10 Saddest Moments In BoJack Horseman
The BoJack moments that tugged our heartstrings the hardest...
BoJack Horseman came to an end recently, drawing to a close one of Netflix’s show harrowing original shows. Sure, it was about a cartoon horse, but underneath that it was about much, much more.
Addiction, alcoholism, adultery, asexuality, abortion, abuse and lots of other topics which don’t begin with A were all covered by BoJack. Along the way, there were some quite significant gut punches too, with the show not afraid to get dark. While BoJack frequently painted himself as the ultimate victim of his own story, he’s caused more than his fair share of pain too.
That said, this isn’t about the worst thing he’s done, or even the show’s darkest moments. It’s all about those really sad events of the six seasons which had us welling up. Almost sleeping with Penny was one of BoJack’s worst moments, for example, but it’s not particularly sad, so you won’t find it here.
There’s still more than enough sadness in the BoJack universe to go around though, so it was no issue filling it up. These are the moments to have tissues ready for on a rewatch.
10. Tell Me That I'm A Good Person
Speaking of a rewatch, you might need reminding that the first series was pretty bumpy. It took around six or seven episodes to find its feet, but once it did it never looked back.
The first real moment of depth in the show came in episode 11 of the first season, Downer Ending. Episode 11 quickly became BoJack’s big hitter, akin to early Game Of Thrones’ episode 9, and it’s not the only time an eleventh episode moment will feature here.
Downer Ending, as they first, certainly leaves room to grow, but is still pretty powerful in its own right. It comes after Diane has written her tell all on BoJack, re-establishing him as a major celebrity but opening him up to ridicule at the same time.
He lets himself be vulnerable for the first time, begging her to tell him he’s ‘a good person’. It’s a desperate request, a wounded BoJack in need of validation. Considering how far he falls, it’s not much in retrospect, but at the time it feels pretty close to his rock bottom.
The episode closes out with Diane’s silence in reply.
9. BoJack Calls Diane
While this is technically from an episode 15, it was the penultimate episode of the extended final season, and so brings with it the big episode 11 energy. This isn’t the only moment from that episode included here either, even if it is the closing scene.
The episode takes place in BoJack’s mind, playing out a purgatory style dinner party with key figures from his life. Sarah Lynn, Herb, his mother, Courdroy Jackson, Crackerjack and his father as Secretariat all appear before ultimately sinking into hell.
BoJack, we discover at the end, has taken way too many pills and has fallen into his pool, slowly drowning. In his purgatory, BoJack is being swallowed by darkness, recalling the ‘you’re the tar pit’ line Charlotte said to him about or ultimate inability to escape ourself and our own demons.
Eventually, the darkness catches up with BoJack and begins to swallow him as he grabs for the phone to call Diane.
As it appears like BoJack is drawing his last breath, he asks his imagined version of Diane if she can stay on the phone with him while he fades away.
8. It Goes Away, Right?
BoJack and Hollyhock's relationship ended up being severed by Hollyhock in the light of all the terrible things he'd done to vulnerable young women, and she was undoubtedly better for it. However, there were a few brief moments in Hollyhock's time with BoJack which were sweet, if tinged with sadness.
In the episode Stupid Piece Of Sh*t, we see BoJack being plagued by harmful and self destructive thoughts. It creates a little bit of sympathy perhaps, but doesn't quite cover up the fact that he'd been a jackass to everyone. At the end of the episode though, BoJack goes and talks to Hollyhock, we she confesses her own thoughts.
She's also suffering through these thoughts, asking BoJack - unaware that he has them - if 'it goes away, right?'. BoJack decides to lie to her, telling her 'yeah', even though it hasn't for him.
It's a nice thing for him to do, but it's rather sad to think that Hollyhock might have the same demons that BJ does. Of course, she's being drugged with amphetamines by Bea at this point, so that has to be taken into account as well.
7. Bea's Confusion
As was probably just proven by the amphetamines part of the last entry, Bea Horseman wasn't always the most sympathetic character. However, despite being a terrible mother to BoJack and all around terrible person, Time's Arrow made it impossible not to feel for her.
The episode explored the destructive effects of Alzheimer's, taking us inside Bea's head. It was clear from the start of the season that she had mentally deteriorated, but it wasn't until Time's Arrow that we actually saw Bea's perspective. It helped unravel the mystery of Hollyhock's mother, but much more importantly than that, it offered Bea a depth and narrative we'd never seen before.
Bea's childhood, early love affair with Butterscotch and her angry, empty marriage were all smashed into one unending trauma, and made it impossible not to feel something for her, even if you still might not like her all that much.
The final twist though comes at the end, when her mind grants her a moment of clarity. BoJack has been waiting for this to tell her off, but when we finally gets the chance, he decides instead to usher her back to her blissful ignorance and walk out of her life.
6. It's You
Todd doesn’t feature very much on this list, mainly because he and Mr. Peanutbutter are the two shining optimists in the show, always there for comic relief to perk things up. That’s not to say that Todd didn’t go on this own journey and experience his own disappointments, just that he usually managed to look on the bright side.
Far more emotionally healthy and less self destructive than BoJack, his low points were usually far less crushing too.
This isn’t even a Todd low point either; it could even be argued it’s a high point for him, even it irreparably severed his relationship with BJ. They might have not fallen out for good, but their friendship was never the same after this point.
When Todd is moving out of BoJack’s house, BoJack tries to apologise, but Todd doesn’t want to hear it. “You are everything that’s wrong with you,” Todd tells him, “It’s you.”
He’s not there for the excuses of BoJack’s drugs, or his parents, or all the bad things that have happened to BoJack. He understands BJ’s failings are his own responsibility, and he needs BoJack to know that too.
It’s a sad moment for BoJack to realise his own responsibility, as well as for the viewers knowing Todd has finally had enough of BoJack’s excuses.
5. I See You
Free Churro is a masterstroke of television. Aside from a brief opening flashback, the entire episode is a single monologue: BoJack speaking at his mother's funeral. Although the ending ultimately reveals that he's not at his mother's funeral but has in fact gone into the wrong room, that doesn't change the power of his actual words.
The monologue drags in parts, rambles in others, dwelling on details here and rushing over stories there. However, it all happens with a searing realism, and the whole thing makes for a deeply compelling twenty minutes of tv. One of the recurring themes of the monologue are Bea's last words to BoJack: "I see you."
He goes back and forth with the phrase, deciding if it is some mystical, meaningful last words from is mother, conferring either absolution upon him or asking for forgiveness of her own. At times though, he thinks it's instead just the weak, empty thoughts of a dying brain.
It's not until he's able to talk it out that he realises she wasn't saying "I see you," but instead "ICU", the unit of the hospital she was in. So it all meant nothing.
4. But It's... Fake
Princess Carolyn got her happy ending with Judah in the end, but boy, did she have to work for it. One of many false dawns was her relationship with Ralph Stilton, which eventually fell apart after tension following the fifth miscarriage.
The episode, appropriately named Ruthie, features Princess Carolyn’s distant descendant Ruthie doing a show and tell on PC for her class. It details PC’s bravery in the face of adversity and lauds her as a great success. However, once the miscarriage is confirmed and Ralph departs, PC tells BoJack about her usual routine when she’s depressed.
It involves her imagining her distant descendant telling her class all about her. When BoJack says, “but it’s... fake,” she simply replies “yeah well. It makes me feel better.”
It’s sad for a number of reasons, not least because it’s tied to her real miscarriage. But it’s also the fact that it feels like PC’s last chance at this sort of life, and that all it’ll ever be is fake.
She later adopts a porcupine and names her Ruthie in tribute, dissipating the sadness a little.
3. I Have Half A Mind
Bea’s Alzheimer’s has already featured here, but her whole arc dates back to her childhood, when we see her mother lobotomised after the death of Crackerjack, Bea’s mother.
Underrated episode The Old Sugarman Place isn’t always held in as high a regard as the big BoJack classics, but it really should be. Mixing between BoJack rebuilding the old house and the flashbacks to his grandparents still living in it, it has some of the best sequences in the show, wrapped up in a heart wrenching story.
Though the current story of BoJack being helped by a lonely old fly who blames himself for his wife’s death is sad, it’s the flashback which comes with all guns blazing. BoJack’s grandparents initially seem to have a happy life, before Crackerjack’s death in the war.
After that, with his grandmother distraught and grandfather cold and unfeeling, things quickly fall apart. His grandmother can’t stand the celebrations of the war ending, and after ‘making a spectacle’ of herself in her anguish, her husband has her lobotomised.
It brings a chilling new meaning to her catchphrase “I have half a mind to kiss you”, as that’s all she ends the episode with.
2. Sarah Lynn's Death
This was always going to feature highly, and in the end it just misses out on the top spot. Sarah Lynn was a series regular, the perfect send up of an off the rails wild child who got too much too soon. But she was a real person too, well developed across her time in the series, and losing her was heartbreaking.
What makes the moment even worse is a revelation which comes in the final season too; BoJack waited 17 minutes before calling an ambulance because of the optics. She later died in the hospital, and those 17 minutes might have saved her.
Even shorn of that context though, it’s a crushing moment. A few minutes prior, when they’re at the hotel room, the show pulls a fake out with BoJack fearing Sarah Lynn is dead when she doesn’t immediately respond to him. It lets our guard down, making it hurt more later.
The fact she dies in the planetarium, after explaining how much she loves the building is especially sad. Her final words, “I wanna be an architect,” really embody her lost potential, and a life that could’ve been.
1. The View From Halfway Down
The penultimate episode of the series has already been addressed, but this isn’t about the episode as a whole; just the poem it’s named after.
Secretariat reads the poem before descending into the darkness, and it unveiled the horrifying reality of Suicide. The poem - written for the show - deals with Secretariat’s suicidal leap from the Golden Gate Bridge, where his eyes open to see ‘the view from halfway down’. Modelled from the stories of real life suicide jump survivors, Secretariat speaks of his regret and hopelessness as he plummets.
It’s a searing poem, with Secretariat getting more and more stressed and uncomfortable as he fights against the inevitable. He doesn’t want the poem to end, he doesn’t want to go into the darkness. He doesn’t want to hit the ground.
Suicide is sad enough; it marks a painful life cut short by a lonely person who simply could not take any more. But to think that someone could regret it halfway through but be completely unable to do anything about it is utterly heartbreaking.
As with all of BoJack’s best moments, the true sadness here comes from how well it reflects reality.