10 Shocking Twists That Would Improve Major TV Shows

Magical TV worlds in which nothing ever changes can become stagnant and pretty boring.

TV shows, particularly popular ones, can be pretty reluctant to change. The old adage, "If it ain't broke, don't fix it" seems like a rallying call for network TV shows. This is why there is a ceaseless barrage of cop shows with will-they-won't-they romantic entanglements and sitcoms with, well, the same thing. Animated shows like The Simpsons and Family Guy point out the ridiculousness of continuing to return to stasis at the end of every episode (Homer becomes a millionaire, then loses all of his money, then goes back to working at the plant probably fifty times). Networks reason that if Gilligan ever left the island, there wouldn't be a show anymore. But magical TV worlds in which nothing ever changes can become stagnant and pretty boring, so we're here to suggest big twists to TV shows that need a kick in the pants to stay fresh. Not all of these shows are bad, in fact some are pretty great, but all of them could take off again after a new creative jolt. Just because a TV show is successful doesn't mean audiences will resist change: the last season of Breaking Bad proved that exciting TV could be made by throwing out the formula altogether. Obviously, some people are going to think that these changes would negatively impact these shows (the title is called Shocking Twists for a reason), but the important thing is for these shows to consider ideas that tweak their concepts. Now on to the list...

10. Don Goes To Jail €“ Mad Men

Back in 2007 when Mad Men premiered, its protagonist Don Draper followed in a grand line of questionably motivated leading men that sometimes made you root for their misdeeds. He has been a family man who cheated on his wife (while being unhappy), a single divorcee who bedded lots of ladies (while being really unhappy), and again a married man who cheats on his wife (while being even more unhappy). But Don Draper is not really Don Draper, he is Dick Whitman, the bastard son of a prostitute who had, surprisingly enough, an unhappy childhood. I'm not a person who thinks Mad Men has dropped in quality over the years €“ in fact, I think season six was one of its finest. But just as the cycle of male antiheroes is dying down, Mad Men could use the opportunity their final season provides to really dig the antihero's grave. One of the ways it could do that is by having Don go to jail. Unlike dying, which several antiheroes have done before him, Don really needs to do penance for his crimes (both literal and metaphorical). Don has always been looking over his shoulder in case any agency is looking to track him down and reveal his true identity, and having a business executive go to jail for his crimes, even if they aren't necessarily because of his business practices, would be a fitting way to tie the end of the show to more contemporary times. But Mad Men will likely just end with another one of those musical montages in which every character's future is mapped out in front of the actors faces, which is fine, but it doesn't provide the same excitement that Don's incarceration would have for the show.

9. Boardwalk Empire €“ Change History

For a show that's about the illegal trafficking of alcohol, gangsters, sex, and violence, Boardwalk Empire receives a lot of criticism for being boring. Yet it's still a good show coming off perhaps its best season yet (SPOILERS), and killing off the show's crowd favorite already constituted one of the more shocking twists of the past year. But this show is also drawing to a close, as showrunner Terrence Winter (writer of the decisively not-boring Wolf of Wall Street) recently announced that the next season would be its last, and it could use another big twist to keep the show on its current high. My suggestion: take a cue from Tarantino and rewrite history. Alphonse Capone is playing a larger and larger role in the show, why not kill him off, or have him take over an even bigger territory? Or, the more recently added J. Edgar Hoover could start to personally track down Nucky so the show could have a straightforward lawman vs. gangster dynamic. I know some of you will rebuke this idea because the show is so accurate to period detail, particularly because the clothing, the dialogue, and the settings all seem to be from the 1920s. But let's not forget that Nucky Thompson is based off of Enoch L. Johnson, a man who was not directly involved in organized crime and who weighed over 250 pounds (unlike the diminutive Steve Buscemi). They already changed history, why not take it even further?

8. Two And A Half Men €“ The Whole Show Is Charlie Sheen's Personal Hell

Two and a Half Men used to be the most popular comedy on television. It rode high on the wave of sex jokes, jokes about Charlie Sheen's past, and more sex jokes. But after Sheen left the show due to a bitter spat with its producers about whether or not it was okay for him to do copious amounts of drugs while he was contractually obligated to be on TV, the show's ratings have dropped considerably. Ashton Kutcher, despite his good looks and his seasoned ability to deliver sitcom-level punchlines after being on That 70s Show, has not been as big of a draw for audiences the former Tiger Blood spokesman. Each episode of the show in its later years became not only an episode of Two and a Half Men but an insight on the damaged psyche and liver of its star, which naturally made it more exciting to watch. But that subtextual chaos has been removed from Men, and now it's scrambling to stay relevant while staying the same. The idea of having Kathy Bates play Charlie Sheen's spirit was good, but why not have the last couple of seasons of the show be all a part of the experience that Charlie Sheen has in hell after dying? No, I don't mean the pseudo-persona Charlie Harper, I mean actually have Charlie Sheen play himself watching the show within the show from hell. It's a pretty steep departure for a show to take, but it would be an uncompromising and insane conclusion. Cut to red.

7. Sherlock €“ Sherlock And John Get Together

I get it, the whole bromance thing allows entertainment to acknowledge a quasi-sexual partnership between two male characters without containing the supposed "transgressive content" of a legitimate homosexual relationship. But what was once a fun way to reference the absurdly close relationships between male characters in action (and in this case detective) stories has become an almost bland representation of the reticence of TV producers to broach controversial subject matter: all the fun of being a homosexual without any of the dudes banging! Sherlock has willingly placed itself into this situation because its admittedly more fun to watch Sherlock and Watson's love/hate relationship play out while you watch its resident sociopath look good and solve crimes. But a welcome twist would be to embrace the barrage of speculative fanfiction and have its two leads consummate their clear attraction to one another. John's new wife could even be his new beard as he traverses in the realm of "unsavory behavior." Shows like Torchwood have embraced heroes in non-heterosexual relationships, and a grand way to ring in Sherlock Holmes new stature in the realm of public domain would be to truly take the character to the next level in his natural progression. It's okay Sherlock, we still love you in just the same way. Now go solve more murders, you clever man.

6. The Walking Dead €“ Kill All Of The Main Characters

All of them, and I mean all of them. Let's face it, people don't watch The Walking Dead because of the characters, they watch it because a (relatively) big-budget take on the zombie apocalypse is a great idea for a serialized TV show. And, as you may have noticed, they already have killed off quite a few of their primary cast members. But The Walking Dead should take a page out of American Horror Story's playbook and become an anthology series about surviving in a zombified world. I know this would break from the plot of the graphic novels, but the show has already done that on multiple occasions. Staying true to the source material isn't the most important thing in the world, but maintaining excitement for a show in which a zombie attack can occur at any time should be easier than it apparently is for the writers. Why not shift focus to another group trying to stay alive before the walkers can get to them? If they don't want to kill all of their characters off, they can simply shift focus to another group and then have original cast members come back to make appearances as they join the new group. Either way, The Walking Dead should make a big change soon so they don't bore their sizable audience.

5. The Big Bang Theory €“ Leonard Dumps Penny

The Big Bang Theory, perhaps more than any other show on television right now, has found its sweet spot. Every episode unfolds in essentially the same way, with an A-plot and a B-plot unfolding and every character providing commentary on the action that can be filtered through their quirks. Sheldon is an intelligent yet annoying borderline sociopath, Leonard is an intelligent romantic, Raj is an intelligent socially incompetent male, Howard is a weirdo, Penny is attractive but not particularly intelligent, Bernadette is an intelligent woman who shouldn't have to be married to the weirdo to be in the gang, and Amy is the one emerging from her formerly socially inept shell. This is the bread and butter of the show, and that is not going to change. Part of the reason why the show does so well now is because it aired on syndication on CBS, and why it did so well on TBS is because it does not differ much from episode to episode. I'm not suggesting a major change that would shake the very premise of TBBT like the other shows on this list, I still think it should go back to its merry band of misfits after Leonard breaks up with Penny, but it would still represent a big turning point for the message of the show. Let's face it, their relationship isn't as happy or natural as it was supposed to be, and the two actors lack chemistry together. They should definitely break up rather than get married (the direction in which the writers seemingly have them heading). It isn't enough that the two break up though €“ Leonard has to be the one to break up with Penny. Isn't it getting annoying that Leonard is expected to grovel at the feet of the more attractive person, despite the fact that they have almost nothing in common, simply because she is more attractive than he is? Their relationship is unhealthy, as any relationship based on a fundamental inequality is, so why not stand up for the "nerds" this show so explicitly states they love and give Leonard some long overdue self-respect. Then they can go back to making jokes about science again.

4. The Show Is A Reenactment Of Senator Leslie Knope's Life €“ Parks And Recreation

Leslie Knope isn't the most media savvy politician, which pretty much means she wouldn't cut it in today's world of the 24-hour news cycle, but despite her eccentric behavior Parks and Recreation does a great job of making the audience want Leslie to succeed. And precisely because she is a person who couldn't become a senator in the real world, she is the type of person that the United States senate needs. She's a hard-worker, a go-getter, and someone with a clear sense of conscience about her actions and the role of the government. So wouldn't it be great if the whole show was a re-enactment by a group playing out the life story of Senator Knope? It would also go some way to explaining the occasionally frustrating mockumentary format that the show uses despite not actually having any cameras filming them in the context of the show. It would be even better if the show was a means of propelling support for Leslie to run for President, sort of a six seasons of an even-handed political advertisement. Sure, this would change the show pretty drastically, but NBC needs a definite ratings boost, and a gimmick like this might just do the trick.

3. Troy Is Recast €“ Community

As I am sure most of you know, Donald Glover is only going to appear on five episodes of Community this season. I don't know how the show is going to deal with his absence yet (I'm only caught up to the most recent episode), but it's going to be sad to see Troy Barnes leave. Glover's acting, mostly his crying, has been a highlight of the show since the first season. It's going to be hard for the show to make up for the loss of two of its group members (including Chevy Chase's departure). So my suggestion is, don't drop the character just because Glover is leaving. In true Fresh Prince of Bel Air style, recast Glover. I know that certain fans of Community are angry at the show for becoming too meta, which is a valid criticism seeing as they just did a David Fincher parody episode about someone putting coins in the butt cracks of Greendale students, so I think mentioning the recasting so overtly would be the wrong direction to take. Instead, why don't they recast Troy so Abed can continue to have a character to bounce off of without mentioning it at all? Not even the hyper-sensitive Abed would bat an eye at the absence of old-Troy, new-Troy would just be seamlessly integrated into the fold. The joke would then be that the show doesn't acknowledge it, but that is a legitimate risk; a risk that would make the show very interesting to watch.

2. Raylan Gets Fired €“ Justified

Raylan Givens is a U.S. Federal Marshal, but he really shouldn't be. He's the loose-cannon cop with a chip on his shoulder, but sometimes his actions take him entirely outside the realm of plausibility, particularly in regards to how he carries himself as a representative of the law. This season (SPOILERS) opened with Raylan accused of police brutality (or federal agent brutality) by Dewey Crowe before the plaintiff receives $300K due to his repeated mistreatment. Of course, Raylan shrugs it off. In fact, later in the episode Raylan again breaks the rules and intimidates Dewey by shooting his new pool. But you would think after constantly causing the Marshal program problems they would finally get fed up with his negligence. A big, and worthwhile twist in the show's structure would be to have Raylan get fired from the Marshal service and then have him branch out on his own. He has always been a character that plays by his own rules to enact justice, so if he were to start up his own agency (say, bounty hunting or private detective firm) he would be infinitely more successful and less constrained by the system. An even better idea? Have him team up with former enemy Boyd Crowder to dole out Kentucky-fried vigilante justice. The show would be extra awesome if it streamlined the stories of the two male leads, because while Boyd's character is a fascinating and complex now, his stories seem to run perpendicular to the main narrative thrust. Tying the two righteous yet unlawful characters together would make for very entertaining television.

1. Ted's Neverending Story Ends In The Apocalypse €“ How I Met Your Mother

This is the only entry on the list that was not my idea €“ it was actually suggested several times by costar Jason Segel. Basically, the premise of the idea is that as soon as Ted finishes his story, the camera pans over to the window in the apartment that his kids are in to show that the world has fallen into chaos in the years after the story's conclusion and Ted's children now live in a post-apocalyptic hellscape. Sure, it wouldn't exactly match the upbeat and romantic tone of the show, but after HIMYM's long walk to mediocrity, wouldn't it be exciting to see the show go out in a blaze of glory? At this point everyone is sort of expecting something to happen with the mother that is relatively unexpected despite the show's insistence that Ted really will find his Mrs. Right by the end of this season. A lot of people expect Robin and Barney won't get married, so Ted will eventually pair up with her again anyway. I don't think that's the case. I think the show really has committed to the Cristin Milioti character being the mother of the two children Ted is talking to in every single episode. So instead of changing yet another aspect of Ted's infinitely complicated love life, they should change the world that Ted is in by ending it. Just because it's a sitcom on a major network doesn't mean it has to play it safe. Hey, maybe his kids could even be the next group of survivors on The Walking Dead.

Contributor

Bryan Hickman is a WhatCulture contributor residing in Vancouver, British Columbia. Bryan's passions include film, television, basketball, and writing about himself in the third person.