10 Ridiculous TV Premises Everybody Fell For

Once you eliminate the impossible, whatever remains, no matter how improbable, must be the truth.

Buffy Becoming Sword
Mutant Enemy

Back in the day, they used to call them ‘water cooler’ shows: those TV programmes that had people talking about them in their tea break at work the next day, obsessed with the latest plot twist, the most hated characters, the will-they-won’t-theys and the haves-versus-the-have-nots.

We lived for those shows, gossiping over who shot J.R., or when David and Maddie would get together. We still do - we just do it in short bursts on social media, and we don’t have to wait the next day to find likeminded people to natter to.

Of course, in all that excitement it’s easy to lose track of your critical faculties… because many of these fun, exciting, shows don’t actually make a whole lot of sense.

Perhaps the high concept is nonsense, or the central plot arc has one major, inescapable hole in it that wrecks everything. Perhaps the show doesn’t actually work in the way that everyone thinks it does.

Maybe the protagonist (or the antagonist) acts in an utterly baffling, nonsensical way… or maybe it’s just that the whole show is so irredeemably stupid that you want to pick it up and shake it to see if a toy car falls out from where its brain should be.

Like an angry Santa, I'm here to present you with a gift of ten recent well known, popular TV shows that, when you think about it a little, don’t really work. No, no. Don’t say anything. You€™’re welcome.

Oh, and here be spoilers...

10. Sons Of Anarchy Is About A Tragic Fall From Grace

Sons of Anarchy Charlie Hunnam
FX

FX’s late, lamented biker melodrama Sons Of Anarchy was a wild ride: a grimly violent Grand Guignol with lashings of black humour.

Except perhaps for the slack, self-indulgent final season, Kurt Sutter’s tragic magnum opus kept its audience on the edge of their seats every episode. It detailed the gradual slide of the protagonist, Sons Of Anarchy motorcycle club (SAMCRO) lifer Jackson ‘Jax’ Teller from principled outlaw with a code of honour to murderous, scheming criminal… right?

Well, no. Not really. Sons Of Anarchy isn’t about a fall from grace, and Jackson is no kind of hero.

Raised in SAMCRO by his father and mother, and then by his step-father, Jax is a violent killer from the pilot episode - he’s spent time in prison for smuggling and gun-running and wears the ‘Men Of Mayhem’ patch on his cut confirming that he’s killed for the club.

Although the birth of his sons, the rekindling of his relationship with his childhood sweetheart Tara and the discovery of his father’s original, less nefarious plans for the club are supposed to change him as a person, they don’t: he just gets worse as the show goes on.

There’s a lot of tragedy in Jackson Teller’s life, but a significant proportion of it is a direct consequence of his own decisions and actions, and the rest is the by-product of a life spent as a murderous criminal. In other words, he’s responsible - directly or indirectly - for every bad thing that happens to him and the people he loves, and that pendulum increasingly swings more towards direct blame as the series progresses.

Committing more and more murders to supposedly end the violence, making more and more criminal deals to eventually end all illegal trade: the fact is that Jax is off the reservation very, very quickly. Tara’s death in the season six finale isn’t the catalyst for his descent downhill - it just takes off the brakes.

By the series finale, Jackson has so much blood on his hands that his death is the final piece of justice he gets to serve.


9. The Pritchett Family Are Taking Part In A TV Documentary

Modern Family
ABC

The mockumentary format is a tried and tested comedy trope in film and television, made most famous in recent years by seminal sitcoms The Office, Parks & Recreation and, still going strong, ABC’s Modern Family.

Each episode of Modern Family is shot as though filmed by an invisible documentary camera crew, including excerpts of interviews direct to camera. Ty Burrell, playing doofus ‘cool dad’ Phil, regularly mugs to camera when he thinks he’s being hip or funny. It’s been this way from the first episode, right the way through to this latest eighth season. The only question is, how the hell did this show within a show happen in the first place?

Family patriarch Jay is a cantankerous and wealthy man in his sixties, semi-retired and uninterested in anything that doesn’t relate to his own personal comfort. His kids Claire and Mitchell are, to varying degrees, both oversensitive, tightly wound control freaks uncomfortable with public expression of affection.

All three have married people who are polar opposites to them, and all of their spouses are the kind of people who might well agree to take part in a fly-on-the-wall show like this. The Pritchetts, the focal point of the entire enterprise? Absolutely not… and for eight years?

Claire and Mitchell wouldn’t last a week. Jay would rather ritually disembowel himself than do it for a day. None of the extended family work, or have ever worked, in film or TV, and they don’t seem to know anyone who does. How did this show-within-a-show even get off the ground?


8. House Is A Character Study

Dr House 13
FOX

House, MD was a procedural show on Fox that ran for eight seasons, a total of 177 episodes telling the story of the titular drug-addicted genius heading the Department of Diagnostic Medicine at Princeton-Plainsboro Teaching Hospital.

As a show greenlit to be a procedural (a medical take on shows like CSI), House follows the network formula. Each season, the show told twenty-odd stories about a brilliant, diverse team of experts, faced each week with an impossible puzzle that would be solved in the final ten minutes of the hour.

Typically, a procedural will relegate character-based plotwork to the background. If there’s a narrative arc, it’ll be a sketchy one like a recurring character or plot device, but nothing the show revolves around. The characters enter the show fully formed, and retain that shape throughout their run on the show. They can be replaced at the drop of a hat, because they’re just hooks to hang that procedural formula on.

House wanted to have its cake and eat it: to be a simple procedural and a character-based drama about Dr. Gregory House, the damaged, obnoxious virtuoso cribbed from Sherlock Holmes. To make that work, he had to become part of the show’s formula… which means he cannot change in any meaningful sense.

However, this is a man who wouldn’t last a week at any professionally run hospital, so the writing staff were tasked with coming up with plot-based red herrings to distract the audience: authority figures who would play mind games with him rather than fire, imprison or sue him; multiple episodes based around dreams and hallucinations; a rotating cast of doctors to put up with him and make him look smart; and the illusion that he could change, that he could become a better person, maybe even be happy.

House fooled people into thinking it was a clever, intricate character study for eight years. The truth is that Dr. Gregory House isn’t even a character, the same way Airwolf wasn’t a character and The X-Files weren’t characters: they were just the cool USP their show was named after.


7. Preacher Is About The Doomed Inhabitants Of A Small Texas Town

Preacher Teaser
AMC

The first season of AMC’s Preacher TV show received mixed reviews, and made some decidedly strange choices in its adaptation of Garth Ennis and the late, great Steve Dillon’s comic book.

You could argue that the notoriously profane and over-the-top Preacher would be impossible to adapt straight to the screen, that significant alterations would need to be made - and you’d be right - but that doesn’t explain the stuttering pacing, the decision to make ultra-cool protagonist Jesse Custer a gormless idiot… or the fact that the plot doesn’t actually start until the season finale.

Yes, showrunner Sam Catlin takes ten hours of television to do what Ennis and Dillion did in the first four issues of the comic. In fact, strictly speaking, most of the set up for the central narrative of Preacher was complete after issue one.

For those who don’t know - which is basically everyone who watched the first season of the show but hasn’t read the comic - Preacher is a lurid, violent and funny road trip where Custer et al are confronted by some of the weirdest grotesques that America has to offer as he sets out to find God and hold him accountable for all the crap in the world.

The first season of Preacher, however, is about the quirky inhabitants of a crappy little town in Texas that (it’s been officially confirmed) were all killed when Annville gets blown up in the season finale. So that was worth watching, then.

Can someone put together an edit of the thirty seconds of footage from season one it’d take to get people ready for season two? Then we can pretend this whole thing never happened.


6. Buffy Summers Is A True Hero

Buffy resurrection
Mutant Enemy

The titular character of a television show is more than just the hero-protagonist: they carry the show on their backs, because they’re everything the show is supposed to be about.

Joss Whedon’s ideal for Buffy The Vampire Slayer was to create a hero from a horror trope that would ordinarily represent a victim - the little blonde who steps into the alleyway at night to be confronted by the monster in the dark. It was a feminist celebration: "The very first mission statement of the show was the joy of female power: having it, using it, sharing it.”

That was the plan: so it’s a shame that’s not what was broadcast in the seven seasons of Buffy The Vampire Slayer that aired. Buffy Summers is a hero-protagonist who doesn’t want to be the hero-protagonist. Despite her supernatural calling and powers, her constant refrain is a valley-girl whine that her life isn’t the way she wanted it to be.

However, Buffy is surrounded by an ensemble cast of friends and allies who are there precisely because of her: people who’ve chosen this life because they want to support her and help save the world.

Those people suffer through their voluntary association with Buffy and rarely (if ever) complain about their lot in life. Her closest friends Giles, Willow and Xander all see their partners murdered during the course of the show. Xander loses an eye, Willow becomes addicted to black magic, Spike is killed: the list goes on and on. They’re the real heroes of Buffy The Vampire Slayer.

At last, in the series finale (after a whole heap of death and mayhem), with every potential Slayer called at once, the Hellmouth is closed and the entire town of Sunnydale collapses to cover it. The final shot of the show? As her friends start to make plans for the next step in their fight against evil, Buffy slowly smiles, realising that with dozens of Slayers in the world she doesn’t need to be one anymore.


5. The Following Is A Serial Killer Drama

The Following Kevin Bacon
Fox

For fans of the serial killer trope, one of the most fascinating in American popular culture, The Following should have been a clear winner.

It had what, on paper, seemed like a peerless high concept. The FBI estimates that there are as many as three hundred serial killers haunting the highways, cities and backwoods of America at any one time. Well, what if someone were to provide them with connections, with leadership?

It's only when you actually start watching The Following that you see what's wrong with it. Making every killer in the show a devotee of the same death cult nullifies the whole concept of profiling. Worse, it completely removes the unique selling point of the serial killer narrative: getting to grips with the fascinating, warped, idiosyncratic and individual psychologies involved.

Without that, The Following is just a succession of gruesome murders carried out by totally inconsequential henchmen, most if not all of whom are casually disposed of as they come between protagonist, lawman Ryan Hardy and his nemesis Joe Carroll.

You can see the writers and directors of the show struggling to create a propulsive, thrilling narrative... not realising that their own premise has shot them in the foot from the word go.

At least Criminal Minds, for all its procedural structure, gives us a different 'unsub' every week, detailing a different persona with unique motivations. A serial killer narrative following a succession of bland, blindly fanatical killers with nothing distinguishing one from the next is a poor entry in the genre.


4. Prison Break Is A Viable Idea For A TV Show

Prison Break Lincoln Michael
20th Century Fox

Network television shows exist to sell advertising slots to brands. Sure, great reviews, high ratings and awards buzz are important, but only because they increase the price point that they can charge for that commercial time. Formulaic television like cop shows, homicide procedurals and hospital dramas can often run to ten years or longer: they hit the reset button most weeks, portraying identikit, placeholder characters that can be replaced without damaging the selling point of the show.

However, the whole premise of Prison Break is based around an arc plot with a quick, definitive ending: engineering savant Michael Scofield will break his brother Lincoln, wrongly convicted of murder, out of maximum security prison. The high concept is so elementary that it can be summed up in a two word phrase... which happens to be the title of the show.

There's no formula, no reset button - and it's completely character based, the show formed around those two protagonists. But in order for it to be a successful network show, it has to run and run, which plays directly against the premise of this show.

Think that’s over-analysing matters? Well, everyone who creator Paul Scheuring originally pitched Prison Break to agreed that the idea just didn’t work as an ongoing network TV show. Apparently several suggested that he rework it as a feature film - and at least initially, that included Fox, the network that eventually picked the show up.

The first season, naturally enough, was about the prison break. In order to sustain Prison Break over subsequent seasons, they had to extend the premise. Bracketed by an absurdly complicated political conspiracy plot, season two showed the protagonists on the run, while season three gave them a second, even more hellish prison to escape. The fourth season abandons the prison break plot entirely except for the feature length series finale, which proffered a third prison break scenario.

Incredibly, the show is set to be revived with a fourth prison break storyline, begging the question: why is it that this supposedly brilliant team of prison break specialists can’t stay out of jail?


3. The Zombie Apocalypse Is The End Of The World

Walking Dead Guts
Gene Page/AMC

The zombie apocalypse is, fundamentally, all about survival. The Walking Dead is one of many zombie narratives that detail a world where a zombie outbreak has brought civilisation to its knees and the survivors (the real ‘walking dead’, naturally) must protect themselves from the dead and the living alike.

However, these bleak tales of post-apocalyptic horror never establish exactly how civilisation, government, and the rule of law are brought low by the zombie pandemic, and The Walking Dead is no exception. In fact, the genre is so well ingrained in pop culture now that barely anyone even bothers asking the question anymore: it’s just assumed that Zombies = Fall Of Man.

Despite the infrastructure of the country remaining intact and the traditionally slow-moving, clumsy nature of this variant of the undead, The Walking Dead sees the collapse of American civilisation take place in short order. Like other zombie narratives before it, it simply fast forwards to the good part and glosses over how implausible it is that local and central government, police and armed forces, communications and power would all vanish overnight because of an infection spread by a few lurching, mindless corpses.

Were humanity to band together to fight the zombie apocalypse in the same way that they always do to fight alien invasions, there would be no zombie apocalypse. That’s what happens at the end of Shaun Of The Dead, after all - the army turn up, shoot them all in the head and life returns to normal, which is exactly what would happen in real life.

Walking Dead prequel series Fear The Walking Dead purported to fill in the blanks and show the fall of civilisation, but skips over all the big stuff, therefore defeating the whole premise of the show. In an extension of that Hollywood trope where crashing cars explode for no reason, suddenly the city is simply on fire.


2. How I Met Your Mother Is Supposed To Have A Satisfying Ending

How I Met Your Mother Ted Josh Radnor
CBS

It's not even a matter of debate anymore - the ending to How I Met Your Mother sucked. The resolution to the story was so ineptly conceived and executed that fans of the show that had been hanging on for grim death for nine years (NINE YEARS) were, and still are, outraged.

However. How I Met Your Mother is a sitcom with many gimmicks, but the central conceit - above and beyond the callbacks, the running gags, the references and the dashing back and forth in time - is that the whole thing, two hundred and eight episodes of story, three and a bit straight days of television, is a story being told by protagonist Ted to his kids in the future. It's the story of how he met their mother... and it's a shaggy dog story.

A shaggy dog story is a form in joke-telling. The prototypical version, the one that gives the trope its name, concerns a dog that's incredibly shaggy, the shaggiest dog, a dog that wins prizes for its shagginess. The story of the dog is built up as it wins more and more prizes, until finally it's in the final for the world's shaggiest dog award… whereupon the judges look at it and say, "it's not very shaggy at all, is it?"

The shaggy dog story plays upon the audience's preconceptions about the way jokes are told. The set-up to the punchline is deliberately convoluted and long winded, using delayed gratification and the teller's powers of storytelling to command the attention while the audience is built up to a punchline that, when it arrives, is a deliberate anticlimax.

Sound familiar? How I Met Your Mother sets out its stall early: we know exactly what the premise is. No matter whether the show lasts for one season or ten, the climax will be "...and that's how I met your mother."

The longer the show went on, the more it used delayed gratification and the cast, crew and creative team’s powers of storytelling to keep our attention, distracting us from the absence of a punchline. When Ted finally meets The Mother, it is an anticlimax... and it always would have been.

This, after all, is a shaggy dog story. It's not supposed to have a quality punchline. That's the whole point.


1. Sherlock Holmes Is A Great Detective

Benedict Cumberbatch Sherlock
BBC

The major problem in all of detective fiction is that, by necessity, you’re writing stories about the prowess of men and women far, far smarter than you. House MD gets around this perennial issue rather conveniently, by creating a specialised setting in which the detective is an expert in a field - diagnostic medicine - which few members of the audience will be familiar with.

Murder mystery shows like the BBC’s Sherlock, adapted from Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s classic stories, don’t have this luxury. In order to show off Sherlock’s dizzying intellect, he has to be able to deduce things no normal man could deduce. The problem is, he’s not actually using deductive reasoning, for the most part: he’s using abductive reasoning.

What’s abductive reasoning? Without going into too much fiddly detail, it’s when you take observed facts and form a hypothesis that satisfactorily explains them. A wrestler lies on the mat and another wrestler stands over him with a metal folding chair. Hypothesis? The second wrestler has hit the first wrestler with the chair.

Benedict Cumberbatch’s Sherlock is forever using abductive reasoning to analyse facts about people and events. The problem is that he then relies upon - and immediately acts upon - those hypotheses, treating them as conclusive in and of themselves.

Of course, it’s just as probable that he’d be completely wrong. What if the first wrestler threw the folding chair to the second wrestler and collapsed to the mat, feigning unconsciousness to have his opponent disqualified? If that sounds unlikely, then you’ve just fallen for Eddie Guerrero’s classic referee misdirection technique. Bad ref. Bad.

Rarely, if ever, does Sherlock test whether his hypothesis is accurate before acting upon it. However, he’s being written by someone of only average intelligence with no background or interest in genuine problem solving and logical puzzle techniques. The show therefore creates an environment whereby, despite the massive potential for error, Sherlock is pretty much always right.

It’s a magic trick, sleight of hand to distract the viewer and make them believe that the character is an extraordinary detective. It doesn’t work if you remove that artificial environment of success, though.

Take any scene of brainy brilliance from an episode of Sherlock. Without the context in the plot of the episode, in which Sherlock is automatically correct, ask yourself whether there could be another hypothesis that also explains the facts being observed.

Nine times out of ten, you’ll come up with another one, two, or maybe more explanations for the facts on display. But that’s the problem with writing detectives who are much smarter than you are. You just can’t do them justice.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Professional writer, punk werewolf and nesting place for starfish. Obsessed with squid, spirals and story. I publish short weird fiction online at desincarne.com, and tweet nonsense under the name Jack The Bodiless. You can follow me all you like, just don't touch my stuff.