10 Scariest Star Trek Episodes Ever

"Space is disease and danger wrapped in darkness and silence".

Scariest Star Trek
CBS

Star Trek is supposed to be many things, but "OH MY GOD THAT'S SO SCARY!! TURN IT OFF!!!" isn't one of them. Challenging, exciting, curious, progressive, educational, bold, entertaining, all of the above are thrown around happily by fans and producers alike, but scary? Nobody's really here for that.

And yet, Star Trek is scary. To quote Karl Urban's Dr. McCoy "space is disease and danger wrapped in darkness and silence" and while that's a great line to use in the final few shots of a JJ Abrams trailer, it's also just a fact. After all, it's called the final frontier because we have absolutely no idea what's waiting for us out there and there are few things humanity fears more than the unknown.

Still though, despite TV networks doing their utmost to make this something for the whole family, occasionally Star Trek will just dip off course and career headfirst into the realms of traditional, creepy, horror. Slasher horrors, psychological horrors, body horrors, even just classic ghost stories have all made an appearance of the show's 54-year history, so let's look at the scariest amongst them, yeah? You're all big and brave.

10. Genesis

Barclay Genesis
CBS Media Ventures

Star Trek: The Next Generation - Season 7, Episode 19

Comfortably one of the highlights of the Next Generation's often-dismissed Season 7, Genesis is a slice of terrifying monster-horror that wouldn't have been out of place on shows with far darker reputations. Giant beasts, disfigured crewmates, something that's half-Reg Barclay, half aracho-nightmare, the episode saw TNG scoop 10 Emmy nominations for its makeup work that year.

After a torpedo veers wildly off course during a training drill, Picard and Data set off on a short Lads Day Out to retrieve it. When they return to the ship, they find it adrift in space with no sign of the crew and one of the bridge officers physically eviscerated in his seat.

They discover that a reactivated T-Cell in Lt. Barclay has triggered a mutation in the rest of the crew, causing them to de-evolve into more savage lifeforms. Worf, in particular, becomes a nightmarish, armoured hell-demon who rampages through the ship attempting to mate with Troi. A cure is found in Data's cat Spot, but not after some ghoulish scenes had the audience leaping out of their seats and scurrying behind the sofa in equal measure.


9. The Haunting Of Deck 12

Voyager Haunting
Paramount

Star Trek: Voyager - Season 6, Episode 25

Very much Star Trek's answer to the old Simpson's staple Treehouse of Horror, this, as Neelix (who's scary enough, let's be real) entertains the young Borg in the cargo bay with a classic ghost story. With the power out and the room plunged into darkness, the cliched campfire vibe quickly gives way to an impressively chilling tale.

Traversing through a nebula (similar to the one that gives us the setting for this episode) the crew were attacked by a strange, non-corporeal, entity that had accidentally come aboard. The ship's systems function erratically, several personnel are injured or go missing, and only on a strange hunch is Janeway able to commune with the creature.

After realising they have inadvertently destroyed its home the entity becomes enraged and attempts to kill everyone on board. Janeway is, at the last moment, able to reason with it, and agrees to find a new place for it to live... right here on the ship, where it remains to this day. Mwa-ha-ha-ha-etc.


8. Conspiracy

Star Trek Conspiracy
CBS Media Ventures

Star Trek: The Next Generation - Season 1, Episode 25

By and large, light-entertainment space adventures only really lend themselves to one type of horror. That classic psychological trope of the terror being implied considerably more than it's seen, leaving your imagination to do all the heavy lifting and, thus, saving money on expensive ghoulies and not upsetting the network.

All of that went out of the window though in the first season of The Next Generation, when the show decided instead to go for a full-on Cronenbergian nightmare complete with exploding human heads and a grotesque alien monster. A quick word of caution, this is easily the most viscerally disgusting thing Star Trek has ever devised, outside of this man's swimwear choices.

Uncovering a plot at the very highest levels of the Federation, Picard and Riker successfully overcome a series of terrifying parasites that have taken over the bodies of Starfleet's decision makers. It all culminates in a disgusting feast of live maggots, an exploding human head, a dissolved chest cavity, and whatever the hell that thing above is supposed to be.

The episode carried a viewer discretion warning before it aired, and the proders were told to reign the gore in for Season 2.


7. The Thaw

Star Trek The Thaw
Paramount

Star Trek: Voyager - Season 2, Episode 23

The entire premise behind Voyager was that, by hurtling the crew to the other side of the galaxy, the possibilities of adventure, discovery, and danger were infinite. Crazy, then, that the scariest thing in the entire universe still just so happens to be a maniacal evil clown.

Discovering the stasis pods of a civilisation that has protected itself from an ecological disaster, the crew are unable to release the survivors because they are cerebrally linked to a computer simulation. Attempting to enter the dream world they live in and inform them that it's time to return to the real world, Harry Kim and B'Elanna Torres enter two vacant pods to contact them.

Oopside, bad idea! The dream world is actually a nightmare being run by the manifestations of the sleeper's own fears that just so happens to have taken the form of a maniacal clown. He has been slowly torturing his victims for decades, accidentally caused two to die from literal fright, and is over the moon to have two brand new playthings.

While there's nothing out-and-out horrifying in this episode the relentlessly unhinged vibes of The Clown are more than enough to drege up any well-surpressed childhood fears.


6. The Man Trap

Star Trek Man Trap
Paramount

Star Trek - Season 1, Episode 1

Critically lauded as one of the show's most seminal episodes, The Man Trap started Star Trek off on a terrifying path. Certainly in the context of the US light-entertainment standards of the 1960s.

Arriving at a planet inhabited by Robert and Nancy Crater, a series of strange and savage murders sees them seek refuge on The Enterprise until the grizzly mystery can be solved. Carter, however, despite being an old flame of Dr McCoy, turns out to be a shapeshifting salt vampire. Women, ey?!

In the end it transpires that the real Nancy was killed by the vampire years previous, but after taking pitty on Robert Carter one of them remained with him and took her form. He'd just been living in complete denial about the whole thing and slipping it salt tablets so it didn't murder him as well - just like any normal grieving husband would have!

While the sudden deaths of the Enterprise crew members aren't exactly nightmare fuel, the creature design absolutely was.


5. Night Terrors

While the episode Night Terrors is, despite the name, designed to have more of a creeping, anxious vibe than anything outright terrifying, it does contain The Next Generation's single scariest moment.

Finding the USS Brattain adrift in space, with all hands apparently murdered and only one survivor, the crew's investigations begin to unravel as they suffer the effects of lack of sleep. It transpires that this patch of space is prohibiting them from dreaming, and thus slowly pushing them towards the same manic fate that befell their bloodied friends on the ghost ship.

Data, not needing sleep, is entrusted with finding a way out of all this, while the rest of the crew attempt to stave off the assorted hallucinations their delirium is causing. One moment though, involving Dr. Cursher and an entire room full of corpses, is still pant-wetting to this day.

Left to her own devices by her assistant, a growing sense of unease sweeps the scene before she realises, silently and entirely, that all the bodies are suddenly sat bolt upright. It's a horror movie


4. The Empath

Star Trek Empath
Paramount

Star Trek - Season 3, Episode 12

Again, it's not what you see in this episode that makes it terrifying, it's more the descriptions you're afforded and what your imagination can do with them from there. In fact, such was the disturbing power of implication in this episode, it was banned by a number of networks when the show originally aired.

In the episode, while visiting an apparently doomed planet, the crew is repeatedly subjected to torturous experiments by its inhabitants. Dr McCoy, in particular, is subjected to the worst of it, having apparently been both psychologically and physically pulled apart off-screen. Virtually all of his internal organs, according to Spock's assessment, have been abused in some capacity.

In the UK, the episode wasn't screened unedited until 1994, owing to its graphic approach to the subjects of "madness, torture and sadism". While it escaped the same censure in the United States, the episode did carry a warning before it aired to warn viewers about the graphic nature of its content. Again though, it's not the content that's particularly graphic, rather how it plays out in your own mind.


3. Impulse

Enterprise Impulse
Paramount

Star Trek: Enterprise - Season 3, Episode 5

A recent survey of 100 Star Trek fans - that I've just entirely made-up - revealed that the scariest things about Enterprise was the state of some of its visual effects. That and the fact The Big Show was in it. However coming in a close 2nd, was the episode Impulse, which dispenses with the usual unnerving psychological horror of Star Trek in favour of an episode about rampaging, murderous, zombie Vulcans.

Discovering a Vulcan ship adrift in an asteroid belt, Archer, T'Pol, and Leuitaentant Reed venture onboard to try and get to the bottom of the situation. En route, T'Pol casually drops in that an entire Vulcan crew went mad and killed every single person on board, while out looking for this exact ship. That wouldn't have been pertinent before deciding to mount a rescue, no?

To the astonishment of absolutely nobody, the vessel is also full of Vulcans who've got irredeemably mad, and it's mere minutes before T'Pol starts to become one of them. Our away team fight ther way back to Entierprise, but not after a heft chuck of jumpscares and elevated heartrates in blackened coridoors.


2. Empok Nor

Garak Empok Nor
Paramount

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine - Season 5, Episode 24

Empok Nor is pretty much the closest thing Star Trek has ever done to an out-and-out slasher movie. Taking Chief O'Brien, Nog, Garak, and a small team to the abandoned sister station of Deep Space Nine, they discover two Cardassian supersoldiers and a psychotropic drug that turns them into deranged, xenophobic, killing machines.

All this would be fine, except that Garak is, himself, a Cardassian.

A cat and mouse game breaks out between the revived killers and the fatally unprepared Starfleet salvage crew, with each of our Brave Boys In Grey being gruesomely murdered by their stalkers. However, when they're finally overcome, the effects of the drug begin to take root in Garak, who turns on his colleagues and picks up where his fellow Cardassians left off.

It's a great, grizzly, and unsettling episode with a proper horror movie twist in its final act. Showcasing the often overlooked Andrew Robinson as one of the show's most compelling (and, when he wants to be, sinister) characters, it's almost the scariest thing Star Trek has ever done.

Almost.


1. Schisms

Star Trek Schisms
CBS Media Ventures

Star Trek: The Next Generation - Season 6, Episode 5

Schisms isn't only the scariest episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation, nor the scariest episode of Star Trek full stop, it's probably one of the scariest things that went out on 90s pre-watershed television. As an X-Files episode, this would have been lauded, on The Twilight Zone it'd have been considered 'too much', but it's Star Trek. Friendly, rewarding, fun-for-the-whole-family Star Trek, and it's terrifying.

Taking the classic alien abduction trope that's made movies like Fire In The Sky so difficult to watch, the episode builds from a growing sense of unease all the way to a horrifying reveal absolutely perfectly.

When several crewmembers start complaining about being tired, it's slowly revealed that they've been missing from the ship's logs overnight. Then when several of them begin experiencing flashbacks trigged by otherwise innocuous objects, it's clear they all share a common, sinister memory. Riker, in particular, has even had his limbs amputated and reattached.

Finding a way to stay awake during their abductions, Will sets off to rescue a missing crew member and get to the bottom of this. He finds himself on a cold metal slab in the midst of an alien autopsy but manages to escape, however not before his captors can send a mysterious energy signal back through the rift they'd taken him with, leaving us on a sinister cliffhanger.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Star Trek
 
Posted On: 
Managing Editor
Managing Editor

WhatCulture's Managing Editor and Chief Reporter | Previously seen in Vice, Esquire, FourFourTwo, Sabotage Times, Loaded, The Set Pieces, and Mundial Magazine