originally a TV series created by Glen A. Larson, the original Battlestar Galactica had a well-thought out concept that dealt with the near-destruction of humanity at the hands of the human-created Cylons. The show was essentially a space opera, occasionally flirting with the themes that it set up, but never fully exploring its concept or deeper implications in the same way that the 2004 reboot did.

That reboot, often considered one of the greatest sci-fi dramas of all time, was a hell of a deep dive into religious and political struggles, and the show never shied away from allegories and parables of our own modern world. Serious in a way that the original never could be, the rebooted BSG was consistently dark and full of twists, whereas the original was a lot more episodic.

While part of the original’s faults lie within the fact that it debuted in the 1970s when TV was procedural by nature, there’s just no denying that the new Battlestar Galactica took a good concept and made it even better. With a perfect cast and special effects that still hold up nearly 15-years-later, Battlestar Galactica is one of the few series to join the ranks of truly thoughtful sci-fi, as well as a reboot that improved on nearly every aspect of its source material.


4. Being Human

Being Human US
Syfy

With Being Human, the US took an original UK concept and pared it down into something truly special. Following a werewolf, a vampire, and a ghost all sharing a house, the UK’s Being Human was a fun but scattershot sci-fi drama that constantly expanded its sci-fi world as time went on. In comparison, while the US version took on the original concept verbatim, it smartly grounded things to an essential degree and became one of the very best science fiction shows on television.

Over the course of four seasons, the US version of Being Human featured one of the best casts on TV (Sam Witwer, Meaghan Rath, and Sam Huntington), and was incredibly funny all while being dreadfully dark. The twists and turns were second to nothing else on television at the time, and the US storytelling simply gave more humanity to its characters than the UK version ever could.

While the UK version seemed intent on expanding its universe and adding new cast members and new sci-fi tropes, the US version wisely stayed focused on the characters from the beginning, and as a result all four seasons of the show tell an intricately plotted story that’s as much about humans as it is about monsters.


3. The Office

The Office US
NBC

This is wildly controversial, but there’s no denying that NBC’s The Office will go down in history as a game-changing comedy series, whereas Ricky Gervais’ original will be an interesting footnote. It might not be fair, and fans who like the BBC Two original but hate the NBC remake will certainly disagree, but in the end NBC’s The Office changed the face of the modern sitcom, whereas the BBC version only aired 12 episodes and two Christmas specials.

Ricky Gervais and Stephen Merchant’s The Office put them both on the map and gave cringe comedy a new face. It also brilliantly skewered everyday life and proved that TV comedies don’t need to deal in wacky, outlandish scenarios to be funny. There’s no doubt that the show was groundbreaking, but when it came over to the US The Office blew up and became a cultural institution in a way that the original never could have dreamed of.

Launching actors’ careers and bringing us the (again, this is controversial) even better Parks and Recreation, The Office thrived in a US television landscape that was too often “nice” and “harmless.” British humour needed to come to America, and thankfully when it did it breathed new life into television comedy and arguably inspired dozens of the great comedies that are on American TV today.


2. Doctor Who

Christopher Eccleston Doctor Who
BBC

Another case of an original show being ground-breaking in its debut but also held back by the television constraints of its time, when Doctor Who debuted in 1963 and ran until 1989 TV was in a different place. Mature men were always the ones playing the Classic Doctors, and the entire series was influenced by the westerns and epics that came before it. Forget about the fact that the show’s lack of budget dates it horribly or that the effects just can’t possibly hold up – the original Doctor Who is, while still very good, just not at all what modern audiences are used to.

When the new Doctor Who debuted in 2005 the show took the classic beloved elements of the series and dropped the soap opera pacing. Gone were overblown clichés, and replacing them were a heavier reliance on modern horror and science-fiction/fantasy elements. The Doctors got younger and so too did the storytelling – Doctor Who entered a new generation with serialized elements and a cinematic flair.

In the new Doctor Who series, every element has upped its game, and it’s tough to watch both versions of the show and deny that the new one isn’t better – at least in some respects. While some fans may decry the new version as a disgrace, the cinematography, score, acting, and storytelling has all been upgraded to the 21st century, and as a result every new series of the show feels like a huge deal rather than just another weekly TV series.


1. Shameless

Shameless Showtime
Showtime

When Shameless aired its first episode on premium cable’s Showtime in the US in 2011, it was a lot like Channel 4’s 2004 UK version of Shameless. That is, it was a crude story about a large, lower class family and their struggles – but that’s where the similarities ended. From the end of the first episode onward, Showtime’s Shameless has distinguished itself as one of the best series on television, while the original UK version dragged on and on while losing sight of what made it a compelling show in the first place.

Comparing the two now, what you’ll see is a US version that knew instantly what it wanted to be – a black as coal comedic drama that didn’t shy away from the crippling realities of life – and a UK version that was more interested in gross-out comedy than in heart. And while there’s nothing inherently wrong with the direction that the UK Shameless took, it just looks amateurish compared now to the growth and emotion constantly on display in the US version.

In fact, with US Shameless now entering its eighth season and getting better every year, to go back and watch the UK’s now nearly 15-year-old version it becomes clear that the US Shameless remake did everything right in order to turn something good into something spectacular.

Agree with this list? Are there any other reboots/remakes you think bettered the original? Share your thoughts down in the comments.


Watch Next


Contributor

Jake Black writes the funny, weird, interesting things that you love reading. He's super cool, really famous, and everyone likes him. He's never once been punched in the face by Johnny Depp on a ferry traveling to Southampton, England.